Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Cancer charity coffee mornings should be banned

371 replies

Luxell934 · 20/07/2023 16:12

So someone on instagram, who usually gives advice to new mums on positive birthing, posted today that she though coffee mornings for cancer charities should be banned. Why? because she thinks cancer loves sugar, cancer grows from sugar and people shouldn't be giving sugar to cancer patients. She said instead of eating cakes and biscuits they should be helping cancer patients to educate themselves to change their diets to beat the disease.

My own personal opinion is that she is spreading complete misinformation to her followers not based on any actual factual studies.

For a start these coffee mornings are not held in the hospital rooms of cancer patients to feed them cake. They’re fundraising events often in school halls, offices, community centres or hospitals as a support system where people are coming together to support and raise money for those diagnosed with cancer. They don't target cancer patients, it's more about the general public raising funds for cancer nurses and research. Cancer coffee mornings are just one of the ways charities fund raise. They also do lots of fitness based ones, like the muddy 5k run, race for life, some do walking based ones. Although not everyone would be able to do something physical for charity, so they might choose the coffee morning. Let's face it, cake is nice right, if it was advertised as a green tea and carrot stick morning, it wouldn't be as popular.

Yes I agree sugar isn't healthy for us. We should all reduce our refined sugar intake. Excess sugar can lead to weight gain which can cause serious health issues including diabetes and obesity which could be a contributing factor to some cancers. BUT cancer is not caused by sugar alone, and cancer can't be cured by cutting out sugar. Cancer also can't be cured by diet alone. I've heard the stories of people saying "My husband cured his stage 4 lung cancer by diet alone!" Right.

There is also no actual evidence that cancer cells grow from sugar. All cells, including cancer cells need glucose (blood sugar) to survive. Glucose comes from any carbohydrate, refined carbs (cake, bread) and unrefined carbs (fruit, veg). Glucose is critical for our cells to survive and function properly. Not consuming sufficient carbohydrates can lead to the breakdown of protein stores in our body, which can contribute to muscle loss and possibly malnutrition. There is no possible way for our bodies to stop cancer cells from getting the glucose and only giving it to the healthy cells.

So should cancer coffee mornings be banned?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
12
BestBeforeddmmyy · 22/07/2023 14:33

This kind of message drives me nuts. I have stage 4 cancer and I have been slightly underweight most of my adult life. I went to the gym before work most days, for over 20 years and before that I cycled to and from work. I have eaten a vegetarian diet since I was 4 (ie 61 years).
Whoever said that you can avoid cancer by eating a healthy diet and keeping fit is only partly right. Some people can avoid cancer this way, but not all. It’s down to genetics in the main. My cancer is hormone induced and no one could have prevented it.
Enjoy your lives everyone and don’t live in fear. No one lives forever and that’s it. My oncologists are pleased I am still alive 4 years after my diagnosis and think that my healthy lifestyle choices MAY have POSSIBLY helped me to live longer post-diagnosis. But better than that, have been chemo, and radiation.

threatmatrix · 22/07/2023 13:25

Drews · 20/07/2023 16:13

There such things as sugar free cakes.

But the use sweeteners which are worse for you.

AutisticLegoLover · 22/07/2023 13:16

It's always interesting to see that on threads about cake or other foods classed as unhealthy that the names from the weight loss board are very present usually extolling the virtues of keto/low carb as a save-all and demonising sugar as the cause-all. These posters are usually not a healthy weight so I'm not convinced they're methods are great. My name is on those threads but I love carbs and am a sugar fiend. I've still lost over 2 stone. Life's too short to not eat cake occasionally. A small slice a day of something like homemade fruit cake or a light sponge wouldn't be terrible either. It's all about balance. There are so many food issues on mumsnet and it's very sad. Let's not demonise food.

LlynTegid · 22/07/2023 11:46

I get the concern about unhealthy eating. Encouraging fruit and other non-sugary alternatives for a coffee morning to be available I think is a better way.

Againstmachine · 22/07/2023 11:44

Pretty much a lot of what I have seen from this thread on the cakes bad side is just the usual Keto obsessives who think keto is the cure to everything. These people treat keto like a cult and they don't deserve any time at all.

sunglassesonthetable · 22/07/2023 11:40

And I noticed that the one instagram bod has removed the post & closed messaging after reams of kick back and objection to her shite sweeping statements.

sunglassesonthetable · 22/07/2023 11:37

@LMNT

@eyesopenedatlast

No comment?

