Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell them to grow up or you’re uninvited?

387 replies

Purewhitegold · 20/07/2023 17:53

MIL and FIL are newly divorced. FIL had an affair and is now engaged to the other woman. MIL is understandably upset and finding it hard to accept. FIL done this because of her disability ‘holding him back’ in his words. We are all angry with him for doing this rather than ending it amicably before pursuing other women, but we have all accepted the situation and want to carry on with our lives.
DH is trying to maintain his relationships with both parents separately and without taking sides. As it’s still raw for MIL she wants DH to cut him off and asks him to pass on (abusive) messages. She guilts him for speaking to FIL and ignores him for days if she thinks they have spent time together. FIL is angry and wants her to move on and leave him alone. He has made petty decisions like cutting off the phone line (she won’t use a mobile phone). It’s all very messy and unfair on their (adult) children and grandchildren. We know it’s hard for MIL being in this position so we are supporting her as much as we can, and I know from experience how much she’s hurting, however she is now being unfairly difficult towards us as a result.
We have a family gathering at the weekend to introduce our new baby to the wider family. MIL is refusing to come if we allow FIL to arrive first. If FIL partner holds the baby she will not consider the baby her grandchild. We have had a long list of ridiculous rules. She has cornered me to find out if FIL partner is prettier than her (I have never met her) and which of us she will consider her true MIL. I have tried to reassure her and spend time with her but it turns back to abusive gossip that makes us all uncomfortable.
SIL has her wedding coming up in September, she obviously wants her dad to walk her down the aisle. MIL is refusing to come to the wedding if FIL goes. SIL is obviously heartbroken.
MIL refused to come to our child’s birthday party at the weekend as FIL dropped in presents (then left) but she wouldn’t come in case he came back or brought his partner. So we had to spend the last part of our child’s birthday at her house where she gossiped about FIL and ignored the children. She told him his grandad should be here but he’s been horrible so he won’t come and made my child cry.
It’s taking it’s toll on DH and his sisters as they want to support their mother but her demands are becoming cruel.
SIL asked me to post to think up the best option moving forward. I have suggested they be encouraged to discuss arrangements together like adults and put to bed the passive aggressiveness for the sake of all the children or neither will be invited to any future events. Everyone thinks that’s unfair, but there needs to be a point where it stops?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Coulditreallybe · 16/10/2023 23:23

Hope things are better @Purewhitegold ?

Emz6103 · 24/07/2023 00:25

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Emz6103 · 24/07/2023 00:13

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Acornsoup · 23/07/2023 19:15

Your MIL is not able to properly moderate her emotions at the moment. This is a relatively new and very difficult situation for her and she is still coming to terms with it. She is making demands because she feels completely powerless and vulnerable. That is not to say her behaviour is acceptable.

I suggest you ask DH and SIL to help MIL source counselling (talking matters is free). And GP for help with depression and anxiety. Then they should help her look at are finances - you and DH paying her bills is not reasonable. They are newly divorced but have they agreed financial settlement yet?

I don't understand why you would invite FIL to the 'meet the baby' event by or any other 'event' for a while. You have created a lot of unnecessary drama for yourselves and MIL. He will be ok if he's not invited - he might not like it, but really he doesn't really care about any of you and he put ALL of you in this situation. FWIW I wouldn't do that to my DM.

SIL wedding is not your concern. Hopefully with counselling and time MIL will be better able to adjust to her new situation. There is no reason I can see other than the wedding why MIL should ever have to see FIL again (and this can be managed). A lot of MNers have been in this position.

Obviously she knows OW will eventually also be another grandparent to baby. This is unavoidable if you are going to maintain contact with FIL.

I am sorry that you are feeling burdened with all of this. Maybe try having the next few meetings in public so it's not as easy for her to behave as you have described and you can make your excuses to leave when you want too. Any sign of manipulation nip it in the bud.

