Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU end of term present

561 replies

Bunny93 · 20/07/2023 08:57

Hello everyone,

I am a reception teacher and my class very kindly gifted me a hamper at the end of the year. It is an M&S hamper worth £75, so very expensive.

It has 6 items inside. 1 of the items is a half bottle of wine, which I don't drink for religious reasons. 4 of the other 5 are things with nuts, which I am allergic to and the remaining item I can make use of is a jar of jam. I am struggling a lot for money at the moment and would really like to swap the hamper in exchange for vouchers where I can buy food.

I don't want to seem ungrateful though, and it would mean asking a parent who organised this gift for the receipt in order to return it. I tried to see if I could take it in without one and was refused. But the thought of having a £75 jar of jam actually breaks my heart ☹️ what would you do? AIBU to consider asking for a receipt?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
JenniferBarkley · 22/07/2023 14:10

I have a DC with a peanut allergy, so it probably would occur to me now but I doubt it would have before.

The parent will have said "let's do a collection and buy the teacher a hamper", and then bought the one at the price point closest to the amount raised. Most people drink alcohol, most people aren't allergic to nuts. Unless they had been told of the allergy then I don't think they did anything wrong, just an unfortunate situation all round.

Blondeshavemorefun · 22/07/2023 14:10

Sorry this has hit the mirror paper esp as the reason you don't want the hamper is due to an allergy and I feel the paper hasn't really acknowledged that

Not that you are ungrateful
For the present

Hopefully it will make more people aware that teachers and probably most people if given a choice would love cash or vouchers like love to shop /Amazon as can buy practically anything you want that way

When you work in an office and get a bonus. It's usually cash /money.

So totally get why op would prefer cash esp as she is struggling

As I said before @Bunny93 do look at uc to see if entitled to anything as a single parent working

carduelis · 22/07/2023 14:08

ReachForTheMars · 21/07/2023 23:57

Please ask for the receipt. I'd be mortified if my contribution to a larger present had been pointless.

Who on earth would be offended by someone saying "I'm ever so sorry, I'm allergic to nuts..id be so grateful if you have the receipt so I could exchange for an alternative."

Ignoring hypotheticals, is there anyone on this thread that wants to put their hands up and say, yes, if this person said they were allergic to my gift, I personally would be offended?

Yes exactly. Imagine giving someone a present that could literally kill them if they ate it and then actually being offended when they pointed that out!

Catza · 22/07/2023 14:00

It’s a pretty big assumption to make that the hotter even has the receipt. Imagine going through a difficult conversation just to find out there is nothing they can do to help. If they wanted you to exchange the gift, they would have provided a gift receipt. In all likelihood, there isn’t much to be done about this anyway.
I am also in agreement with others that your personal financial situation, however unfortunate, has nothing to do with this.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 22/07/2023 13:57

It's getting quite tiresome (and somewhat cancel-the-cheque-y) how many people are still regularly suggesting trying to return/exchange the gift - whether with or without the receipt - when goodness knows how many people have said, and shown proof from M&S's own website, that M&S DO NOT ACCEPT EXCHANGES OR GIVE REFUNDS ON HAMPERS!!!

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 22/07/2023 13:52

There’s nothing wrong in gifting to an adult individual something that includes nuts. Op is an adult and frequently will go into buildings where nuts are present in some form. The parents did nothing wrong to gift an item that contains nuts.

Being able to avoid allergens in general life is completely different from being given something with them in as a personal gift. Nut allergies and not drinking alcohol are very common to a lot of people; surely you would check discreetly beforehand, assuming that you were trying to give somebody a nice treat as a kind gesture that they would actually enjoy.

I would love to receive one of those posh steaks - and so would loads of people, going on the fact that they actively market them as gifts. Something like that does make a lovely gift that would be greatly-appreciated by a steak-lover; but I wouldn't dream of buying one for somebody whom I didn't know all that well without initially checking that they aren't vegetarian or vegan, as a very large number of people are - that's the in-your-face obvious gift-check 101 thing that anybody would do, surely?

It can't be difficult to realise that you normally take a moment to think about the recipient before choosing a gift for them?

JenniferBarkley · 22/07/2023 13:50

T1Dmama · 22/07/2023 13:35

Dear kind parent who organised my gift.

I am so grateful for the lovely gift and for you taking the time to do a collection for me, I know organising these things aren’t always easy.
it is such a lovely thought and I’m so grateful but I hate having to ask, but I am sadly allergic to nuts and can not use 4 out of the 6 items in the hamper, I feel horrible asking but could I please have the receipt so that I can swap the hamper for one that doesn’t contain nuts?
yours gratefully
@Bunny93

I think that would be fine but based on the policy others have posted I don't know that she will be able to return it even with a receipt.

I'd contemplates selling it on OP but with a message that makes it clear that it's a lovely gift you just can't have for allergy reasons and you don't want it to go to waste.

