Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My manager has denounced non-strikers but I truly can’t afford it

308 replies

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:05

In the office today the topic of upcoming strikes came up (public sector). My manager is as left-wing as they come and was not shy in sharing her contempt for people who don’t choose to strike. I’m really worried because I can’t afford to go on strike and she’s (obviously) going to find out that I’m not striking. I’m worried it’s going to damage our relationship. Has anyone been in this situation before?

OP posts:
JudgeJudee · 20/07/2023 10:28

I always thought that the employers were punished by having to pay employees for not working!

Apply a bit of critical thinking here, OP.

Why should employers be “punished”?

Why would anyone ever work if you could strike, get paid for it, secure a pay rise. Surely everyone would go straight back out on strike again immediately and continue that cycle?

I have little time for most modern unions as my work involves working with people who have often taken advice of one and it’s caused issues. With no exception, every single union I’ve ever encountered is shit at local level. I’ve been privy to meetings where I’ve seen union reps basically barter people.

But I can’t get my head around voting for strike action then sitting back and planning to pass a picket of fellow members, collect your day’s wages, and then clapping yourself on the back when the action has had a positive outcome.

I hate when there are strikes covered on tv/in the press and strikers hide behind their placards. If you believe in something and cote to support it, support it.

Honestly OP, if this is real, think really hard about what you’re going to do on strike days. Passing a picket, especially when you’re a member, will mean you’ll get eaten alive.

Pippa12 · 20/07/2023 10:20

You would be a fool to leave a union over disagreeing in strike action in health care. The union does far more than organise strikes??? Especially if you make a ginormous mistake? Indemnity insurance?

FWIW we were all very open and honest who was striking and who wasn’t, it was no problem. No hard feelings or bullying either way!

Thank god we don’t work with a lot of you lot!

TheOtterInTheHat · 20/07/2023 10:15

WilkinsonM · 20/07/2023 08:12

She's talking about following the majority decision of the union and not crossing picket lines as being 'invisible rules' of being in a union. Of course they aren't invisible at all, but she is as just ignorant to them.

But surely using logical thinking OP could’ve come to that conclusion? I’m not in a union, don’t know anyone who’s in one (at least none that have spoken about it), but even I know that a union works if members act as a collective. It’s called a ‘union’ not a ‘suggestion’.

That being said though, especially after reading another thread the other day where an OP’s DP and many posters couldn’t decipher typos and make context connections, logical thinking isn’t something many take the time out of their day to engage in.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 10:11

OTOH I do remember our Union Reps being very veryclear in associated comms on the issue that if you were not prepared to actually withdraw your labour you should not vote "yes" to IA.

Thanks for clarifying - that seems clear enough, then; but I suppose it depends on how active your union reps are and how good their communications. I get the distinct impression that some of them are so longstanding and entrenched in their position and associated fundamental beliefs/politics, that they forget that others may not be as aware of it all as they are.

I would also hope that they would make clear to people what their free options are and not just assume/browbeat everybody into doing what they personally believe is the right thing.

cyclamenqueen · 20/07/2023 10:08

DisquietintheRanks · 20/07/2023 09:58

Do you think most strikers are "very privileged "? Really?

No one is owed more than common courtesy at work. Certainly not friendship.

No I don’t but this poster has specifically said that she has lost ‘thousands’ which means either she is very highly paid and privileged or she is exaggerating

0021andabit · 20/07/2023 10:06

Clementineorsatsuma · 20/07/2023 09:59

@Clutchy
OP explained that she supports it ethically. But she has to prioritise her family situation. 3 days of vastly reduced income would be enough to break many people atm.
Let the others like her wealthy manager take the strain right now.

But if only managers or the better paid workers were to strike, the strike would collapse.

The point of the union is collective action. You get the protection of the Union, their legal advise, the pay & conditions etc they win for you etc & in exchange you work collectively to fight for your rights & conditions.