Good luck OP and congratulations :)

TammyJones · 23/07/2023 12:38

@YSoSirius

@TammyJones

I did actually say this
'
don't care how hurt she is or how much worse the grandfather is

But it was meant in the context of regardless of OPs MILs hurt, she should never have made her grandchildren cry so she could get her dig in at her ex. It's wrong and selfish. I'll never change my mind about that

^^^*
Apologies it wasn't clear and it had be quoted by someone else but they'd not put your name by it.

I agree with your posts.

YSoSirius · 23/07/2023 11:56

Highdaysandholidays1 · 23/07/2023 11:24

I think sometimes the wronged parent forgets that in the vast majority of cases, they are not genetically related to the 'bad' parent but the children are- it's 50% of their genetics. So hating on their other parent is like hating on part of their children, and why the children feel damaged by that. Now, if the children decide themselves that they don't want anything to do with the cheating parent, that's different. But most people do want to have some relationship with their parents, even if they are flawed and not perfect and trying to prevent that, under the guise of a moral crusade, is very wrong. My mum left me to sort out my own relationship with my dad and that's absolutely correct IMO.

Yes this. Something I have said before to my parent.

Highdaysandholidays1 · 23/07/2023 11:24

I think sometimes the wronged parent forgets that in the vast majority of cases, they are not genetically related to the 'bad' parent but the children are- it's 50% of their genetics. So hating on their other parent is like hating on part of their children, and why the children feel damaged by that. Now, if the children decide themselves that they don't want anything to do with the cheating parent, that's different. But most people do want to have some relationship with their parents, even if they are flawed and not perfect and trying to prevent that, under the guise of a moral crusade, is very wrong. My mum left me to sort out my own relationship with my dad and that's absolutely correct IMO.

YSoSirius · 23/07/2023 11:20

@TammyJones

I did actually say this

don't care how hurt she is or how much worse the grandfather is

But it was meant in the context of regardless of OPs MILs hurt, she should never have made her grandchildren cry so she could get her dig in at her ex. It's wrong and selfish. I'll never change my mind about that

YSoSirius · 23/07/2023 11:17

Sirius, you’ve held onto your anger and hatred and resentment toward your mother for your whole life. It could be you’re more like your mother than you thought

I don't hate them at all, I have a good relationship with them (never said it was my mother either who was the injured party).

But I acknowledge now as an adult that their behaviour in front of and toward me was inappropriate and it definitely damaged me into adulthood so yes I think the way they behaved was selfish and more about them and their feelinfs rather than what was best for me, their child. It's also made me promise myself never to place my child in the middle or weaponise them if the same situation happens to me because I know how it feels to be that child. No matter what you tell yourself, making your child take sides because of an issue that happened between their parents is not good parenting. It is selfish. Perhaps understandable but selfish and wrong still and it shouldn't happen.

I am not the only poster on here who's been put in that situation by their parent who has said it was horrible for them. And it really rather does come back to bite in the sense that I look back now rather unfavourably at the way the parent who was cheated on behaved toward me and I haven't forgotten it.

And yes I refuse to let my children now be put through the same by them so it's move on and act how you should have done when I was a child or don't have a relationship with their grandchildren. Thankfully they chose the former.

TammyJones · 23/07/2023 11:07

@MysteryBelle
Bit confused now but they are your words NOT
@YSoSirius
*

TammyJones
@MysteryBelle
The 10 year old child did not side with the cheater
Quote from @YSoSirius

I had this all through my childhood, one parent cheated on the other which was completely wrong of course but in the end it was actually the parent who was cheated on that caused me the most damage way into adulthood.
^^
She said it 'was completely wrong'
That is NOT siding with the cheater.
BUT she did want to see her Dad.
Just because her parents had problems, none of this is ever the child's fault.
The children are innocent in this.
@MysteryBelle
“I don't care how hurt she is or how much worse the grandfather is.”

TammyJones · 23/07/2023 11:01

@MysteryBelle

“I don't care how hurt she is or how much worse the grandfather is.”

