Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My manager has denounced non-strikers but I truly can’t afford it

308 replies

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:05

In the office today the topic of upcoming strikes came up (public sector). My manager is as left-wing as they come and was not shy in sharing her contempt for people who don’t choose to strike. I’m really worried because I can’t afford to go on strike and she’s (obviously) going to find out that I’m not striking. I’m worried it’s going to damage our relationship. Has anyone been in this situation before?

OP posts:
Boomboom22 · 21/07/2023 07:33

You do pay quite a lot for that protection though, usually between 15 to 30 quid a month. So it's not an obligation to strike! What strange views are held here, very nasty.

Sapphire387 · 21/07/2023 07:20

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:38

I’m not forcing anyone. By voting yes, I’m literally giving others chance to do so if they do choose.

Translation:

'I am giving other people the opportunity to lose a day's pay, even though I won't, in order to win me a payrise'.

I don't think this was a good thing to do, OP.

Do you agree with the strikes in principle? If so, maybe have a look into whether your union has a strike fund - some of the big public sector ones do, to partially cover lost wages.

poetryandwine · 21/07/2023 06:47

Of course you join for a level of protection against personal unfairness but membership comes with responsibility

SunRainStorm · 21/07/2023 03:53

Strik · 21/07/2023 00:53

The advice on here is always to join a union for the protection it offers you. I’ve never come across striking before or even considered that it would be something I’d have to consider. Awesome to hear I’m “thick” because my life experiences are different from others’.

That 'protection' comes from the workers acting in unison - AKA in a union. Collective action requires.... you guessed it- the collective actions of the members of the UNION.

If you were never willing to do you but to protect others then you have no business seeking that protection from them.

ElizaMulvil · 21/07/2023 03:23

Indigotree · 20/07/2023 07:47

I grew up in a background of family/community involvement strikes, protests and workers rights' and even I am not aware of all the ins and outs of how strikes work, as I've not been in a job where it's come up for me (am self-employed).

However, younger people know less about these things because the world has moved to the right, what was normal is now considered 'leftist' and what was disturbingly far right wing in my youth is now considered bland centrist (or the Labour Party).

The OP voted for the strike to show her support for its cause and would strike if she were not afraid of being unable to cope financially. Those saying 'we all suffer financially' don't know her particular position: some people could end up homeless with children if they get into any more arrears or debt; others might just have a few weeks of one meal a day.

OP, I'd talk to the manager if it were me, explaining how much I want to support the strike, but how scared I am of the consequences for me personally. It's important she understands that not everyone is in a position where they feel able to.

Having said that, we owe the basic rights and freedoms we still have left to the many workers who starved on strikes or were imprisoned or even died in protests to give them to us. I grew up with being a strikebreaker or a scab as the worst sin anyone could commit (really difficult for me atm trying to come to terms with my DH, an academic, not striking).

I just wouldn't judge someone as it can be scary and there isn't often in workplaces the solidarity and sense of community support that, for example, a mining community might have fostered.

YES

EmmaGrundyForPM · 21/07/2023 02:36

@Strik So you joined a Union in case you ever needed support from them, you voted to strike for better pay/conditions, but you're not prepared to strike yourself even though its presumably a condition of membership.

I'm not going to reduce myself to your level by name calling but my opinion of you probably couldn't get any lower.

L0bstersLass · 21/07/2023 01:19

ilovesooty · 21/07/2023 01:14

It's certainly a fact that people do join unions simply to be protected without ever considering that something might be asked of them in terms of collective responsibility. I do find it quite hard to believe though that people like the OP had ever even given any thought to a situation where there might be a strike ballot.

Or even when getting their ballot paper, not actually understanding what they were voting for but ticking a box regardless.

L0bstersLass · 21/07/2023 01:15

Incidentally, I've worked in the private sector my whole career, I am not a member of a union but I understand what membership involves. Mainly through the news and films. I find it difficult to believe that someone working in the public sector would not understand this.

ilovesooty · 21/07/2023 01:14

It's certainly a fact that people do join unions simply to be protected without ever considering that something might be asked of them in terms of collective responsibility. I do find it quite hard to believe though that people like the OP had ever even given any thought to a situation where there might be a strike ballot.

