Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

People are announcing my baby’s birth

207 replies

Gotthekeeys · 19/07/2023 22:56

Would this annoy you?

I had a difficult birth and we told our parents they baby was here safely. Before I was even compos mentis MIL had announced it on the wider family WhatsApp group that I am in and included it ended in a c section.

AIBU to be very pissed off?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Muminthebluecoat · 27/07/2023 09:06

Did you tell them you didn't want anyone else to know. If you've announced it to them they may not have realised you weren't fully announcing it?

LawnmowerBlues · 25/07/2023 18:45

@GrinAndVomit I don't read it that way. I mean, maybe she does, but maybe she doesn't. I had almost every intervention going other than a C-section, and I genuinely had no bad feelings about that in terms of shame, disappointment etc (obviously I wasn't thrilled about some of what happened because it wasn't that pleasant, but I didn't take it personally iykwim). That said, it is still personal stuff about my private parts that happened behind closed doors! I don't mind telling other people about it where relevant and where the context feels right, but I'd feel violated to learn that my MIL had told the rest of my in-laws about it on WhatsApp. Frankly even if she said "LawnmowerBlues had a really straightforward vaginal birth" I'd feel violated too! Makes me feel like a unit of livestock, you know?

(I know I said I was bowing out but we're not arguing now 😅)

GrinAndVomit · 25/07/2023 18:34

LawnmowerBlues · 24/07/2023 13:50

"The last part of your reply is nonsense or bizarre paranoia"... Or, you know, having a sense of humour and perspective, which I think always helps with family stuff. What more can I say, clearly we are thinking of all sorts of different scenarios and comparing apples and oranges. I tried to bring lightness to it, you think the OP needs counselling because she wasn't thrilled about her MIL broadcasting details of her birth while she was still in hospital. I'm bowing out!

I think she needs counselling because there are obviously underlying feelings of discomfort with the fact she has had a cesarean. Women’s mental health is very important post birth.
Like there being no shame in having a caesarean, there is also no shame in having counselling to help with birth trauma.

Blossomtoes · 25/07/2023 09:43

SStarlet · 25/07/2023 08:21

All families are different, but personally I think this is about respecting that this is someone else's news to share. A simple, "I'm sure they'll let us all know when they're ready" would shut down any gossiping. I get people are excited and want to know everyone is OK, but give the parents a bit of space and time to share their own news. With the way things are now, but the time they've got over the shock of it all, everyone has moved on and they don't get to share the joy with everyone - seems a bit short sighted.

Nobody would believe it. Everyone knows grandparents are the first to know. If they said "I'm sure they'll let us all know when they're ready" while quite obviously bursting with excitement other people would just think they were complete tits and roll their eyes. The parents and grandparents are the only ones who really care anyway.

SStarlet · 25/07/2023 08:21

All families are different, but personally I think this is about respecting that this is someone else's news to share. A simple, "I'm sure they'll let us all know when they're ready" would shut down any gossiping. I get people are excited and want to know everyone is OK, but give the parents a bit of space and time to share their own news. With the way things are now, but the time they've got over the shock of it all, everyone has moved on and they don't get to share the joy with everyone - seems a bit short sighted.

Tempone · 24/07/2023 19:38

It's also different as it was abprivate family wats app group, not exactly telling half the town is it?;

Harry12345 · 24/07/2023 17:42

SStarlet · 24/07/2023 14:38

Having been through exactly the same experience as the poster, I can confirm that it's perfectly valid to be pissed off. I too had a difficult first arrival almost 12 years ago, which ended up in a C-section. My parents were first priority, as I'm an only child and they deserve to know that their daughter is safe and well, which then naturally extends to the grandchild. I was unwell afterwards, so we asked my parents not to share onwards yet. Next up were my husband's parents, who again we asked not to share onwards yet until we were home/settled/OK.

MIL decided the rules don't apply to her and preceded to immediately send an email out to half the world sharing about how amazing it was to become a grandmother etc etc with full details of everything, which included our very close friends who we had not yet told. I was furious (and hormonal) and so was my husband. This was our news to share first and foremost and I felt she stole that single chance to share news of our first born arriving.

