Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if eating healthily is worth it?

115 replies

Doesitmakeadifference · 20/07/2023 10:34

I'm late 30s, throughout my life my diet hasn't been very good but it probably hasn't been horrendous either. I've never eaten enough veg.

Several years ago dh and I were in a rut and our diet became very bad, loads of takeaways, way too much junk processed food. Both put on weight.

So a few years ago we turned our whole lifestyle around and now eat well, we exercise every day. Every so often we go on a complete health kick and eat very clean. We go to bed early, rarely drink generally I'd say we have a very healthy lifestyle.

I do wonder though sometimes how much difference it honestly makes. To be honest nearly everyone I know eats what they want. Dh often tells me while he's eating his salad or healthy sandwich or homemade whatever all his workmates are eating Greggs, pizza, sausage rolls crisps chocolate bars.

Apart from being slimmer I can't honestly say I feel massively different to when I was eating junk food all the time. Can't say I've got glowing skin or that I'm full of energy.

OP posts:
WaltzingWaters · 20/07/2023 14:08

It’s all about balance. I know I feel awful, tired, heavy, bloated when I’ve eaten loads of carbs and junk and little healthy stuff. I feel much better when I’ve eaten healthily. But life is also short, I enjoy wine, chocolate, crisps etc, so I’ll work them into my diet as well, amongst healthy nutritious meals.
You never know what will happen. Unfortunately you could eat very healthily, never smoke or drink alcohol and still get a life threatening illness young. You could eat awfully, smoke and drink exclusively and live to be 100. But overall, of course eating healthily is better for you, but no need to be too restrictive.

Doesitmakeadifference · 20/07/2023 14:06

@DeliciouslyDecadent you make a really interesting point.

I'm in a bit of a weird place with food at the moment I think. Once upon a time I used to live for my takeaways, ordering an enormous pizza with sides and fizzy drinks was the highlight of my week.

I can't drink fizzy drinks for example anymore, when I do have a very occasional takeaway now it's usually very mediocre, and certain things like as you say Greggs, you would probably have to pay me to eat. Of course I still do enjoy some of this stuff but I'm way more selective and generally I prefer homemade anything.

So I suppose I do enjoy eating healthy food, but my brain is still telling me that Greggs is calling me in.

OP posts:
Work2live · 20/07/2023 14:05

I suppose it all depends on your definition of ‘healthy eating’ too, along with how much exercise you do.

Lots of people think certain foods are healthy when actually they’re not particularly. Lots of people eat far less calories than they should do during the day. Many people have no idea how much they should actually be eating, how much protein they need etc. The education levels around nutrition are generally poor.

And if your diet is ok but you don’t keep fit and active then you probably won’t feel great.

Fairyliz · 20/07/2023 14:00

Think I am going to go against the grain and say I’m not sure.
I’m in my 60’s and when I look at my generation and the one above me there doesn’t seem to be a huge correlation between healthy lifestyle and actually being health.
My view is that it helps a little but it’s mainly down to genes.

malificent7 · 20/07/2023 13:58

I like being slimmer. I look better which people comment on. I want to put less pressure on my joints. Imo it makes a big difference. I work in healthcare and obesity is bad fir the body. Many people in the uk are obese. You can still have treats but I prefer healthy food now.
i have treats but less of them.

Namechangedforthis25 · 20/07/2023 13:51

TheReverendBeeb · 20/07/2023 13:47

I rarely comment on these types of threads but there are some of us with chronic health conditions who struggle with mobility just because we were lucky enough to be the chosen ones. The ones that did the healthy eating etc and still got unlucky in the health lottery. Of course having a healthy diet is important but I wish people would think before making throwaway remarks about how having limited mobility makes life not worth living, or words to that effect.

Those of you who are fit and active into old age are extremely lucky. Yes you may have made healthy choices throughout your life but you have also been lucky. I cannot and will never be able to run for a bus, no matter how many whole foods I eat!

Sorry to hear that you are going through that

I really don’t think other posters are meaning to be offensive though

yes of course there is always luck - 20 year old football players have cardiac arrests on the pitch

but for those who are lucky enough to be relatively mobile there are some who would like to do what they can to maintain that to the extent they can - there are no guarantees in life obviously but why wouldn’t they want to give themselves the best chance

DeliciouslyDecadent · 20/07/2023 13:50

Doesitmakeadifference · 20/07/2023 10:34

I'm late 30s, throughout my life my diet hasn't been very good but it probably hasn't been horrendous either. I've never eaten enough veg.

Several years ago dh and I were in a rut and our diet became very bad, loads of takeaways, way too much junk processed food. Both put on weight.

