Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell them to grow up or you’re uninvited?

387 replies

Purewhitegold · 20/07/2023 17:53

MIL and FIL are newly divorced. FIL had an affair and is now engaged to the other woman. MIL is understandably upset and finding it hard to accept. FIL done this because of her disability ‘holding him back’ in his words. We are all angry with him for doing this rather than ending it amicably before pursuing other women, but we have all accepted the situation and want to carry on with our lives.
DH is trying to maintain his relationships with both parents separately and without taking sides. As it’s still raw for MIL she wants DH to cut him off and asks him to pass on (abusive) messages. She guilts him for speaking to FIL and ignores him for days if she thinks they have spent time together. FIL is angry and wants her to move on and leave him alone. He has made petty decisions like cutting off the phone line (she won’t use a mobile phone). It’s all very messy and unfair on their (adult) children and grandchildren. We know it’s hard for MIL being in this position so we are supporting her as much as we can, and I know from experience how much she’s hurting, however she is now being unfairly difficult towards us as a result.
We have a family gathering at the weekend to introduce our new baby to the wider family. MIL is refusing to come if we allow FIL to arrive first. If FIL partner holds the baby she will not consider the baby her grandchild. We have had a long list of ridiculous rules. She has cornered me to find out if FIL partner is prettier than her (I have never met her) and which of us she will consider her true MIL. I have tried to reassure her and spend time with her but it turns back to abusive gossip that makes us all uncomfortable.
SIL has her wedding coming up in September, she obviously wants her dad to walk her down the aisle. MIL is refusing to come to the wedding if FIL goes. SIL is obviously heartbroken.
MIL refused to come to our child’s birthday party at the weekend as FIL dropped in presents (then left) but she wouldn’t come in case he came back or brought his partner. So we had to spend the last part of our child’s birthday at her house where she gossiped about FIL and ignored the children. She told him his grandad should be here but he’s been horrible so he won’t come and made my child cry.
It’s taking it’s toll on DH and his sisters as they want to support their mother but her demands are becoming cruel.
SIL asked me to post to think up the best option moving forward. I have suggested they be encouraged to discuss arrangements together like adults and put to bed the passive aggressiveness for the sake of all the children or neither will be invited to any future events. Everyone thinks that’s unfair, but there needs to be a point where it stops?

OP posts:
AcrossthePond55 · 20/07/2023 22:39

Poor MiL. To get older, find herself disabled, then be kicked to the kerb for 'better' (younger?) model. I'd be angry, bitter, and frightened too. Especially if my family apparently didn't think it was a big enough deal to affect their relationship with the husband who dumped me so cruelly. If he was that unhappy, why didn't he see if the marriage could be saved, and if not why couldn't he have behaved with honour and left before he cheated? At least MiL would have been left with her dignity.

Perhaps if more people took a stand against this sort of thing and weren't so concerned with 'let's all just get along' maybe more would-be cheaters would think twice before taking up with an OW/OM. It used to be that cheats were ostracized from 'polite society' and were sent to Coventry. I'm not saying we should be that severe, but this attitude of 'never mind, off with the old on with the new' is disgusting.

Another thing that's disgusting is the number of men who desert their wives when their wives become seriously ill.

"However, researchers were surprised by the difference in separation and divorce rates by gender. The rate when the woman was the patient was 20.8 percent compared to 2.9 percent when the man was the patient."

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/11/091110105401.htm#:~:text=However%2C%20researchers%20were%20surprised%20by,the%20man%20was%20the%20patient.

Men Leave: Separation And Divorce Far More Common When The Wife Is The Patient

A woman is six times more likely to be separated or divorced soon after a diagnosis of cancer or multiple sclerosis than if a man in the relationship is the patient, according to a study that examined the role gender played in so-called "partner abando...

https://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2009/11/091110105401.htm#:~:text=However%2C%20researchers%20were%20surprised%20by,the%20man%20was%20the%20patient.

MentholLoad · 20/07/2023 22:37

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 20/07/2023 22:28

I would sit down with MIL and tell her the truth, that you don't want anything to do with OW and FIL has accepted that but she needs to get her shit together. It is so hard when someone treats you like utter shit yet everyone else 'doesn't want to take sides' but unfortunately that's her reality and she needs to deal with it. I am a huge fan of taking sides. When someone acts despicably I don't want to be around them. People continue to act despicably when they are safe in the knowledge that the people around them daren't say a word.

