Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Family holiday. How should the costs be split?

437 replies

Sallyrush · 20/07/2023 05:05

3 families looking to hire a Villa. (Siblings. Not sure if relevant or not)
2 families are 2 adults and 2 kids, other family is 1 adult, 2 kids.
Families 1 & 2 (2 adults, 2 kids each) think Villa should be split per family.
Family 3 (1 adult, 2 kids) thinks the cost should be split per person, their reason being they have 1 salary to pay for the holiday, other families have 2 - all adults work full time.
Families 1 & 2 feel they all use same facilities so it’s per family.
Family 3 would also like to split costs like food per person but other families think this is petty.
who is right?
YANBU. Families 1 & 2 are correct. Split per family
YABU Family 3 is correct. Cost split per person

OP posts:
BluNomad · 20/07/2023 07:08

I’m with them on accommodation cost (you are using the same facilities as other families) they shouldn’t have to subsidise you & as they both feel same way you’ll have to suck it up but food shouldn’t be split equally, can’t you just buy for your family & let them get their own?

sweepleall · 20/07/2023 07:07

LaPerduta · 20/07/2023 07:06

Exactly! I've read the whole thread wondering why nobody has made this point.

In a villa you're also paying for living areas, kitchen, bathrooms, probably a pool, outside space, etc. The single parent is using 1/5 of those, not 1/3.

Why 1/5? I would see it as 3/11

LaPerduta · 20/07/2023 07:06

MoreCoffeeAndCake · 20/07/2023 07:01

I don't understand why people are basing on bedrooms.

Is the entire holiday going to be spent in the bedroom? Are both adults in the 2 parent families not using the communal spaces? Are both adults taking up only one spot on the sofa, is only one dining chair needed for both of them, etc?

Exactly! I've read the whole thread wondering why nobody has made this point.

In a villa you're also paying for living areas, kitchen, bathrooms, probably a pool, outside space, etc. The single parent is using 1/5 of those, not 1/3.

Lacucuracha · 20/07/2023 07:06

Sallyrush · 20/07/2023 07:02

OK. So I am family 3.

When I suggested cost per adult (like other posters have said we all have 2 kids so I was ignoring them!) this was a definite no, mainly based on each family having ‘2’ rooms and us all using the same facilities.

I agreed about the faculties but pointed out the villa we are looking at has 7 bedrooms so is irrelevant but I am more than happy to look for alternatives and share with my kids (if we go on holiday we always share one room) however this is the Villa everyone else seems to want.

So I suggested per person as that is, IMO, fair. If the boot was on the other foot and my siblings were the single parents I would never expect them to pay the same as the people with 2 salaries.

They are sticking to their guns and the implication is I am being difficult and petty.
my sisters words were ‘we can’t be having this every time we book something. It puts a damper on it already’ to which I responded ‘which is why I’m trying to sort this out now for things in the future’.

When I said I wanted to split food costs she said it was ridiculous and my son eats more fruit so should she be paying the same and if this is the route we are going down then she’s not interested in going. My son is 8. Hers is 14.

I feel very hurt and as some people have said ‘ganged up on’. My kids will be so upset if I say I’m not going and worry it will cause a rift in the long term.

We lost our mum and step dad in the past couple of years so they are the only family I have.

Ok, with new info that they want a 7 bed villa and you would be happy with a smaller villa, and also the disparity in ages (a 14yo will eat much more than an 8yo), YANBU.

It sounds like even if they agree to your suggestion, this holiday will be fraught with tension, so I would back out now and go away with just your dc or with a friend.

MyTruthIsOut · 20/07/2023 07:05

Sallyrush · 20/07/2023 07:02

OK. So I am family 3.

When I suggested cost per adult (like other posters have said we all have 2 kids so I was ignoring them!) this was a definite no, mainly based on each family having ‘2’ rooms and us all using the same facilities.

I agreed about the faculties but pointed out the villa we are looking at has 7 bedrooms so is irrelevant but I am more than happy to look for alternatives and share with my kids (if we go on holiday we always share one room) however this is the Villa everyone else seems to want.

So I suggested per person as that is, IMO, fair. If the boot was on the other foot and my siblings were the single parents I would never expect them to pay the same as the people with 2 salaries.

They are sticking to their guns and the implication is I am being difficult and petty.
my sisters words were ‘we can’t be having this every time we book something. It puts a damper on it already’ to which I responded ‘which is why I’m trying to sort this out now for things in the future’.

When I said I wanted to split food costs she said it was ridiculous and my son eats more fruit so should she be paying the same and if this is the route we are going down then she’s not interested in going. My son is 8. Hers is 14.