^^*
Eh?
You don't can't about 10 yrs old child ?
Children always come first
The mil made her 5 yr old grandchild CRY
I know she's hurting but now MIL is Hurting everyone else.
Op is asking for advise about how to move forward

Quote from op
@Purewhitegold

It’s taking it’s toll on DH and his sisters as they want to support their mother but her demands are becoming cruel.
^^^^^^
It seems op's MIL , in her understandable grief / bitterness, doesn't now care either, what she says or who she hurts.
Making her GS cry on his birthday- come on!!

MysteryBelle · 23/07/2023 11:00

YSoSirius · 23/07/2023 10:23

Because no matter how hurt you are, making your grandchildren cry over it is wrong? What's so hard to understand?

Again, here are your own words,

“I don't care how hurt she is or how much worse the grandfather is.”

There is a thing called a moral compass and also a concept called empathy. Neither can be found in Op’s posts nor in the posters’ comments who think what fil did is forgivable but what mil did is unforgivable.

There is a scene in It’s a Wonderful Life when George Bailey is a young boy working for Mr. Bower. Hopefully you’ve seen it, it’s probably one of the best films ever made. Yes it’s just a film but it illustrates something important.

Druggist Mr. Bower is drunk and accidentally and unknowingly fills a prescription bottle with the wrong thing, actually poison, and tells George to deliver it. Mr. Bower is drunk and incoherent because he had received a telegram informing him that his son has died of influenza. George does not deliver the bottle. Mr. Gower hits George out of anger and frustration and grief. George then tells Mr. Gower that the bottle had poison in it and importantly, tells him he knows Mr. Gower is upset because of his son. They go on to have a lifelong bond.

Sirius, you’ve held onto your anger and hatred and resentment toward your mother for your whole life. It could be you’re more like your mother than you thought.

It's a Wonderful Life - George and the druggist

1946 - Frank CapraWon academy awards for : Best Picture - Best Director - Best actor : James Stewart

https://youtu.be/X8QA95mTcbI

YSoSirius · 23/07/2023 10:28

I don't think every single reaction by the hurt party is always excusable. Especially when it comes to emotionally harming their own children or grandchildren because they have been hurt. You should be accountable for how you behave hurt or not and making your own grandchildren cry because of something their grandfather did to you is wrong. In OPs shoes I'd be saying I understand why she's hurting but it's not my children's responsibility to heal her and they cannot be expected to bear her emotions on their young shoulders so if it happens again she won't be seeing them until she can better control herself around them.

It's wrong to place the onus on the children to take sides or to listen to you bitch. Whatever the circumstances. They are children, it is not their problem.

YSoSirius · 23/07/2023 10:23

MysteryBelle · 23/07/2023 10:02

“I don't care how hurt she is or how much worse the grandfather is.”

Because no matter how hurt you are, making your grandchildren cry over it is wrong? What's so hard to understand?

MysteryBelle · 23/07/2023 10:17

janeyredlion · 20/07/2023 20:13

Totally agree with @MysteryBelle

Fil Has behaved appallingly. To all of you. He has brought this on your family. What kind of monster deliberately ensures an elderly disabled woman who now (presumably?) lives alone doesn't have a phone!!! (Just one example of his awful selfish behaviour)

As for sil... is she 12? "daddy's girl wants daddy to walk her down the aisle"?? Sometimes the right thing is to judge a little when someone behaves so badly. Respect and adoration of a parent are not unconditional. If he had abused a child would daddy's girl still want him walking her down the aisle?

I know you are just trying to do what's best for everyone OP and this isn't your circus.... but I think all of you should stop with the "it is what it is" and if mil feels a bit of empathy and understanding from her family she might heal a little and stop behaving so unpleasantly

Yes the fil is a monster, how he’s treated his wife, but everybody’s contemptuous of her not him and can’t understand why she doesn’t want to attend family gatherings with him. And can’t understand why she would appreciate someone actually standing up for her.

