Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that employers will have to pay more for working in the office roles?

232 replies

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 10:59

Following on from the poster who is annoyed she will have to come back into the office two days a week, I honestly think this argument will come up again and again.
I have never been able to work from home, apart from the odd day when I had COVID. Worked through the pandemic in an office. I am an NHS employee and need to be in the hospital even if not necessarily clinical.
My trust is now fully back to pre covid 'everyone must come in every day'. I don't disagree with this. We should be in supporting the clinical staff and patients!
This means spending on

  • transport (£12 a day for me)
  • parking
  • childcare including wraparound and school holidays
  • food which can be transported. Milk for work, butter for work etc. I was home I could just make something out of what I had at the back of the cupboards
  • some have cleaners as they are out the house more.
  • some gym memberships are cheaper if you can go off peak. Which I can't.
  • contributions to leaving presents, maternity leave, big birthdays. These contributions are presumably are less pressured if not in person.
  • sickness. There's many days when you can't pull yourself in to the office, or when you're contagious, but you probably could log in from home. I have defo noticed my friends are rarely 'calling in sick' anymore for their children or themselves but WFH instead.
So whilst I appreciate that not all jobs require an office presence, if I was a job seeker why would I choose one that's not hybrid or working from home, especially nowadays. I feel there is going to have to be some sort of reimbursement for taking on a job which requires you to make all the sacrifices in order to do it. Also can't help noticing that it is generally the lower paid who are having to keep paying all these necessary costs. We don't have people falling over themselves to do jobs in care, retail, hospitality as it is and I think this would really help with adding an incentive. Otherwise why would anyone become an NHS band 2 admin or a cook in a nursing home? Also I'm aware heating costs may be more but that's just one thing and most just put another jumper, my workplace is freezing anyway!
OP posts:
FartOutLoudDay · 20/07/2023 14:45

csandsickofit · 20/07/2023 14:42

It does! Certainly our Dept anyway. Not only are we expected to work in the office, our hours have been extended and the pay rise is absolute crap. I will be leaving shortly and I really hope I have an exit interview. We struggle to even get temps...

Which Dept, out of interest? Have just applied for CS (DLUHC) thinking hybrid was fairly well embedded but maybe not!

csandsickofit · 20/07/2023 14:42

kfhurs · 20/07/2023 11:12

This is why the civil service has always been that bit more flexible, because the pay (in many areas) can't compete with private but the flexibility often makes up for it. If the CS tried to get very rigid across the board, it would have a retention problem.

It does! Certainly our Dept anyway. Not only are we expected to work in the office, our hours have been extended and the pay rise is absolute crap. I will be leaving shortly and I really hope I have an exit interview. We struggle to even get temps...

nonman · 20/07/2023 14:37

We need a £150k grant from DH employer to buil an extra soundproof office space. Or to fund a move to a bigger house. I have lost all privacy ow the house is full office workers. I can’t have the radio on blaring out like I used to .

StormShadow · 20/07/2023 14:36

Blackbyrd · 20/07/2023 13:24

Anyone working from home is surely aware that their role can be done from anywhere in the world theoretically? They will be the first to be replaced. Plenty of people wfh are quite obviously multitasking and not concentrating on the job they are being paid for. Especially ime local government officers, as quite often when you have to call them there is substantial background interference.
If you have children of an age to need childcare, then your employer should ask to see evidence of such. So in answer to the OP, people on site shouldn't receive any recompense and many wfh should be recalled to their place of work for various reasons. Nationally productivity is suffering and as a PP said, this is all becoming very divisive

Your premise is wrong.

People who are wfh have in most cases been doing so for at least three years now, and often longer. There has been ample time for offshoring, and yet in most cases that hasn't happened. Sometimes that's due to regulatory or tax requirements meaning organisations have to have people who are physically in the UK, other times because it's just not a good idea. If it hasn't happened by now, there's no reason to assume it's a possibility.

On the subject of employers asking for evidence of childcare, a lot of phone based roles simply don't pay enough to be able to recruit staff who can and will pay for childcare, pet care etc these days. Even if they boot the ones who are wfh and looking after kids at the same time, doesn't mean replacements will be forthcoming.

So in some cases, organisations are responding to this when they don't try and force staff to use childcare. No point in pushing the issue if you can't be pretty confident that the outcome is going to be staff who don't have kids with them. And the same is true of paying staff more to come into the office. Some employers will indeed have to do that, some will be able to get what they want without going the extra mile. It all depends.

BringOnSummerHolidays · 20/07/2023 14:36

Angryappendix · 20/07/2023 11:06

You still have childcare costs when you work from home, granted wrap around care may not be needed but I work from home and toddler is in nursery.

Not everyone has toddlers. No need for childcare for Year 5+ if you work from home. Our primary school allow you to give permission to Year 5 and 6s to walk home themselves. Even Year Rs can be picked up by Year 7s. I won't let my two home alone for long periods but they don't need childcare from Year 5 if they come home to a non empty house.

