Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell them to grow up or you’re uninvited?

387 replies

Purewhitegold · 20/07/2023 17:53

MIL and FIL are newly divorced. FIL had an affair and is now engaged to the other woman. MIL is understandably upset and finding it hard to accept. FIL done this because of her disability ‘holding him back’ in his words. We are all angry with him for doing this rather than ending it amicably before pursuing other women, but we have all accepted the situation and want to carry on with our lives.
DH is trying to maintain his relationships with both parents separately and without taking sides. As it’s still raw for MIL she wants DH to cut him off and asks him to pass on (abusive) messages. She guilts him for speaking to FIL and ignores him for days if she thinks they have spent time together. FIL is angry and wants her to move on and leave him alone. He has made petty decisions like cutting off the phone line (she won’t use a mobile phone). It’s all very messy and unfair on their (adult) children and grandchildren. We know it’s hard for MIL being in this position so we are supporting her as much as we can, and I know from experience how much she’s hurting, however she is now being unfairly difficult towards us as a result.
We have a family gathering at the weekend to introduce our new baby to the wider family. MIL is refusing to come if we allow FIL to arrive first. If FIL partner holds the baby she will not consider the baby her grandchild. We have had a long list of ridiculous rules. She has cornered me to find out if FIL partner is prettier than her (I have never met her) and which of us she will consider her true MIL. I have tried to reassure her and spend time with her but it turns back to abusive gossip that makes us all uncomfortable.
SIL has her wedding coming up in September, she obviously wants her dad to walk her down the aisle. MIL is refusing to come to the wedding if FIL goes. SIL is obviously heartbroken.
MIL refused to come to our child’s birthday party at the weekend as FIL dropped in presents (then left) but she wouldn’t come in case he came back or brought his partner. So we had to spend the last part of our child’s birthday at her house where she gossiped about FIL and ignored the children. She told him his grandad should be here but he’s been horrible so he won’t come and made my child cry.
It’s taking it’s toll on DH and his sisters as they want to support their mother but her demands are becoming cruel.
SIL asked me to post to think up the best option moving forward. I have suggested they be encouraged to discuss arrangements together like adults and put to bed the passive aggressiveness for the sake of all the children or neither will be invited to any future events. Everyone thinks that’s unfair, but there needs to be a point where it stops?

OP posts:
ejbaxa · 21/07/2023 12:41

Firstly, I think you need to let SIL deal with her wedding and her parents. I know she’s asking you to post and that you are supporting her, but there’s no actual answer to her wedding problem.

secondly, I’d let mil see the new baby the day before over lunch or tea or something. Make that a nice day for her and tell her you’d like to spare her the pain of the big gathering the next day.

what fil has done - she’ll never get over it. They must have been together about 40 years. Most of her adult life and she’s now nearly a pensioner. Her life torn to shreds, unrecognisable. Because fil thinks in sickness and in health only meant other people. She is probably going to lash out and behave quite badly for a while. She might feel bitter forever. And she might even feel suicidal. I would just not take it personally in your position.

whilst it’s a life changing big deal for her, it’s pretty irrelevant (and in no way traumatic) to the grandchildren so ask her not to speak to them about it.

billy1966 · 21/07/2023 12:31

I suppose with your recent posts things definitely shift somewhat.

An awful controlling mother and they were closer to their father.

The marriage wasn't great in the first
place and your FIL had little interest in caring for her.

A very sad ugly situation no doubt.

I still feel great sympathy for your MIL as it is an awful situation, but it is exacerbated by her children having understandable resentment towards her.

If only parents realised the damage they do long term to their children when they behave like this.

This is a topic in our house as one of my daughters parents are like this and at 17 she is clashing so much.
As she is a really quiet child, afraid of boys, they are shoring up huge problems.
They are nice people, well the mother is, not so sure about the father, but my daughter tells me she can't wait to leave their beautiful home to just get away from their controlling ways.
No phone allowed EVER in her bedroom, which seems a bit OTT, is one of many rules.
Her friends can't fathom this of course.

OP, you may need to pull back from your MIL and put some space between you.

Her controlling ways may well have morphed into fury and it is not good for you to be around it.

I think you need to put your children and yourself first.

Making her 5 year old grandchild cry on his birthday is definitely line in the sand that would be the start of new boundaries going forward.

