Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder if eating healthily is worth it?

115 replies

Doesitmakeadifference · 20/07/2023 10:34

I'm late 30s, throughout my life my diet hasn't been very good but it probably hasn't been horrendous either. I've never eaten enough veg.

Several years ago dh and I were in a rut and our diet became very bad, loads of takeaways, way too much junk processed food. Both put on weight.

So a few years ago we turned our whole lifestyle around and now eat well, we exercise every day. Every so often we go on a complete health kick and eat very clean. We go to bed early, rarely drink generally I'd say we have a very healthy lifestyle.

I do wonder though sometimes how much difference it honestly makes. To be honest nearly everyone I know eats what they want. Dh often tells me while he's eating his salad or healthy sandwich or homemade whatever all his workmates are eating Greggs, pizza, sausage rolls crisps chocolate bars.

Apart from being slimmer I can't honestly say I feel massively different to when I was eating junk food all the time. Can't say I've got glowing skin or that I'm full of energy.

OP posts:
Tulpenkavalier · 20/07/2023 17:09

the doctors told many people like my dad to eat stuff that said diet, no fat or low fat. All the crap with extra sugar in. They were told the wrong information as we know now that sugar is a killer. Animal fats are good and healthy with collagen, vitamins and minerals in abundance. Sugar is the enemy with absolutely no nutritional value.

Amen.

I have always tried to eat a healthy diet and never had an excessively sweet tooth. However, I feel so much better since I gave up sugar altogether!

As you say, sugar is in everything, all the ultra-processed foods are full of it. One often sees already fat/obese people drinking huge quantities of soda - what are they thinking?

Unfortunately, diet sodas aren't much better as the artificial sweeteners trigger the release of insulin and insulin spikes, which ultimately leads to insulin resistance.

Illstartexercisingtomorrow · 20/07/2023 16:50

Your post resonates with me OP.

I think for me it’s about feeling more energetic and less sluggish. And the knowledge that I’m looking after the most incredible piece of machinery I’ve been given (my body), with the hope that I’ll be a healthy active older person when I get there, rather than multiple chronic illnesses. It’s an investment for the future.

But I won’t lie - that bit you wrote about ordering a massive pizza with sides and fries 🤤🤤 Part of me really misses that carefree time when I didn’t bother thinking too much.

Doesitmakeadifference · 20/07/2023 16:28

vegantubbycustard · 20/07/2023 16:22

So a few years ago we turned our whole lifestyle around and now eat well, we exercise every day. Every so often we go on a complete health kick and eat very clean. We go to bed early, rarely drink generally I'd say we have a very healthy lifestyle.

Define your idea of eating well / health kick / eating very clean / healthy lifestyle, because this all seems a bit vague. People who claim to "eat well" can be blinded by the halo effect, especially when they don't have an objective food diary right in front of them.

What do you mean when you say blinded by the Halo effect in the context of living a healthy lifestyle?

OP posts:
vegantubbycustard · 20/07/2023 16:22

So a few years ago we turned our whole lifestyle around and now eat well, we exercise every day. Every so often we go on a complete health kick and eat very clean. We go to bed early, rarely drink generally I'd say we have a very healthy lifestyle.

Define your idea of eating well / health kick / eating very clean / healthy lifestyle, because this all seems a bit vague. People who claim to "eat well" can be blinded by the halo effect, especially when they don't have an objective food diary right in front of them.

FluffyFluffyClouds · 20/07/2023 16:20

Doesitmakeadifference · 20/07/2023 10:34

I'm late 30s, throughout my life my diet hasn't been very good but it probably hasn't been horrendous either. I've never eaten enough veg.

Several years ago dh and I were in a rut and our diet became very bad, loads of takeaways, way too much junk processed food. Both put on weight.

So a few years ago we turned our whole lifestyle around and now eat well, we exercise every day. Every so often we go on a complete health kick and eat very clean. We go to bed early, rarely drink generally I'd say we have a very healthy lifestyle.

I do wonder though sometimes how much difference it honestly makes. To be honest nearly everyone I know eats what they want. Dh often tells me while he's eating his salad or healthy sandwich or homemade whatever all his workmates are eating Greggs, pizza, sausage rolls crisps chocolate bars.

Apart from being slimmer I can't honestly say I feel massively different to when I was eating junk food all the time. Can't say I've got glowing skin or that I'm full of energy.

You say you're late 30s. You start seeing the difference in your 40s and 50s. I'm late 50s and have already lost one friend to cancer most probably caused by his prodigious intake of booze and fags.
My Mum died of diabetes complications in her late 70s, following years and years of poor health. Her gran made it to her 90s, so not unreasonable to surmise that if she'd taken a different route, one of moderation, she might still be here and enjoying life.
So yeah it is worth it, you don't see it so much now because you're still young!

