Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My manager has denounced non-strikers but I truly can’t afford it

308 replies

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:05

In the office today the topic of upcoming strikes came up (public sector). My manager is as left-wing as they come and was not shy in sharing her contempt for people who don’t choose to strike. I’m really worried because I can’t afford to go on strike and she’s (obviously) going to find out that I’m not striking. I’m worried it’s going to damage our relationship. Has anyone been in this situation before?

OP posts:
SunRainStorm · 20/07/2023 12:48

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 12:25

By working she is not just failing to do her part but actively undermining those who are striking - striking to obtain better conditions for her and her family.

Yet again, somebody coming from a point of relative privilege.

If I said to you "Give me a million pounds today and I will give you two million pounds back in a month's time" - and could give you paperwork and legal proof that I would honour it - would you do it? Would you really turn down the chance of a free million that could do so much for you and your family?

No idea what point you're trying to make

Megifer · 20/07/2023 12:30

notimagain · 20/07/2023 12:16

I'd be careful of using the term "work to rule" if the ballot didn't mention it as an option and it's not the Union's choice of action.

How somebody behaves in the office in the course on a strike day is of course another matter, but they might want to be cautious in how they describe motives for their behaviour, especially if they work for an employer who has the lawyers on speed dial ..(as I did) 🤐

The legislation around this is quite specific and can be unforgiving...

"When you’re balloted, your voting paper must ask whether you want to take part in either (or both):

  • strike action
  • action short of a strike
The union can only call on members to take action if a majority of members who voted were in favour of that particular action. If both questions are asked on the ballot paper and members vote yes to both, the union can decide what industrial action to take".

https://www.gov.uk/industrial-action-strikes/holding-a-ballot

Yes I wouldn't recommend telling your employer you're working to rule 😬 that phrase isn't always connected to union action though. Employees often stop using "discretionary effort" if they are peed off with their employer and while this might be expected in some roles and industries an employer would be on shaky ground if they took action against an employee who simply carries out their contracted role as expected. Was just suggesting to op that it could be a way of supporting colleagues (for herself i guess) if she can't afford to strike

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 12:25

By working she is not just failing to do her part but actively undermining those who are striking - striking to obtain better conditions for her and her family.

Yet again, somebody coming from a point of relative privilege.

If I said to you "Give me a million pounds today and I will give you two million pounds back in a month's time" - and could give you paperwork and legal proof that I would honour it - would you do it? Would you really turn down the chance of a free million that could do so much for you and your family?

Megifer · 20/07/2023 12:20

Quveas · 20/07/2023 12:02

Working to rule is not a form of support. Striking is the form of support. Working to rule is an action in itself, and only supportive if that is the action everyone is taking. Breaking a strike is breaking a strike.

Not everyone has an exact start or finish time, and exact role, or even "gets in" to an office - it is possible to wfh and still strike.

People who strike are not "people who can afford to lose pay" - they are people whose ethics say that they are willing to fight for themselves and other people regardless of the impact it has on their immediate position. If people only struck when they can afford to, there would be no strikes at all. The point is that the disputes about pay are that people also can't afford to live even when in work!!!

I do not agree with "giving shit" to strike breakers, and as a manager (who would be on strike) I would not do it, nor would I allow any member of staff to do so. But that doesn not mean we have to like or collude with strike breaking either. I don't have to like any individual either. I can be professional and still maintain my own right to like or dislike something. As can others.

Working to rule and go slows are a form of industrial action so i just suggested it is a way of supporting colleagues for those who can't afford to strike. By definition if people are willing to lose pay then they can afford to lose the pay.

I'm not saying it wouldn't sting badly and might mean things are extremely tight, but id very confidently bet my own days wage that absolutely no body would strike and lose pay if it would put them at real risk of e.g. not being able to pay rent, eat or support their dependents. I don't think some realise that's the position a lot of people would be in. Thankfully I'm not now, but I was previously, losing pay would have genuinely meant not being able to provide for my children when I lived hand to mouth. id have definitely crossed a picket line with no shame at all rather than see my children go hungry that week, what parent wouldn't?

notimagain · 20/07/2023 12:16

Megifer · 20/07/2023 11:52

Working to rule is also a form of strike action so people who can't afford to strike can still support their colleagues. Get in exactly at your start time, take your breaks, leave on time, don't do anything outside your expected job role.

If your colleagues or manager give you shit because they in the position where they can lose pay but you can't, you'd be within your rights to raise a grievance.

I'd be careful of using the term "work to rule" if the ballot didn't mention it as an option and it's not the Union's choice of action.

How somebody behaves in the office in the course on a strike day is of course another matter, but they might want to be cautious in how they describe motives for their behaviour, especially if they work for an employer who has the lawyers on speed dial ..(as I did) 🤐

The legislation around this is quite specific and can be unforgiving...