L0bstersLass · 21/07/2023 00:59

Strik · 21/07/2023 00:53

The advice on here is always to join a union for the protection it offers you. I’ve never come across striking before or even considered that it would be something I’d have to consider. Awesome to hear I’m “thick” because my life experiences are different from others’.

It's nothing to do with your different life experiences. Do you make a habit of signing up for things without understanding the associated commitments? Do you not watch the news? Have you never heard of people being on strike on wondered why? Have you never seen a union representative being interviewed on the news and wondered what it's about?
Open your eyes.

Strik · 21/07/2023 00:55

You can call her ignorant and disgusting, or you can accept that this is actually not universal common knowledge and tell your union that you’ve recently realised many people, even those in unions, don’t understand how these votes are meant to work and perhaps some changes need to be made to communication.

yup.

OP posts:
Strik · 21/07/2023 00:53

The advice on here is always to join a union for the protection it offers you. I’ve never come across striking before or even considered that it would be something I’d have to consider. Awesome to hear I’m “thick” because my life experiences are different from others’.

OP posts:
L0bstersLass · 21/07/2023 00:48

Strik · 21/07/2023 00:29

It’s really interesting to me that you think that I am “a plant,” whatever that means. Are some people really so blinkered that they can’t fathom how other people would have different experiences and perspectives? Report me all you like. I’ve been a member since 2009 🤷🏽

It means that rather than thinking that you're so thick that you've joined a union without understanding what it entails, rather than believing that you're so cruel that you've voted to strike without intending to suffer the consequences yourself - that it's easier to believe you're a plant - someone posting to harm the solidarity of unions and generally undermine the concept.

Strik · 21/07/2023 00:29

ArcticSkewer · 20/07/2023 07:30

Yes I always consider leaving my union. Now I know that people in them vote deliberately for strikes they never intend to go on, that makes me all the more annoyed.

I am suspicious though that the op is a plant. I've never met anyone in rl who admitted making other people go on strike to win themselves a pay rise at no expense to themselves. What a way to undermine people.

It’s really interesting to me that you think that I am “a plant,” whatever that means. Are some people really so blinkered that they can’t fathom how other people would have different experiences and perspectives? Report me all you like. I’ve been a member since 2009 🤷🏽

OP posts:
Megifer · 20/07/2023 22:30

SweetSakura · 20/07/2023 22:17

It would appear they genuinely hold that view, yes

(The mind boggles)

Ah, thanks, honestly wasn't sure if it was me! I don't think I'll be replying then 😬

SweetSakura · 20/07/2023 22:17

Megifer · 20/07/2023 22:14

"Or you get on well with racists, misogynists and their ilk?"

Before i re-read your post again to reply (as genuinely I'm wondering if I shouldn't have had that 3rd gin afterall), are you comparing people who don't strike to racists and misogynists? Or have I indeed read that with my gin goggles on? 😬

It would appear they genuinely hold that view, yes

(The mind boggles)

Megifer · 20/07/2023 22:14

"Or you get on well with racists, misogynists and their ilk?"

Before i re-read your post again to reply (as genuinely I'm wondering if I shouldn't have had that 3rd gin afterall), are you comparing people who don't strike to racists and misogynists? Or have I indeed read that with my gin goggles on? 😬

Indigotree · 20/07/2023 22:03

Quveas · 20/07/2023 21:02

And those of us who don't like scabs don't think they have a moral high ground. Scabs are, whether they like it or not, lining up with bullying employers who don't give a shit about their employees - which is very questionable conduct and definitely bullying. You pick a side. This is a question of sides. You can't be on both sides. And if you want favours from others, then isn't that a trade? Nobody has to trade? Why would they trade with someone they dislike for that person's benefit? I notice you didn't answer my actual point - I have a right to dislike someones attitudes or opinions, and to do them no favours, if that is what I want to do, provided I remain professional. Or you get on well with racists, misogynists and their ilk? Is your diatribe only relevant for people you think don't deserve it because that is your opinion?

Just out of interest, do those who are strongly obedient to their unions believe that they must throw their full support behind everythingthat the union proclaims
It has nothing to do with obedience, and everything to do with my class interests. Did you vote for the Tories? Do you agree with everything they say? Did you vote for Brexit? Do you agree with the outcomes? Are you waiting on tenterhooks for the government to rewind all those hard fought for pieces of employment legislation that unions funded the fight for - maternity rights, patrenity rights, sickness entitlements, unfair dismissal etc - when EU legisation falls later this year? I am the union. We are the union. If you are willing to sit back and do nothing, fight for nothing, then you get the union that you deserve. You already have the government you deserve.

