Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

24 hours in A&E

65 replies

1down · 19/07/2023 21:47

How do they get the unwell or injured patients concent? Do they film first then ask?
Watching it ATM and a lad has been taken to the hospital after being run over. He was airlifted in. In no condition to agree to something. So do they film all his medical stuff to the point he can say yes and if he says no they then delete?? His family didn't get to the hospital till an hour later. And they can't give his permission anyway.
Because if it happens like that it seems like a total violation of his privacy.
Anyone know?

OP posts:
ASGIRC · 19/07/2023 23:58

From what ive seen, in resus, at St Georges, it doesnt seem like there are many camera crews. The cameras seem to be fixed, most in the ceiling/sides of the rooms. Much like CCTV.
And then there might be crews once the family is there and the patient is awake and probably has given consent.

CactusUmbrella · 19/07/2023 23:57

I was on 24 hours in A&E so feel I can answer this!

They asked my sibling (who was the one rushed into the hospital) for consent. They groggily said yes.

They had the main story of the episode and I was interviewed as part of it. They asked constantly for consent, we signed so many forms and had so many opportunities to pull out. One of the crew came round and showed us the DVD first, too. To make sure we were happy.

They were all very nice!

(PS the interviews with the family are filmed in airbnbs rather than their houses!)

wbanso · 19/07/2023 23:49

FannyCann · 19/07/2023 23:47

No way would I consent. My pain/distress/family member's accident is not entertainment for the masses.

Maybe we should get bright red wristbands saying #NoConsent to wear like emergency alert bracelets, that hospitals and camera crew all recognise.

You're going to wear a wrist band every day in case you somehow end up in car crash and can't say no to filming, seems a bit OTT.

FannyCann · 19/07/2023 23:47

No way would I consent. My pain/distress/family member's accident is not entertainment for the masses.

Maybe we should get bright red wristbands saying #NoConsent to wear like emergency alert bracelets, that hospitals and camera crew all recognise.

XenoBitch · 19/07/2023 23:40

I just Googled about consent required for such programs. For 999 Whats Your Emergency, you can still appear on the series even if you do not give consent. You are blurred out/voice is disguised. This is disgusting.

I would absolutely still recognise myself.

TaigaSno · 19/07/2023 23:36

Leo227 · 19/07/2023 21:51

at St George's once when I went there were signs everywhere saying filming was taking place, so they must film a bit of it and then ask consent when possible

I've heard before that this was the case, and it really annoyed me. For some people, they wouldn't want to be on camera for all sorts of reasons, and I wonder if there was ever an instance that someone needed to go to hospital but didn't go because they were worried about being filmed. It seems horribly invasive, the way they do it.

Swansandcustard · 19/07/2023 23:35

24 hrs in police Custody: police/staff are asked if they’re happy to be featured, blurred out if they’re not happy. Those victims/witnesses/suspects are all asked.

The cameras are set up rolling at intervals, for an interesting job a crew trots around and films specific segments. There are fixed cameras inside offices as well as traditional mobile cams and microphones. The on site teams are YOUNG! And lovely 🙂

BumWhisperers · 19/07/2023 23:32

What gets me is that for some procedures or in investigations, private regions of the body would be seen on the footage - even if you dont consent to it being shown on tv, the very fact that it was filmed at all would make me seriously angry and feel very violated.

XenoBitch · 19/07/2023 23:31

Bluelightbaby · 19/07/2023 23:24

We regularly have film crews at our ambulance station. They film first then ask for consent, either from patient or family of

Can the staff deny consent?
TBH, I would think poorly of a paramedic who would let film crew go out with them.

1down · 19/07/2023 23:28

Bluelightbaby · 19/07/2023 23:24

We regularly have film crews at our ambulance station. They film first then ask for consent, either from patient or family of

What happens if the patient is not able to either give or deny concent?

OP posts:
1down · 19/07/2023 23:27

Cctv is there for the saftey of all the staff and users. Not the entertainment of the masses.
And is not in areas where treatment may be happening and could be of a personal nature. It would be illegal to have cctv in a bay for instance as people would potentially be undressed etc.

