Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU end of term present

561 replies

Bunny93 · 20/07/2023 08:57

Hello everyone,

I am a reception teacher and my class very kindly gifted me a hamper at the end of the year. It is an M&S hamper worth £75, so very expensive.

It has 6 items inside. 1 of the items is a half bottle of wine, which I don't drink for religious reasons. 4 of the other 5 are things with nuts, which I am allergic to and the remaining item I can make use of is a jar of jam. I am struggling a lot for money at the moment and would really like to swap the hamper in exchange for vouchers where I can buy food.

I don't want to seem ungrateful though, and it would mean asking a parent who organised this gift for the receipt in order to return it. I tried to see if I could take it in without one and was refused. But the thought of having a £75 jar of jam actually breaks my heart ☹️ what would you do? AIBU to consider asking for a receipt?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
BarryStyles · 20/07/2023 17:46

@OrwellianTimes M&S don't exchange hampers (or any kind of food). Otherwise they'd get loads back because no-one really wants a hamper!

OrwellianTimes · 20/07/2023 17:35

listsandbudgets · 20/07/2023 09:05

I think you should take the organising pare t to one side, thank her profusely but explain that while it was very kind and generous you are allergic to lots of the contents so you'd like to exchange as you don't want to waste it. If I'd donated towards this I wouldn't want to think the only benefit was a small jar of jam!!

This.

id be beyond mortified if I knew we’d gifted someone something they are allergic to, and if we’d spent £75 on a jar of jam.

Susuwatariandkodama · 20/07/2023 17:34

I’d just accept it and donate/give out what I couldn’t use.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 16:55

I know it sucks, but they were probably thinking you'd enjoy the treat you'd never buy yourself.

To be fair, there's a very good reason why people never buy hampers full of random food (at 5 times the true value) for themselves...

they aren't allowed to give monetary gifts anyway

I know that's the ruling, but practically speaking, how is giving an Amazon voucher not essentially the same as giving cash? With cash, you can buy absolutely anything that can possibly be bought (except for items sold exclusively by shops that don't accept cash); with Amazon vouchers, you can buy something like 90% of anything that can possibly be bought!

I reckon that the online shops that sell all the identical 'Best Teacher' mugs aren't actually run by the people who manufacture them, but rather by teachers themselves shifting all the stock that they've been given over the years - and they thus perpetuate the cycle!!

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 20/07/2023 16:53

DinnaeFashYersel · 20/07/2023 10:09

If I was the organising parent I would really want you to tell me so I could give you the receipt

This. As a donator or as an organiser I wouldn't think it was remotely rude to say thank you for such a generous gift but that unfortunately they weren't to know you have so many allergies and if it were possible to give you the receipt so you could exchange it. Anyone who could take offence at that given the value of the gift and the effort gone to to collect from parents needs a head wobble.

It is worth dropping these things (allergies and preferences) into conversation with parents during the year. Our parents WhatsApp groups get lots of tips passed on from parents who have inadvertently given booze to non drinkers, non specific food gifts to vegans. And so on. It's always really appreciated to hear that Miss X is partial to abc but hates gin

BodegaSushi · 20/07/2023 16:44

Pressed send too early. I meant it isn't their problem, as they aren't allowed to give monetary gifts anyway, so you'd still be worse off with a hamper even if you could eat what was it it. It's always chocolates and biscuits anyway, hardly a grocery shop.

I'm wondering if you can sell it?

BarryStyles · 20/07/2023 16:43

I'm giving to 5 school staff this time and have got a mix of chocs, biscuits etc for under a fiver each - I assume that teachers who get more share them out with lunch supervisors, cleaners etc. The idea of care assistants, retail staff etc having a whip round for vouchers for 'underpaid' teachers seems bizarre to me. I'm sympathetic to the OP's situation of course - it's very hard to be hoping for gifts from kids to get to the end of the month.
Don't put on a local selling page though - someone will see!

BodegaSushi · 20/07/2023 16:42

Bunny93 · 20/07/2023 10:02

Thank you everyone for giving me your opinions.

I don't think I will ask the parent for a receipt. They might be fine with me asking but they also may think I'm ungrateful and I really don't want that, so best not to risk it.

It just makes me want to burst in to tears knowing I have £61 in my account to last for 3 weeks and I have a jar of jam worth £75!

I am going to see if a charity shop will want the hamper with alcohol, I'm not sure if they accept it or not? I asked around to see if a few friends/colleagues wanted it they all said they don't really like the things inside so wouldn't make much use of it either.

