Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Air BnB is a bit shit?

86 replies

airbnbargh · 20/07/2023 18:05

So booked an apartment in NY for December, booked flights separately (so obviously paid in full) and now months later the host has cancelled- no message, no explanation, just been told we can book something else or get a refund. We are now constrained by our flights so can't look at package deals, and the choice on Air BnB is now much more limited. We're a group and everyone raves about it so I thought it was a good option, but now left feeling pissed off, I wish I could at least leave a negative review! (I wouldn't mind so much if we got some kind of apology or explanation, but nothing).

OP posts:
HundredMilesAnHour · 20/07/2023 19:31

It's important to always check the rules before you book if it's a short term let as lots of places have restrictions and/or people illegally sublet and you could easily be the one who ends up with nowhere to stay for the night and/or losing money or having a lot of stress. A quick Google usually throws up problems at a city level. For example, cities have specific rules requiring a licence so you'll see genuine AirBNBs displaying their licence number. Cities like London don't allow properties to be AirBNBs for more than 90 days per year so AirBNB actually blocks bookings once a property hits 90 days. Obviously some landlords break the law and that's harder to police.

I use AirBNB a lot but always book with SuperHosts (they lose their status very easily if they get a bad review).

bellac11 · 20/07/2023 18:58

Ive read on here on airbnb threads that such and such place doesnt allow them or they're illegal yet you go and look in that area and theres tons to rent!

I think a recent one mentioned Sicily or somewhere like that and there were tons to rent despite apparently being illegal

airbnbargh · 20/07/2023 18:57

Thankfully no issue with getting a refund so I have no issues with Air BnB itself, just kicking myself how naive I was with booking flights, I didn't give myself much room for error!

OP posts:
airbnbargh · 20/07/2023 18:56

I don't understand how you booked in the first place op if it's illegal to do holiday lets in NYC

If you look on Air BnB there are loads of them, complete news to me that it's not allowed, didn't occur to me for a second when I saw loads on there!

OP posts:
Ohmylovejune · 20/07/2023 18:55

I should add they refused a refund but air b and b upheld my compliant and sent me 10 percent back, which I guess is some positive to say air b and b.

But we've never ever contemplated asking for any sort of refund before. I don't want that I want a nice property that's equipped to stay in comfortably for a few weeks!

bellac11 · 20/07/2023 18:54

I use airbnb for every holiday/break and so far touch wood we havent had an issue, thats in the UK and the EU

Im very fussy and I travel around the neighbourhood on streetview to get the best guess (and sometimes I spot the exact property) of exactly where it is, Im normally correct, you can sometimes see the street out of one of the windows in the pictures.

But it takes a long long time of researching and scouring the internet to book each one. I read all of the reviews, I also often contact the hosts prior to booking to double check things.

No holiday booking will be perfect and you cant know everything

They're not cheap either, mind you holiday costs seem to have gone through the roof now

Ohmylovejune · 20/07/2023 18:52

It's a real gamble, yes.

We stay in a lot of holiday let's using local holiday property agents. They clearly advise the owners on what people want and many grade them. Then.you have that on top.of reviews that are left, albeit maybe really poor reviews the agents have some control over not showing? Anyway, we've always been happier than expected.

This year we tried air b and b. Picked what I believe was a lovely property but my daughter, who luckily lives in that area and works in property, saw it suddenly come up for long term rental.including our dates! On contact, yes, she has a cancellation right up to stay just in case she changes her mind and cannot guarantee our dates despite accepting the booking. We had no choice to cancel as we were travelling with elderly folk.

Then we picked another. Hosted by a company who replied quickly but without really answering the question. The house had certainly not been given any thought to holidaymakers. The only cook ware was frying pans, saucepans and one oven pan. No serving dishes. No oven.dishes..no grill pan. No microwave dishes. Awful and impossible to self cater properly. One bedroom had no curtains or blinds! In the sunny days we had a few months ago.it was impossible to sleep at 4.30 in the morning! There were a whole bundle of other issues which paled into insignificance but you can't trust the listing to be accurate which is sad.

So we won't use air b and b again. Sadly.

User63847484848 · 20/07/2023 18:51

I feel your pain. I had similar when it was that crazy first May half term after covid when people could go away. Host tried to get me to pay more money (after I’d booked and she’d confirmed months earlier), then cancelled, then re advertised the same dates for more money.
air bnb supposedly penalise hosts for this but they did nothing and there was nothing decent left for that week.
thankfully got a last minute booking for glamping via another site (featherdown farms) as they’d had a cancellation and it was much nicer and cheaper in the end. But she should be ashamed of herself and Airbnb were useless

madeleine85 · 20/07/2023 18:50

The issue in NYC is that people rent directly from management companies, then put apartments into AirBnb (be in Manhattan, Brooklyn, it is no different) to make a few extra dollars while out of town, sleeping at a friends place etc. If the management companies who own the lease find out, and they usually do, as airbnbs tend to irritate neighbours who report them to the company, the renter's lease usually terminates, so the listings are withdrawn. For that reason, I never use Airbnb in New York.