Nannyseaside · 22/07/2023 08:09

No I don't think coffee mornings to raise funds for any cancer charity's should be banned,,I am a cancer survivor and without the research into cancer treatments I properly wouldn't be here now, writing this,so carry on with the coffee mornings and fund raising,and let's help alot more people survive cancer

sunglassesonthetable · 22/07/2023 07:42

The PP seems to be unaware that cancer doctors in the private sector and cancer doctors in the NHS are the same doctors. They're NHS doctors doing private work as well. And if they thought a treatment worked they'd use it, NHS or private. Oncologists and haematologists talk to each other, across the world, within their speciality. They routinely fight for trial drugs and compassionate access for their patients. There are not private doctors in onc and haem just keeping stuff for their paying patients.

This

Rosebel · 22/07/2023 06:45

JusthereforXmas · 20/07/2023 18:22

Also my mam could only stomach sweet stuff during chemo, her whole diet change and sugary stuff was all she could keep down.

FIL was the same. Until he got cancer he had a very healthy diet but during treatment his eating habit changed totally. Unfortunately he didn't survive but find it insulting that some people blame cancer on sugar.

SeaToSki · 22/07/2023 00:26

Cancer is caused by a mutation in the genetic material in a cell that causes it to reproduce in a non normal way (often over reproduce which is why tumors build up)

What causes the mutation is a whole different kettle of fish. We have proof on a very few causes, radiation above a certain level, exposure to some chemicals above a certain level and most worryingly just sheer random chance as our genetic material just randomly mutates all on its own, and this builds up as we age.

Scientists have been trying to pin down factors that can accelerate our natural random mutation speed, but havent found many concrete links, just a whole lot of ‘well there is a chance’.

Correlation does not mean causation.

Elevenutionary · 22/07/2023 00:02

Big Pharma 🤣🤣. Makes me howl. Do people seriously think that there’s a conspiracy amongst medics, keeping ‘natural treatments’ quiet so they can shill Big Pharma Products and get paid for doing so?? So many medics worldwide keeping a secret. Yes, yes, that seems completely reasonable. Seriously. Give yer head a Big Wobble.
So insulting.

The so called ‘alternative, natural’ industry makes far higher profits than Big Pharma. That’s the real shill.

Sugar free diet. 🙄 Would that it were so easy.

Jesus wept at what people will believe. Sad.

angelfacecuti75 · 21/07/2023 23:49

Drews · 20/07/2023 16:13

There such things as sugar free cakes.

But they suck...

JFM27 · 21/07/2023 23:37

Perhaps she would like to meet me.i hsd breast cancer 8 yrs sgo.iver never had a sweet tooth,never have sugar in tea or coffee,never eat cakes or biscuits,in fact only sweet i eat is dark chocolate and that h as less sugar than any chocolate. And i weigh same as when i was in my 20s..

Mine i was told was caused by my long term use of HRT taken to avoid the awful osteoporosis my mum had, i havent got that and no after effects of the cancer or treatment.

RockyReef · 21/07/2023 23:37

LMNT · 20/07/2023 16:18

Good lord your post is horrendously wrong about the links between sugar and cancer.

When you get a scan to check for cancer they inject you irradiated GLUCOSE because guess where the glucose goes first?!

I suggest you look at the work of Otto Warburg and Thomas Seyfried.

She is 100% right that sugar feeds cancer.

Ha! "When you get a scan to check for cancer" yes that really makes you sound as if you work in clinical oncology! I can categorically state (as I have cancer and going through treatment now) that you don't "get A scan" (in fact I have had numerous different scans) and I have not been injected with irradiated glucose for any of them!

Good lord YOUR post is horrendously wrong, not just about scans and cancer, but also that all cancers are fed by sugars. Mine is driven by something completely different and I can assure you it wasn't caused by eating sugar either, rather by a faulty gene 🙄🙄🙄

nothingcomestonothing · 21/07/2023 23:34

TopOfTheCliff · 21/07/2023 23:13

“This approach is not mainstream yet, but docs in the private sector are using the technique “
That sets off alarm bells for me. Do you not think that if it worked NICE would approve it for NHS use? My cancer clinic promotes exercise to prevent Recurrence of breast cancer for which there is solid evidence. They would adopt any treatment if it was evidence based because they have our best interests at heart. My DD is an oncology trainee and I know how much she cares.