It is best to be clear on this as it woud be such a shame for her to lose even more than she has.

However painful this is for her, she needs this harsh truth to be told to her before it is too late.

I would be very upset at my child being collateral damage in this.

Completely unacceptable.

waterrat · 21/07/2023 12:19

There is a lot of empathy here for your MIL - but you know what - marriages break down, people leave, people fall for other people.

It might be needed for someone - one of her children - to start setting some boundaries for MIL. ie. - look, it hurts - but he's our dad.

They are grown up - but she is still the parent. This would not be acceptable to put onto young kids would it? They are still her children - she needs to try to a certain extent to leave them out of her anger and rage.

I think if you give too much leeway this will just never end.

CatsSnore · 21/07/2023 12:19

Gosh this is dreadful. I'm quite surprised at posters saying they would take sides!

Keep doing what you're all doing and hold those boundaries in a really kind and caring way.

BadNomad · 21/07/2023 12:17

Being in a shit marriage means she deserved to be cheated on?

Plenty of people leave shit marriages without being vile and nasty. Plenty of people end their marriages first before even looking for someone else to shag.

saraclara · 21/07/2023 12:10

SeulementUneFois · 21/07/2023 11:36

It seems like MIL used to be a worse person than FIL - demanding and controlling to her children, allowing them zero socialising as teens.
So while what FIL just did is terrible, their children might think that that doesn't make him a worse person than MIL (rather equal while he used to be better than her as she used to be the toxic one).

Yep, that plus OP says that the parents in law used to constantly fight, makes it unfair to say that their offspring should just dump their father. MIL clearly wasn't a great mum by any stretch of the imagination, nor was the.marriage so great that this was an out of the blue split. So there's a lot more to the family relationships than this one action by FIL.

longtompot · 21/07/2023 12:05

MrsSkylerWhite · 21/07/2023 10:03

longtompot · Today 10:00
FIL done this because of her disability ‘holding him back’ in his words

This is an incredibly hurtful thing for your fil to say and I can understand why your mil is finding it difficult to move on like he has. She can't do anything to change the fact she is disabled and so for her to even contemplate meeting someone else, she runs the risk of them feeling the same. I know I wouldn't forgive a relative who did this to someone. My dd had this happen to her, and it was awful. She wasn't with her partner for as long as she is only in her early 20s, but to know the reason someone has left you is because of something you have no control over is hard.
Personally I would go very low contact with the fil. He can live his happy life with the new woman if he wants, but he wouldn't get to be playing happy families with the rest of us. I would be showing my mil I support her, but wouldn't tolerate the nasty messages etc”

Disability isn’t a free pass to behave intolerably towards other people. Given her behaviour towards OP and family, I imagine FIL’s life with her was pretty awful.

I know it isn't. Maybe read what I wrote what I did in my last sentence

CleverLilViper · 21/07/2023 11:59

MrsSkylerWhite · 21/07/2023 09:02

I’m not surprised your FIL left.

Yes, grow up or don’t come.

Vile.

Emz6103 · 21/07/2023 11:46

Exactly yet this who thread is full of nasty toxic women, it's like divorce doesn't happen to anyone.... Yet almost everyone has a step parent! It's full of ridiculous comments FIL has lost out too, he now has a cloak n dagger relationship with his children who will not accept his new wife, not invited to any family gatherings unless he leaves her behind, subjected to abuse even after his divorce. Good grief its no wonder men cheat if this is what's happened to the female gene pool. Look at the hate towards amber Heard for abusing Jonny......the whole thread reads like MIL is a helpless child who was innocent. Like I stated earlier no man leaves a happy marriage that he's spent years bringing up children and caring for 11 years a disabled wife.....I suspect hes at the end of his rope as are the grown up children. I'm glad I don't have a partner, my husband was a drinker and my partner after was a complete psycho but I'm happy my grown up children have a somewhat limited relationship with their father and I'm happy he's moved on and found love again. All I can see here is that women can be the most spiteful creatures

SeulementUneFois · 21/07/2023 11:36

It seems like MIL used to be a worse person than FIL - demanding and controlling to her children, allowing them zero socialising as teens.
So while what FIL just did is terrible, their children might think that that doesn't make him a worse person than MIL (rather equal while he used to be better than her as she used to be the toxic one).

