Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if eating healthily is worth it?

115 replies

Doesitmakeadifference · 20/07/2023 10:34

I'm late 30s, throughout my life my diet hasn't been very good but it probably hasn't been horrendous either. I've never eaten enough veg.

Several years ago dh and I were in a rut and our diet became very bad, loads of takeaways, way too much junk processed food. Both put on weight.

So a few years ago we turned our whole lifestyle around and now eat well, we exercise every day. Every so often we go on a complete health kick and eat very clean. We go to bed early, rarely drink generally I'd say we have a very healthy lifestyle.

I do wonder though sometimes how much difference it honestly makes. To be honest nearly everyone I know eats what they want. Dh often tells me while he's eating his salad or healthy sandwich or homemade whatever all his workmates are eating Greggs, pizza, sausage rolls crisps chocolate bars.

Apart from being slimmer I can't honestly say I feel massively different to when I was eating junk food all the time. Can't say I've got glowing skin or that I'm full of energy.

OP posts:
Naimee87 · 20/07/2023 15:13

I think once in a while a treat or take-away is not a huge deal.

But it absolutely is worth eating healthily. Your body can actually use fruits and vegatables and wholegrains etc. There is literally nothing your body can do with a take-away loaded with fat and sugar other than just store it.

I like what a PP said that I think you notice more when you arent eating healthy as you dont feel as good. More likely to get sick or lack energy. The healthier you eat the more likely you are to have a nice amount of energy that you can maintain over a long period of time. So your motivated to exercise or socialize even concentration is improved with a healthy diet. As opposed sugar-spiked enegry then crashing after.

Plus I think the more junk food you eat the more you crave it. But this is just my view i suppose. I also really think that adults have an obligation to eat healthily so their kids can grow up knowing what nutritious food is vs what a treat is. If all kids ever know is junk food they face a much higher risk of developing the very same health issues in their teens/early adulthood that their parents will.

TheChosenTwo · 20/07/2023 15:08

One of my parents suffered a huge near fatal stroke aged 46, the other a heart attack at 48. Both my paternal grandparents died fairly young from cancer. There is a history of diabetes on my maternal side.
I live a fairly healthy life, and by that I mean I do eat crisps and chocolate etc but I do eat them in moderation and they’re not a part of my daily diet. Pre my parents being poorly and when I was younger ate atrociously, UPF every day for main meals, near enough no fruit or veg, grew up in a smokey house, did little to no exercise. It was a sharp learning curve but I’m so happy I made the changes.
Who knows, I might drop down dead in 10 years time from an undiagnosed underlying health condition. I can’t directly control my future but I can put myself in a better position than my parents and give myself a chance.

diamondpony80 · 20/07/2023 15:07

I felt like that when I was younger too, but now at 43 I already feel the effects when I have a blow out (usually a couple of days or weeks of bad eating prompted by a family get together, a holiday, or an event like Christmas!) I enjoy myself but eating badly makes me so tired and brain foggy that I look forward to getting back to my normal reasonably healthy diet. I dread to think how eating badly all the time would affect one in their sixties and beyond.

101jobs · 20/07/2023 15:04

Watchkeys · 20/07/2023 14:40

it’s the luck of the draw

People who eat more healthily have more luck, though.

It's like hard work. It gets many people nowhere. So we should all just sit on our arses all day, right? Is that what you're teaching your kids, @101jobs , or are you thinking they'd better improve their chances by trying their best at things?

My post never stated that “people should sit on their arses”, neither did it say that I teach my kids to do so. I have no idea why you’re inferring that I said that.

My post clearly stated that I maintained a healthy lifestyle! I do it to maintain my weight.

Do I believe my healthy lifestyle will lower my chances of illness? No, I don’t. I really do believe that longevity is luck of the draw. If I am lucky enough to live a good life upto the age of 100 then I’m lucky, I don’t personally believe it’s because of what I eat and because I exercise. I am allowed that opinion without you rudely and incorrectly inferring that I teach my children to “sit on their arses”.