It would take so little (genuine support) to reassure her but they can’t even do that. Many of us have suggested specific things to do but no, mil must be humiliated at the family gatherings or else not come. 🙄

CatsSnore · 23/07/2023 10:14

Forcing a child to choose sides is emotional abuse. I was made to choose my dad as he was the 'injured' party. Really screwed me up! Even now when either side of my family slag off the other it does something to me in the way it makes me feel. I hate it.

For context my Dc dad cheated on me. I couldn't care less anymore and we go out for birthday meals altogether, have the odd conversation, he will be in my life forever with graduations, weddings, birthdays, grandchildren etc. I rarely ever think about what he did. My dc was never in the middle of it, never made to choose sides and as much as I don't like him I can get along on a surface level with him just fine. Why would you want to make your dc feel awful about something their other parent has done. I don't need validation from my dc, I don't have a deep desire to be my dcs only parent, their world and want my dc to have as much love and support that is available to them. Why would any mother want their dc to be mixed up emotionally over what went on in their parents relationship. It's their business and not the child/adult childs.

MysteryBelle · 23/07/2023 10:02

TammyJones · 23/07/2023 08:19

@MysteryBelle
The 10 year old child did not side with the cheater
Quote from @YSoSirius

I had this all through my childhood, one parent cheated on the other which was completely wrong of course but in the end it was actually the parent who was cheated on that caused me the most damage way into adulthood.
^^
She said it 'was completely wrong'
That is NOT siding with the cheater.
BUT she did want to see her Dad.
Just because her parents had problems, none of this is ever the child's fault.
The children are innocent in this.

“I don't care how hurt she is or how much worse the grandfather is.”

YSoSirius · 23/07/2023 09:57

Still stand by the fact is selfish as hell to expect a child to take sides between their parents.

I've witnessed this from another side too in fact. My husband has children with his ex, who cheated on him, he has NEVER ever expected his children to not see or love their mother anymore because she hurt him. He appreciates she is still their mum and that is an important relationship and one they shouldn't sacrifice to save his feelings. Probably because he's not selfish and doesn't expect young kids to manage his feelings for him.

He can't stand here and is looking forward to the day he no longer needs to speak to her regularly but whilst his kids are young he slaps on a fake smile at the door and never bad mouths her in front of them. Because it's a shit thing to do and I'm surprised anyone would call it good parenting to expect a child to take sides in a separation.

Adelyra · 23/07/2023 08:28

I would:

A - lay down the law with MIL very very firmly. Not you - her adult children need to do so as a joint enterprise.

B - see them in shifts that day or uninvite them from the event and get them to meet baby on different set days.

Or

C - tell both of them you are taking a break from both until they can keep their issues to themselves.

It's fine for MIL to be very upset, but it sounds like she is very manipulative and emotionally abusive. Maybe her disability isn't the sole motor in FIL cheating & leaving. (Good grief! why would he ever tell another soul about leaving her because she is disabled...).

TammyJones · 23/07/2023 08:19

@MysteryBelle
The 10 year old child did not side with the cheater
Quote from @YSoSirius

I had this all through my childhood, one parent cheated on the other which was completely wrong of course but in the end it was actually the parent who was cheated on that caused me the most damage way into adulthood.
^^
She said it 'was completely wrong'
That is NOT siding with the cheater.
BUT she did want to see her Dad.
Just because her parents had problems, none of this is ever the child's fault.
The children are innocent in this.

TammyJones · 23/07/2023 08:13

@Fabulousdahlink
Good post.
Made me think back over the last 30 year. Not quite the same but not had one single 'joint' do with my ex.
Never came up.
DD would visit her dad and partner, every other weekend- but DD didn't attend her own graduation, will probably never get married or have children.
For her 18th we took her out for a meal (she didn't want a party ) and then she went off afterwards to meet friends.
My dh has attended one christening in 30 odd years when his ex wife was there. He said a polite hello and that was it. (I had a long chat with her as I like her) I wasn't the OW though - ex wife left him.
My point is you can avoid these things.