I feel very hurt and as some people have said ‘ganged up on’. My kids will be so upset if I say I’m not going and worry it will cause a rift in the long term.

We lost our mum and step dad in the past couple of years so they are the only family I have.

They sound absolutely vile!!

How on earth can anyone treat their sibling this way?! How can they be this hurtful?

Ot might upset your children if you don’t go but how could you even bear to be near your siblings both when you know how little respect and empathy they have towards you.

I would be so incredibly upset if I were you 😢

I’m astounded by this.

AutumnCrow · 20/07/2023 07:05

sweepleall · 20/07/2023 07:03

I would have assumed that one of the children might want or need more privacy/quiet and would nab it - if more than one of the children were in that position, they might take turns. So that could well be the single parent's children.

Not by the sounds of her last post.

RichardsGear · 20/07/2023 07:04

Well that's just shit OP and I'm sorry your family is treating you like that. You may have to be blunt and say you can't afford it, especially when you've offered to share in a different villa and they're adamant they want this one.

chocolateisavegetable · 20/07/2023 07:04

On the face of it, it would be fair to split accommodation costs evenly, but food definitely by person. In reality, as it’s siblings, it would be nice if the duel income families could help out the single parent financially if able to
do so

Nagado · 20/07/2023 07:04

If they’re siblings and can afford to rent a 7 bedroom villa between them, then I’d split the cost whichever way the family on the lowest income wanted to split it.

We go away with my DB and SiL for a cheapy UK break each year. This year, we’ve paid for 99% of it because they are broke and we’d rather have that time away with them than haggle over a few pounds. I appreciate that the cost of a 7 bedroom villa is going to be more than a few pounds, but it’s all relative to income. So I suppose it depends on what is more important to the other two families; that everything is totally equal or that all of you are able to spend that time together.

UndercoverCop · 20/07/2023 07:04

We went away with DN SIL and DNs they have two children and we have one, we didn't share accommodation it was a hotel, but the premise is the same.
They were happy to all bundle in to a family room with a sofa bed, we prefer our own space so booked a two bed suite. It cost us more because we had more accommodation. If we'd had the same accommodation it would've cost the same.
In your situation each family has two bedrooms so the cost should be split equally. Food per person because the single parent family will have less food than a couple

HoppingPavlova · 20/07/2023 07:03

Not enough info. For example the suggestion of splitting per person including adult/child inclusive of food etc would be relevant if all kids were roughly the same age, but a 1yo won’t eat nearly the same amount as a 10yo for example. So a family with 2 kids age 1 and 3 would likely ‘cost’ the same as a family with 1 child age 10. How is that dealt with. It all becomes so complicated so if everyone is using the same number of rooms roughly, I would just split it per family.

RhubarbFairy · 20/07/2023 07:03

We did this a few years ago, but with parents.
Family 1: Us. 2 adults. 2 DC
Family 2: 2 adults
Family 3: 1 adult.

We split the cost per person for accommodation.
If the 4 of us went away without extended family, we'd pay per person. Why should the others subsidise our holiday? Naturally, we paid more because there are more of us.

We paid for most of the food shop, but the others chucked in, too. We didn't get too hung up on that. Everyone was pretty easygoing if we had food, drinks, or snacks out, and it was a fairly even split, but done informally,'I'll get these, you got the last one'.

sweepleall · 20/07/2023 07:03

AutumnCrow · 20/07/2023 07:00

I’m still interested in Bedroom 7.

Who gets that? Because someone will nab it, and I doubt it’ll be the single parent.

I would have assumed that one of the children might want or need more privacy/quiet and would nab it - if more than one of the children were in that position, they might take turns. So that could well be the single parent's children.

IheartNiles · 20/07/2023 07:02

Accommodation by rooms used per family.
Food divided by head but obviously if some are teens and some toddlers then this needs to be factored in.
If the two earner families are better off it would be nice for them to help out the single parent sibling with some of the costs.
Budgets for these sort of trips should be dictated by the poorest family.

Sallyrush · 20/07/2023 07:02

OK. So I am family 3.

When I suggested cost per adult (like other posters have said we all have 2 kids so I was ignoring them!) this was a definite no, mainly based on each family having ‘2’ rooms and us all using the same facilities.

I agreed about the faculties but pointed out the villa we are looking at has 7 bedrooms so is irrelevant but I am more than happy to look for alternatives and share with my kids (if we go on holiday we always share one room) however this is the Villa everyone else seems to want.

So I suggested per person as that is, IMO, fair. If the boot was on the other foot and my siblings were the single parents I would never expect them to pay the same as the people with 2 salaries.