Not that I need to explain myself to you but as you seem quite invested in what I teach my children……my child eats very healthy and is sporty. He doesn’t just “sit on his arse” all day.

malificent7 · 20/07/2023 15:04

He*

malificent7 · 20/07/2023 15:03

I bet those of you who eat well and exercise are a lot slimmer than your friends who don't.
However, dp is skinny fat. Eats loads of junk. Tbh it worries me. I like the odd galaxy but he eats quite a few today.
I once made him a low sugar flapjack...ge immediately fished out his massive galaxy bar afterwards.
Sadly i think it's the reason why he has aches and gut issues.

JudgeAnderson · 20/07/2023 14:58

We have a huge obesity crises, both nationally and increasingly globally, with all the knock-on health effects of that and the pressure on the health service. It is squarely at the door of people's diets, well that and very sedentary lifestyles, so of course eating a healthy diet would make a huge difference at a population level.

Of course there are outliers, people who live to 100 on a bottle of whisky a day or drop dead at 35 despite being a super fit health fanatic, but eating well and moving enough will massively tip the odds in your favour.

It's also not just about how old you want to become - it's how you want to feel when you get there.

Sigmama · 20/07/2023 14:57

I think health is one of the most important things in life and the human body us amazing, so have always eaten well and exercised.

Watchkeys · 20/07/2023 14:53

Worrying number of people on this thread seem to think that the benefits of a healthy diet are 'good skin and slim'.

tattygrl · 20/07/2023 14:52

I also think it's about finding the lifestyle and diet that works best for you. There's increasing scientific evidence that each individual person's body responds in a unique way to different foods and food groups. Obviously there's still the general rules, such as sugar being bad for teeth and vegetables being very nutritious, etc., but things like insulin spikes and storage of fat seems to vary between individual people, so different diets and lifestyles will work for different people.

tattygrl · 20/07/2023 14:49

In my experience, the benefits of a healthy lifestyle tend to be felt more in their absence than in their presence. For example, when I'm drinking plenty of water, I just feel... fine. I don't feel like a superhuman or anything, just, fine. Comfortable. OTOH, when I'm not hydrating myself enough, I feel headachy, stiff, sluggish and my digestion is poor. So I would notice the shitty effects of not hydrating well, but it's easy to overlook the good that it's doing when I am hydrated, because it's simply my body working how it should, nothing extra special.

However. The one thing I do notice is the effect of eating a wide variety, and plenty, of fruit and veg. I find this hard to do sometimes (my autism makes me funny about textures sometimes), but lately I've been eating a huge variety of fruit and veg (thanks to starting a meal subscription box, mainly), and oh my god. My mood is so boosted! I have a natural kind of zingy energy in me. It's really a lovely, noticeable difference, and I do attribute it to eating lots of fruit and veg, and a wide variety of food. I think it's linked to the gut microbiome.

Comedycook · 20/07/2023 14:47

But yeah keep convincing yourself that your whole foods diet and trips to the artisan bakery are the be all and end all

Comedycook · 20/07/2023 14:46

My mother died young of a random illness. My slimmest, "healthiest" friend got diagnosed with breast cancer. My slim and active DH has high bp...like all his family

Comedycook · 20/07/2023 14:43

I think we like to believe we are more control of our health than we actually are. Of course, extreme alcohol and nicotine abuse and eating shit food is not good for us but I think a lot of health problems are genetic or just luck of the draw.

IHeartGeneHunt · 20/07/2023 14:42

The women I work with are all thinner than me, and for lunch every day they have share bags of crisps, white bread cheese sandwiches or jam sandwiches, and two or three bars of chocolate, with cans of pop.
Their skin is terrible, their teeth are too, and two of them have had heart attacks in their 40s. They all smoke and drink alcohol.

I don't drink or smoke, I'm vegetarian, cook from scratch and haven't got anything wrong with me other than I had my thyroid removed ten years ago. I'm fat yes but I've lost three stone since Xmas and I feel healthy and have loads of energy. It's definitely worth it.

Fannieannie63 · 20/07/2023 14:42

Yes it’s very important in fact it’s the first question that was asked after ‘coming to’ after a stroke

Watchkeys · 20/07/2023 14:40

it’s the luck of the draw

People who eat more healthily have more luck, though.