MysteryBelle · 23/07/2023 08:05

Tammy, if a 10 year old is siding with the cheater, as the poster made clear he, or she, did and does, then I think that’s weird and I would wonder, just out of curiosity, why the child 1) is choosing sides, and why he 2) is choosing the cheater. His mother probably was baffled too and was trying to figure it out.

TammyJones · 23/07/2023 07:57

@YSoSirius
I completely get where you're coming from.
I'm sorry this happened to you.
Your mother was bang out of Oder
@MysteryBelle can't you see how inappropriate it is bad mouth the other parent to a 10 year old child is?
To the point of blaming said parent for any preconceived personality 'flaws'?
It is sad what happened to op's mil but to bring children into an argument to score points off the other parent is unacceptable and abusive.

Fabulousdahlink · 23/07/2023 07:39

I have been where your MIL has been, married 25 years before FIL left for someone else.
They are still together after 6 years and I have not spoken to him for several years.

It took at least 4 years for the anger and betrayal to fade to a point where his name could be.mentioned, and my then early teen children do an excellent job of keeping in touch with him separately. We have a rule that there are two separate lives going on now, and they do stuff with him ( which I dont need to know about) and stuff at home ( which he does not need to know about). They do a good job of enjoying both sets of parents and their new partners without involving anyone else.
He was a lousy cheating husband and a dreadful liar and a pretty much absent dad, but I recognise that they want to see him as much as they want to see me. We just do it separately.

Honestly, I've no desire to see him or attend any event where he is present, as he's very much a stranger to me, I've no longer any rage, happily remarried now, but out of respect for other family members we no longer attend 'joint' family dos. He does his family thing, We do ours. Neither of us would dream of attending anything jointly.

I did not attend his parents funerals but sent a card to his family expressing my sadness and sharing some happy memories of them.

I suggest that you and your family accept your MIL pain and distress as it is deep and long lasting. Arrange separate opportunities for meeting with FIL and MIL independently, not two parties for everything, just invite MIL to meet the baby before FIL , not on the same day, but for coffee. Alternate invitations to parties. Christmas etc. Agree with your other family members a system and stick with it . It works well for us here. I didnt expect an invitation to his parents funeral ( although they were my in laws for 25 years and I loved them dearly) nor did I invite him to my wedding last year. None of his business!

Separate people seperate lives will make it easier for everyone, the expectation that they can all just move on and be civil now just isnt the case, clearly nor might it ever be.Joint family events are over now their marriage is over, regrettably I think you must accept that both of them at the same event isnt good. Organise and invite one to one thing, one to another.
I am happy without being any part of my exes life, but happy for my children ( and future grandchildren) to be part of his life if that is what they need. He does not deserve their love and attention, but it is important to them, so I let them get on with it without involving me. I am healed and happy, as are my teens by running two happy seperate household events.

I personally dont like that my teens call her family granny and uncle x and nephews y, as they really arent, but this isnt those.peoples fault and they are in their lives and must call them something. I cant insist or micromanage this so I.let it ride. Seperate lives, much easier.

My advice to you all is to accept that joint family events where both will attend, that time is over. Arrange seperate events for MIL to do special things with you and her grandkids. ( not two 18ths, two christmases etc) and ensure that both FIL and MIL have equal opportunities with you all, but separately. We are all quite used to this arrangement here and it's quite 'normal' now .
I feel for you all, but this solution has definitely worked for our extended family.
Finally, Be aware of social media though. I dont want to see his holiday pictures, his Christmas with my kids or their party they threw for a christening, wedding or 18th.
Help your MIL to clean up , block and delete those contacts. So she doesnt feel she has been left out from celebrating and encourage her to be involved in organising some of your family events, but ask family and friends to be mindful of what pictures they post.

For example, for my sons 18th I posted a pic of his cake and a few pics of him and his friends. Didnt include any family so no one feels omitted.

YSoSirius · 23/07/2023 06:43

What? I replied to your comment on a single thread and that's stalking? 🤣 weirdo.

Don't comment if you don't want a reply.