742EvergreenTerrace · 20/07/2023 16:13

My dad was sporty, but meat and potatoes no veg man most of his life. Loved his fry ups. Eventually he had a heart attack and then was registered disabled, and developed diabetes. His doctor told him (this was in the 90s) eat things that say no fat or less fat. So my dad took the drs advice and carried on his meat and potatoes dinners with no veg, with his daily Diet Coke and marshmallows for treats as the packet of marshmallows says low in fat. My dad was not a healthy man in the last few years of his life, had to quit the sports he loved, so no exercise. My dad died of a heart attack at 70, his lifestyle absolutely killed him.

the doctors told many people like my dad to eat stuff that said diet, no fat or low fat. All the crap with extra sugar in. They were told the wrong information as we know now that sugar is a killer. Animal fats are good and healthy with collagen, vitamins and minerals in abundance. Sugar is the enemy with absolutely no nutritional value.

willWillSmithsmith · 20/07/2023 16:03

tattygrl · 20/07/2023 14:49

In my experience, the benefits of a healthy lifestyle tend to be felt more in their absence than in their presence. For example, when I'm drinking plenty of water, I just feel... fine. I don't feel like a superhuman or anything, just, fine. Comfortable. OTOH, when I'm not hydrating myself enough, I feel headachy, stiff, sluggish and my digestion is poor. So I would notice the shitty effects of not hydrating well, but it's easy to overlook the good that it's doing when I am hydrated, because it's simply my body working how it should, nothing extra special.

However. The one thing I do notice is the effect of eating a wide variety, and plenty, of fruit and veg. I find this hard to do sometimes (my autism makes me funny about textures sometimes), but lately I've been eating a huge variety of fruit and veg (thanks to starting a meal subscription box, mainly), and oh my god. My mood is so boosted! I have a natural kind of zingy energy in me. It's really a lovely, noticeable difference, and I do attribute it to eating lots of fruit and veg, and a wide variety of food. I think it's linked to the gut microbiome.

You make a good point. I remember years ago doing all the Disney/Universal Studios stuff in Florida and all the food in the parks was your typical junk - burgers, hot dogs, fizzy drinks etc. I really started to crave fresh food although I had never usually had to think about what I was eating (younger and naturally thin). All that junk made me feel unwell but I never really noticed all the fresh food I ate making me feel actively good (although it was, I just didn’t notice).

moderndaywitch · 20/07/2023 15:56

To me it makes a huge difference. I used to eat whatever I wanted, but I had bad skin, was a little overweight (not by much, mind) and I always caught colds.

Now I am more conscious, and while I'm not the healthiest person, I notice a big difference when I eat well compared to a junk food day. I don't get spots anymore, I sleep better, my hair looks better. If I eat crap I feel crap with gas, stomach problems and awful sleep. What you put into your body is so important!

Beowulfa · 20/07/2023 15:55

I'm a vegetarian and actually like vegetables. Therefore I don't see it as consciously eating "healthily"; it's just my dinner. I find it a shame that most see eating this way as a tedious chore.

CaptainMyCaptain · 20/07/2023 15:48

I agree @2bazookas a friend of mine always had plenty of exercise - walking holidays, dancing etc - and eat very healthily. She had a stroke at 71 due to genetics but her previously healthy lifestyle enabled her to make a complete recovery although she now enjoys cruises rather than walking long distances.

LadyKenya · 20/07/2023 15:48

It is always going to be a positive thing to eat as well as you can. A well nourished body is going to perform better than a body fueled by a low nutritional diet, and poor food. Time will tell how those who are eating very poorly will fare.

2bazookas · 20/07/2023 15:46

Comedycook · 20/07/2023 11:06

I think eating appallingly ie constant fast food, sugary fizzy drinks and no fruit veg or decent protein will make you feel awful and is bad for your health...but...I am actually quite sceptical about how much control we actually have over our health. So much, including certain cancers, seem to be genetic.

The WORSE your genestic inheritance is, the more important it is to look after your health; so that when you develop the familial inherited problems you have the best possible chance of surviving both the disease and the treatment.
DH and I are living proof.

FuppingEll · 20/07/2023 15:42

The women I work with are all thinner than me, and for lunch every day they have share bags of crisps, white bread cheese sandwiches or jam sandwiches, and two or three bars of chocolate, with cans of pop.

Do people really eat like this? Like a whole bunch of them? How long is your lunch break that they manage to eat a share bag of crisps, a jam sandwich and 3 chocolate bars? I'm in Ireland not the UK but I presume eating habits are similar and I genuinely can't think of a single person I know who would eat this for lunch nevermind a whole table or whatever of women. Maybe a white bread ham sandwich and a packet of crisps maybe even a chocolate bar too but not a share bag, not multiple chocolate bars in one lunch sitting.