I am a huge fan of taking sides

👏👏👏👏

me too

saraclara · 20/07/2023 22:34

PollyThePixie · 20/07/2023 22:28

As adults I think it’s important they find a way to compromise for the sake of their children

OP, it’s way too soon for any compromise for the sake of the children. Especially on your mother in laws side. Have your gathering and don’t expect anything of either of them. Just let the dust settle a bit and remember that your MIL’s heartbroken and not capable of thinking beyond how much she’s hurting right now. My marriage broke up after 35 years. It still hurts like hell 10 years later even though I’m happy and I’ve made a good life for myself. My children still hurt also. You just don’t get over that length of a marriage breaking down in 6 months.

No-one's expecting her to be over it. But her behaviour is applling and she's taking it out on all the wrong people. Her five year old grandson for instance. How can you read what she did to him and think that's okay? It isn't.

Likewise her DD might be in her 30s, but the threats MIL is making re the wedding are just spiteful, however much she must be dreading it.

BanditsOnTheHorizon · 20/07/2023 22:34

I think you have to try and remove yourself from the situation

Invite them both, if your MIL won't come then tell her that's fine and don't engage, if she starts to ask questions about fil or be nasty etc simply say to her 'I'm not talking about this to you any longer, I'm here for you but I won't be party to you slagging him off and I won't be getting in the middle' then repeat every time.

Hopefully she'll realise she's missing out on things and start to come round.

My ex mil was like this after her dh ran off with her best friend. They can just about sit in the same room together now - after 39 years

MentholLoad · 20/07/2023 22:33

MentholLoad · 20/07/2023 22:23

her 'demands' aren't unreasonable. she is devastated and traumatized and needs to avoid seeing her cruel ex and the woman that he left her for. she is totally destabilised and disoriented. that isn't going to get better if her children continue to be neutral and start giving her ultimatums. I actually think the MIL would be better without any of them, until she has healed but that probably isn't realistic

actually, can I retract this and alot of my other posts please and apologise to OP. forr whatever reason, I hadn't seen any of OPs other posts on the thread besides the first. I can see that they have been supporting MIL substantially. please accept my apology

I would still invite MIL and not FIL to occasions until MIL felt comfortable though

hotchocandtwosmokybacon · 20/07/2023 22:33

I would just put myself in MIL shoes. Sadly seems noone cares about her pain and just want to move on. 6 months is not a long time. How long has she cared her family for over the years? It just shows her kids don't really care about her that much. She is entitled to take as much time to heal as possible. You should all help her to move on and not force her to and then blaming her for not behaving the way you all want her to. Her behaviour may be unreasonable to you but if she was not usually like this before FIL's betrayal, this obviously is how she tries to cope with the situation. I feel sad for your MIL.

saraclara · 20/07/2023 22:32

when she starts to bring it up, say to her I know you're hurting. I've already told you I won't be put in the middle of this as I love you both. So I'm changing the subject now. Then if she continues, repeat what has been said and say you need to talk to a professional about this because it's starting to affect everyone around you negatively.

That. And what she said to the child and made him cry is absolutely appalling, and I'd be bringing that up as a sign that she's affecting her relationships with the rest of you, and needs some counselling.

As for you being criticised for holding family events...what are those posters thinking? Two weddings? Two birthday parties for every family member? No, that's insane. You and your family need and deserve to live your lives normally. It's up to your PILs to navigate who comes to which half of birthday events.

Your SIL's wedding though...that's awful, and I honestly can't see a resolution there. If they both come, even if the OW isn't there, I foresee huge rows and the wedding being ruined, unless MIL gets some counselling pronto.

Epidote · 20/07/2023 22:31

OP I've read all your updates and you seems far more reasonable there that in the thread title.

Just give your MIL reassurance as you did telling her that there is no way OW will meet the baby at this point.

Be patient with her, she is hurt, lonely and she fears to be replaced in the family by OW. I'm not saying to tell yes to everything to her. But she need to know she still has her place in your lives.

Tell her to divorced and get half of everything. Hopefully will be something on the pot and she will be able to afford bills etc. Also encourage her to check if she can claim any benefit or money from him. It may be legal but abandon your life partner in a situation like this is completely inmoral.

anyolddinosaur · 20/07/2023 22:31

Your MIL's life has been torn apart and in cutting off the phone your FIL has shown he is a total shit but after a mere 6 months you want to treat them equally, that doesnt say a lot for you or your husband. In another 6 months when you have made it clear OW is not welcome then you can start telling MIL to rein it in. Until then just stick to you must not involve my children in this or you will not be welcome in my home.

Your husband should be making it clear to his dad that however much he loves him and wants to keep a relationship with him his father has been a shit and if he continues to treat his ex wife badly he is not going to be very welcome among civilised people.

