Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell them to grow up or you’re uninvited?

387 replies

Purewhitegold · 20/07/2023 17:53

MIL and FIL are newly divorced. FIL had an affair and is now engaged to the other woman. MIL is understandably upset and finding it hard to accept. FIL done this because of her disability ‘holding him back’ in his words. We are all angry with him for doing this rather than ending it amicably before pursuing other women, but we have all accepted the situation and want to carry on with our lives.
DH is trying to maintain his relationships with both parents separately and without taking sides. As it’s still raw for MIL she wants DH to cut him off and asks him to pass on (abusive) messages. She guilts him for speaking to FIL and ignores him for days if she thinks they have spent time together. FIL is angry and wants her to move on and leave him alone. He has made petty decisions like cutting off the phone line (she won’t use a mobile phone). It’s all very messy and unfair on their (adult) children and grandchildren. We know it’s hard for MIL being in this position so we are supporting her as much as we can, and I know from experience how much she’s hurting, however she is now being unfairly difficult towards us as a result.
We have a family gathering at the weekend to introduce our new baby to the wider family. MIL is refusing to come if we allow FIL to arrive first. If FIL partner holds the baby she will not consider the baby her grandchild. We have had a long list of ridiculous rules. She has cornered me to find out if FIL partner is prettier than her (I have never met her) and which of us she will consider her true MIL. I have tried to reassure her and spend time with her but it turns back to abusive gossip that makes us all uncomfortable.
SIL has her wedding coming up in September, she obviously wants her dad to walk her down the aisle. MIL is refusing to come to the wedding if FIL goes. SIL is obviously heartbroken.
MIL refused to come to our child’s birthday party at the weekend as FIL dropped in presents (then left) but she wouldn’t come in case he came back or brought his partner. So we had to spend the last part of our child’s birthday at her house where she gossiped about FIL and ignored the children. She told him his grandad should be here but he’s been horrible so he won’t come and made my child cry.
It’s taking it’s toll on DH and his sisters as they want to support their mother but her demands are becoming cruel.
SIL asked me to post to think up the best option moving forward. I have suggested they be encouraged to discuss arrangements together like adults and put to bed the passive aggressiveness for the sake of all the children or neither will be invited to any future events. Everyone thinks that’s unfair, but there needs to be a point where it stops?

OP posts:
SquirrelSoShiny · 21/07/2023 20:55

caringcarer · 21/07/2023 20:36

At my DD graduation ceremony exh and I were both invited. We had been divorced about 6 weeks and still had not got finances sorted. I divorced him after he cheated on me after 21 years of marriage. DD assured me that her Dad was invited but the OW was not. I agreed to go but said I wanted to sit away from exh. I was seated about 6 seats away. Part way through the ceremony I looked up and there she was sitting next to exh. I watched until my DD got her award then left. I was shaking. I've never found out how OW got a ticket. I was inclined to believe DD must have given it to her Dad. She says not but entry was ticket only. She was very angry with me for not staying for photos after the ceremony. I drove home. We argued and she didn't speak to me for almost 6 years. She contacted me through my son to say she wanted me at her wedding. By this time I had remarried. She invited me and DH and her Dad and a different partner by then. We are cordial and I have helped her out with nursery fees for dgc and a car when her old one broke but I don't feel the emotional closeness to my DD that I feel to my 2 DS's. My boys ring me and message me every few days and I see them often. I see DD and dhc about 4 times a year partly because of geographic distance but partly I'd rather spend time with my son's now. I felt like she chose to invite her Dad's OW to an event that she had no right to be at.

God that is awful. Yes, another one sorry you were treated that way.

saraclara · 21/07/2023 20:54

I've never found out how OW got a ticket. I was inclined to believe DD must have given it to her Dad

So you destroyed your relationship with your daughter without even finding out whether your inclination was correct, @caringcarer ?

Seriously, that's just incredibly and unnecessarily sad.