If your circumstances have changed since you voted & you really, really can’t afford to strike anymore then speak to your union about hardship funds but don't take crossing a picket line lightly.

notimagain · 20/07/2023 10:04

Clementineorsatsuma · 20/07/2023 09:59

@Clutchy
OP explained that she supports it ethically. But she has to prioritise her family situation. 3 days of vastly reduced income would be enough to break many people atm.
Let the others like her wealthy manager take the strain right now.

Supporting Industrial Action ethically counts for absolutely nothing and going into work actually weakens/undermines the position of those that do actually take IA.

If the OP wasn't prepared to strike, for whatever reason, including family, they should not have voted yes to the action.

holycannaloni · 20/07/2023 10:02

I have sympathy with you in some ways as I am not someone who has ever struck, even when I worked in areas where there was striking. I personally don’t agree with it. BUT, I have never joined a union and I have never voted to strike. You have done both so you have entered into a contract to strike. This is why people shouldn’t just blindly join unions without understanding the point of them. I do think it’s pretty poor if you stay in the union and want to benefit from their help but don’t strike. If I were you and felt as you do and were in your position of realising that I had voted for strike action I didn’t want to participate in then I would leave the union. It’s the only fair thing to do.

Jellycatspyjamas · 20/07/2023 10:01

Let the others like her wealthy manager take the strain right now.

Except it won’t be her manager, it’ll be her peers and colleagues taking the strain while she reaps the benefit of them taking that strain. If you don’t agree with collective action, don’t join a union.

Clementineorsatsuma · 20/07/2023 09:59

@Clutchy
OP explained that she supports it ethically. But she has to prioritise her family situation. 3 days of vastly reduced income would be enough to break many people atm.
Let the others like her wealthy manager take the strain right now.

User894532765 · 20/07/2023 09:58

ArcticSkewer · 20/07/2023 09:20

I think op's manager is the least of her worries, frankly.

I hope for her sake she hasn't told anyone she voted for strike action because when they find out she worked, I would expect her to be ostracized by her colleagues. I'd keep very quiet about that.

People know not everyone will strike, that's expected, but to vote for it then not strike, OMG

And what a bully you sound

0021andabit · 20/07/2023 09:58

Obviously, your manager should not be harassing or intimidating you, but the whole point of a Union is strength is numbers. If you’re a member of the union & you voted to strike I do think you have a moral obligation to strike alongside your coworkers - you’ll benefit from the pay rise if your union wins one. Speak to your Union about hardship funds.

DisquietintheRanks · 20/07/2023 09:58

cyclamenqueen · 20/07/2023 09:53

I would keep quiet about that, bullying is gross misconduct and even if you do it to a work colleague outside of the work space that’s still applicable. Only the very privileged few can afford to give up ‘thousands’ and if you are one of those then you are very lucky . Are you prepared to put a roof over someone’s head, buy their food shop or maybe you could offer to pay someone’s rent. A little compassion for people less fortunate might be a better recruiting tool than name calling and sending people to Coventry .

Do you think most strikers are "very privileged "? Really?

No one is owed more than common courtesy at work. Certainly not friendship.

notimagain · 20/07/2023 09:56

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 09:25

I've never worked in a unionised job, so I don't know. What do the ballots actually say? Do they say something like 'Are you in favour of an agreement for strike action?' or is it more explicit, like 'Will you join us in striking if the majority agree?' ?

I get that OP might well have been misguided in her vote, but I think the way it's framed is important. On the one hand, people are angrily criticising those who don't strike yet don't refuse any pay increases or concessions (is this even possible?) won as a result of the strike action; but on the other hand, are those who vote not to strike - whether because they don't believe in it/don't want to/can't afford to - also angrily criticised for not showing solidarity with those who do want/feel the need to strike?

I voted in two or three ballots over the years and TBH I can't remember what they all said..

OTOH I do remember our Union Reps being very very clear in associated comms on the issue that if you were not prepared to actually withdraw your labour you should not vote "yes" to IA.

