Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that employers will have to pay more for working in the office roles?

232 replies

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 10:59

Following on from the poster who is annoyed she will have to come back into the office two days a week, I honestly think this argument will come up again and again.
I have never been able to work from home, apart from the odd day when I had COVID. Worked through the pandemic in an office. I am an NHS employee and need to be in the hospital even if not necessarily clinical.
My trust is now fully back to pre covid 'everyone must come in every day'. I don't disagree with this. We should be in supporting the clinical staff and patients!
This means spending on

  • transport (£12 a day for me)
  • parking
  • childcare including wraparound and school holidays
  • food which can be transported. Milk for work, butter for work etc. I was home I could just make something out of what I had at the back of the cupboards
  • some have cleaners as they are out the house more.
  • some gym memberships are cheaper if you can go off peak. Which I can't.
  • contributions to leaving presents, maternity leave, big birthdays. These contributions are presumably are less pressured if not in person.
  • sickness. There's many days when you can't pull yourself in to the office, or when you're contagious, but you probably could log in from home. I have defo noticed my friends are rarely 'calling in sick' anymore for their children or themselves but WFH instead.
So whilst I appreciate that not all jobs require an office presence, if I was a job seeker why would I choose one that's not hybrid or working from home, especially nowadays. I feel there is going to have to be some sort of reimbursement for taking on a job which requires you to make all the sacrifices in order to do it. Also can't help noticing that it is generally the lower paid who are having to keep paying all these necessary costs. We don't have people falling over themselves to do jobs in care, retail, hospitality as it is and I think this would really help with adding an incentive. Otherwise why would anyone become an NHS band 2 admin or a cook in a nursing home? Also I'm aware heating costs may be more but that's just one thing and most just put another jumper, my workplace is freezing anyway!
OP posts:
MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 13:29

So the majority of those WFH are actually financially worse off and don't like it? What's stopping you applying from a role outside of the home?

OP posts:
SliceOfCakeCupOfTea · 20/07/2023 13:28

I half agree with you. I've always disliked the idea of spending your salary to get to your job. I understand there isn't a logical, fair solution to that as someone should be paid less because they live closer to their workplace or whatever.

I can understand there being a 'commuters bonus' of sorts where your company pay X% of your travel costs.

Your other examples are silly. Cleaners, gym memberships, childcare etc are not valid reasons for you to have a payrise.

Blackbyrd · 20/07/2023 13:24

Anyone working from home is surely aware that their role can be done from anywhere in the world theoretically? They will be the first to be replaced. Plenty of people wfh are quite obviously multitasking and not concentrating on the job they are being paid for. Especially ime local government officers, as quite often when you have to call them there is substantial background interference.
If you have children of an age to need childcare, then your employer should ask to see evidence of such. So in answer to the OP, people on site shouldn't receive any recompense and many wfh should be recalled to their place of work for various reasons. Nationally productivity is suffering and as a PP said, this is all becoming very divisive

JassyRadlett · 20/07/2023 13:20

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 11:10

@Angryappendix hardly any of the parents in my daughters class are planing to use holiday clubs whilst my childcare bill for the summer is close to £1000

Gosh, that would be a disciplinary issue where I work.

We're hybrid and there is a very strong focus on being present and working when you're wfh, with targets, collaboration and productivity a real priority.

I think the only cases where things are marginal is early secondary when you might not have been comfortable with them staying home alone all day, but they are fine with zero parental input as long as an adult is there for true emergencies.

Otherwise - if you wouldn't leave them by themselves, then you aren't allowed to work with them there. My eldest is starting secondary and we'll still be doing camps etc when we can't find other arrangements; he's one of those on the cusp of being ok alone but he can't really do a full day alone yet.

BrieAndChilli · 20/07/2023 13:17

Everyone is different - when i WFH a lot of what you said doesnt apply:

transport (£12 a day for me) - work is 5 minute walk so no saving for me
parking - parking is free at my office so when i need the car eg if going onto a client meeting etc there is no cost
childcare including wraparound and school holidays - mine are all secondary age so no child care needed
food which can be transported. Milk for work, butter for work etc. I was home I could just make something out of what I had at the back of the cupboards Work provides tea/coffee/milk and snacks and often lunch eg fridays they get us subway ordered.
some have cleaners as they are out the house more. no I clean my house on a weekend/during the week as I go
some gym memberships are cheaper if you can go off peak. Which I can't. I dont go to the Gym - partyl cost and partly laziness and mostly lack of time
contributions to leaving presents, maternity leave, big birthdays. These contributions are presumably are less pressured if not in person. probably agree with you here but we are a close team so would still contribute
sickness. There's many days when you can't pull yourself in to the office, or when you're contagious, but you probably could log in from home. I have defo noticed my friends are rarely 'calling in sick' anymore for their children or themselves but WFH instead. I normally work in the office but if sick have the option of working from home

So really nothing changes for me if I were to WFH all the time but I actually prefer being in the office - you abosrb more info and details that you just cant from sparodic emails/teams calls.