Year 5 starts at 8 year old. You really just pay childcare for the first 8 years of their lives.

WhoWants2Know · 20/07/2023 14:34

Most of the organisation I work for are based at home. They get an allowance to reimburse them for their working from home costs. If they travel for work purposes, the mileage is calculated from home.

I work in the same role, but I'm based in an office. I travel an hour to and from work and pay the associated commuting costs.

So I'm approximately £2700 worse off than my colleagues in the same role because of the office requirement. And time wise, I lose around 380 hours commuting.

But I also deliver much more face-to-face client interaction and outreach work than colleagues because I'm on the ground and not based a million miles away

Lemonyfuckit · 20/07/2023 14:34

OP I don't disagree with all your points but the comments re childcare / holiday clubs / off peak gym membership / cleaner are precisely why many employers are moving back to in the office requirement even for jobs that can be done from home. If people are taking the piss by not arranging childcare / going to the gym / cleaning their house when they're supposed to be working then no wonder employers want people back in the office.

And I say that as someone who loves WFH / the increased flexibility it gives me, so definitely wouldn't want to be 5 days on the office; thankfully my workplace has adopted a hybrid model but that's for a job that can very much re done from home, not all can be.

DinnaeFashYersel · 20/07/2023 14:28

I reckon WFH with dependent kids is only realistic after they are about 13

It's been fine for us since about age 8/9.

ChocChipHandbag · 20/07/2023 14:26

ChocChipHandbag · 20/07/2023 14:20

Well they are either neglectful parents or they are not concentrating properly on their work. My son is in Year 1, I work 4 days hybrid (2 days at home 2 days in office) DH WFH on my office days. So there is an adult at home every weekday. Son is in holiday club unless we take annual leave because there is no way we could just leave him on an iPad all the time we are working and we can’t keep dipping in and out of work to interact with him on and off all day. I manage other people and we do not allow this.

I reckon WFH with dependent kids is only realistic after they are about 13.

cadburyegg · 20/07/2023 14:23

I wfh 3 days a week and my childcare bill for summer holiday club is nearly £600. My employer is quite clear that wfh isn't a substitute for childcare and employees are still expected to make necessary arrangements. During term time they go to ASC twice a week too. I was able to work with my 8yo around for a strike day a few weeks ago but that was the exception rather than the rule. And if my 5yo was around too that would make it more difficult

ChocChipHandbag · 20/07/2023 14:20

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 11:10

@Angryappendix hardly any of the parents in my daughters class are planing to use holiday clubs whilst my childcare bill for the summer is close to £1000

Well they are either neglectful parents or they are not concentrating properly on their work. My son is in Year 1, I work 4 days hybrid (2 days at home 2 days in office) DH WFH on my office days. So there is an adult at home every weekday. Son is in holiday club unless we take annual leave because there is no way we could just leave him on an iPad all the time we are working and we can’t keep dipping in and out of work to interact with him on and off all day. I manage other people and we do not allow this.

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 14:17

But for those who talk about personal responsibility, who are going to do these jobs?
When I left my last role we had one applicant for an NHS admin. Were they the best person for the job? Who knows?
All of you will need to see a nurse at one point.
Some of you will have children in school.
Some of you have children with special needs who require multiple professionals and input from secondary care and the charity sector. These people will, on the whole, have to leave their homes to see and help your child.
People in supermarkets, shops, cafes, bars, people who pack your Amazon orders.
The last three people who left the NHS who I know, left to do WFH roles. Who will replace them, and would they be the best candidate or is the best candidate out there looking at WFH roles?

OP posts:
Feverly · 20/07/2023 14:16

I wouldn't go to an office for any sum of money. My job pays everyone extra for WFH costs.

Motnight · 20/07/2023 14:12

Zebedee55 · 20/07/2023 14:02

I don't know if it's general, but, in London, a while ago, some firms were looking at taking away the London Weighting, if people weren't working in the office.

In the part of the NHS I work in, in order to receive London weighting you have to be in the office 2 days a week. Which is very reasonable.

KinooOrKinog · 20/07/2023 14:09

There seems to be a trend where people don't want to take responsibility for anything. Your employer pays you to do the work associated with your job. It's up to you to manage any costs associated with getting there.

How would you feel if your cleaner decided to demand extra because there's a cost associated with them getting to your house? You'd not be too chuffed I imagine. Or if your solicitor decided to bill you a bit more because they live quite far away?
During covid you were saving money, so it's not actually costing you any more now, you're just saving less.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/07/2023 14:09

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 12:27

@supersonicginandtonic but would you rather commute and be in the office or workplace every working day?

When I was first brought back in after lockdown, I felt like I had been released from solitary confinement - the benefits of a regular routine that involved getting dressed in work clothes, physical movement, daylight and meaningful contact with somebody other than DP, the cats and the Ocado/Amazon driver far outweighed the convenience of rolling down the stairs to switch on my crappy laptop 3 minutes before my start time.

