Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My manager has denounced non-strikers but I truly can’t afford it

308 replies

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:05

In the office today the topic of upcoming strikes came up (public sector). My manager is as left-wing as they come and was not shy in sharing her contempt for people who don’t choose to strike. I’m really worried because I can’t afford to go on strike and she’s (obviously) going to find out that I’m not striking. I’m worried it’s going to damage our relationship. Has anyone been in this situation before?

OP posts:
loopyloutoo · 20/07/2023 03:57

CorvusPurpureus · 19/07/2023 21:56

Leave the union. You aren't in tune with their values, which is fine. Just leave.

I would also rather go hungry than cross a picket or not strike alongside my union.

I understand that others see things differently, but don't have much time for fair weather friends. If you don't understand how unions work, it's not compulsary to be in one.

Tone deaf. Would you let your kids go hungry? Different story. Op needs to contact union to advise of her situation and avail of hardship fund if available or necessary.
Meanwhile, advise the manager that while she may have good intentions in promoting collective action, some people do not have the same liberty. It is not professional at all to be coercing or even discussing union membership in this way.

Growlybear83 · 20/07/2023 03:53

Strik · 20/07/2023 01:10

I hear what you say about leaving the union but it offers protections that are nothing to do with striking/pay.

I genuinely thought I was doing a good thing by voting yes to striking as the union said they needed a certain % of people to vote in favour for it to happen. I am not from a mining/factory background like previous posters. My family all work in the private sector so no I don’t have any idea about the moral code. In fact it was only fairly recently I learned that you don’t get paid on strike days. I always thought that the employers were punished by having to pay employees for not working! Bit harsh to repeatedly call me a dick. Some people just don’t know the invisible rules about all this stuff.

I'm really shocked by your reply. How can you have got to an age where you're old enough to have a permanent job and have joined a trade union but not have a basic understanding of the role of the unions, their members, and how industrial action works? What did you think you were signing up for when you joined your union? Having family who all work in the private sector is no excuse for such fundamental ignorance.

maybebalancing · 20/07/2023 03:46

I found there was quite a lot of unpleasant bullying around striking when I worked in local government, people definitely felt pressured to strike even though they really couldn't afford it.

I didn't join a union so worked during strikes as a certain number of staff were needed in our job at all times.

I wouldn't have joined a union, voted to strike and then not done it. Why on earth someone would behave like that I really don't get.

MrsTerryPratchett · 20/07/2023 03:33

Strik · 20/07/2023 01:10

I hear what you say about leaving the union but it offers protections that are nothing to do with striking/pay.

I genuinely thought I was doing a good thing by voting yes to striking as the union said they needed a certain % of people to vote in favour for it to happen. I am not from a mining/factory background like previous posters. My family all work in the private sector so no I don’t have any idea about the moral code. In fact it was only fairly recently I learned that you don’t get paid on strike days. I always thought that the employers were punished by having to pay employees for not working! Bit harsh to repeatedly call me a dick. Some people just don’t know the invisible rules about all this stuff.

OK so you didn't understand. Attend union meetings, read up, talk to your rep, read some books, watch Pride and North and South at the very least!

Yes the strike vote is supposed to signal the intention to the management. But that's because it's supposed to be an honest intention to strike. And it should tell management that that number of people who voted yes will be refusing to work.

You've signaled your intention to strike. You should see if it's possible to make it work.

TheOtterInTheHat · 20/07/2023 03:17

I sympathise but imagine if most of the union decides not to strike. Defeats the whole purpose of a union so we might as well disband it then!

ArcticSkewer · 20/07/2023 03:16

Strik · 20/07/2023 01:10

I hear what you say about leaving the union but it offers protections that are nothing to do with striking/pay.

I genuinely thought I was doing a good thing by voting yes to striking as the union said they needed a certain % of people to vote in favour for it to happen. I am not from a mining/factory background like previous posters. My family all work in the private sector so no I don’t have any idea about the moral code. In fact it was only fairly recently I learned that you don’t get paid on strike days. I always thought that the employers were punished by having to pay employees for not working! Bit harsh to repeatedly call me a dick. Some people just don’t know the invisible rules about all this stuff.