It's like hard work. It gets many people nowhere. So we should all just sit on our arses all day, right? Is that what you're teaching your kids, @101jobs , or are you thinking they'd better improve their chances by trying their best at things?

101jobs · 20/07/2023 14:37

OP I completely agree with you. I eat healthily, exercise daily and only occasionally treat myself to the foods I really enjoy. The rest of the time I eat food that I don’t want, just because it’s healthy.

Unfortunately my skin and hair is no better than all my friends who have unhealthy lifestyles.

As for health, I really do not believe that eating healthy maintains a healthy body. I know people who have been extremely healthy and died young of illness and I know people with unhealthy lifestyles living into their 80’s… it’s the luck of the draw.

The only benefit I can see is that it helps maintain your weight and that’s why I do it. Apart from that - nothing at all!

Watchkeys · 20/07/2023 14:31

lastminutewednesday · 20/07/2023 14:15

I think the exact same op. I had a year once (6 years ago when I was 37 and for various reasons had time as finances to do so), where I ate incredibly well-clean and very balanced and nutritious, drank only water and the occasional cup of tea, trained 5 days a week. I was slimmer absolutely but I didn't feel any better in myself than I feel now eating a normal (not great, not awful diet and the only exercise is walking really). My sleep was still awful (Insomniac since late teens), my skin didn't look noticeably better, (again it was fine as it is now), my hair didn't grow loads of anything like that.
I still had a bit of arthritis in my joints, got just as many colds etc. I wasnt suddenly brimming with energy or confidence and I didn't feel much less stressed. Which leads me to believe it's all slightly bunkum tbh... though I'm sure there are going to be some scientific types that tell me it isn't!

It's not bunkum because it didn't make you feel great. It's bunkum if most people who do it get just as ill and die just as young as people who don't do it.

That's not 'scientific', it's basic common sense and understanding of life.

willWillSmithsmith · 20/07/2023 14:31

My main motivation for losing weight and keeping to a healthy diet (without obsessing) is to try and keep mobile as I get older. All the older members of my family who stayed overweight suffered mobility problems in older age which led to more isolated lives and all sorts of other ailments (high blood pressure etc). I feel (well hope) that if I can be slim and mobile now I’m getting older I’ll have a more enjoyable old age than my relatives had.

2bazookas · 20/07/2023 14:26

Wait till you and all your friends are old. You'll see the difference then.

willWillSmithsmith · 20/07/2023 14:22

Eating habits tend to come home to roost when you’re older. Once you start hitting the late autumn/winter years a person is likely to reap what they’ve sown from the preceding years. Risk of high blood pressure, type 2 diabetes, weight, mobility, heart etc will all come into play.

lastminutewednesday · 20/07/2023 14:15

I think the exact same op. I had a year once (6 years ago when I was 37 and for various reasons had time as finances to do so), where I ate incredibly well-clean and very balanced and nutritious, drank only water and the occasional cup of tea, trained 5 days a week. I was slimmer absolutely but I didn't feel any better in myself than I feel now eating a normal (not great, not awful diet and the only exercise is walking really). My sleep was still awful (Insomniac since late teens), my skin didn't look noticeably better, (again it was fine as it is now), my hair didn't grow loads of anything like that.
I still had a bit of arthritis in my joints, got just as many colds etc. I wasnt suddenly brimming with energy or confidence and I didn't feel much less stressed. Which leads me to believe it's all slightly bunkum tbh... though I'm sure there are going to be some scientific types that tell me it isn't!

oi0Y0io · 20/07/2023 14:13

Live fast
die young

Watchkeys · 20/07/2023 14:11

It's just odds and risk. It will increase your likelihood of good health. It's not about whether it's worth it; you're not playing off one thing against another. It's like whether it's worth taking an umbrella when it looks like rain. It's not worth it if it doesn't rain, but you can't know, from your perspective. I always think of it as 'What will I look back and kick myself for if I get a hideous diagnosis one day?'