I have had occasional days WFH because conversely, constant interruptions can get too much after a while, but on the whole, actually going to a workplace and being around people is far, far, better for me physically and psychologically.

daffodilandtulip · 20/07/2023 14:03

Surely you should be paying for childcare wherever you are working, not looking after your child?

DinnaeFashYersel · 20/07/2023 14:02

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 13:29

So the majority of those WFH are actually financially worse off and don't like it? What's stopping you applying from a role outside of the home?

Personally I'm financially far, far, far better off and happier wfh.

I will never do 9-5 M-F again.

Zebedee55 · 20/07/2023 14:02

I don't know if it's general, but, in London, a while ago, some firms were looking at taking away the London Weighting, if people weren't working in the office.

Toooldtocareanymore · 20/07/2023 14:01

I think most employers would make the following points in relation to your post, which seems to equate working form home as being the same as putting in hours when it suits you, which is not teh case most people working from home have to work within defined time bands.

Transport and parking can be an issue- but there are in various tax schemes available to lessen the load for staff- should they refuse jobs to anyone who moved further away, or didn't chose to live close to work? or chose not to cycle? obviously not, that is the employees choice, so why should they pay staff more based on staffs choice where to live?

Childcare including wraparound and school holidays Must be provided during working hours when you are working from home and have contracted hours -you need child care during those times, yes there can be a little flexibility eg use lunch hours to do school runs , finish early etc. but many "in office" workplaces also have flexi hours to facilitate this. I'm sorry if you are working form home then childcare should be provided by someone else.

Food which can be transported. Milk for work, butter for work etc. I was home I could just make something out of what I had at the back of the cupboards- milk and butter are just the same, sandwiches from home are just the same, the same shopping pays for those cupboard items, unless you expect the employer to pay you in their time to prep your food. (but that aside I've never worked anywhere that didnt provide milk tea coffee sugar etc for free. )

Some have cleaners as they are out the house more. if you are out of the house more then house doesn't get messy by you, employers often pay cleaners too -to clean those office spaces you use. Again are you talking of proper dedicated cleaning when on the employers time? If so then you are being dishonest.

some gym memberships are cheaper if you can go off peak. Which I can't. Nor can most workers working from home's they are working the same hours you are. There is as likely a gym near teh workplace as near the home.

Contributions to leaving presents, maternity leave, big birthdays. These contributions are presumably are less pressured if not in person. If you are being pressurized please report this to someone senior - employer can just ban it if the staff want

sickness. There's many days when you can't pull yourself in to the office, or when you're contagious, but you probably could log in from home. I have defo noticed my friends are rarely 'calling in sick' anymore for their children or themselves but WFH instead. If you are unwell and cant make it in we would rather that you don't give a half hearted performance at home,

BillyBraggisnotmylover · 20/07/2023 14:01

It’s over 3 years since the first lockdown and many places are struggling to recruit - if mass outsourcing of jobs to workers abroad was the solution, they would have done it already.

DinnaeFashYersel · 20/07/2023 14:00

Supply and demand.

Employers will pay the going rate (including terms and conditions) to recruit and retain the employees they want and need.

They need to factor in that choice of wfh, hybrid and full time in person are things that employees include in their choice of where to work.

Moooooooooooooooooo · 20/07/2023 13:58

HaudYerWheeshtYaWeeBellend · 20/07/2023 11:14

Most of the issues you’ve mentioned is nothing to do with your employer and your own personal responsibility to ensure you can work for the role you’re employed to do.

This ^^^ a THOUSAND times this.

You take a job based on several things but money is (probably) the most important aspect. It’s then up to you to work out your own budgets. Stop moaning and whinging and expecting to be given more. If you want more bloody well earn it.

STOP expecting everyone else to pick up your expenses. Childcare is already subsidised by the government.

I’m sick and tired of this me, me, me culture with people wanting more and more and more. Then you cry when prices of go up, which it has to to cover the extra expenses of paying employees who want more.

Flatandhappy · 20/07/2023 13:38

My concerns would be; if you argue that you can do your job from anywhere then companies may well find people in other countries who expect much less pay and are probably just as well educated to do those jobs. Also, younger people starting off in the workforce may well want the social aspect of being in an office and may not have the space to work from home so will cheerfully take those jobs that people who want to stay home for childcare reasons are arguing have to be wfh. It will be interesting to see how this pans out over the next few years.

TheSeaDoesntKnowMyName · 20/07/2023 13:38

MrsMarieMopps · 20/07/2023 11:17

If you look at the other thread there's lots of parents up in arms because they won't be able to pick up their kids from school. I'm sympathetic as a lone parent but I think those of us without that luxury should be reimbursed.

Why should a company have to pay more for your lifestyle choices? You chose where you live, you chose if you have children

If you go down that route, it will make parents even less attractive to employers