Meeting · 21/07/2023 11:26

If MIL doesn't think enough of her daughter to behave herself for one day and not look at or engage with FIL then she should stay at home.

Pumpkindoodles · 21/07/2023 11:24

Gosh it’s all very petty isn’t it
I don’t know why you’re not happy with MIL punishing people but you are punishing the OW. It seems unreasonable to refuse a relationship with someone who has an affair with a married man who’s disabled wife is at home
but carry on having a relationship with the married man who ditched his disabled wife to shag someone else.

i think I’d lean more to MILs side. I would offer she come round to meet GC first, or with the rest of the family. And FIL comes later. But I would expect that she shut up and leave me out of all of her issues and complaining and not involve us in the toxic mess they want to hang on to. I wouldn’t engage, listen, or be in any related conversations and I would make it clear that we love her, we want her in our lives but we do not want to be in their argument.

with SILs wedding, I’d invite them both, do what I want, and expect they both behave. But SIL needs to prepare for the fact they won’t behave and try not let it ruin her wedding.

Clytemnestra21 · 21/07/2023 11:14

@saraclara yes I read them. I agree with the PP who pointed out it isn't enough to just go through the motions and maintain neutrality when someone is broken as a result of the selfish actions of someone they ought to have been able to trust. It's a stressful situation for OP, I really hear that, but her DH and his family need to step up in their efforts to make MIL feel she isn't crazy and make clear they will prioritise her over their horribly selfish and callous father. If they acknowledge how hurt she is and show her unconditional love and support she'll likely calm down.

threefiftysix · 21/07/2023 10:57

If my father behaved like this to my mother (not only the affair but a) saying he had the affair because her disability held him back b) cutting phone line off c) threatening not to come to a family gathering if OW wasn't invited etc etc) I would want nothing to do with him, at least for a long while. I'm surprised your DH and SIL are so tolerant

MentholLoad · 21/07/2023 10:47

I have posted too much on this thread now. but I just really empathise with MIL. it seems from your last post that her kids are going through the motions of supporting her but reality is they prioritise their dad and are just finding her emotions too much. this is going to get worse not better, I think. I really hope she finds the strength and courage to go off and live a new fabulous independent life with people who don't resent her

GoodChat · 21/07/2023 10:35

MIL doesn't get to make a speech if she can't be trusted. This is her daughter's special day. It's not about her.

Purewhitegold · 21/07/2023 10:33

MIL has always been lovely and we have a great bond. DH and his sisters find her difficult because she can be demanding and controlling, although never to the point it’s currently at. She was a very strict parent (no socialising allowed as teens) which they were resentful for and were naturally closer to FIL as they got older. The situation has put them in the middle, because morally what FIL done was wrong but they were closer with him and don’t want to cut that off completely. They’re all still supporting MIL and going above and beyond what other adult children would do, but understandably they don’t want to cut one parent off for something that shouldn’t involve them.
I’ve never had a mum so I naturally bonded with MIL more and she is great with all her grandchildren (again prior to this). I know there were issues in the marriage for years with constant arguments, but they didn’t drag us into it then so we left it alone. Maybe the issues ran deeper than we thought, she may well have been a nightmare wife/mum, but while her reaction is perfectly natural it’s not fair to continuously bring it up and make us part of it.
SIL would prefer FIL came to her wedding as normal, it’s MIL that she fears would cause drama and make an angry speech aimed at FIL. MIL should definitely be there and shouldn’t feel less of a mum for it, but it’s one day and she doesn’t need to so much as look at him. He doesn’t stop being their father because he had an affair. Refusing FIL to be at the wedding would make MIL worse as she knows she then has the power to dictate what we all do, something we’re desperate to avoid.

OP posts:
saraclara · 21/07/2023 10:33

Another one here saying someone needs to be kind to your mil and protect her in this

Have you read OP's posts @Clytemnestra21 ? This is exactly what she has been doing. As has her husband who visits every day and pays his mums bills. This has been going on for a long time and all they're getting back is threats of her disowning their new baby and demands that DH acts as her flying monkey. Not to mention her treatment of their five year old.

There's a line, and for me, however sympathetic I'd been, the treatment of her grandchild (and threat to my new baby) would be it.
She cannot continue like this. She's going to drive everyone away.