So a few years ago we turned our whole lifestyle around and now eat well, we exercise every day. Every so often we go on a complete health kick and eat very clean. We go to bed early, rarely drink generally I'd say we have a very healthy lifestyle.

I do wonder though sometimes how much difference it honestly makes. To be honest nearly everyone I know eats what they want. Dh often tells me while he's eating his salad or healthy sandwich or homemade whatever all his workmates are eating Greggs, pizza, sausage rolls crisps chocolate bars.

Apart from being slimmer I can't honestly say I feel massively different to when I was eating junk food all the time. Can't say I've got glowing skin or that I'm full of energy.

This implies that you think 'healthy' food is something to be endured, and not pleasant.

I'd rather have healthy salad any day than a Greggs whatever.

'Healthy and delicious' can exist in the same sentence.
Or even on a plate.

And yes, it makes a difference.
Start by reading about the gut microbiome and USPs, Prof Tim Spector, if it's all passed you by so far.

TheReverendBeeb · 20/07/2023 13:47

I rarely comment on these types of threads but there are some of us with chronic health conditions who struggle with mobility just because we were lucky enough to be the chosen ones. The ones that did the healthy eating etc and still got unlucky in the health lottery. Of course having a healthy diet is important but I wish people would think before making throwaway remarks about how having limited mobility makes life not worth living, or words to that effect.

Those of you who are fit and active into old age are extremely lucky. Yes you may have made healthy choices throughout your life but you have also been lucky. I cannot and will never be able to run for a bus, no matter how many whole foods I eat!

Madamecastafiore · 20/07/2023 13:13

If I eat shit, a pizza, Chinese or any other junk. It's what your body gets used to.

We are veggie and pretty much don't eat anything unhealthy bar the odd ice cream and for our ages look younger and are far more fit and healthy than lots of people in late 40s early 50s. It's future proofing your body not just on the outside but the inside too.

NicholasAngle · 20/07/2023 12:44

6 months ago at the age of 47, I had a heart attack. If I hadn’t been a regular runner, walker and healthy eater I would have died. My cholesterol was low, my BP was normal, I’m a non-smoker and I have always been a size 8-10 and relatively careful with what I eat. I have since cut out white carbs, sugar, saturated fats and red meat, upped my fruit and veg intake and run every single day instead of a few times a week.

Ive lost a stone - have never been this slim since my early 20’s - and feel great. I also feel so lucky that my heart survived with no damage. It was nothing within my control that caused my heart attack but now it has happened, I’m doing everything in my power to ensure nothing like it ever happens again. If I’d regularly been packing away saturated fats and sugar I wonder if I would have survived this long. It was a massive wake-up call and one I feel fortunate to have had.

So yes - I think healthy eating is completely worth it! Even if it doesn’t prevent health events from happening it can lessen the effects if they do.

heckmuffin · 20/07/2023 12:05

Both my grandmothers ate well (as in, unprocessed meat, fish and veg) and moved around, and enjoyed great health, both physical and mental, until their mid-80s.

I generally eat whole foods, cooked from scratch. And I feel good pretty much all the time. I don't want to eat processed foods. I love treats from my local indie bakery, but I know they're using plain, simple ingredients.

I will say, it's not always cheap to eat well. But there are other things I'm happy to sacrifice in order to afford good food. I go without a lot of stuff that other people have. For most of human history, nothing mattered more to us than dinner time. I think what I put in my body each day matters more than pretty much any other choice I make.

BertieBotts · 20/07/2023 11:54

I think you just have to balance the risks and benefits which apply to you.

For example if you are spending a lot of time and money and energy on preparing meals from scratch, is that something that works for you, or is it a significant cause of stress in which case is it worth going back to using some shortcut items?

I know that some people are very concerned about UPFs. Personally I just do not have the brain space to worry about it. I will stop consuming stuff when it is banned. Until that point, I will eat whatever is available, affordable and I feel like preparing.

For me ditching guilt about using processed or "cheat" foods is way more beneficial to my mental health than eating perfectly all of the time. But everyone has different goals, priorities, challenges. I don't think there will be an easy answer that works for everyone.

Tulpenkavalier · 20/07/2023 11:50

@Doesitmakeadifference- just look around you....... check out people 20, 30 years older than you... Mostly it's not a pretty sight.

There's a woman in my street, same age as me. Cannot walk to the nearby busstop without leaning on her shopping trolley or hanging on to her daughter's arm. Running for the bus....... forget it.

But it doesn't need to be this way. I'm nearly 70, slim, strong, fit. I eat a healthy diet and exercise most days. I go to the theatre, meet with friends, keep my mind active, challenge myself.