I'd want dh to see his father away from my home for as long as FIL is financially abusive.

pillsthrillsandbellyache · 20/07/2023 22:28

I would sit down with MIL and tell her the truth, that you don't want anything to do with OW and FIL has accepted that but she needs to get her shit together. It is so hard when someone treats you like utter shit yet everyone else 'doesn't want to take sides' but unfortunately that's her reality and she needs to deal with it. I am a huge fan of taking sides. When someone acts despicably I don't want to be around them. People continue to act despicably when they are safe in the knowledge that the people around them daren't say a word.

PollyThePixie · 20/07/2023 22:28

As adults I think it’s important they find a way to compromise for the sake of their children

OP, it’s way too soon for any compromise for the sake of the children. Especially on your mother in laws side. Have your gathering and don’t expect anything of either of them. Just let the dust settle a bit and remember that your MIL’s heartbroken and not capable of thinking beyond how much she’s hurting right now. My marriage broke up after 35 years. It still hurts like hell 10 years later even though I’m happy and I’ve made a good life for myself. My children still hurt also. You just don’t get over that length of a marriage breaking down in 6 months.

DameEdna1 · 20/07/2023 22:27

I feel really sorry for your MIL, your FIL has been an absolute shithead. I suspect her extreme behaviour is because she feels a bit like she's screaming into the void- she KNOWS she's been horribly wronged, yet she's getting the impression that the rest of the family don't see it with all of this 'not taking sides' business. Your FIL has behaved appallingly and a totally appropriate consequence of his actions is that he doesn't get invited to family gatherings for a considerable period of time until the dust settles. Why should she miss out?

I really think in this situation you should either not have a party or not invite FIL and have him meet the baby another time.

Her behaviour trying to make people pass on messages and making your child cry is completely unacceptable and I'd be really firm and specific that you won't tolerate anything of that kind. But I'd also go to lengths to make her feel more secure- letting her have first hold of the baby before FIL, for example, and reassuring her that she doesn't need to worry about OW usurping her in your lives.

I also think this is your DH's responsibility to handle- you've been really kind being there for her but you're in a difficult situation as they're not your parents, plus you've just had a baby. I'm not sure your DH's neutrality is going to work.

MentholLoad · 20/07/2023 22:23

BreadInCaptivity · 20/07/2023 22:17

these aren't 5 year olds. they are adult children, presumably with moral compasses and at least average cognition/empathy/intelligence. why are they prioritising smooth running of social events/facade of normality over the MILs emotional damage/well being?

But they haven't been doing that if you read the posts.

They've been understanding and supportive.

They've made many accommodations to make things easier for MIL.

The problem is her demands are getting increasingly unreasonable.

It's not sustainable.

her 'demands' aren't unreasonable. she is devastated and traumatized and needs to avoid seeing her cruel ex and the woman that he left her for. she is totally destabilised and disoriented. that isn't going to get better if her children continue to be neutral and start giving her ultimatums. I actually think the MIL would be better without any of them, until she has healed but that probably isn't realistic

grayhairdontcare · 20/07/2023 22:22

So your FIL cheated on his wife and had her phone cut off and stopped paying her bills and you think she is overreacting??

DiscoDeborah · 20/07/2023 22:22

Livelovebehappy · 20/07/2023 22:20

Can’t you just have FIl and mil at these gatherings for the time being? Minus the OW? With it being very new, it’s clearly very difficult for your mil to move on yet, and must hurt massively to have his GF brought along to every family situation atm,when it’s still a new situation.

The OW isn't invited!

Livelovebehappy · 20/07/2023 22:20

Can’t you just have FIl and mil at these gatherings for the time being? Minus the OW? With it being very new, it’s clearly very difficult for your mil to move on yet, and must hurt massively to have his GF brought along to every family situation atm,when it’s still a new situation.

4timesthefun · 20/07/2023 22:18

To be honest, I don’t necessarily judge the cheating that harshly, but when people make mistakes, a decent person is usually apologetic and accepts the impact of their actions. To then be cruel and financially abusive speaks volumes about your FIL. I’d be bloody terrified about my marriage now. I’d lose all respect for DH if he didn’t take a far harder line with his father about his cruel behaviour after. If your FIL and DH were decent people, it would be pretty obvious that FIL doesn’t come to family parties (weddings different) while your MIL is in a space of extreme hurt. My guess is she is acting out, partially out of the grief of now knowing she also raised two pretty shit humans. That would almost be too much to bear for me.

DiscoDeborah · 20/07/2023 22:18

I absolutely understand how devastated your MIL is and rightly so.
He's behaved appallingly.