Guardiansofthegalaxi · 20/07/2023 09:54

If you can’t afford it, don’t do it. There is absolutely no point putting yourself in financial difficulty. Ignore anyone who has a go for you voting to strike but not striking. Maybe circumstances have changed. Maybe an unexpected bill came about. Whatever. These people and your manager are not living your life with your specific set of circumstances and with the stretch on finances everywhere right now, you absolutely should not put yourself in a position where you then struggle financially.

cyclamenqueen · 20/07/2023 09:53

ArcticSkewer · 20/07/2023 09:47

Would I endorse it?
Difficult.

Honestly, on the back of months of lack of pay, I couldn't be more than 'work civil' with someone who had voted for strike action then not done it themselves. So I wouldn't do anything beyond minimal work communication.

Other people where I work would be really vicious about it. As I said, I am more sympathetic when people either leave the union or choose not to strike because they can't afford it, and voted against it.

I don't know though, in a case like this. I wouldn't want anything to do with them in a non work context for sure. I suppose that is a type of social ostracism but can you really expect anything else when your actions cost someone else thousands? Certainly I don't support violence.

I certainly wouldn't advise her to tell anyone she voted for the strikes. I really think her manager is the least of her problems. Her manager is more bound by duty to be impartial. Her colleagues could be a lot nastier. If people don't know she's in the union, or assume she voted against, they might not be too bothered. Depends where she works.

I would keep quiet about that, bullying is gross misconduct and even if you do it to a work colleague outside of the work space that’s still applicable. Only the very privileged few can afford to give up ‘thousands’ and if you are one of those then you are very lucky . Are you prepared to put a roof over someone’s head, buy their food shop or maybe you could offer to pay someone’s rent. A little compassion for people less fortunate might be a better recruiting tool than name calling and sending people to Coventry .

Jellycatspyjamas · 20/07/2023 09:51

I thought if you voted to strike you have to strike and if you didn’t then you can’t? That’s what I’ve always been told, but maybe that’s wrong!

That is wrong. If you’re a union member and the membership vote for strike action, you should go on strike regardless of how you individually voted. Unions exist to organise workers to take collective action to protect workers rights - members sign up to gain the protections afforded by that collective action and so should be part of collective action when called for.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 09:51

I can see some parallels here with when people harshly criticised the very elderly people who voted in favour of Brexit, on the grounds that they were forcing their opinions and suffering on younger people who would have to live with it, whilst they themselves would soon have passed on.

Interestingly, I don't recall seeing criticism of very elderly people who used their vote and voted to remain - even though somebody in their mid/late 90s was clearly not likely to end up affected either way, by the time any changes would be seen, so could arguably have figured that the 'fairest' course of action was to abstain and leave it for those who would be affected to decide.

namechange55465 · 20/07/2023 09:50

itsmyp4rty · 20/07/2023 08:25

People are really funny about unions and striking OP, they turn into fucking communists I swear.

I would not say anything to anyone about your choices, you can choose to vote for people to strike if they choose to and you don't have to strike yourself - there is literally nothing to say you can't do that. You can also vote against a strike and then choose to strike. You pay to be in that Union and you are perfectly entitled to do what you need to.

People are assholes about it though, militants on their own high horses bleating on like it's still the 1970's. Unfortunately your boss sounds like one of them so don't tell her what you're doing and if she finds out after then say you couldn't afford not to work. If she starts treating you badly over it then make a complaint as she is not allowed to do that - and that is actually a rule.

It's just a bit of a dick move though isn't it, voting for other people to strike on your behalf?

They probably don't want to lose a day's pay either but they understand that being in the union carries an obligation to strike if the majority of the union wants to strike.

If you don't want to take part in strike action when the union votes for it then you shouldn't be in the union, and you CERTAINLY shouldn't vote for the strike.

The OP clearly knows that now, but I don't think it's reasonable to refer to posters who have pointed that out as "fucking communists", "militant" etc.

ArcticSkewer · 20/07/2023 09:47

WeightInLine · 20/07/2023 09:28

Would you endorse that @ArcticSkewer ? Ostracising someone at work? Isolating them?

What’s quite shocking on this thread is how righteous people can be, when they are basically being nasty.

