Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think Air BnB is a bit shit?

86 replies

airbnbargh · 20/07/2023 18:05

So booked an apartment in NY for December, booked flights separately (so obviously paid in full) and now months later the host has cancelled- no message, no explanation, just been told we can book something else or get a refund. We are now constrained by our flights so can't look at package deals, and the choice on Air BnB is now much more limited. We're a group and everyone raves about it so I thought it was a good option, but now left feeling pissed off, I wish I could at least leave a negative review! (I wouldn't mind so much if we got some kind of apology or explanation, but nothing).

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Maddy70 · 21/07/2023 13:01

I completely agree with you.

waterst · 21/07/2023 13:00

Airbnbs can be legal in NYC if you are staying for longer than 30 days or if the host lives there too.

Brooklyn is NYC same as Manhattan is.

Backstreets · 21/07/2023 12:49

Air b n b was great in the beginning but it’s had such a destructive effect. I tend to avoid it now although I caved in for an upcoming Paris trip as I needed to stay centrally and hotel prices have jumped SO much since pre-Covid.

Filament · 21/07/2023 12:23

There seems to be more flaky owners on Airbnb that other rental sites like Holiday Lettings or Vrbo. They seem to cancel more regularly than others. Airbnb is also very poor when there's an issue. We arrived at a very expensive rental only to find video cameras recording us and our conversations at the front door. It was very intrusive and against Airbnb regulations not to have declared it. But Airbnb didn't even reply to the complaint we made.

Frannyhy · 21/07/2023 12:11

For all those who say they are safer in a hotel. The Albion Hotel in Brighton caught fire last weekend. All their upcoming booked guests have had their reservations cancelled.

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 21/07/2023 11:45

They don't have the same constraints and have to abide by the same rules and regs as b'n'b's and other rental sites.

I was let down 20 mins before arrival after driving 3 hours (so not so bad as the op), but we were going to a wedding and meeting up with family the next day. Ended up cutting our trip short and driving back after the wedding. Was a right royal fuck up. If I do use Airbnb I'm now careful that it won't fuck up plans if they cancel

escapingthecity · 21/07/2023 11:44

This is why we stay in hotels and B&Bs. Had too many Airbnb cancellations.

CarlaH · 21/07/2023 11:42

We used them a few times years ago. Once when we arrived we got a message saying that they didn't know if we would be able to stay the whole time as the neighbours were taking them to court and we might be evicted half way through our stay. Luckily we weren't but it was nerve wracking. Another place left a note inside which said that we should lie and say we were friends of the owners if a neighbour asked us who we were because it was illegal to let out a property for holidays in the block where we were staying. Both times in the US on the same holiday and we wouldn't use them again now.

TheGaffer · 21/07/2023 09:51

Try the Sonder Battery Park…brilliant location…right next to about 5 subway lines so can get around really quickly, quiet, clean, good size apts for New York. We got a two bedroom and had a big open plan kitchen dining living space (and oddly a peloton bike as a perk which the kids used as a climbing frame 🙈).

Yesquiteright · 21/07/2023 09:32

Elphame · 21/07/2023 08:49

Use booking.com instead. You'll find more professional hosts there.

Airbnb was set up to provide cheap "spare room for a night" style accommodation for anyone to rent out their spare space and whilst it has grown, the casual mentality still prevails.

Incidently have you complained to Airbnb? They were starting to fine accommodation owners who pull this kind of trick as it happens way too much and is giving them a bad name!

Like I said above, lots of us put our properties on multiple sites, I'm every bit as professional on Airbnb as I am on booking. com

Porridgeislife · 21/07/2023 09:18

We stayed in an apartment in Brooklyn via AirBnB early last year and mid way through our stay got a visit from the local council enforcement officers! We also didn’t realise it was illegal in all of NYC.

Fortunately we didn’t get kicked out on the spot but it was a tense couple of days until our stay ended.

Dulra · 21/07/2023 09:17

I have used airbnb a few times both in Ireland (where I a live) and abroad and I have to admit I have never had any issues but maybe that is luck. We are a family of 5 and I find getting hotel rooms for us can be either really expensive because you have to book two interconnecting rooms in a lot of cases or near on impossible on the continent, family rooms often don't seem to exist. I guess like everything there is a risk with it but thankfully we have never had any trouble. We have just come back from a few days in an Italian city where we had a fabulous apartment with three big bedrooms in the middle of the old town which fitted me, dh and 3 kids perfectly. I tend to check air bnb and booking.com and go for whichever one has the best option for us for our stay.

