Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My manager has denounced non-strikers but I truly can’t afford it

308 replies

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:05

In the office today the topic of upcoming strikes came up (public sector). My manager is as left-wing as they come and was not shy in sharing her contempt for people who don’t choose to strike. I’m really worried because I can’t afford to go on strike and she’s (obviously) going to find out that I’m not striking. I’m worried it’s going to damage our relationship. Has anyone been in this situation before?

OP posts:
Mumof2teens79 · 20/07/2023 19:54

NeverDropYourMooncup · 20/07/2023 12:05

  1. I've never encountered a picket line for any union in the various places I've worked where there have been strikes. Maybe they were off demonstrating somewhere else, maybe they were at home looking after kids or on holiday because the strike was straight before or after a non working day?
  2. Your manager won't know either way - she doesn't do your payroll, so won't see if you make contributions from your salary (if you're that concerned, make your contributions personally by DD instead) or what your pay is for the month. And she won't be in work herself.
  3. If you did get confronted and she already knew you were a union member 'I had to let my membership lapse because I couldn't afford it, so I'm not able to strike'.

When we have had strikes, as a manager its up to me to report who is in work and who isn't and put that into SAP for payroll, so she will know, and if she is a die hard union member will probably be on the picket line

WeightInLine · 20/07/2023 19:47

Agreed. It can’t be many wipe that think this is appropriate.

User894532765 · 20/07/2023 19:36

it does seem to be a thing to call people scabs on the strike threads on MN, on one thread about the teachers they were even calling the children scabs for going to school on a strike day, I suspect it's the same few posters that do this.

WeightInLine · 20/07/2023 18:06

What is this thread? There are people on here genuinely advocating calling people scabs, or blanking people. That’s nasty work and no, you do not have moral right on your side. To be clear: It does not ‘depend on the dispute’.

If you don’t like someone, that’s fine. THINK IT IN YOUR HEAD. But if you make them feel uncomfortable in the workplace you are

  1. likely to fall foul of your workplace bullying and harassment policies
  2. just not very nice.
Megifer · 20/07/2023 18:05

Boomboom22 · 20/07/2023 17:58

Or that those who do strike are willing to let patients/ students / customers suffer for their gain. Like the consultants today, one said starting salary 88k up to 120k.
I did vote to strike as a teacher but certainly in no way see it as a moral option more a last resort that is quite immoral but less immoral than the wages paid and conditions etc.

Quite. In fact I'm probably going to lose my mum a lot earlier than I should because her various appointments keep getting pushed back due to the strikes.

I have nothing against strikes despite the fact that they will likely now be the direct cause of my mums premature death, but think they could at least own it and acknowledge that they too are doing it for partly selfish reasons.

Boomboom22 · 20/07/2023 17:58

TheOtterInTheHat · 20/07/2023 17:35

I don’t agree with name calling for the most part. But not striking when the union strikes is a selfish act and I’d seriously doubt you can see your friends in the same light after finding out that they’re willing to step on someone’s head for personal gain.

Or that those who do strike are willing to let patients/ students / customers suffer for their gain. Like the consultants today, one said starting salary 88k up to 120k.
I did vote to strike as a teacher but certainly in no way see it as a moral option more a last resort that is quite immoral but less immoral than the wages paid and conditions etc.

Addymontgomeryfan · 20/07/2023 17:42

Some replies have been pretty damn nasty. You can't be forced to strike, it's your personal choice, and at the end of the day, a roof over your head and food on the table is more important than what others might think.

If you can't afford to strike then don't do it.

TheOtterInTheHat · 20/07/2023 17:35

Megifer · 20/07/2023 17:15

I dunno, calling someone a scab, possibly changing your attitude towards someone who you were previously sociable with and employees suddenly stopping swapping shifts/hols/cover as a pp mentioned because they didn't strike is pretty questionable conduct and bordering on bullying. I don't think it elevates those doing it to the higher moral status they mistakingly believe they hold by striking anyway.

I don’t agree with name calling for the most part. But not striking when the union strikes is a selfish act and I’d seriously doubt you can see your friends in the same light after finding out that they’re willing to step on someone’s head for personal gain.

notimagain · 20/07/2023 17:29

@FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper

It's interesting how some unions seek to band together to fight bullying from 'the man' but then quite happily become the new bullies themselves. Not even just deciding to blank somebody themselves, but demanding that others do the same as well.....I'd understand it if it were, say, a serial killer or a child abuser, but just somebody who didn't want to go on strike from their job? Really?

It really depends on the dispute...if you're into a real battle, not just over the percentages on pay but over something structural,, the result of which can define your career for the next couple of decades or more, then there's much more at stake and people find it very hard to be forgiving.

I saw some interesting behaviour in another workgroup/another Union in my industry a while back and the after effects were obvious for many years.