What's his financial situation and has he done anything to support his ex whilst she can get sorted. Abandoning his disabled wife and leaving his kids to financially support her makes him a shitty, horrible person. Can he afford to contribute? Can she sell up/downsize?

But, their kids do have a right to maintain a relationship with him and I can understand they want to do this in some capacity.

I think the children all need to speak to their mum and explain that they support her, they love her but this has to stop. She stops making her kids and grandchildren feel shit, she stops making demands and she needs to find a way to accept her kids seeing their dad. Not because it's fair and it won't be easy but because it's not helping her or anyone else.
The way she is behaving is manipulative and will alienate every one.

Then dad needs to be told to behave like an adult too. Stop sulking about his OW not being accepted. She doesn't have the right to be part of your family unless the family want her to.
He also needs to understand and respect he's put a bomb in the middle of everyone's lives so he needs to suck up the discomfort.

BreadInCaptivity · 20/07/2023 22:17

these aren't 5 year olds. they are adult children, presumably with moral compasses and at least average cognition/empathy/intelligence. why are they prioritising smooth running of social events/facade of normality over the MILs emotional damage/well being?

But they haven't been doing that if you read the posts.

They've been understanding and supportive.

They've made many accommodations to make things easier for MIL.

The problem is her demands are getting increasingly unreasonable.

It's not sustainable.

IcedBananas · 20/07/2023 22:16

Hang on, he had an affair, then left his wife and then cut off his abandoned disabled wife’s phone line. That’s not petty that’s appalling. All in the last 6 months. I’d be surprised if they can ever be in the same room again. No chance if this has all been happening in the last 6 months. Your MIL does not need more exposure to this awful ex just because it’s easier for you all. Nor does she need to be effectively cut off from family events by you all insisting that he attends. You need to plan events so that only 1 is there at a time and make 100% sure they don’t cross paths as they leave/enter (or even pop in to drop off gifts!). Even for SILs wedding id say it’s too soon to have them together. Try to get some kind of agreement where they both attend half and don’t need to see each other. As for MIL making your child cry. She’s not being logical or sensible at all because she’s so emotional. That kind of thing needs to stop. You’ll just have to be firm. If she’s willing some counselling may help. But you all have to adjust to this new reality where MIL and FIL can’t be in same place. Family events will never be as easy or fun as before there’s no getting around that. There are long term consequences of FILs behaviour for the whole extended family unfortunately

drpet49 · 20/07/2023 22:14

GoodChat · 20/07/2023 18:40

MIL doesn't have to attend the 'meet the baby' party. She doesn't get to dictate who holds your baby or who arrives when, though.

You all need to he firm with her.

If she chooses not to attend gatherings, parties, weddings, that's fine. But she needs to realise she's only hurting the people she loves.

This. I feel sorry for the MIL but she is being very manipulative here.

MentholLoad · 20/07/2023 22:09

BreadInCaptivity · 20/07/2023 21:57

Children (even as adults) should never be made to take sides between their parents.

They are not extensions of our relationships with our spouse.

They have parental relationships in their own right.

these aren't 5 year olds. they are adult children, presumably with moral compasses and at least average cognition/empathy/intelligence. why are they prioritising smooth running of social events/facade of normality over the MILs emotional damage/well being?

Damnedidont · 20/07/2023 22:07

readbooksdrinktea · 20/07/2023 22:01

This is what I'm thinking too.

And me!

Highdaysandholidays1 · 20/07/2023 22:02

@BreadInCaptivity I agree. It's up to the children how they relate to their parents, plus in most instances they are genetically related (50%) to the parent whereas of course the MIL is not related to the FIL.

Reading the OP again, I don't see why people say that the OP and her family have been cruel- they are paying her bills, inviting the MIL, supporting her, cutting short a birthday party to go to her house, listening to her moan.

The MIL is actively punishing her own child for having a relationship by asking them to cut them off and not speaking to them for days if they have contact.

That's not ok at all, I don't see MIL as at all justified in her behaviour, it's extremely destructive.

In about 1/3 of marriages in the states, the divorce occurs after the wife gets ill. There's no such relationship when the husband does. FIL is a shit, there's a lot of them about, the DH here has to forge his own relationship he is not an extension of his mum and her extreme anger.

readbooksdrinktea · 20/07/2023 22:01

Mikimoto · 20/07/2023 20:43

Why does DH want a relationship with his adulterous father who split up the family?
Why does SIL need to be walked down the aisle by her adulterous father who split up the family?

This is what I'm thinking too.