I'm not really sure what you mean about assault tho

OP posts:
Bluelightbaby · 19/07/2023 23:25

I should add as we go into a job we ask them and then legal consent is gathered after all filming

Bluelightbaby · 19/07/2023 23:24

We regularly have film crews at our ambulance station. They film first then ask for consent, either from patient or family of

XenoBitch · 19/07/2023 23:19

lljkk · 19/07/2023 23:16

already been filmed before the person is able to concent. So their privacy has already been invaded.

How is that so different from CCTV, which is everywhere including in the same hospitals. TV Broadcast is what consent is for.

Unless you commit a crime, then it gets broadcast anyway, consent or not.

I'm amazed I've never seen patients try to assault the health care workers on these programmes. Guess they didn't get consent...

CCTV is a world apart from a camera crew zooming in on a poorly loved ones face, or filming conversations in the waiting room.
It is also different to filming a very intimate interaction between someone on a bridge and the cops trying to talk them down.

lljkk · 19/07/2023 23:16

already been filmed before the person is able to concent. So their privacy has already been invaded.

How is that so different from CCTV, which is everywhere including in the same hospitals. TV Broadcast is what consent is for.

Unless you commit a crime, then it gets broadcast anyway, consent or not.

I'm amazed I've never seen patients try to assault the health care workers on these programmes. Guess they didn't get consent...

loobylou10 · 19/07/2023 23:04

'Try google that will tell you how it’s obtained'

Helpful! Added so much to the discussion.

Lisdeflores · 19/07/2023 23:00

I agree it is unethical .
I wonder if you would have any legal recourse if you were brought in unconscious or unable to give informed consent and filming took place. Even if that film never made it to the tv its still an invasion of privacy.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 19/07/2023 22:52

I don't know but I think it's unethical of them to film people receiving medical treatment. If I was in a major accident I wouldn't want random footage being taken even if they asked consent before airing it.

XenoBitch · 19/07/2023 22:46

Lisdeflores · 19/07/2023 22:45

Perhaps there should be a box on our medical records, -I do/don't consent to bring filmed during my stay in hospital.
I would hate it, my pain being presented as entertainment
I often wonder why the hospitals agree to it I presume they make money out of it

That wont make much different to the series that get material outside of hospital... ambulance crews and the like.

Lisdeflores · 19/07/2023 22:45

Perhaps there should be a box on our medical records, -I do/don't consent to bring filmed during my stay in hospital.
I would hate it, my pain being presented as entertainment
I often wonder why the hospitals agree to it I presume they make money out of it

Prescottdanni123 · 19/07/2023 22:41

Personally, I would hate being filmed and would feel violated if someone filmed me unconscious or incapcitated to the point where I didn't know what was going on around me or couldn't consent.

Another thing that makes me uncomfortable is that the people sat at home watching don't want to see a whole series of broken ankles and mild concussions. Whenever a serious or interesting case is brought in, the producers and camera men must be jumping up and down with excitement. And I just keep thinking 'That is a human being lying there. Vulnerable and terrified'.

CarrieO · 19/07/2023 22:36

Wrong not worth!

CarrieO · 19/07/2023 22:36

I was in St George’s A&E a few years ago. There were signs up everywhere. They asked if I consented to being filmed and I said no - I felt far too ill!

I agree it feels worth to film people without consent even if the footage won’t be shown.

Elphame · 19/07/2023 22:33

1down · 19/07/2023 22:28

I think my issue with it is that it has already been filmed before the person is able to concent. So their privacy has already been invaded.
Seems incredibly insensitive

Completely agree. There is no way I would ever consent to being filmed.

XenoBitch · 19/07/2023 22:31

1down · 19/07/2023 22:28

I think my issue with it is that it has already been filmed before the person is able to concent. So their privacy has already been invaded.
Seems incredibly insensitive

I totally agree!

Swipe left for the next trending thread