We're talking private sector with an aggressive management who were absolutely determined to split that portion of the workforce with a view to driving all that groups T&Cs down dramatically, dismantling all agreements, limit their careers and no doubt ultimately break the Union.

Despite the company's obvious intentions quite a few union members did go to work through several bouts of industrial action...reasons given were various..

After it had all finished I honestly didn't witness anything that I would call bullying and in the workplace everybody continued to be professional but it was often obvious outside the office that there wasn't much love lost between those that had worked and those that had actually taken IA....

Took a long time for the wounds to heal.

daisychaindays · 20/07/2023 17:17

Megifer · 20/07/2023 17:15

I dunno, calling someone a scab, possibly changing your attitude towards someone who you were previously sociable with and employees suddenly stopping swapping shifts/hols/cover as a pp mentioned because they didn't strike is pretty questionable conduct and bordering on bullying. I don't think it elevates those doing it to the higher moral status they mistakingly believe they hold by striking anyway.

Agreed

Megifer · 20/07/2023 17:15

I dunno, calling someone a scab, possibly changing your attitude towards someone who you were previously sociable with and employees suddenly stopping swapping shifts/hols/cover as a pp mentioned because they didn't strike is pretty questionable conduct and bordering on bullying. I don't think it elevates those doing it to the higher moral status they mistakingly believe they hold by striking anyway.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 17:12

Just out of interest, do those who are strongly obedient to their unions believe that they must throw their full support behind everything that the union proclaims - whether the stewards unilaterally or anything that 51% or more of the members agree on?

How about if your union proclaimed firm support for and agreement with all that TRAs insist and say (except for the actual threats of violence)? Would you then cheerfully refuse to stand up for women's rights when they demand that some of those women's rights be yielded up to the trans cause and obediently keep your mouth shut? Especially considering that a great many men simply don't 'get it' and could very likely constitute 51% of any workforce who could vote for the perceived '#bekind' option that won't really affect them adversely?

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 17:06

Not saying I agree with it but when I started in 2004 they still were not talking to someone who crossed the picket line in 1981 🤦‍♀️ literally I said hello to him and was told "don't talk to him, he's a scab"

It's interesting how some unions seek to band together to fight bullying from 'the man' but then quite happily become the new bullies themselves. Not even just deciding to blank somebody themselves, but demanding that others do the same as well.

Referring to another human being as a 'scab' is truly nasty and extremely loaded language. I'd understand it if it were, say, a serial killer or a child abuser, but just somebody who didn't want to go on strike from their job? Really?

maybebalancing · 20/07/2023 16:42

I do think the bullying I witnessed around striking was very unpleasant. I saw people joining unions just to strike because they were worried about other staff members being unpleasant to them.

But I do think if you join a union and vote to strike you absolutely have to strike. In fact I think that if you join a union you have to strike if the collective vote for it.

The union I could have joined had no interest in my profession and case loads etc weren't considered at all. So I never joined as I had minimal interest in paying dues for the senior union officials in local government and the bin men weren't interested in any of the same issues as I was.

Quveas · 20/07/2023 16:22

But coercion/bullying/social isolation is a terrible thing to deal with at work and those people who subscribe to it need to take a hard look at themselves. There is no excuse.

Nobody has advocated coercion or bullying. But if I do not wish to have anything other than a professional relationship limited to work matters only with a scab, that is my right, just as I would limit my relationship with a misogynist or a racist. This is my workplace and I am not required to like the people that I work with, nor am I required to like their attitudes or opinions. I am required to attend work and to act in a professional manner whilst there. Their right to break my strike does not trump my right to dislike them for it; and I will not be coerced or bullied into pretending that I like them for it. What makes you think that forcing me to pretend that their actions are ok, or that I like them for it, is not coercion or bullying? If they do not like that, tough luck; and I have no intention of taking a long hard look at anything other than them. If they want to turn down the pay and conditions that we have negotiated and fought for, then we can be pals. Until that time they are hypocrites.

Scunnered123 · 20/07/2023 16:00

EmmaGrundyForPM · 20/07/2023 13:13

This!

I get so cross with this attitude. If you want things to change, you need to take action.

If the rest of us lose pay by striking, but achieve what we set out to, will you accept the benefits/increased pay? Of course you will.

Totally agree.

ArcticSkewer · 20/07/2023 15:01

cyclamenqueen · 20/07/2023 10:08

No I don’t but this poster has specifically said that she has lost ‘thousands’ which means either she is very highly paid and privileged or she is exaggerating

How much do you think people get paid a day?

Times that by 20 and what do you get?

Even minimum wage it equals, what, £70 a day, £1400.

My wage is okay to be honest but losing a month of pay is substantial.

Zimunya · 20/07/2023 14:34

I didn't grow up in the Uk and have never had the opportunity to join a union, so it's not a surprise that I know very little about how unions work, how strike action works, and what happens if you don't strike when everyone else does. However, it's abundantly clear from this thread that many people who are familiar with unions, indeed, even union members, are equally unsure how the whole process works. From the outside looking in, it seems to me that the union in this case has not been at all clear about expectations. The union really has to step up and start communicating with their members.