Exactly. I agree on the whole, but, as OP's post shows, there are some strikebreakers who don't deserve derogatory names.

SweetSakura · 20/07/2023 21:48

I'm afraid anyone who uses language like scab just comes across as having low intelligence and being without any humanity. As bad as the opposite extreme.

Quveas · 20/07/2023 21:02

Megifer · 20/07/2023 17:15

I dunno, calling someone a scab, possibly changing your attitude towards someone who you were previously sociable with and employees suddenly stopping swapping shifts/hols/cover as a pp mentioned because they didn't strike is pretty questionable conduct and bordering on bullying. I don't think it elevates those doing it to the higher moral status they mistakingly believe they hold by striking anyway.

And those of us who don't like scabs don't think they have a moral high ground. Scabs are, whether they like it or not, lining up with bullying employers who don't give a shit about their employees - which is very questionable conduct and definitely bullying. You pick a side. This is a question of sides. You can't be on both sides. And if you want favours from others, then isn't that a trade? Nobody has to trade? Why would they trade with someone they dislike for that person's benefit? I notice you didn't answer my actual point - I have a right to dislike someones attitudes or opinions, and to do them no favours, if that is what I want to do, provided I remain professional. Or you get on well with racists, misogynists and their ilk? Is your diatribe only relevant for people you think don't deserve it because that is your opinion?

Just out of interest, do those who are strongly obedient to their unions believe that they must throw their full support behind everythingthat the union proclaims
It has nothing to do with obedience, and everything to do with my class interests. Did you vote for the Tories? Do you agree with everything they say? Did you vote for Brexit? Do you agree with the outcomes? Are you waiting on tenterhooks for the government to rewind all those hard fought for pieces of employment legislation that unions funded the fight for - maternity rights, patrenity rights, sickness entitlements, unfair dismissal etc - when EU legisation falls later this year? I am the union. We are the union. If you are willing to sit back and do nothing, fight for nothing, then you get the union that you deserve. You already have the government you deserve.

Livinginanotherworld · 20/07/2023 20:30

WeightInLine · 20/07/2023 05:59

OP, just ignore this stuff. It is bullying.

You make your own decisions for your own circumstances and leave this level of social control back in the 70’s where it belongs.

Fortunately, we live in a free society and there’s nothing to be gained by this sort of coercion.

I think you’ve missed the whole point of why people are pissed off here !

Livinginanotherworld · 20/07/2023 20:24

Hbh17 · 19/07/2023 22:40

It should be personal choice. Many years ago, I left my union because I don't believe that public sector staff should ever go on strike. So I continued to go to work quite happily, because the strikes were nothing at all to do with me.

And that is perfectly fine….however, in this instance the OP joined the union and actually voted to strike…..she has shafted her colleagues if she has no intention of doing so.

Livinginanotherworld · 20/07/2023 20:09

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:16

I am in a union. I voted yes to strikes because that way it enabled people who want to/who can, go on strike.

So ……. you are in a union and voted for it, yet you don’t want to strike and you are happy to cross a picket line ? Either you strike along with the rest of your union colleagues or you leave the union, you can’t have you cake and eat it. Will you also accept any pay rise or enhanced working conditions if your colleagues were successful ? You all need to stick together, nothing will change otherwise.

Mumof2teens79 · 20/07/2023 20:00

Jellycatspyjamas · 20/07/2023 09:51

I thought if you voted to strike you have to strike and if you didn’t then you can’t? That’s what I’ve always been told, but maybe that’s wrong!

That is wrong. If you’re a union member and the membership vote for strike action, you should go on strike regardless of how you individually voted. Unions exist to organise workers to take collective action to protect workers rights - members sign up to gain the protections afforded by that collective action and so should be part of collective action when called for.

This
It's not always necessarily about pay or collective benefits. There have been many strikes in support of one individual who has been mistreated. That could be you.
Those protections such as union reps in disciplinary process only happen because of the principal of standing together.

Mumof2teens79 · 20/07/2023 19:55

There are whole debates on the wording of the ballot

Swipe left for the next trending thread