Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People are announcing my baby’s birth

207 replies

Gotthekeeys · 19/07/2023 22:56

Would this annoy you?

I had a difficult birth and we told our parents they baby was here safely. Before I was even compos mentis MIL had announced it on the wider family WhatsApp group that I am in and included it ended in a c section.

AIBU to be very pissed off?

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 20/07/2023 01:10

Unless a whole pregnancy is a surprise to everyone else what reaction would people be looking for?

Is it some weird instagram new thing?

nokidshere · 20/07/2023 01:10

YABU to be 'very pissed off' because it really doesn't matter. A secret is only a secret if you keep it to yourself. Once you have told another person you lose control over it.

We told my mum exactly because we knew she'd tell everyone else and they wouldn't keep ringing us for news.

Don't spoil what is a happy time with such nonsense.

ThereIsThat · 20/07/2023 01:08

What does your partner think? I think it was a bit daft not mentioning to her beforehand that you didn't want her to share the news.

I've four kids who are now adults and I honestly can't remember how the baby news was distributed. It seems very unimportant.

Congrats on the new baby.

DeoForty · 20/07/2023 01:04

Comment under my MIL post read 'oh, I guess baby's born then' from my BIL wife. As if they hadn't ignored the phone call and text message to tell them so.

Easier to let it go OP. But no, it's not cricket.

DeoForty · 20/07/2023 01:02

I had a similarly shit birth and my MIL had put it on her Facebook before I had the control of my thumbs back again. To be fair, the really important people were told at the same time she was, and our FB circles don't really overlap, so I made a decision to shrug it off. It's a real lack of thought though.

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 20/07/2023 00:59

I'd be pissed. Common courtesy to at least ask though she may have asked your husband "shall I let your brothers and sisters know?" And he was too dazed to even recall that he said yes.
Re the section. It is odd why people call it out in a way that they would (mostly) never say "baby X delivered hale and hearty after a long battle with a pair of forceps" . But it is major surgery and it sets expectations that a) you will be in hospital for a few days and b) will need looking after for a bit so don't all expect a pub meet up on Sunday.
Only you know whether your MIL is thinking of you or is borderline judgemental. Make your own announcement in the way you wanted and with a beautiful pic with a clear request not to share on social media if that's what you want.

Congratulations - try to chill and look after yourself.

off · 20/07/2023 00:55

I don't have kids, so I'm missing any experience on that whole side of things. I don't have any opinion on how you "should" feel about it, and my perspective on it is that of someone who's never been in anything like your situation, so it can only really be about a possible viewpoint of the some of the other people in this whole thing.

I don't want to offend with my own perspective, as someone who's never experienced this situation but does have a family… this isn't meant as a comment on anything you might be feeling or would have wanted. It's more about imagining how I might feel as a family member, in the context of my own family situation.

If I had a sister, or even a cousin I was close to, and she had had a difficult labour resulting in (what sounds like) emergency major surgery, and possibly there had also been worries about my niece or nephew's life/health being at risk at some point, but it all turned out okay… well, to be honest being told only after a long delay of many hours or even some days might feel weird. Only finding out much, much later that a serious emergency had been happening for a member (or two) of my family, people I love had potentially been in danger, it had thankfully resolved well and happily, and I'd been oblivious to it all — when a family member knew about it, was in the WhatsApp group, and could have told us all straight away that this had happened but all involved were now doing well — it's… an unfamiliar situation. It might feel strange to look back on a conversation I'd had with the person who knew, in those hours or days afterwards before you shared your news, when they knew you'd been through hell and come out okay, but hadn't told anyone.

I absolutely know that I wouldn't be entitled to that information about somebody's health, but any other situation where a family member had a worrying medical emergency, had surgery and was now doing well etc., it would seem a bit odd to keep the whole thing from family for potentially hours or days, until the person involved chose to share.

But I do realise that giving birth isn't "any other situation", though, that there are big differences emotionally, culturally, relationally, socially, etc., and that people have really strong preferences about things like delaying announcements until they feel ready, choosing when/where/how/to whom they'll share, and so on.

I think maybe in a situation where there had been risk of things going wrong, in your MIL's position I might just feel an urge to share with family as soon as it's reasonable to do so — if not when the emergency is happening, then at least as soon as I know that everything's okay. A rush of relief, perhaps — releasing all that worry by sharing the fantastic news that everyone's okay. The trouble is, that doesn't mesh well with your autonomy, and your right to be the one sharing your big news when you're ready. It's a tough one.

I'm sorry it all feels like it's been taken out of your hands — I hope that the news-sharing was entirely without malice, and your relationship with your MIL isn't badly damaged.

Gotthekeeys · 20/07/2023 00:53

i felt the c section information was unnecessary

OP posts:
BorderlineCool · 20/07/2023 00:48

My mother in law announced my baby's birth on fb. She had literally just been born, I hadn't even told my siblings yet. I can't even tell you how angry I was!

I feel like it is definitely our news to share. I didn't go through a long, painful labour for someone else to announce the news. Sod that!! I feel you.