We totally changed how we organised things when we had DD2 because of her behaviour (there were a bunch of other things which happened where she also ignored our requests/needs).

It turned out to be quite indicative of her relationship with our kids - essentially she wants to make it about her, she can't be bothered to be in contact with them or really speak to them when she does see them, and she's desperate to take the glory especially taking photos of her looking like a great grandparent. We have done our best to remain as neutral as possible and let the kids make their own minds up.

This is different you asked them not to

Harry12345 · 24/07/2023 17:35

GrinAndVomit · 24/07/2023 09:11

If mother and partner weren’t replying I would assume she was in labour, yes.
I would then probably ask the MIL the next day if everything was ok.
If that was ignored or was answered in a way similar “I’m not allowed to say”
then yes, I’d be worried.
I care about my family members. Even my in laws! #shock horror

Agree! Some families are obviously a lot closer than others. My sister would be worried sick and it wouldn’t be nice for her to ask my mum if there’s any news and my mum stay silent, really strange. My partner called grandparents and they let all siblings and aunts etc know. If you want it differently you would need to specify

SStarlet · 24/07/2023 14:38

Having been through exactly the same experience as the poster, I can confirm that it's perfectly valid to be pissed off. I too had a difficult first arrival almost 12 years ago, which ended up in a C-section. My parents were first priority, as I'm an only child and they deserve to know that their daughter is safe and well, which then naturally extends to the grandchild. I was unwell afterwards, so we asked my parents not to share onwards yet. Next up were my husband's parents, who again we asked not to share onwards yet until we were home/settled/OK.

MIL decided the rules don't apply to her and preceded to immediately send an email out to half the world sharing about how amazing it was to become a grandmother etc etc with full details of everything, which included our very close friends who we had not yet told. I was furious (and hormonal) and so was my husband. This was our news to share first and foremost and I felt she stole that single chance to share news of our first born arriving.

We totally changed how we organised things when we had DD2 because of her behaviour (there were a bunch of other things which happened where she also ignored our requests/needs).

It turned out to be quite indicative of her relationship with our kids - essentially she wants to make it about her, she can't be bothered to be in contact with them or really speak to them when she does see them, and she's desperate to take the glory especially taking photos of her looking like a great grandparent. We have done our best to remain as neutral as possible and let the kids make their own minds up.

LawnmowerBlues · 24/07/2023 13:50

GrinAndVomit · 24/07/2023 13:05

I’ve had three. I’m familiar with labour.

I’m unfamiliar with people not allowing anyone to tell family members that mum is ok and baby has arrived safely. The last part of your reply is nonsense or bizarre paranoia. MIL knew she was ok and simply passed on the good news.

I don’t get on with my MIL, and funnily enough had a horrific birth experience concerning her, but even I wouldn’t give a shit about this. It’s standard family communication.

The real issue here is that OP has negative feelings about receiving a caesarean. She should possibly consider counselling to help her reframe this. There’s no shame in having major abdominal surgery but it’s also not usual to inform other family members.

"The last part of your reply is nonsense or bizarre paranoia"... Or, you know, having a sense of humour and perspective, which I think always helps with family stuff. What more can I say, clearly we are thinking of all sorts of different scenarios and comparing apples and oranges. I tried to bring lightness to it, you think the OP needs counselling because she wasn't thrilled about her MIL broadcasting details of her birth while she was still in hospital. I'm bowing out!

Runnerduck34 · 24/07/2023 13:46

When my DC were born our parents let family know, siblings, aunts ,uncles etc
We told our friends.
Mind you our parents werent on SM so it was a phone call, no photos.
I suspect people were asking and MIL didnt realise it would upset you, however I think announcing it on the group whatsapp that you are also on probably wasnt the best way to do it. Congratulations on your new baby.