Luxell934 · 22/07/2023 13:48

T1Dmama · 22/07/2023 13:35

Dear kind parent who organised my gift.

I am so grateful for the lovely gift and for you taking the time to do a collection for me, I know organising these things aren’t always easy.
it is such a lovely thought and I’m so grateful but I hate having to ask, but I am sadly allergic to nuts and can not use 4 out of the 6 items in the hamper, I feel horrible asking but could I please have the receipt so that I can swap the hamper for one that doesn’t contain nuts?
yours gratefully
@Bunny93

Ship has probably sailed on this now, since most schools broke up yesterday.

DuchessOfSausage · 22/07/2023 13:41

Why not support British companies? I don't use Amazon because I don't like the ethics of the company, and the parcels are left on doorsteps not delivered.

T1Dmama · 22/07/2023 13:35

Dear kind parent who organised my gift.

I am so grateful for the lovely gift and for you taking the time to do a collection for me, I know organising these things aren’t always easy.
it is such a lovely thought and I’m so grateful but I hate having to ask, but I am sadly allergic to nuts and can not use 4 out of the 6 items in the hamper, I feel horrible asking but could I please have the receipt so that I can swap the hamper for one that doesn’t contain nuts?
yours gratefully
@Bunny93

threatmatrix · 22/07/2023 13:33

T1Dmama · 22/07/2023 13:30

That’s what we did. A class collection, Amazon vouchers for teachers and TA’s.
one year we knew the teachers better and the TA got £100 voucher for a shop we knew she liked and the teacher got a family tocket for a cool day out with his wife and kids. A meal voucher for him and wife and an activity day and parking for himself. Hopefully he enjoyed it all

This is the best way, I mean how many mugs does a teacher need.

T1Dmama · 22/07/2023 13:30

threatmatrix · 22/07/2023 13:26

This is why parents should all buy an Amazon voucher for the teacher, cheaper for the parent and fab for the teacher.

That’s what we did. A class collection, Amazon vouchers for teachers and TA’s.
one year we knew the teachers better and the TA got £100 voucher for a shop we knew she liked and the teacher got a family tocket for a cool day out with his wife and kids. A meal voucher for him and wife and an activity day and parking for himself. Hopefully he enjoyed it all

threatmatrix · 22/07/2023 13:26

This is why parents should all buy an Amazon voucher for the teacher, cheaper for the parent and fab for the teacher.

WombatChocolate · 22/07/2023 13:18

Stopcomplainingandsortit · 22/07/2023 13:10

What if the OP gets the same hamper next year too?? I'm still shook at 6 items for £75. Thats such a shame OP you must have been so looking forward to opening this. Maybe sell it on? Or I like the idea to ask around if anyone would swop!!

Those parents are perfectly at liberty to give or not give whatever they choose. The recipient has no control over it.

Im a bit surprised how many many people are shocked at the idea of 6 items for £75 in a hamper. Yes, it’s a lot of money, but if 30 parents gave £2.50 each, you’d get £75.

In lots of state schools, a parent will organise a collection like this and raise close to £100. In some independents, a collection will raise £300.

Often a gift is intended to be a treat, rather than functional and useful.clearly, OP needs functional and useful, but the parents wouldn’t know that and it’s not their role to provide functional and useful and to cover her living costs with their gifts.

If the basket itself is worth £15, then the items are £10 each. Yes, you could buy the individual items for less each…but this isn’t about going to Lidl and buying the cheapest items..it’s a package and probably included delivery and fillings etc. It’a luxury product. Do t forget M and S sell hampers that cost over £1k that lots of companies buy at Christmas for clients or staff. Often people won’t like all the items. We often won’t like gifts people buy us. Hey ho!

Stopcomplainingandsortit · 22/07/2023 13:10

What if the OP gets the same hamper next year too?? I'm still shook at 6 items for £75. Thats such a shame OP you must have been so looking forward to opening this. Maybe sell it on? Or I like the idea to ask around if anyone would swop!!

cantstaymadatyou · 22/07/2023 12:44

I can’t believe the writer of that Mirror piece is a journalism lecturer. She completely missed the point of the thread and all her work just seems to be lifted from various threads.

WombatChocolate · 22/07/2023 12:14

There’s nothing wrong in gifting to an adult individual something that includes nuts. Op is an adult and frequently will go into buildings where nuts are present in some form. The parents did nothing wrong to gift an item that contains nuts.

Look, most parents probably threw £5 or £10 into the envelope or transferred it to the gift organiser’s account. They didn’t dwell long and hard in what the gift would be. Part of joining a group gift is you do t have to worry about it too much. The reality is that most groups of parents simply want to acknowledge thanks and don’t spend ages thinking about what this teacher loves and dislikes. It’s a bit self-indulgent if recipients to overly dwell on the nature of the gift in relation to their specific likes/dislikes or allergies which the gift givers know nothing about. There is no reason why the givers should spend ages researching and checking these things out. The giving of the gift simply isn’t really a big deal.