GodspeedJune · 20/07/2023 00:35

Yanbu. It is your news to share first, not theirs. The C-section detail is personal medical info that you may or may not have ever shared with them.

LawnmowerBlues · 20/07/2023 00:30

Yeah actually agree that telling everyone "it ended in a c section" is nobody's business.

Alba82 · 20/07/2023 00:26

SIL did this to us, all over Facebook including pics hubby had sent her privately. Our other kids & none of the grandparents were yet to see pics let alone meet baby. I was raging, I'd just had a c-section too & i really didn't need the world & his dog telling about it all.

You are definitely not being unreasonable

saraclara · 20/07/2023 00:25

If you want to announce the birth to the rest of the family yourself, then you need to make that clear to the grandparents..

pregnancyrollercoaster · 20/07/2023 00:24

First off congrats OP and delighted your bundle has arrived safely earthside ❤️

I would be extremely disappointed / pissed off if someone announced / shared the news of arrival before we had the opportunity to tell those we want to tell and there was absolutely no need to share the method of arrival either.

Try and enjoy the newborn bubble and don't be rushing to have visitors or go visiting 💖

Clymene · 20/07/2023 00:22

YABU. It's a family WhatsApp. Surely she was doing you a favour and saving you a job.

Good luck with the recovery and congratulations on your baby

LawnmowerBlues · 20/07/2023 00:17

BreadInCaptivity · 19/07/2023 23:13

I honestly don't get this hang up if I'm honest.

When DS was born DH and I spoke to both (now grandparents).

Didn't give a hoot beyond that - rather expected them to send the news through the family grapevine.

Was far too busy at the time with newborn.

Why this interest in other peoples reactions?

Enjoy your time with your baby.

Yeah, this. And thinking about other births in the family, I'm pretty sure I've always heard of them via the new grandparents too. Otherwise you are either waiting for the exhausted new parents to take time out of their precious day to text everyone they know, or nobody finds out about the new baby in the family for days or weeks! I really don't get the issue - and it's their news too, they have a new grandchild.

Agree on the sharing of photos though - that's not cool without permission, especially candid shots of the tired mum!

purpleboy · 20/07/2023 00:02

BreadInCaptivity · 19/07/2023 23:13

I honestly don't get this hang up if I'm honest.

When DS was born DH and I spoke to both (now grandparents).

Didn't give a hoot beyond that - rather expected them to send the news through the family grapevine.

Was far too busy at the time with newborn.

Why this interest in other peoples reactions?

Enjoy your time with your baby.

This...

How do you even have the time to be offended over this?

Wrongsideofpennines · 19/07/2023 23:25

YANBU. This would piss me off too. Its not their news to share. Both about the baby and about the birth which is your own personal medical details.

I ended up having an emergency c section with my 2nd pregnancy after a hugely traumatic first pregnancy. I was devastated and sharing details around the birth was super sensitive for me for a long time.

Congratulations on your new arrival BTW.

TheIsleOfTheLost · 19/07/2023 23:18

I was annoyed when someone put it on my facebook feed, as I didn't want there to be a public record for the child's privacy. Don't give a monkeys about relatives telling each other or their friends. She has become a grandma too. Unless you specifically called out beforehand that you would rather tell the family whatsapp, I think you are being a bit unreasonable. Congratulations on the birth of your child.

Waffle19 · 19/07/2023 23:14

YANBU. I could definitely see my MIL & FIL doing something like this so specifically asked them not to share the news any further when we sent them the first pic of DS2. It was 3am and I’d just had an EMCS and really didn’t want them to steal our thunder, just wanted to recover and enjoy baby before telling wider family, so I do really understand and sympathise with you.

BreadInCaptivity · 19/07/2023 23:13

I honestly don't get this hang up if I'm honest.

When DS was born DH and I spoke to both (now grandparents).

Didn't give a hoot beyond that - rather expected them to send the news through the family grapevine.

Was far too busy at the time with newborn.

Why this interest in other peoples reactions?

Enjoy your time with your baby.

EsmeSusanOgg · 19/07/2023 23:06

Though, as you mentioned it happened to be your MIL who blabbed - expect to be roasted jver the coals in this thread for no good reason.

EsmeSusanOgg · 19/07/2023 23:04

Yes. It is common knowledge it isn't an ok thing to do, but lots of people here will give be faic excuses for this behaviour because x/y/z was 'excited'.

Get your partner to reply in group and say, 'Baby is here, but we're not sharing this publically/ not for social media at the moment. @Gotthekeeys baby and I are getting some rest and will be happy to let you know when we have announced it more widely. For the moment we just need a little bit of time to recover. Speak to you all soon.'

Dinosauratemydaffodils · 19/07/2023 23:04

That the baby was here, probably not too much but bringing up the csection would have really annoyed me (but I have baggage).

Kaiserchief · 19/07/2023 23:03

I would not like it - I don’t share other people’s news and I wouldn’t expect them to share mine.