They are sticking to their guns and the implication is I am being difficult and petty.
my sisters words were ‘we can’t be having this every time we book something. It puts a damper on it already’ to which I responded ‘which is why I’m trying to sort this out now for things in the future’.

When I said I wanted to split food costs she said it was ridiculous and my son eats more fruit so should she be paying the same and if this is the route we are going down then she’s not interested in going. My son is 8. Hers is 14.

I feel very hurt and as some people have said ‘ganged up on’. My kids will be so upset if I say I’m not going and worry it will cause a rift in the long term.

We lost our mum and step dad in the past couple of years so they are the only family I have.

OP posts:
MoreCoffeeAndCake · 20/07/2023 07:01

I don't understand why people are basing on bedrooms.

Is the entire holiday going to be spent in the bedroom? Are both adults in the 2 parent families not using the communal spaces? Are both adults taking up only one spot on the sofa, is only one dining chair needed for both of them, etc?

MyTruthIsOut · 20/07/2023 07:00

TheCrystalPalace · 20/07/2023 06:52

The single parent is getting a whole room to themselves, whereas the couples are having to share.

Bloody hell!

A whole room to herself….well that totally makes up for the fact that she’s a single mother trying to cope in a COL crisis with possible little support from the childrens’ father.

She’s so lucky to be single….I bet she’s secretly laughing at her married siblings and their two incomes households as she’s thinking how much better she has it because they have to share a room and she doesn’t.

I hope you wouldn’t say something so offensive to someone who’d just been widowed.

AutumnCrow · 20/07/2023 07:00

I’m still interested in Bedroom 7.

Who gets that? Because someone will nab it, and I doubt it’ll be the single parent.

RichardsGear · 20/07/2023 06:56

sweepleall · 20/07/2023 06:45

I agree with that.

Where does it end otherwise?

What if one of the couples had a SAHP so were also a single income household? What if the single parent actually out earns one of the couples? What if one household inherited a house so they have no mortgage?

It's just too complicated to try and divide it by who has most money, much easier to go for what people actually use - family 3 uses a third of the villa but eats a bit less than a third of the food. They should pay for that.

Presumably the single parent isn't in any of these situations as they've actually indicated that the money is an issue. If they could happily absorb the extra cost then they wouldn't have brought it up.
OP has also said the other families have two incomes so no SAHP. In this particular situation they should pay per person.

sheeplikessleep · 20/07/2023 06:56

Accommodation split three ways.
Food and drink split by person.

No way would I expect family 3 to pay the same as family 1 and 2 for food and drink.

Even this approach, if I was in family 1 or 2, would offer / insist to pay more for accommodation than a family 3 (round up/ down).

What a delightful way to start a holiday 😬

Simplelobsterhat · 20/07/2023 06:56

I think the fairest way is to look at what it is actually costing, so villa split equally between families if getting to use the same number of similar size rooms each, but food split per person (maybe counting kids as half if they aren't teenagers). That's also a compromise between the two different suggestions on the post so also seems most diplomatic.

I think families 1 and 2 are being very unfair to expect everything to be equal between families when they know there are more people in their families - I get it if they were just trying to keep things simple and didn't think anyone was bothered, but once family 3 have objected how can they continue to dig their heels in when it is clear there are more of them so family 3 would be subsidizing them? It would be like continuing to insist on a restaurant bill being split equally after someone pointed out they had no alcohol and less courses. I'm not sure how they justify that to themselves?

Even going with the suggestion of just rooms being split equally between families the 2 parent families are getting a good deal as they will take up more space in communal room, bathroom times etc, but I get that's hard to account for. But I really can't see the justification of food being split by family unless the single parent family have said they don't mind to keep it simple, which they obviously haven't.

Herefornames · 20/07/2023 06:55

Accommodation should be split by rooms but food should definitely be split per person

PlasticineKing · 20/07/2023 06:55

Villa split equally as rooms/facilities approx the same.

Meals/food split per person, as the smaller family shouldn’t be subsidising the bigger two. Unless, as a PP pointed out there’s an imbalance of teens vs younger ones.

I’m not sure why you keep saying about the rooms and no other detail.

Interested to know what family you’re part of, at this point you have a fair amount of feedback.

LakieLady · 20/07/2023 06:54

A303 · 20/07/2023 06:36

My siblings would have to pay me to go on family with them and their offspring.

😁

I was having similar thoughts. My only sibling doesn't have kids, but I imagined a holiday with the in-laws and I struggle spending an afternoon with one lot and their kids, never mind a whole holiday!

MadamWhiteleigh · 20/07/2023 06:53

Accommodation split by rooms used per family.

Food per person.