WeightInLine · 20/07/2023 14:24

The actual issue here is not whether the OP will strike but how her colleagues behave afterwards. Which is awful.

Think - in your head - whatever you like about the people you work with.

But coercion/bullying/social isolation is a terrible thing to deal with at work and those people who subscribe to it need to take a hard look at themselves. There is no excuse.

Indigotree · 20/07/2023 14:06

I think people who went on strike in previous decades and centuries were often very severely poverty-stricken as a result.

They also faced far worse working conditions and lower pay, so the stakes were higher either way and the choices bleak. We have them to thank for our relatively better position today, but the importance of strikes as a means of maintaining our rights and freedoms remains.

We lack a unified working class or employees' movement, really.

Chesneyhawkes1 · 20/07/2023 13:56

@DisquietintheRanks exactly. At my work if someone crossed the picket line they would literally get the bare minimum off people.

We swap shifts to help each other out, we swap annual leave, we cover the ends of each others shifts etc - they'd be none of that.

Not saying I agree with it but when I started in 2004 they still were not talking to someone who crossed the picket line in 1981 🤦‍♀️ literally I said hello to him and was told "don't talk to him, he's a scab"

We are 100% union membered where I am, so it would be very noticeable.

Megifer · 20/07/2023 13:41

*That is utter rubbish. You don't get to decide on having a personal form of alternative industrial action.

And nowhere in the world is the defintion of a strikers someone who can afford to lose pay.

You clearly haven't got a clue what a union or industrial action is.*

So someone can't decide to stop using discretionary effort/work to rule themselves? It will happen every day in pretty much all workplaces by at least one employee Confused. I offered it as a way of op supporting it in her own way

Note I didn't say the definition of a striker - i said by definition if someone is willing to lose the pay, then they can afford to. As I say I'm not suggesting it wouldnt be be gruelling or taking anything away from the strikers, I genuinely hope it gets the outcome they want. But id be genuinely surprised if someone would endanger their families wellbeing and financial position by striking. In fact id probably judge them a bit if they did (though in fairness I am basing that on my own past financial position - any parent doing something deliberate that puts their children's basic needs at risk deserves to be judged!)

I know enough about unions and strike action to get by. Unless only people who are experts can offer views (which would discount a huge portion of the population who support the strikes). Tbh though yes I'd probably shy away from actual unions after this thread because frankly it all seems really unpleasant.

I guess I'm struggling with the juxtaposition of strikers on the one hand really coming across as being selfless, doing it for the greater good, caring about each other....but then be pretty horrible about their colleagues who can't afford to strike 😔

EmmaGrundyForPM · 20/07/2023 13:13

BeetyAxe · 19/07/2023 21:32

So you won’t take the pay rise the strike might win then? You can’t afford to strike because you aren’t paid enough! Why should others take the hit and you not. Can you not ask the union about some payment?

This!

I get so cross with this attitude. If you want things to change, you need to take action.

If the rest of us lose pay by striking, but achieve what we set out to, will you accept the benefits/increased pay? Of course you will.

Quveas · 20/07/2023 13:08

@Megifer
Working to rule and go slows are a form of industrial action so i just suggested it is a way of supporting colleagues for those who can't afford to strike. By definition if people are willing to lose pay then they can afford to lose the pay.

That is utter rubbish. You don't get to decide on having a personal form of alternative industrial action.

And nowhere in the world is the defintion of a strikers someone who can afford to lose pay.

You clearly haven't got a clue what a union or industrial action is.

Yes I wouldn't recommend telling your employer you're working to rule 😬 that phrase isn't always connected to union action though.

And industrial action by its very nature is action against the employer that the employer knows about. Secret industrial action is not industrial action - it is cowardice.

If someone votes against a specific indistrial action then that is their opinion and they are entitled to it. You don't (a) get to vote for it then expect others to do it for you; (b) get to decide that your own personal form of industrial action is legitimate provided nobody knows about it; or (c) think you are entitled to the fruits of industrial action that others take because you need it. Fair enough if you are happy with your lot, or if you aren't prepared to take industrial action. Complaining about your low pay not being enough to live on, voting for industrial action you expect others to take when you won't, or whining about your employer/pay/ conditions when you are prepared to do nothing about them - that is hypocrisy.

I am all in favour of people having the right to not be in a union, or to not take industrial action. I am also in favour of those people not having any of the benefits that the union negotiates for its members.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 20/07/2023 13:04

No idea what point you're trying to make

I thought it would be obvious: trying to spell out to those who are clearly unable to understand that not everybody has the luxury of being able to forego their earnings today in pursuit of hopefully earning more in the future, however much more that might be.

Having low cash reserves or needing to be a bit frugal for a while are not the same as having your children sitting at a bare table, screaming with hunger.