GrinAndVomit · 24/07/2023 13:05

LawnmowerBlues · 24/07/2023 12:58

Yeah but where have you got the idea that people would be refusing to answer normal questions in a weird way? Surely more likely is, you happen to text when unbeknownst to you the mum's in labour, and soon enough you'll either get a text announcing the birth, or some kind of generic holding text if it's taking a while? But it's that thing about "dumping out" - we should put your worries onto people further removed than us, not closer. Birth can be stressful enough without the mum having to worry about keeping up with correspondence, or having every detail splashed around before she is even aware. Can't think of much worse than the idea of people sitting around at home saying "ooh, she's taking a long time! Waters broke at 2.15, Derek said, so you'd think we'd have heard by now... Now, she does have narrow hips, I've always said, so I wouldn't be surprised if she has trouble, but then the young girls these days make such a fuss... " 😅😓

I’ve had three. I’m familiar with labour.

I’m unfamiliar with people not allowing anyone to tell family members that mum is ok and baby has arrived safely. The last part of your reply is nonsense or bizarre paranoia. MIL knew she was ok and simply passed on the good news.

I don’t get on with my MIL, and funnily enough had a horrific birth experience concerning her, but even I wouldn’t give a shit about this. It’s standard family communication.

The real issue here is that OP has negative feelings about receiving a caesarean. She should possibly consider counselling to help her reframe this. There’s no shame in having major abdominal surgery but it’s also not usual to inform other family members.

LawnmowerBlues · 24/07/2023 12:58

GrinAndVomit · 24/07/2023 09:11

If mother and partner weren’t replying I would assume she was in labour, yes.
I would then probably ask the MIL the next day if everything was ok.
If that was ignored or was answered in a way similar “I’m not allowed to say”
then yes, I’d be worried.
I care about my family members. Even my in laws! #shock horror

Yeah but where have you got the idea that people would be refusing to answer normal questions in a weird way? Surely more likely is, you happen to text when unbeknownst to you the mum's in labour, and soon enough you'll either get a text announcing the birth, or some kind of generic holding text if it's taking a while? But it's that thing about "dumping out" - we should put your worries onto people further removed than us, not closer. Birth can be stressful enough without the mum having to worry about keeping up with correspondence, or having every detail splashed around before she is even aware. Can't think of much worse than the idea of people sitting around at home saying "ooh, she's taking a long time! Waters broke at 2.15, Derek said, so you'd think we'd have heard by now... Now, she does have narrow hips, I've always said, so I wouldn't be surprised if she has trouble, but then the young girls these days make such a fuss... " 😅😓

GrinAndVomit · 24/07/2023 09:11

bussteward · 24/07/2023 08:35

You wouldn’t think, “Oh, the baby’s due around now, she’s probably in labour or busy enjoying the baby”. You’d leap straight to worry?

It’s not OP’s family group anyway, it’s her in-laws’ and we’ve no idea how active she is in the chat.

If mother and partner weren’t replying I would assume she was in labour, yes.
I would then probably ask the MIL the next day if everything was ok.
If that was ignored or was answered in a way similar “I’m not allowed to say”
then yes, I’d be worried.
I care about my family members. Even my in laws! #shock horror

bussteward · 24/07/2023 08:35

GrinAndVomit · 24/07/2023 06:39

Imagine if a close family member was approaching her due date, when suddenly she and her partner stopped replying to messages and when I asked in the family WhatsApp group if everything was ok, I got radio silence from even the MIL or a reply that said “I’m not allowed to say”
I’d be very worried.

You wouldn’t think, “Oh, the baby’s due around now, she’s probably in labour or busy enjoying the baby”. You’d leap straight to worry?

It’s not OP’s family group anyway, it’s her in-laws’ and we’ve no idea how active she is in the chat.

Noodles1234 · 24/07/2023 08:03

I’d be annoyed too.

i also think this when people post photos online of a newly married couple / video the ceremony and post it live etc. It’s not yours to share it’s theirs if they want to!
there is a social gravitas people should uphold, I think just pre elation from new grandparents is to blame, and in a way it’s quite sweet - annoyingly sweet!
congratulations.

Peddlefaster · 24/07/2023 06:59

YABU. It’s happy news and you really shouldn’t get wound up by people being happy for you. Congratulations

GrinAndVomit · 24/07/2023 06:39

bussteward · 24/07/2023 04:58

Why would they be sitting worried and waiting? As far as they were aware, OP was pregnant; unless MIL was also WhatsApping updates on the labour and the surgery. Life would be long and stressful if we all worried and stressed for the last weeks of someone else’s pregnancy.