Op you are not going away until December so hopefully you can find something else. Nothing is a given any more even airlines can muck about with things we had a holiday booked and our return flights were cancelled and rescheduled for two days later so we are scrambling to find accommodation for those two extra days 😩

StarchySturgess1 · 21/07/2023 09:14

#boycottairbnb

AuntieJune · 21/07/2023 09:11

Airbnb was good a decade or so ago, then it mushroomed and loads of people bought properties to put on there, with marginal affordability - then cost of living and pandemic reduced profitablity a lot.

It's full of amateurs who think they can make a mint without the hard work of admin, repairs, cleaning etc. So people stick properties on then take them off when it's too much like hard work.

I use it but I wouldn't if it was a trip with a big cost or hard to find alternatives - a weekend away in UK yes, a trip to new York no.

ScarletWitchM · 21/07/2023 09:10

Have used them for about 12 years all over the world and never had any issues but we may have just been lucky.

PrtScn · 21/07/2023 09:10

RaidFlySpray · 20/07/2023 18:20

It's had a huge and terrible effect on the area where I live. 6 out of 9 houses on one terrace in a tiny village are airbnbs, small properties that would make brilliant starter homes. Young people are priced out, so schools are closing... It's really awful. I think it was a great idea when it was about renting out your spare room, but now it's mainly entire homes.

Exactly this. Where I am it’s similar. Lots of terraces snapped up for AirBnB. I’ve got 5 a stones throw away from me.

Pugdogmom · 21/07/2023 09:05

I used Airbnb once. There was no issue with it,however stopped using it because in so many places, people can't get accommodation to rent because of the amount of places rented out on short term lets.

MrsSkylerWhite · 21/07/2023 09:04

We’ve had 3 excellent stays. Things happen. Not the company’s fault. Book hotels in future (which can still cancel you, of course).

LaterHarold · 21/07/2023 09:02

There's seen to be a lot of misconceptions about Airbnb. It started as a way of people being able to let a room in their home, but quickly evolved into just another self catering company. It's no different from any other company that lets holiday properties, other than it's usually (almost always actually) a more expensive option than booking direct, or via one of the other platforms including small companies.

Airbnb seems to have taken off in a way that other self catering companies haven't, it's very odd. I'd always look elsewhere before booking with them, but they do have a monopoly on a lot of places.

HappiDaze · 21/07/2023 08:54

I hate air B&B

The people that rent them out near us are selfish noisy loud pigs who couldn't care less about anyone

Elphame · 21/07/2023 08:49

Use booking.com instead. You'll find more professional hosts there.

Airbnb was set up to provide cheap "spare room for a night" style accommodation for anyone to rent out their spare space and whilst it has grown, the casual mentality still prevails.

Incidently have you complained to Airbnb? They were starting to fine accommodation owners who pull this kind of trick as it happens way too much and is giving them a bad name!

justasking111 · 21/07/2023 08:36

"Airbnb | Piermont – Holiday Rentals & Places to Stay - New York - Airbnb" https://www.airbnb.co.uk/s/homes?dynamic_product_ids%5B%5D=15299184&omni_page_id=36021

Friends live in Piermont and commute, cast your net wider. They're some beautiful places just outside the city.

Yesquiteright · 21/07/2023 08:36

Yes I run a BnB and am on Airbnb, VRBO and booking. com . I've never cancelled anyone unless there's been a genuine emergency i.e whole electric cable to property was damaged

TheDogsMother · 21/07/2023 08:25

Just to echo others Airbnb is simply the platform. There are zillions of properties and zillions of hosts so I don't really understand hating the whole thing.

Hosts are penalised for cancellations. The rating hosts have are calculated on several metrics including cancellation rate.

Hosts on booking.com can pay a larger chunk to influence the rating that appears on their listing.

Many properties appear on multiple platforms including booking.com and Airbnb at the same time. So it's not really one or the other.

FelicityFlops · 21/07/2023 08:00

Have a look on Trivago first of all for the area and hotel facilities you want.
Then review any suitable hotels directly on their own websites, as you may be able to pick up a decent rate if you book directly with the hotel.
It is often worth contacting the hotel directly, especially if you are making multiple room bookings. It is also worth finding out if any of your party belongs to a loyalty programme, such as GHA, ALL, Hilton or Marriott Boyvoy, for example, as there can be associated benefits if they are able to book via the programme.
However, be aware that some "third party" websites offer really good deals (price-wise) that turn out to be not so good when compared to a hotel's own offering. I have encountered this a few times on third party sites, where the cost has appeared very reasonable, but does not include use of pool or fitness facilities.