MentholLoad · 21/07/2023 20:50

caringcarer · 21/07/2023 20:36

At my DD graduation ceremony exh and I were both invited. We had been divorced about 6 weeks and still had not got finances sorted. I divorced him after he cheated on me after 21 years of marriage. DD assured me that her Dad was invited but the OW was not. I agreed to go but said I wanted to sit away from exh. I was seated about 6 seats away. Part way through the ceremony I looked up and there she was sitting next to exh. I watched until my DD got her award then left. I was shaking. I've never found out how OW got a ticket. I was inclined to believe DD must have given it to her Dad. She says not but entry was ticket only. She was very angry with me for not staying for photos after the ceremony. I drove home. We argued and she didn't speak to me for almost 6 years. She contacted me through my son to say she wanted me at her wedding. By this time I had remarried. She invited me and DH and her Dad and a different partner by then. We are cordial and I have helped her out with nursery fees for dgc and a car when her old one broke but I don't feel the emotional closeness to my DD that I feel to my 2 DS's. My boys ring me and message me every few days and I see them often. I see DD and dhc about 4 times a year partly because of geographic distance but partly I'd rather spend time with my son's now. I felt like she chose to invite her Dad's OW to an event that she had no right to be at.

I'm so sorry you were treated like this 💐

caringcarer · 21/07/2023 20:36

At my DD graduation ceremony exh and I were both invited. We had been divorced about 6 weeks and still had not got finances sorted. I divorced him after he cheated on me after 21 years of marriage. DD assured me that her Dad was invited but the OW was not. I agreed to go but said I wanted to sit away from exh. I was seated about 6 seats away. Part way through the ceremony I looked up and there she was sitting next to exh. I watched until my DD got her award then left. I was shaking. I've never found out how OW got a ticket. I was inclined to believe DD must have given it to her Dad. She says not but entry was ticket only. She was very angry with me for not staying for photos after the ceremony. I drove home. We argued and she didn't speak to me for almost 6 years. She contacted me through my son to say she wanted me at her wedding. By this time I had remarried. She invited me and DH and her Dad and a different partner by then. We are cordial and I have helped her out with nursery fees for dgc and a car when her old one broke but I don't feel the emotional closeness to my DD that I feel to my 2 DS's. My boys ring me and message me every few days and I see them often. I see DD and dhc about 4 times a year partly because of geographic distance but partly I'd rather spend time with my son's now. I felt like she chose to invite her Dad's OW to an event that she had no right to be at.

saraclara · 21/07/2023 20:18

I agree with this. You are really rubbing salt in her wounds by organising events that you expect her to socialise with her ex at.

So her daughter has to scrap her wedding?
OP isn't organisng family events at which MIL has to socialise with FIL. The birthday party and baby introduction were arranged so that they wouldn't be there at the same time. But that wasn't good enough for MIL.

The second half of the birthday party had to be moved to her house, where she ignored the birthday five year old except for making him cry.
The baby introduction...well despite being told that the OW wouldn't come at all, and that she and PIL would be there at different times, that wasn't good enough either. Her paranoia was such that she threatened to disown her own brand new grandchild.

OP and her DH have gone out of their way to support her, but after a year, yes, they get to live their lives reasonably normally and plan whatever family events they want. And SIL gets to have the wedding she wants.

caringcarer · 21/07/2023 20:12

Throwawayme · 20/07/2023 17:58

I feel a bit sorry for your mil to be honest. Sounds like it's all really raw for her and your family party sounds like it would be very hard for her. I imagine it's much easier for you all to accept and move on with your lives than for her. He probably was her while life. Maybe the new woman shouldn't be at your party?

I feel sorry for your MiL too. It's easy for you to move on your life partner hasn't betrayed you. I think it is insensitive to invite FiL and OW to your child's birthday party if your MiL is invited. She will feel very uncomfortable and probably will choose to stay away unless she knows her cheating exh is not going to turn up with the OW. Remember your MiL is the victim here. If FiL had not cheated she wouldn't be in this position. I'd send FiL a piece of cake and not invite him to your child's birthday party. I'd invite MiL and reassure her she won't get put in a difficult position. It might be that your SiL will have to choose between her Dad attending her wedding or her Mum, especially if he wants to bring OW.

Shudahaddogs · 21/07/2023 19:48

Darkandstormynite · 20/07/2023 18:17

I agree with this. You are really rubbing salt in her wounds by organising events that you expect her to socialise with her ex at.

She disabled, her husband has dumped her in her older years, she's probably financially hit and probably very scared. She doesn't have the option to rebuild her life the same way she would if she were younger. Do you really expect her to just smile and wave alongside the guy who blew her world apart? I think that's pretty naive.

If you've been cheated on in the past, you've at least had the chance to move on and rebuild your life, remember it's not the same for your MIL.

I'd be pretty disappointed in my family if they just wanted to airbrush my pain away for the sake of a social event.