The PP seems to be unaware that cancer doctors in the private sector and cancer doctors in the NHS are the same doctors. They're NHS doctors doing private work as well. And if they thought a treatment worked they'd use it, NHS or private. Oncologists and haematologists talk to each other, across the world, within their speciality. They routinely fight for trial drugs and compassionate access for their patients. There are not private doctors in onc and haem just keeping stuff for their paying patients.

littlegrebe · 21/07/2023 23:23

@eyesopenedatlast When my grandmother was diagnosed with bowel cancer in the 1970s no one expected her to live, and they were right, she had some treatment but it didn't stop the cancer and she died. When my DH was diagnosed with the same cancer 2 years ago the oncologist was very clear he was taking a curative approach and that didn't change when the cancer spread and became stage 4. He is now completely cancer free thanks to immunotherapy, a new type of treatment which teaches the body's own immune system how to fight the cancer cells. He didn't even need to have surgery on his bowel, which is a very big deal because the old standard surgery would have left him shitting into a bag for the rest of his life.

I'm not sure what planet you'd have to be living on to think that didn't constitute a significant development in the treatment of one of the most common cancers in the world. To be fair I know you're not listening but the thought that someone in DH's position recently diagnosed might read the shameful rubbish you and others have been posting on here and decide to turn down proper treatment in favour of a fad diet horrifies me so I couldn't leave it unchallenged.

TopOfTheCliff · 21/07/2023 23:13

“This approach is not mainstream yet, but docs in the private sector are using the technique “
That sets off alarm bells for me. Do you not think that if it worked NICE would approve it for NHS use? My cancer clinic promotes exercise to prevent Recurrence of breast cancer for which there is solid evidence. They would adopt any treatment if it was evidence based because they have our best interests at heart. My DD is an oncology trainee and I know how much she cares.

Finlandia · 21/07/2023 22:41

Er, no they don’t

simiisme · 21/07/2023 22:30

Tell her to have a carrot stick and water morning. I'm sure she'll raise loads of money.

T1Dmama · 21/07/2023 22:26

While talking about misinformation spreading : please clarify that obesity is linked to TYPE 2 DIABETES.
Type 1 diabetes is a different disease entirely

Juced · 21/07/2023 21:56

Bet she’s fun at parties 🙄

gardenflowergirl · 21/07/2023 20:36

You are wrong. Different cancers use different fuel to grow and one of them is glucose. Colon cancer is fed by glucose, for instance, when it moves to the lymph glands it changes its fuel to fats. Some cancers are fed by hormones, like breast cancer. If you stop one fuel, like glucose, cancers are smart enough to change fuel. So it's not as simple as stopping glucose. Look at the work of Jane McLelland on this, her course and her book called 'How to starve cancer'. It's about using medicines and supplements to stop all the different fuels of cancer, so Metformin is one of the drugs used to stop cancers getting sugar. This approach is not mainstream yet, but docs in the private sector are using the technique. There is also a trial that cancer patients can join using this protocol run by Care Oncology Clinic in London and the US as well.

PotatoLove · 21/07/2023 20:31

I'd say everything in moderation and these coffee mornings are a good way of raising money for a fantastic cause. We're not talking about eating straight out of the sugar jar ffs.

MumOfOneAwesomeHuman · 21/07/2023 20:27

tt9 · 21/07/2023 20:13

i'm very sorry to hear what your father went through. must have been awful...

the study you mention consists of lab based experiments on yeast and mammalian cells (not sure if they used human stem cell lines) and how a particular component of metabolic pathway MAY regulate cell proliferation. given that our understanding of metabolic pathways are by no means comprehensive and the actual results of the study... it is a massive (inaccurate) leap to then say from this that sugar causes cancer.

Absolutely agree and I didn’t say that it causes cancer, but the study did find sugar affected cancer cells dramatically and the op asked to read studies about this.
my sister also died of an incurable cancer and tried several fasting and starving cancer of sugar diets none of which had any effect or reduction in her cancer so I know that first hand. Dramatic affect doesn’t equate to causes by any means. Definitely worth a read though to anyone interested in where the idea comes from or the science around it. A lot more research is needed and the causes of cancer are incredibly complex. Having lost most of my family to cancer I’m very interested in the affects of diet & nutrition & chemical avoidance on preventing cancer but yes, it’s way more complex than avoiding sugar.