On a typical day, I do a 5minute warmup, 20 push-ups, a 10-minute plank, and a 30-40 minute workout with Caroline Girvan or Growingannanas. Typically I eat 2 meals a day: omelette or big salad for brunch, and loads of vegetables plus protein for dinner. Plus fruit, nuts, berries, yoghurt, cottage cheese etc - in moderation - in betweisn't.

Is there a guarantee I'll live longer - no there isnt. But I do not feel deprived. In fact I feel great. I cannot imagine why I'd want to be a couch potato and eat crap instead

NutellaEllaElla · 20/07/2023 11:40

My skin goes to shit when I eat lots of crap, and I always have a sense of feeling a little bit sick. Doesn't stop me from eating crap sometimes but I regret it when I do

noworklifebalance · 20/07/2023 11:33

MrsSkylerWhite · 20/07/2023 10:35

Time will tell.

This.

It’s about the long game - not necessarily about you are now but how you are as a 60, 70, 80 year old.
Will you be independent? Will you enjoy your retirement, go on holiday, do gardening, socialise? Will you manage the stairs? Will you reduce your risk of falls?
Being old and of poor health is miserable.

I love processed sugar - cakes, chocs etc - and I am trying to focus on the future to help curb my vices.

dameofdilemma · 20/07/2023 11:25

It depends how you feel about diabetes, heart disease, increased risk of certain cancers, restrictions/pain in mobility etc. Keep eating unhealthily and don't exercise and these are far more likely.

I don't want to be 60 and just existing, in pain, limited mobility etc. I want an active, enjoyable and varied life.

Figmentofmyimagination · 20/07/2023 11:16

The big one for me is constipation (tmi!) I’m 59. A short term unhealthy diet without enough fruit and vegetables leads inevitably to constipation for me, often followed after a couple of days by a uti. So I try to avoid processed stuff where I can. In my 30s I tended to eat whatever I wanted.

Lamelie · 20/07/2023 11:11

I’m mid 50s and have 2 distinct groups my age to compare.
Friends- mc, fit and slim. Living the same lives and doing the same activities they did in their 20s travelling park run and half marathons, beach and walking holidays. Mix of veggie flexitarian/ vegan but definitely “eat your veg and fresh air is good for you” types.
Colleagues- long term health conditions, struggle to walk far, restricted in what they can eat where they can go. Lots of meat and energy drinks, don’t feel comfortable being outside.
There’s a third group of colleagues younger than us all who at the moment are active and enjoying a full life

ThankTwixItsFriday · 20/07/2023 11:07

I try and eat healthily. However, I know 3 people in their late 80s and early 90s and their diet has always been quite bad. High salt and sugar, pride themselves on never eating veg or salad (that’s for rabbits according to them), fry a lot, eat a lot of red meat, drink alcohol regularly and only really eat convenience foods. They all have good health.
By contrast I know several people who ate relatively healthy who all died young of cancer. So I’m not sure I think healthy eating is the key to a long healthy life.

Comedycook · 20/07/2023 11:06

I think eating appallingly ie constant fast food, sugary fizzy drinks and no fruit veg or decent protein will make you feel awful and is bad for your health...but...I am actually quite sceptical about how much control we actually have over our health. So much, including certain cancers, seem to be genetic.

FormerlyPathologicallyHappy · 20/07/2023 11:04

All it means is that your the one left behind when your partner dies. Dh never held back, food, booze he just did what he liked and died of a cancer caused by radiotherapy 40 years ago. Lifestyle changes were not going to save him.

So here's me little miss healthy eating left behind eating unhealthily and refusing screening etc to try and tip the odds in my favour.

I worked in elderly care for 13 years too so I'm under no illusion that old age if enjoyable.

Tourmalines · 20/07/2023 11:02

Oh believe me it is making a huge difference. If you kept on eating all junk food and drinking alcohol you would certainly not look as good in your 60s compared to what you do now . The aging process creeps up slowly .All the healthier food is good for your mental state too .Being overweight causes lots of health issues . I also believe in living , so have all the good stuff in moderation .

AuntieMarys · 20/07/2023 11:01

guzzleandstuff · 20/07/2023 10:48

Wait until you're all in your sixties - then you'll see. (Cancer, strokes, joint pain, mobility, poorer skin, ). It most certainly IS worth it. Believe me

This.

towriteyoumustlive · 20/07/2023 11:01

It's not just eating healthy fresh food but unprocessed food. Or at least less processed food.

The amount of chemicals/sugar/saturated fat in junk food can make your mood variable, poorer quality sleep, lethargic etc... In the long run it's a very good thing.

Breakoutbertha · 20/07/2023 10:59

Well not dying of a cholesterol induced heart attack before you are 60 could be classed as a benefit.

Swipe left for the next trending thread