Imagine if a close family member was approaching her due date, when suddenly she and her partner stopped replying to messages and when I asked in the family WhatsApp group if everything was ok, I got radio silence from even the MIL or a reply that said “I’m not allowed to say”
I’d be very worried.

whatthinkyou · 24/07/2023 05:53

I don't think anyone is "announcing" the birth.

They are simply telling someone else you've had the baby!

What's wrong with that?

The only problem I see is if you asked them NOT to tell anyone!

bussteward · 24/07/2023 04:58

Harry12345 · 24/07/2023 01:16

Jesus Christ she shared it with her sons siblings and family who would all be sitting worried waiting to hear how they both are!

Why would they be sitting worried and waiting? As far as they were aware, OP was pregnant; unless MIL was also WhatsApping updates on the labour and the surgery. Life would be long and stressful if we all worried and stressed for the last weeks of someone else’s pregnancy.

Harry12345 · 24/07/2023 01:16

Soothingaftersun · 20/07/2023 07:51

I'm in and included it ended in a c section

Telling family that baby has arrived is one thing but MIL should not have put this bit IMO. I agree with you OP but it's done so I'd let it go.

I'd be weary of the level of detail you share with MIL about personal things as she is obviously prone to repeating everything and anything with everyone. So if she doesn't know she can't share. Tell DH if this is your wish going forward.

Congratulations on your baby , hope you have a speedy recovery Bear

Jesus Christ she shared it with her sons siblings and family who would all be sitting worried waiting to hear how they both are!

phoenixrosehere · 23/07/2023 13:00

bussteward · 21/07/2023 12:24

Yes, how dare a woman control who knows when she’s likely to be in labour Confused

My DH mentioned when I was induced (didn’t say he couldn’t and hadn’t even entered my head about them knowing) and it was about three days of texts ”is the baby here yet”, “why is it taking so long”, etc.

It was our first and if the baby was here, we would have let them know.

SIL went into labour a few years later while we were visiting DH’s family and we saw firsthand them moaning about how long it was taking, even FIL saying SIL was being difficult as if she has any control over how quickly birth happens. It was the sixth grandchild so it’s not like it was something new and several of the grandchildren are less than two years apart including two that were two weeks apart.

I can absolutely understand why some parents aren’t keen or wouldn’t tell family members until baby is here.

hot2trotter · 23/07/2023 12:36

So are "people" announcing the birth (as per the thread title) or is it just MIL?

If it bothers you that much why tell her in the first place. Wait until you actually want people to know.

celticprincess · 23/07/2023 10:55

Gotthekeeys · 20/07/2023 01:19

@WandaWonder of course the whole pregnancy wasn’t a surprise but ideally I’d have rathered the c section part was omitted

Why wouldn’t you want people to know about the c section? Surely it would set expectations of the next few weeks such as not jumping up and meeting people, not being able to drive, and needing a bit more time to recover.

Our issue with news was that not long after our baby was born, naturally, they were whisked up to SCBU as they weren’t breathing properly. We didn’t see baby for quite a few hours and weren’t kept as in the loop as we would have liked. Then, if news had have leaked we would have had people texting and wanting pictures and us not even knowing how our baby was. We rang both our parents to explain the situation and not to tell anyone until we knew the actual situation. Once we did, we had to explain we couldn’t really have visitors to see the baby in the hospital due to rules in the SCBU. With our other child we were happy to have the news shared further out from those we told immediately. But we knew we would have to be quick. My DM was first to know as she drove us to the hospital as MIL/FIL live miles away. Baby was early so not in the position where we were being asked daily, so we were able to contact them pretty swiftly. No group what’s app back then and neither used social media.

HoobleDooble · 23/07/2023 10:38

My MiL took it upon herself to announce our wedding in the local paper without consulting me. Told everyone far and wide my street address, where I worked, spelled my sister's name wrong and put the crappiest photo of me on it. I still love her most of the time.