Livelovebehappy · 20/07/2023 18:49

I had a couple of really bad experiences with Booking.com a few years ago. Too long to go into on here, but never used them again. Then started using Airbnb, and use all the time now. We use them for city breaks abroad, beach holidays and weekends away in the UK. Have always had brilliant experiences. I think you’ve just been unlucky OP with this one.

Remotecontrolatmyside · 20/07/2023 18:48

A lot of Air BnBs are illegal in New York so be careful.

dodeca · 20/07/2023 18:46

Yep I’d always just find a hotel. I think it’s more secure anyway I’ve seen far too many horror stories about people spying on you in Airbnb, you don’t know if the host has got a second key… all that sort of stuff

VisionsOfSplendour · 20/07/2023 18:46

IMustDoMoreExercise · 20/07/2023 18:40

Yes I have never used them and would never use them.

Airbnb is cheap for a reason. This is the rescue take on fortunately if you don't book a package deal.

But Airbnb isn't a thing it s a platform for people to list on exactly the same as ebay or Etsy or Amazon marketplace

You're booking with a host in the same way that in the olden days you'd book say a cottage through a brochure

It's not some kind of cut price second rate homogenous market

I don't understand how you booked in the first place op if it's illegal to do holiday lets in NYC

Caspianberg · 20/07/2023 18:45

Yes use booking.com. We find them much better and you can filter for apartments or full houses as well as hotels. Plus all costs are clearer upfront

airbnbargh · 20/07/2023 18:45

@IMustDoMoreExercise thing is it wasn't cheap, it was more about having more sociable space with a group of us rather than cost, it wasn't much different pp to a hotel, but I need to look again now, dreading how much prices will have jumped since I booked 😩

OP posts:
airbnbargh · 20/07/2023 18:43

I never realised it was illegal there, it's in Brooklyn if that makes a difference although there were plenty in Manhattan when I was looking, host definitely not there. Clearly I need to look into more!

OP posts:
IMustDoMoreExercise · 20/07/2023 18:40

"risk you take

IMustDoMoreExercise · 20/07/2023 18:40

Yes I have never used them and would never use them.

Airbnb is cheap for a reason. This is the rescue take on fortunately if you don't book a package deal.

0021andabit · 20/07/2023 18:37

I agree that I think it was a great idea when it was about renting out your spare room, or even renting out your whole house when you away (for example we used to regularly rent an Air B&B on the British coast that belonged to a family who stayed with family in France all summer) but I think it's been ruined a bit by people who want to be landlords but without the hassle buying up properties to use purely as Air B&Bs.

Im99912 · 20/07/2023 18:34

If you can find the host listing on Google then leave them a review
but I think AirnB is illegal in NYC

itsmyp4rty · 20/07/2023 18:32

If they cancel and refund you it goes against them in my understanding. So don't let them tell you that you need to cancel to get your money back. In fact if you try to do this AirBNB warns you not to do it, if you're not the one cancelling.

It is a risk but we've stayed in so many great places for so much cheaper than hotel prices. It's always worth checking booking.com as well though as sometimes the options are better there.

Cosyblankets · 20/07/2023 18:30

I use booking com now instead of air bnb . I prefer that you can see the address before you book so you can see how far it is to the shop or bar or whatever. You only get a circle on air bnb you don't get the address until you book
I didn't realise until last year that it wasn't just for hotels

EightChalk · 20/07/2023 18:29

RaidFlySpray · 20/07/2023 18:20

It's had a huge and terrible effect on the area where I live. 6 out of 9 houses on one terrace in a tiny village are airbnbs, small properties that would make brilliant starter homes. Young people are priced out, so schools are closing... It's really awful. I think it was a great idea when it was about renting out your spare room, but now it's mainly entire homes.

This. Loads of cities also have terrible problems because of Air BnB. There seems to be something especially callous about actively damaging the place you're choosing to visit.

Nunganungas · 20/07/2023 18:28

Airbnb is actually illegal in New York so you should look for alternatives anyway, you wouldn’t be protected if you turned up and the property didn’t exist

Boopear · 20/07/2023 18:27

Yes, AirBnB is illegal in NY so this is always a risk when booking there. I’ve had no problems anywhere else at all (was in Washington last week in a wonderful AirBnb) Such a shame though. Springfield Suites (Marriott) is a decent place in NY if you are looking at alternative options.