Do not bully your colleagues, however they vote, whether they strike or not. Do not go along with ‘having an opinion’ and airing that with the intention of making people uncomfortable at work. Just don’t be unpleasant - leave people to their own lawful decisions. You are not entitled to dictate or spite their behaviour and work environment.

Would I endorse it?
Difficult.

Honestly, on the back of months of lack of pay, I couldn't be more than 'work civil' with someone who had voted for strike action then not done it themselves. So I wouldn't do anything beyond minimal work communication.

Other people where I work would be really vicious about it. As I said, I am more sympathetic when people either leave the union or choose not to strike because they can't afford it, and voted against it.

I don't know though, in a case like this. I wouldn't want anything to do with them in a non work context for sure. I suppose that is a type of social ostracism but can you really expect anything else when your actions cost someone else thousands? Certainly I don't support violence.

I certainly wouldn't advise her to tell anyone she voted for the strikes. I really think her manager is the least of her problems. Her manager is more bound by duty to be impartial. Her colleagues could be a lot nastier. If people don't know she's in the union, or assume she voted against, they might not be too bothered. Depends where she works.

SunRainStorm · 20/07/2023 09:46

If you receive a pay rise as a result of the strike I hope you donate it to your colleagues who made it happen while you undermined them by continuing to work.

Contact your union and ask if there is a hardship fund.

Zimunya · 20/07/2023 09:46

If there's one thing that has become clear throughout this post, it's that the unions need to get a lot better at communicating.

Carryonkeepinggoing · 20/07/2023 09:40

ArcticSkewer · 20/07/2023 09:18

"I suspect those banging the you must do it or your a scab drum aren’t in the midst of repeated strikes"

Isn't it more likely that we are the ones in the midst of repeated strikes?

I'm only just getting back on track after losing weeks of pay. Honestly, I would be beyond pissed off if I found out that someone I worked with voted in favour of putting me on strike while they never had any intention of doing it. I voted against and am mightily pissed off to be having to strike but I decided to go with the majority vote.

The idea that some total user would deliberately vote to make other people do it on their behalf is awful! I personally would understand people voting against, or not voting, then not striking because they can't afford it. But to vote others into weeks of poverty is absolutely disgusting.

I think you should leave the thread now. You’re just berating the OP for a situation she can no longer change and actually for something she did not actually do. She did not deliberately act in a way that would cause financial hardship to her colleagues in order to benefit herself. She voted wrong, and people on this thread have clearly explained to her that she misunderstood the purpose of voting. You can call her ignorant and disgusting, or you can accept that this is actually not universal common knowledge and tell your union that you’ve recently realised many people, even those in unions, don’t understand how these votes are meant to work and perhaps some changes need to be made to communication. Like they could write on the ballot papers that strike votes are meant to be a real indication of who will actually go on strike if one is called, not just a vague representation of support for the concept of a hypothetical strike, or support for others’ right to strike. Put it in capital letters on the ballot paper ! ´Please vote for a strike only if you are willing and able to strike for at least X days if a strike is called’.

DisquietintheRanks · 20/07/2023 09:40

Nat6999 · 20/07/2023 02:28

If you aren't prepared to support the results of the ballot, you shouldn't have voted to strike & you shouldn't be in the union.

This. Its just getting other people to take the hit on your behalf.

BodegaSushi · 20/07/2023 09:38

Strik · 20/07/2023 01:10

I hear what you say about leaving the union but it offers protections that are nothing to do with striking/pay.

I genuinely thought I was doing a good thing by voting yes to striking as the union said they needed a certain % of people to vote in favour for it to happen. I am not from a mining/factory background like previous posters. My family all work in the private sector so no I don’t have any idea about the moral code. In fact it was only fairly recently I learned that you don’t get paid on strike days. I always thought that the employers were punished by having to pay employees for not working! Bit harsh to repeatedly call me a dick. Some people just don’t know the invisible rules about all this stuff.

I'm not from a mining family, and I'm not even from this country, yet I know that if you're in, you're in. Not just for some of the benefits. Then again, you'll still benefit from the payrise even if you don't strike, right?

I couldn't afford to strike whether, but I did. And we got out payrise. And people like you got to eat their cake and have it too.