"When you’re balloted, your voting paper must ask whether you want to take part in either (or both):

  • strike action
  • action short of a strike
The union can only call on members to take action if a majority of members who voted were in favour of that particular action. If both questions are asked on the ballot paper and members vote yes to both, the union can decide what industrial action to take".

https://www.gov.uk/industrial-action-strikes/holding-a-ballot

Taking part in industrial action and strikes

How legal industrial action is organised, picketing and the law and what your employment rights when you are on strike

https://www.gov.uk/industrial-action-strikes/holding-a-ballot

Brefugee · 20/07/2023 12:15

FWIW we were all very open and honest who was striking and who wasn’t, it was no problem. No hard feelings or bullying either way!

Were you open and honest about saying "yeah I voted to strike but I'm not going to - make sure you get us a big fat pay rise"

As for bullying: I'm with pp. Work related only contact and no socializing. I wouldn't hinder them doing their job but I also wouldn't be doing them favour's like holiday cover or swapping shifts unless actually ordered to.

In the vain hope OP is still reading: when you do work on strike days don't cover work done by striking colleagues. Management should be picking up that slack (safety issues aside - but then do the minimum required)

Hopefully you have learned something

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/07/2023 12:05
  1. I've never encountered a picket line for any union in the various places I've worked where there have been strikes. Maybe they were off demonstrating somewhere else, maybe they were at home looking after kids or on holiday because the strike was straight before or after a non working day?
  2. Your manager won't know either way - she doesn't do your payroll, so won't see if you make contributions from your salary (if you're that concerned, make your contributions personally by DD instead) or what your pay is for the month. And she won't be in work herself.
  3. If you did get confronted and she already knew you were a union member 'I had to let my membership lapse because I couldn't afford it, so I'm not able to strike'.
Brefugee · 20/07/2023 12:04

Beezknees · 20/07/2023 09:08

I'm as left wing as they come but I understand OP. I'm a lone parent and no way would I risk losing the roof over my child's head. I'm not in the public sector but I support the strikes, I also feel for people like you.

I feel for people who can't afford to strike.

I feel contempt for people who vite to strike then scab. It's a secret ballot. Vote "no" and keep your trap shut?

Not a communist. But I do think people should think a bit more about the consequences of their words/actiins

Quveas · 20/07/2023 12:02

Megifer · 20/07/2023 11:52

Working to rule is also a form of strike action so people who can't afford to strike can still support their colleagues. Get in exactly at your start time, take your breaks, leave on time, don't do anything outside your expected job role.

If your colleagues or manager give you shit because they in the position where they can lose pay but you can't, you'd be within your rights to raise a grievance.

Working to rule is not a form of support. Striking is the form of support. Working to rule is an action in itself, and only supportive if that is the action everyone is taking. Breaking a strike is breaking a strike.

Not everyone has an exact start or finish time, and exact role, or even "gets in" to an office - it is possible to wfh and still strike.

People who strike are not "people who can afford to lose pay" - they are people whose ethics say that they are willing to fight for themselves and other people regardless of the impact it has on their immediate position. If people only struck when they can afford to, there would be no strikes at all. The point is that the disputes about pay are that people also can't afford to live even when in work!!!

I do not agree with "giving shit" to strike breakers, and as a manager (who would be on strike) I would not do it, nor would I allow any member of staff to do so. But that doesn not mean we have to like or collude with strike breaking either. I don't have to like any individual either. I can be professional and still maintain my own right to like or dislike something. As can others.

lanthanum · 20/07/2023 11:56

Have you checked out what is available from your union in the way of strike pay? Some will have funds for this, and although they can't cover everyone's losses, they often prioritise those in greatest need - the strike will be more effective the more people take part.

AccountCreateUsername · 20/07/2023 11:56

Carryonkeepinggoing · 20/07/2023 09:40

I think you should leave the thread now. You’re just berating the OP for a situation she can no longer change and actually for something she did not actually do. She did not deliberately act in a way that would cause financial hardship to her colleagues in order to benefit herself. She voted wrong, and people on this thread have clearly explained to her that she misunderstood the purpose of voting. You can call her ignorant and disgusting, or you can accept that this is actually not universal common knowledge and tell your union that you’ve recently realised many people, even those in unions, don’t understand how these votes are meant to work and perhaps some changes need to be made to communication. Like they could write on the ballot papers that strike votes are meant to be a real indication of who will actually go on strike if one is called, not just a vague representation of support for the concept of a hypothetical strike, or support for others’ right to strike. Put it in capital letters on the ballot paper ! ´Please vote for a strike only if you are willing and able to strike for at least X days if a strike is called’.

I really don’t think you should tell
people what threads to post on @Carryonkeepinggoing, if you’ll pardon the direction ;)

I'm surprised at the number of people who seem unaware about the history of industrial action and the benefits we have because of unionisation.

I support public sector strikers. I’d never criticise a colleague for what the OP describes but OP does come across as selfish and individualistic. I’d definitely judge them poorly. But that isn’t anybody’s business either.

Megifer · 20/07/2023 11:52

Working to rule is also a form of strike action so people who can't afford to strike can still support their colleagues. Get in exactly at your start time, take your breaks, leave on time, don't do anything outside your expected job role.

If your colleagues or manager give you shit because they in the position where they can lose pay but you can't, you'd be within your rights to raise a grievance.

KimberleyClark · 20/07/2023 11:47

My last employer would allow annual leave if booked prior to the strike date announcement but not otherwise.