Clytemnestra21 · 21/07/2023 10:26

Another one here saying someone needs to be kind to your mil and protect her in this. What a devastating experience for her. And completely unreasonable to expect her to be anywhere near the affair partner. The insensitivity of loved ones who expect someone to just tolerate something they would find intolerable if it were them could be as harmful to her as the fil's original betrayal.

MrsSkylerWhite · 21/07/2023 10:03

longtompot · Today 10:00
FIL done this because of her disability ‘holding him back’ in his words

This is an incredibly hurtful thing for your fil to say and I can understand why your mil is finding it difficult to move on like he has. She can't do anything to change the fact she is disabled and so for her to even contemplate meeting someone else, she runs the risk of them feeling the same. I know I wouldn't forgive a relative who did this to someone. My dd had this happen to her, and it was awful. She wasn't with her partner for as long as she is only in her early 20s, but to know the reason someone has left you is because of something you have no control over is hard.
Personally I would go very low contact with the fil. He can live his happy life with the new woman if he wants, but he wouldn't get to be playing happy families with the rest of us. I would be showing my mil I support her, but wouldn't tolerate the nasty messages etc”

Disability isn’t a free pass to behave intolerably towards other people. Given her behaviour towards OP and family, I imagine FIL’s life with her was pretty awful.

saraclara · 21/07/2023 10:01

MentholLoad · 21/07/2023 09:41

yes, it really seems like that doesn't it.

now I have read all of OPs posts, I have every sympathy for her. small children, new baby, in-laws not own parents, sounds like she is supporting as much as she can. and suffering for it

I do not; understand the SIL and her wedding. why would you want your dad to walk you down the isle after her just blew up your mum's life. it makes a mockery of the vows. and why would you want your mum to put on a brave face. I couldn't enjoy my wedding day if I knew my mum was in torment and putting on a facade, for me. everytime I looked at photos of the day, I would just think about how hurt my mum was. I would either, uninvite dad entirely or post pone wedding or go and have a quiet ceremony with just my husband

You don't always stop loving someone who does something cruel to someone else. Especially if it's a parent. And OP's later posts imply that MIL's other chhildren already found her very difficult, which is why they're not as invoved with her at the moment.

I'm not sure why anyone's saying theat DH is leaving things to OP. He goes to visit his mum and check on her every day, not to mention he's paying her bills. And presumably he has a job to go to every day, too.

longtompot · 21/07/2023 10:00

FIL done this because of her disability ‘holding him back’ in his words

This is an incredibly hurtful thing for your fil to say and I can understand why your mil is finding it difficult to move on like he has. She can't do anything to change the fact she is disabled and so for her to even contemplate meeting someone else, she runs the risk of them feeling the same. I know I wouldn't forgive a relative who did this to someone. My dd had this happen to her, and it was awful. She wasn't with her partner for as long as she is only in her early 20s, but to know the reason someone has left you is because of something you have no control over is hard.
Personally I would go very low contact with the fil. He can live his happy life with the new woman if he wants, but he wouldn't get to be playing happy families with the rest of us. I would be showing my mil I support her, but wouldn't tolerate the nasty messages etc

MentholLoad · 21/07/2023 09:41

dolorsit · 21/07/2023 09:15

Tbh I am unimpressed that your husband and his siblings seem to have left the bulk of the emotional support to you.

yes, it really seems like that doesn't it.

now I have read all of OPs posts, I have every sympathy for her. small children, new baby, in-laws not own parents, sounds like she is supporting as much as she can. and suffering for it

I do not; understand the SIL and her wedding. why would you want your dad to walk you down the isle after her just blew up your mum's life. it makes a mockery of the vows. and why would you want your mum to put on a brave face. I couldn't enjoy my wedding day if I knew my mum was in torment and putting on a facade, for me. everytime I looked at photos of the day, I would just think about how hurt my mum was. I would either, uninvite dad entirely or post pone wedding or go and have a quiet ceremony with just my husband

Meeting · 21/07/2023 09:17

SeulementUneFois · 21/07/2023 09:16

OP

Start doing separate family gatherings - FILs side of the family and MiL's respectively.

Stupid and expensive idea.

You do your normal family gatherings and those who can behave may attend.

SeulementUneFois · 21/07/2023 09:16

OP

Start doing separate family gatherings - FILs side of the family and MiL's respectively.