AnxiousFairyQueen · 20/07/2023 15:41

I’m very careful about what I eat (although I have tended to binge eat sugar when stressed) and I rarely drink. I walk 4 miles a day, go to the gym and do yoga.

I’m 50 and I look embarrassingly young. Yes I know people are rolling their eyes but people are genuinely confused when I tell them my age and a gp had to check she’d got the right person. However, my energy levels are very low to the point that I can’t do a full time job. If I don’t do the above, they’re even lower and my mental health is horrendous.

So who knows? If you look into ‘blue zones’ you’ll see that social support (which greatly decreases stress levels) plays a huge role in longevity. We’re nearly all separated from our tribe so of course we’re all stressed and comfort eating.

TheReverendBeeb · 20/07/2023 15:38

@Namechangedforthis25 - yes you are quite right. I think I have spent too much time on MN threads lately, especially ones about keeping young! I'm not usually so grumpy. And of course it makes sense to take care of the things that are within your control when so many things aren't. It's just that sometimes people don't admit, or perhaps realise that luck does play a part (sometimes a big part). A bit like saying there's a person in their 80s who does marathons. I mean, yes it's fantastic, and they may well have lived an extremely healthy life as regards diet and exercise, but to pretend that they haven't been lucky to escape illness is somewhat disingenuous imho.

CaptainMyCaptain · 20/07/2023 15:34

MrsSkylerWhite · 20/07/2023 10:35

Time will tell.

This. You are less likely to develop Type 2 diabetes or bowel cancer among other things.

5128gap · 20/07/2023 15:32

I don't know if it does in your 30s, but I firmly believe it's been a game changer for me in my 50s. I've lost two stone, feel full of energy, have vastly improved skin and hair and much reduced minor ailments. In your 30s you probably don't have many problems with that stuff anyway so there's nothing to 'cure'.
I'm also of the opinion that the 50 years I spent eating a poor diet didn't cause irreversible damage, as as soon as I cleaned up my act I felt great. I think you probably feel as good as your diet at any given time. So if I was young again I might be tempted back on the junk food, giving it up only when age required it!

Iamblossom · 20/07/2023 15:27

I am fascinated by how much I see seemingly everyone else eat and stay a reasonable size compared to myself.

I am pretty regimented with my diet, I do like a glass of wine, but I NEVER eat cake, biscuits, chocolate, rarely eat fast food at all if ever - I keep to 1800 calories or less 6 days out of 7 and exercise most days. Yes it keeps my weight down but I am far from skinny and I see others just eating whatever they fancy and maintaining their weight and it just seems so unfair!

I guess it's the inside long term health benefits not just the outward ones that count.

JudgeAnderson · 20/07/2023 15:26

@Naimee87 that is fantastic. He must have a great quality of life and that's really what it's all about.

Watchagotch72 · 20/07/2023 15:26

you do it because it’s the right thing to do. that’s all.

You do it because the research tells us that it will lead to better health outcomes in the long (and short) term. That’s as far as you need to think about it tbh. There are no guarantees in life and health outcomes are not ultimately in your control: all you can do is choose to to the balance in your favour.

i just spent a week with my BIL who eats the biggest load of crap, constantly. He’s very overweight, both his parents have type 2 diabetes and he’s been warned he’s pre diabetic. But it’s entirely possible that he will live into his 90s or whatever, and I’ll be dead in a few years, despite all the brocoli I eat. But I’d rather tip the balance in my favour.

JoeyRamoney · 20/07/2023 15:25

I mean, there no downside to eating healthy and exercising, as long as you find a balance. Its not a guarantee for health or the pass to living a long happy life. There are no guarantees. That is why its important to still live and enjoy your life because food is delicious, its social, it brings people together. You exercise because it makes your body feel amazing and strong, not as punishment for eating.

Naimee87 · 20/07/2023 15:23

@JudgeAnderson my 84yr old neighbour is still trail running in the mountains, biking and bare-foot running in the woods near us. His diet is key (his words) and he hasnt ever smoked or been a drinker.

Watchkeys · 20/07/2023 15:21

Not that I need to explain myself to you but as you seem quite invested in what I teach my children……my child eats very healthy and is sporty. He doesn’t just “sit on his arse” all day

So relieved, it's so important to me, @101jobs

Confused
Namechangedforthis25 · 20/07/2023 15:19

I agree with this

since having a baby I’ve been one of those people - walked but no other exercise or strength training. Really felt so much older than my age

I think exercise is critical to feeling better too

JudgeAnderson · 20/07/2023 15:17

It also horrifies me the number of people who aren't even that old who have reduced flexibility, reduced strength and awful levels of fitness, as well as aches and pains and put it down to "getting older", when there are people the same age as them who are scaling mountains, running races etc.