WilkinsonM · 20/07/2023 11:43

SunRainStorm · 20/07/2023 11:21

@Strik

Obviously you should strike but if you financially cannot then I'd suggest you take paid leave for those days instead.

At least then you aren't going to be undermining the strike by getting the work done in your coworker's absence.

You can't book annual leave on announced strike days.

notimagain · 20/07/2023 11:42

@SunRainStorm

Obviously you should strike but if you financially cannot then I'd suggest you take paid leave for those days instead.

Might be worth investigating but FWIW I know some employers won't allow change of shift patterns, leave etc, once strike dates are announced.

Indigotree · 20/07/2023 11:41

Ffs the OP made an honest mistake. Yes she ought to have taken social responsibility and found out more about strikes, as we all ought as it's our duty as citizens in a democracy, but there's no need to attack her.

How about actually offering support or directing her to some so that she can actually join the strike, as she clearly would if she weren't scared of what might happen to her? Wouldn't that be in the spirit of collective action? Collective action is about supporting one another!

WilkinsonM · 20/07/2023 11:39

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 09:25

I've never worked in a unionised job, so I don't know. What do the ballots actually say? Do they say something like 'Are you in favour of an agreement for strike action?' or is it more explicit, like 'Will you join us in striking if the majority agree?' ?

I get that OP might well have been misguided in her vote, but I think the way it's framed is important. On the one hand, people are angrily criticising those who don't strike yet don't refuse any pay increases or concessions (is this even possible?) won as a result of the strike action; but on the other hand, are those who vote not to strike - whether because they don't believe in it/don't want to/can't afford to - also angrily criticised for not showing solidarity with those who do want/feel the need to strike?

If you're a member of a union and your union calls you out to strike you should strike whether you voted yes or not.

BusyLemon · 20/07/2023 11:23

It’s not that the OP will be working through the strike, it’s that she’s in the Union and has actively voted for the strike action. But then plans to work through it.

I think you have more to fear from your colleagues finding out, OP, than your manager. You have been foolish at best.

SunRainStorm · 20/07/2023 11:21

@Strik

Obviously you should strike but if you financially cannot then I'd suggest you take paid leave for those days instead.

At least then you aren't going to be undermining the strike by getting the work done in your coworker's absence.

TheOtterInTheHat · 20/07/2023 11:12

Supporting it ethically means nothing. It’s like people who say ‘oh I don’t support the meat industry’ and yet consistently buy and purchase mass produced meat.

SunRainStorm · 20/07/2023 11:07

Clementineorsatsuma · 20/07/2023 09:59

@Clutchy
OP explained that she supports it ethically. But she has to prioritise her family situation. 3 days of vastly reduced income would be enough to break many people atm.
Let the others like her wealthy manager take the strain right now.

By working she is not just failing to do her part but actively undermining those who are striking - striking to obtain better conditions for her and her family.

Quveas · 20/07/2023 11:01

0021andabit · 20/07/2023 10:06

But if only managers or the better paid workers were to strike, the strike would collapse.

The point of the union is collective action. You get the protection of the Union, their legal advise, the pay & conditions etc they win for you etc & in exchange you work collectively to fight for your rights & conditions.

If your circumstances have changed since you voted & you really, really can’t afford to strike anymore then speak to your union about hardship funds but don't take crossing a picket line lightly.

I am a very well paid public sector manager. Obviously I would like more money for myself - I might be happy with what I have but (a) more would be nice and (b) my skills and experience are still underpaid in terms of the wider private setor market. I am a member of UNITE and voted to strike. If we stike I shall strike. But mainly for the lower paid. If we were just talking about my pay, then I'd like more but I am satisfied and can afford to live. Others around me cannot. But I would resent like hell if they voted for me to strike and didn't do so themselves!!!!

MummyLaLa88 · 20/07/2023 10:58

Your manager needs to shut up OP. It is none of anyones business what you do x

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 10:38

I think it's probably time to lay off OP for not understanding that voting for strike action meant that she would join in, rather than just giving agreement for those who want to/can afford to to do so. It may seem obvious to you, but not everybody is au fait with how industrial action works. Without it being clearly explained, I can understand how voting No might seem to some that they are signalling their clear disapproval of others who do want to strike.

I wouldn't choose to watch women's sport; I wouldn't choose to watch men's sport either, as sport bores me solid. Yet, at the same time, I'm passionate about the principle that women's sport should be restricted to women only, and would gladly give my full support from the physically-inert shadows to the sporty people and fans whom this does greatly affect.

TheOtterInTheHat · 20/07/2023 10:29

DisquietintheRanks · 20/07/2023 09:58

Do you think most strikers are "very privileged "? Really?

No one is owed more than common courtesy at work. Certainly not friendship.

obviously hyperbolic but imagine if someone from your workplace voted to remove certain rights from women. Professional courtesy is the best I’ll be able to afford them. It’s all nice and kumbaya to call it a personal decision but personal decisions do affect the collective, especially when your personal decision becomes normalised. Some posters are just ridiculously individualistic and won’t think beyond the ‘me’.

Swipe left for the next trending thread