I do think there will be a return to the office among the younger generation - it is fine for us oldies with experience to crack on with our jobs in isolation but new graduates who need to learn from others and probably have moved city will want the office for learning and networking and socialising!

FrivolousTreeDuck · 20/07/2023 13:11

Agree that transport, parking and childcare will affect many (not all, though - e.g. if you can walk or cycle to work and don't have children of childcare age).

Agree strongly with the point you make about sickness:

  • Food which can be transported. Milk for work, butter for work etc. I was home I could just make something out of what I had at the back of the cupboards

Offices can install a fridge/kitchenette

  • some have cleaners as they are out the house more.

In my dreams 😄

  • some gym memberships are cheaper if you can go off peak. Which I can't.

No interest in joining a gym

  • contributions to leaving presents, maternity leave, big birthdays. These contributions are presumably are less pressured if not in person.

Appreciate their can be peer pressure but ultimately these are optional (and still happen remotely).

Sunshineandflipflops · 20/07/2023 13:07

I am a single parent and WFH f/t. I pay more in electricity and heating to do so, work from my dining room as have no spare room and can't afford a gym membership -off peak or not. I also do all the cleaning and everything else that goes with it. I get what you're trying to say but a lot of what you have said is a generalisation and just not true for many.

wishingitwasfriday · 20/07/2023 13:06

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 11:02

@Ifailed well that's sort of my point, why would someone do that job rather than one based in their home like dealing with calls for an insurance company?

Because not everyone wants to do call centre work?

ButterflyOil · 20/07/2023 13:05

I’m pretty sure the OP meant there is more time to do things like cleaning or going to the gym if you WFH - as in before work and after when you would normally be commuting. Or sticking a load on during lunch and hanging it up on a screen break - that sort of thing.

I WFH four days and that gives me an extra 8-10 hours of extra time to exercise and do other tasks before and after work that I would spend in the car commuting otherwise. I don’t like stick Teams into away and do a yoga workout at 3pm! I do it during commuting times around my full days hours.

cherriobigfjaje · 20/07/2023 13:02

My DH works from home, I'm a classroom assistant so I'm off but my kids are 10 and 12 so too young to be left alone but old enough to be in the house with an adult upstairs. I don't however agree that people should take the mick with childcare, cleaning, going to the gym etc on working hours.

WomblingTree86 · 20/07/2023 13:01

carduelis · 20/07/2023 12:09

Fair enough. No point trying to contribute to a discussion unless your situation applies to everyone I guess!

OP's point is that employers will need to pay more to attract people who can't work from home because everyone working from home from home saves so much money. If working from home only benefits a relatively small number of people financially that won't be the case.

Panthereyes · 20/07/2023 12:53

I WFH permanently and so does my DH, this saves us both 6 hours a week commuting. As a family this 12 hours makes a massive difference to our work life balance. I would never want to go back to an office based job.

BillyBraggisnotmylover · 20/07/2023 12:48

The main problem with WFH I find is too many meetings. It is possible to be in back to back meetings from 8-6 with no break, whereas in the olden days when we might have had to travel between venues for meetings there were natural breaks built into the day, or you declined. We’ve tried to mandate starting meetings just after the hour and ending them just before but inevitably people still feel bound to stay until the hour is up. We also miss those adhoc discussions that happens in a physical room once the meeting has ended - it’s much harder to ask someone to hang on for 5 minutes on a Teams call just as everyone is logging off.

But the benefits still outweigh those downsides for me. Our office is not set up for working well - no second screens, no docking stations, no keyboards or mice, no canteen, limited meeting spaces. It is not a nice place to be, and is almost impossible to do focused work there where you need quiet and no interruptions, whereas at home I can do that with ease.

BCCoach · 20/07/2023 12:36

AndWordsWhen · 20/07/2023 11:43

Your list highlights exactly why employers want people to go the the office. Nobody should be doing childcare, school pickup, going to the gym, or cleaning during the work day.
Travel costs are additional, but could be offset by not having to heat the house. You can take a packed lunch if that's a big cost for you.