Perfectly said

2Rebecca · 21/07/2023 19:35

I'm divorced. My ex remained in the " marital home" Any bills that were in my name or joint names got moved to his name when we separated ling before the divorce was finalised. The MIL is only 2 years older than me, not a frail old lady. Why would you be surprised when someone you are now divorced from stops paying your household bills? Why did sh not put the bills in her name years ago when they separated?

Why does the man have to be the provider and the woman expected to live off him? There are lots of sexist assumptions in this thread.

MentholLoad · 21/07/2023 15:43

Honeychickpea · 21/07/2023 15:32

Between that, disability bebfit and PIP, she can't be that badly off. Did she also get a settlement from the accident?
The son paying the bills sounds like she may be forcing him into the role of surrogate husband.

PIP IS disability benefit and it is £272/month

Honeychickpea · 21/07/2023 15:32

CatsSnore · 21/07/2023 14:41

And FIL had the worst end of the financial deal if MIL kept the house.

Between that, disability bebfit and PIP, she can't be that badly off. Did she also get a settlement from the accident?
The son paying the bills sounds like she may be forcing him into the role of surrogate husband.

CatsSnore · 21/07/2023 14:41

And FIL had the worst end of the financial deal if MIL kept the house.

Emz6103 · 21/07/2023 14:35

Exactly.....AIBU , we're divorced and he still expects me to pay his expensive landline bill and refuses to get a cheap £10 a month mobile....
Wonder how that would go down on here??

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 21/07/2023 14:07

TiredCatLady · 21/07/2023 13:40

To PP - the thing I’m getting at is that we don’t have FIL side of it.

Being cheated on and left in your 60s will be shit but then so is living with a controlling person. Abuse is abuse - whether it’s 10 days or 10 years.

Maybe he said nothing about the bills for fear of the reaction or because he was finally in a position to break away from it.

As I say - reverse the genders and many of the responses on here would be extremely different.

Agree. I bet FIL's life was hell for years. MIL sounds like a histrionic narcissist.

Turfwars · 21/07/2023 13:46

malificent7 · 21/07/2023 13:01

I wouldn't be having fil new woman coming to any events. If he objects, sod him. Your poor mil.

But nobody has ever said she was either invited, or welcome. The OP has made it clear that she's never been invited and won't for the foreseeable future.

It's all projection from the MIL. All of it.

The grilling they get as to whether they've spoken to FIL, if so, how often, have they seen OW, is she pretty etc... The OP has never met her. Her DH has met her only a couple of times at his dads house and kept it civil.

She wants them to carry nasty messages, spy for her, but also cut off their own dad as and when she demands - not because of what he did to them - but because she wants to spite her ex husband for what he did to her.

So now you have a MIL who absolutely created about a birthday (where there was no invite extended to OW, or FIL but even so half the birthday was moved to MILs house on demand, whereupon she made a child cry. There's no excuse for being a cunt to your grandchild on his birthday and making him cry because your husband fucked off.

And creating about an event for people to meet a new baby. She threw a tantrum about disowning a GC, knowing that the OP has never and would never invite any OW and certainly not give her first cuddle.

I've sympathy for the MIL, I really do. She deserves support but they ARE giving her that in every way they can. Any time that they've told FIL that he can't come or arranged an alternative, he's backed away. But even then, every single family event, even when he's not there, she makes it all about her situation.

So the OP, DH and SIL do need to put in boundaries - they've all been suggested uptread. They can do it with kindness but they need to do it. They could have another 40 years of MIL and FIL attending family events so they might as well set it in stone now.

CatsSnore · 21/07/2023 13:45

I don't think an exit affair is as bad as shagging around. People fall out of love, relationships fail, some people fall in love with other people, life works out.

Regulary cheating on someone and gaslighting them about it is different. That's abusive. Exit affairs not so much imo.

BadNomad · 21/07/2023 13:42

MentholLoad · 21/07/2023 13:40

I think statistically men DONT leave marriages until they have secured the next woman

Yes. Selfish pieces of shit don't care about anyone or anything other than themselves.

MentholLoad · 21/07/2023 13:40

BadNomad · 21/07/2023 12:17

Being in a shit marriage means she deserved to be cheated on?

Plenty of people leave shit marriages without being vile and nasty. Plenty of people end their marriages first before even looking for someone else to shag.

I think statistically men DONT leave marriages until they have secured the next woman

TiredCatLady · 21/07/2023 13:40

To PP - the thing I’m getting at is that we don’t have FIL side of it.

Being cheated on and left in your 60s will be shit but then so is living with a controlling person. Abuse is abuse - whether it’s 10 days or 10 years.