The problem is when it becomes a big deal to the recipient. And to be honest, this is about OP’s economic circumstances which the parents will have known nothing about and have zero to do with. They simply bought what they thought would be a treat. Yes, hampers are a bit generic and over-priced, but they are frequently given when the person being given to isn’t well-known. And most people receiving a hamper will recognise the sentiment is good and enjoy some items and not others but not be really upset by there being only 1 or 2 items they can enjoy. It’s just one of those things. All the posters who are STILL saying OP should ask M and S for a refund or exchange haven’t spotted the many posts saying hampers are non-returnable.

Soemtimes we do get a gift which is useless to us. It happens to us all sometimes. It’s just one of those things.

WombatChocolate · 22/07/2023 12:05

Look, this thread shows that gift giving is a minefield and people dont all like the same things or have the same attitudes towards gift giving.

Those pronouncing definitive ‘right’ and ‘wrong’ responses fail to appreciate that people feel differently about this and there isn’t a correct response.

All we can take from this is that gift giving is always optional and quite what is given is totally determined by the giver. As a recipient, we have no control over the gift…whether one is given or what it is. As such, we shouldn’t become too invested or dependant on receiving anything, or anything g in particular. Smile, say a warm thank you and move on…either enjoying the gift, or doing something else with it. As gift givers, take the same approach….chose to give or not give and make your own choice of what to give…a specific item or a gift voucher. Give it, and then forget about it…do t become too invested in how the recipient responds to it. We can’t control everything in life.

To me, this thread is really about OP’s financial struggles. She is struggling to meet basic costs of living. Her life circumstances have been really hard and she is struggling. She’d hoped a gift would help cover some of these costs, but the nature of it means that hasn’t been possible and so her disappointment in it being a gift she can’t use is magnified. It isn’t that the gift was wrong or awful. The hamper and the flowers and other gifts were a sign of appreciation from the parents. It was their prerogative to choose what to give. They’ve frequently gifted vouchers, so Perhaos wanted something less generic this time. Who knows why, but it was their prerogative to choose.

Move on OP. Enjoy the jam if you can and if not, give the items to different people or charity. End of.

noglow · 22/07/2023 11:37

Ridemeginger · 22/07/2023 11:07

I remember being involved in a PTA event asking for donations for prizes and raffle hampers. There was always a clear instruction - NO NUTS. Everything was left in an area of the playground at drop off, then sorted and put away by volunteers when the bell went. Some complete tosser donated a giant, leaking string bag of peanuts still in the shell.

I mean that sounds like someone is deliberately trying to kill someone tbh

DuchessOfSausage · 22/07/2023 11:23

@Inwiththenew , It's not even a jar of jam. It's a basket with stuff the OP can't use other than for re-gifting in it.

Inwiththenew · 22/07/2023 11:12

When I give someone a gift I’d really like it to be useful to them and would never be offended if they asked for the receipt to get something else that would be useful. I don’t understand the logic behind this like it or lump it attitude that some people have but the fact is, a lot of people get offended if you have the temerity to express your own personal desire over their idea of your desire! Just kindly explain and ask for the receipt. No one can argue that £75 is a lot of money for a jar of jam. I think secretly regifting is far more offensive than being upfront. At least by being honest you are allowing people to get to know you through the channel of a gift which I am sure has much more purpose than secretly regifting.

Ridemeginger · 22/07/2023 11:07

noglow · 22/07/2023 09:18

You'd be surprised. Some people are so self absorbed they literally don't care if someone dies

I remember being involved in a PTA event asking for donations for prizes and raffle hampers. There was always a clear instruction - NO NUTS. Everything was left in an area of the playground at drop off, then sorted and put away by volunteers when the bell went. Some complete tosser donated a giant, leaking string bag of peanuts still in the shell.

JenniferBarkley · 22/07/2023 11:01

I wonder what how the readership of MN and the Mirror compare - especially among parents of primary school aged DC in the UK. Suspect they were more likely to see it here than there!

Ohyousillydivvy · 22/07/2023 10:35

Bunny93 · 22/07/2023 09:25

Oh no oh no oh no oh no :(

It wasn't that I wanted to return a gift for groceries. I was considering asking for a receipt to return an expensive gift I was allergic to, and then I would have used the money for food instead of a replacement hamper as that is what I needed more.

I am hoping so much my parents don't see this and think I am ungrateful. I really do appreciate the effort they went to try to get me something nice and wasn't to know I couldn't have what was inside the hamper.

I felt it was too rude to ask for the receipt in person and explain why. I Couldn't bring myself to do it. It is 10x worse to read about it from the Mirror. My poor parents :(

Actually this is good that the mirror picked up on it because it will make people think about gifting hampers. More consideration needs to be given to those who have dietary requirements. I never gift food or drink for this reason plus I don't drink alcohol either. I understand that some don't because I don't but the amount of people who think I'm an alien because I don't is huge.

Swipe left for the next trending thread