I understand your frustration at the gift, I'm lactose intolerant and people that know me well and know this still boy me chocolate as a gift.

But that is really a separate issue from you having no money. As much as I feel for you, that really isn't their problem

AnnaMagnani · 20/07/2023 16:34

The problem with generic gifts is that the givers don't realise they are a minefield.

Over the years I have re gifted practically every work gift due to allergies, eczema, asthma. And my non drinking colleague re gifted every bottle of wine.

To both of us a card would have been better.

WhoDoUThinkUAre · 20/07/2023 16:07

DuchessOfSausage · 20/07/2023 15:10

@Luxell934 , just what the teacher OP needs, another job to do - regifting or reselling.

She's now got the summer off!

WombatChocolate · 20/07/2023 15:59

DuchessOfSausage · 20/07/2023 15:35

@Luxell934 , if she bins it, it's a waste of the parents' money.

Listing things on a marketplace is a job to do. You need photos, a description, think of a price etc, handle postage/collection ... Not a huge job, but it's still a set of tasks, and she'd probably not get £75 for it.

Stop being a martyr about ‘more jobs to do’.

OP doesn’t need to do anything. It’s perfectly fine for that hamper to sit under her bed until she happens to see someone who would like some of the items. No work needed.

It doesn’t need beating or photographing. Treks to M and S or emails to their customer services etc are not needed. There is no ‘project’ of disposing of unwanted gift or translating it into cash or a wanted gift required. Awkwardly approaching the parent who organised the gift isn’t needed.

Approaching gidt-givers to ask for a receipt or return is best avoided or kept for only very best friends who you absolutely know would want you to, or very close family that you know woukd want you to. It is not something to approach clients (and parents are essentially clients) or people you are professionally connected to through work.

Think how many bosses have given gifts that weren’t appreciated. It’s not the end of the world.

I don’t drink. Over the years I’ve been gifted hundreds of bottles of wine, champagne, Prosecco, gin etc etc. They are nice gestures. I re-gift them. I’m grateful to the people who thought of me and gave me a gift, even if they didn’t remmeber or know I don’t drink. End of.

ZiriForEver · 20/07/2023 15:52

As a parent I would want to know about the nut allergy (and alcohol preference), at least to not make the same mistake the next time.

WombatChocolate · 20/07/2023 15:52

The OP has not lost out through receiving this gift.

It was kindly meant. She just needs to take it as a kindly gesture and move on.

People are making it all into too big a thing. Gifts dont always have to be really carefully thought out with lots of love and effort put into them. Recipients don’t always have to adore their gift.

All this angst is why people get anxious about giving gifts, about arranging communal gifts and about getting them.

The gesture and thought is the important thing. Parents wanted to say thank you and express it. They have and the OP just needs to receive that thanks. The disappointment about it being something g she can’t really use, needs to be a fleeting g moment of disappointment which is moved on from very very quickly. What she needs to remember is the parents wanted to thank her and made an effort (it doesn’t have to be a vast effort where someone researched in detail what she would love).

OP can now think of some friends who’d like the booze and the nuts. She can give them those items and enjoy seeing their pleasure. It doesn’t matter that she hasn’t got £75 worth of stuff she herself will love. The gift could itself have just been some lovely jam.

People who get overly invested in the gifts they receive and in wanting to exchange things and return them seem like little children to me. It’s a bit self-indulgent to feel every gift needs to be wonderful.

I get that OP is finding things tight financially and a voucher or different gift might have been more useful…but you can’t dictate what you get, nor exchange to have stuff you’d buy yourself. Just move on and try to remmeber pleasure at being thanked not annoyance or disappointment at stuff that’s not so useful to you. It’s all about mindset.

FloweryName · 20/07/2023 15:51

It would be really rude to do ask for the receipt.

Needmorelego · 20/07/2023 15:50

@Luxell934 well my examples were a bit extreme but I do dislike “I hope they like this”gifts.
Either get a gift that you know 100% they want/will like or give money or vouchers.
The 10 thousand threads that will be on here on Boxing Day about inappropriate gifts shows that being given random gifts is hated.

Dixiechickonhols · 20/07/2023 15:48

Even if it’s strictly no return some big businesses do have discretion it’s definitely worth a try with contacting customer services higher up with the allergy point especially.