Maybe he said nothing about the bills for fear of the reaction or because he was finally in a position to break away from it.

As I say - reverse the genders and many of the responses on here would be extremely different.

Snugglemonkey · 21/07/2023 13:33

Justmuddlingalong · 20/07/2023 18:31

I think you have to invite everyone you want to be there. Tell them all you understand that emotions are running high, but you will not be involved in peoples demands. You are holding a celebration for your new DC and if anyone feels unable to attend without spoiling it by behaving badly then perhaps they shouldn't attend.

This. You are being supportive. You are there for her. But she cannot ruin family events. They can go and behave, or not go. If they kick off, they must be told to leave. A child's party is not a place for drama. There will be no alternative party.

Newestname002 · 21/07/2023 13:31

@TiredCatLady

It's not so much that FIL stopped paying his ex-Wife's bills, but that he did so without telling her, eg from one of Purewhitegold posts:

he cut off her main phone line for everyone as he paid for it, he didn’t tell her he’d stopped paying some of the bills until she got letters.

Maybe she should have considered what would happen to utility bills after the divorce but I'm sure she had other things she was trying to deal with at the time. 🌹

billy1966 · 21/07/2023 13:24

@TiredCatLady

That thread had the OP abused and working full-time and doing everything for a lazy abusive man.

Not similar IMO.

So often threads are compared with others that have the slimest of comparisons.

Whilst they didn't get on, I don't think there was any suggestion of abuse.

Also I believe that spouse had refused to contribute for many many years.

I wouldn't dream of criticising someone who was abused for years refusing to now be that persons carer.
Absolutely not.

It has been a decade but being abandoned in your 60's must really sting and her mobility issues will have shrunk her life immeasurably

I think it is hard to overstate how vulnerable she must feel and angry, to find herself disabled and dumped in your 60's.

Frankly, it doesn't bear thinking about.

Agree that SIL should sort her wedding out herself, and say a prayer she isn't marrying a man in her fathers likeness.

TiredCatLady · 21/07/2023 13:07

Having read your most recent update OP (and please can other posters do this), it’s clear there were issues in their marriage for a long time and MIL was extremely strict, demanding and controlling with the children.
It is not like she became disabled and he left the next day - the accident was over a decade ago and she’s been through rehab/therapy by the sounds of it. FIL has stuck with her through all of that but he’s still a relatively young man if MIL is now only 62.

A few weeks back a poster on here detailed being with a disabled husband, who was angry, financially controlling and with whom she felt trapped and lonely. Posters were quick to point out she was being financially abused and “well he can get PIP” and encouraged her to leave without guilt so she might have some happiness.

How is this different? Because the genders are reversed? Because someone doesn’t want to spend another 25 or more years of their life (on top of the last decade), being someone’s carer or, dare I say it, the subject of abuse? Stopping paying the bills is being termed petty and cruel - would it be the same if it was a woman who had stopped paying the bills? If it was the other way round so many posters would be cheering them on.

FIL seems to have stepped back, OW isn’t being pushed on anyone however MIL is being horrible - I mean, come on, how many times have posters railed against GPs upsetting kids and that’s exactly what she’s doing.

I really feel for OP - in her shoes, I’d be stepping back from MIL as well, at the very least until she stops weaponising the GCs to her own ends.

malificent7 · 21/07/2023 13:01

I wouldn't be having fil new woman coming to any events. If he objects, sod him. Your poor mil.

ejbaxa · 21/07/2023 12:58

2Rebecca · 21/07/2023 12:46

Not everyone makes vows in sickness and in health any more, most people have civil ceremonies. Also MIL's ill health may be only part of the reason he left her. I'm surprised so many people see marriage as a life sentence and don't seem to think anyone should be allowed to get divorced. We only get one life. Spending it shackled to someone you don't want to be with benefits no-one. Many mumsnetters seem to become Christian fundamentalists where divorce and the 12 commandments are concerned

If you’ve been married 40 ish years, yes of course you are allowed to get divorced - but the point is not to underestimate what this does to the dumped spouse of 40 years.

2Rebecca · 21/07/2023 12:46

Not everyone makes vows in sickness and in health any more, most people have civil ceremonies. Also MIL's ill health may be only part of the reason he left her. I'm surprised so many people see marriage as a life sentence and don't seem to think anyone should be allowed to get divorced. We only get one life. Spending it shackled to someone you don't want to be with benefits no-one. Many mumsnetters seem to become Christian fundamentalists where divorce and the 12 commandments are concerned