Loads of people go to the gym or for a run when working at an office - in fact many workplaces have gyms, pools, running clubs etc.

Pollyputthekettleonha · 20/07/2023 12:34

Your examples don't stack up. WFH doesn't mean you are at the gym, cleaning your house or looking after your kids. If you are then your employer should be pulling you up on this. Generally the lack of productivity will be noticeable if this is what you are doing at home instead of working.
Yes it does save some time/ money on commuting which would have the knock on effect of making your child care costs a bit lower if you are able to collect them earlier due to the reduced commute. Although my nursery will charge me until 6pm regardless of what time I collect them. And there are additional costs associated with heating and power working from home, so this would need to be balanced out.
I see your point to an extent, but not to the extent you have made it out to be.
And obviously some people will work outside of the home because the industry or type of work they like doing requires them to, some people would find WFH for a call centre or doing admin very boring and wouldn't do it just for the benefits alone.
I do think that some types of work ( mainly to do with caring) are undervalued and should be paid better , although not necessarily because you have to work outside of the home to do them.

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 12:29

I just worry about where nurses, teachers, TAs, speech therapists, those who work for autism and learning difficulties teams are going to come from. It effects my life as a parent to a SN child and with elderly relatives who might need carers. We have to make these jobs more appealing.

OP posts:
MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 12:27

@supersonicginandtonic but would you rather commute and be in the office or workplace every working day?

OP posts:
Bluevelvetsofa · 20/07/2023 12:26

If you are working from home and not using child care during your working hours, you are probably short changing both your employer and your child, depending on age. Using child care should be no different if you work from home or commute. The only caveat would be if you choose to complete your hours when the children are in bed asleep, but that’s not going to be possible in many roles.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/07/2023 12:21

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 11:05

@PuttingDownRoots I would give up my dining room table which is in my kitchen for an extra £300 a month

What about if it were for £300 less, though? As places will reduce what is paid to those WFH, rather than award extra to those coming in.

supersonicginandtonic · 20/07/2023 12:15

I hate working from home. I much prefer to be in the office, for the social side if nothing else.

thecatsthecats · 20/07/2023 12:13

I disagree on the specifics.

I also think that it comes down to proper operational planning, and leadership getting off their arse and working it out. It's been three years, work out a system and stand firm on it, don't fanny about chivvying things along.

FWIW, my own implementation of hybrid was to cut our office costs by 4/5 to the minimum office and facilities required, to mandate whole team fortnightly attendance in office for two days together (food provided), and to allow free and flexible agreement between staff for F2F work on other days. A weekly Teams stand up on the "home" week. And a one off set up costs plus annual home working allowance. It definitely cost less to have people in office all the time.

What happened was that the shared fortnightly time ensured that all projects had regular feedback, good team socialising, better attendance, and due to the synchronised working, we all planned plenty of F2F time in smaller groups as needed.

(side note: I make a lot more mess by being in my house for 20h a day and 3 meals, so the cleaner one is batshit)

WomblingTree86 · 20/07/2023 12:10

With the exception of picking children up early from childcare and potentially paying less for it (a benefit which applies to a relatively small number of the working population) most of the benefits you mention only apply to people who take the piss. Perhaps you should ask your employer if they would pay you more because you can't skive off as you would do if you worked from home and being at work means you are forced to do your job.

carduelis · 20/07/2023 12:09

WomblingTree86 · 20/07/2023 12:02

That is just you though. Not everyone with children needs to use more wrap around care because they work in an office vs. working from home and not everyone has children of primary school age in the first place.

Fair enough. No point trying to contribute to a discussion unless your situation applies to everyone I guess!

Mumtothreegirlies · 20/07/2023 12:07

User894532765 · 20/07/2023 12:04

Nobody reimbursed me for DH having to use a room in the house that could have been used for other things

If having to allocate a room in your house is an inconvenience to you, try getting real problems and think yourself lucky that you have a spare room. When my husband wfh years ago he had a corner of the living room in our 2 bed house.

farmerswife7 · 20/07/2023 12:04

Incentives do need to be given to get people into jobs such as grade 2 admin/ cook as you said. Or yes we will end up with people not willing/ wanting to work in those areas. I would be a believer that the market would work itself out though.

I wfh, because of where I live it is a God send unless I was willing to commute 2hrs each way daily I couldn't have this sort of job. But I do still pay child care. Even the other day someone said 'that's great you WFH, no childcare cost' I would not be able to do my job! Although I can see that can be different for someone with older children who just need an adult in the house when they come home from school. Not to be looked after necessarily

Swipe left for the next trending thread