JessieJoJames · 20/07/2023 15:48

Regardless of whether or not people think it is rude to ask for the receipt ( I do - whatever happened to it's the thought that counts?) As PP has said - M&S do not accept the return of hampers. With or without a receipt. I am glad to hear it tbh - some of the food could have been tampered with.

Eat the jam. Use the basket or sell it. Donate the other things or regift.

DuchessOfSausage · 20/07/2023 15:35

@Luxell934 , if she bins it, it's a waste of the parents' money.

Listing things on a marketplace is a job to do. You need photos, a description, think of a price etc, handle postage/collection ... Not a huge job, but it's still a set of tasks, and she'd probably not get £75 for it.

Luxell934 · 20/07/2023 15:30

DuchessOfSausage · 20/07/2023 15:10

@Luxell934 , just what the teacher OP needs, another job to do - regifting or reselling.

Not sure how regifting is another "job" for her to do. She can keep it, do nothing and then give it to the next person she knows with a birthday or anniversary coming up.

Or she could literally just throw it in the bin.

DuchessOfSausage · 20/07/2023 15:10

@Luxell934 , just what the teacher OP needs, another job to do - regifting or reselling.

Moveoverdarlin · 20/07/2023 14:57

This why I hate contributing to a communal gifts and just buy my own presents for teachers.

Hampers are such crap presents. Wine isn’t my favourite and I couldn’t get remotely excited about chutney, nuts, jams and pickles. It’s a good present for the man who has everything and you have fuck all idea what to buy your grandad, but few women I know would like this gift.

Just think of all the nice things you could buy in M&S with a £75 voucher (make-up, beauty, nice new underwear, three new pairs of jeans, some nice cushions for the sofa, perfume, luxury hair stuff) oh no, I’ve got cheese and crackers and a spiced apple chutney!!

Luxell934 · 20/07/2023 14:52

Needmorelego · 20/07/2023 13:26

I still don’t think it’s rude to ask for the receipt because the OP cannot literally use this gift. Some may say not drinking alcohol due to her faith is a “choice” but no one chooses to be allergic. She is allergic to this gift. Depending on the severity of her allergies this gift could possibly kill her.
It’s not that she doesn’t like it - she cannot use it.
Would you give someone who is blind a paperback book as a gift? No - because they can’t read it. Would you give someone who is paraplegic a pair of roller skates? No - because they can’t use them.
If I had contributed to a joint present I would be annoyed my money was spent on something that was unusable to the person receiving the gift.
Any gifts involving alcohol and food it should be checked the gift recipient will be ok with it before buying.

Would you give someone who is blind a paperback book as a gift? No - because they can’t read it. Would you give someone who is paraplegic a pair of roller skates? No - because they can’t use them.

Are you serious?😂
Ummm, well no you wouldn't, because surely those things would be blaringly obvious?!?
How on earth would the parents know she didn't drink and had a nut allergy? They didn't do it on purpose, they haven't all schemed together to buy her the worst gift in the world.

A hamper can be a nice gift and another teacher might have really liked this gift. It's unfortunate for the OP that she couldn't use her gift. But asking for the receipt is not a good idea. Fair enough if it was a friend, family member or someone outside of work, but in a professional setting, where gifts are concerned it would be almost unprofessional of her to turn around and ask for the receipt. A gift is a gift, smile, say thank you, and then regift.

Angelou79 · 20/07/2023 14:13

What about eBay?

Namechangey23 · 20/07/2023 14:04

Plumbear2 · 20/07/2023 09:11

This is why I have never given to group presents for teachers. I think hand written notes and a drawing from the child are much more appreciated. The organisers just do it for the glory 🙄

I've organised a group present.. I'm still waiting for my glory, when and what should I expect? 🤣 Come on, organising a group present just means all the busy parents don't have think about it and we can get the teachers something more meaningful/bigger value if we club together, why so grumpy?Many parents also run side businesses so can get a discounted present which also then helps their business. I've got a voucher that can be used in multiple places so on food if necessary..sad to think that might be necessary though 😭 we did the hampers before but you get less and less for your money although it looks pretty..

Clarinet1 · 20/07/2023 13:55

I feel sorry for the OP. She’s obviously feeling the pinch and had been hoping for something that would help more in a practical way such as vouchers. I suggest going for selling the hamper if she really needs the cash.
Also, nuts are a pretty common severe allergy - I wouldn’t choose a hamper that had a lot of them in if I didn’t know for sure that the recipient could eat them.