What you have done is really cruel.
You are forcing other people who can't afford it either but who believe in collective action, to go on strike.
You voted for strike action with no intention of doing it yourself, to make other people lose money so you would gain money.
Next time please either don't vote or vote no to strike action so that other people don't suffer because of your actions. I've never heard of anyone doing what you've done. I sincerely hope it isn't common. When I think of the money I have lost on stupid strikes I voted against but ended up having to do, I could cry to think there were people like you voting for it knowing they wouldn't do it themselves. It's a very selfish and cruel approach to a ballot.

VashtaNerada · 20/07/2023 03:10

Use the hardship fund and strike FFS. None of us can afford it, that’s the point. I find your attitude really quite shocking.

Pawpatrolsucks · 20/07/2023 02:57

I would point out she is in privileged position to strike. You agree with it you don’t have a choice.

Hardertheyfall · 20/07/2023 02:43

@ArcticSkewer exactly as Arctic says, no sympathy.
You think you are the only one ? So the workers just go on and put up with crap wages then? Some people are on even lower wages than you and need a proper! We strike to stick together ! No power if we don't stick together ! What is the point if others break the strike and scab ?And for your info , I can't afford it either ,if it's the same strike .( public sector)

L0bstersLass · 20/07/2023 02:41

Strik · 20/07/2023 01:10

I hear what you say about leaving the union but it offers protections that are nothing to do with striking/pay.

I genuinely thought I was doing a good thing by voting yes to striking as the union said they needed a certain % of people to vote in favour for it to happen. I am not from a mining/factory background like previous posters. My family all work in the private sector so no I don’t have any idea about the moral code. In fact it was only fairly recently I learned that you don’t get paid on strike days. I always thought that the employers were punished by having to pay employees for not working! Bit harsh to repeatedly call me a dick. Some people just don’t know the invisible rules about all this stuff.

Invisible rules?
Some people take time to work out what they're voting for before they put a tick in a box.

If you want the protection of the union, and have voted for the strike, then you should strike. That's bloody obvious.

If you don't want to play by the rules then you should leave the union and not rely on its protection.

Nat6999 · 20/07/2023 02:28

If you aren't prepared to support the results of the ballot, you shouldn't have voted to strike & you shouldn't be in the union.

Coyoacan · 20/07/2023 01:41

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:38

I’m not forcing anyone. By voting yes, I’m literally giving others chance to do so if they do choose.

You make it sound like you voted for to have a holiday. You want other people to strike so you can enjoy the benefits if they win

nokidshere · 20/07/2023 01:28

I understand but please realise it's the same for everyone and their actions benefit you.

Patronising 🙄

You think OP doesn't know that? You think the rest of the workforce who don't belong to the union even care? Everyone will benefit from a pay rise even if they aren't members.

Hawkins0001 · 20/07/2023 01:18

What's the point in striking when bills ain't gonna get paid by pickets and chants

gherkeen · 20/07/2023 01:16

Most people striking can't afford it. Those who strike make things better for everyone. I understand but please realise it's the same for everyone and their actions benefit you. Could the union help you?

Strik · 20/07/2023 01:10

I hear what you say about leaving the union but it offers protections that are nothing to do with striking/pay.

I genuinely thought I was doing a good thing by voting yes to striking as the union said they needed a certain % of people to vote in favour for it to happen. I am not from a mining/factory background like previous posters. My family all work in the private sector so no I don’t have any idea about the moral code. In fact it was only fairly recently I learned that you don’t get paid on strike days. I always thought that the employers were punished by having to pay employees for not working! Bit harsh to repeatedly call me a dick. Some people just don’t know the invisible rules about all this stuff.

OP posts:
nokidshere · 20/07/2023 00:58

Unions can be as tyrannical as the people they claim to be fighting.

Absolutely, as evidenced by its members on this thread. If 50% of the workforce were in a union and they all went on strike and 'won' then 100% of the workforce would get the pay rise. That's how it works.

As for leaving the union if you don't agree with the strike, that's also ridiculous. Unions cover a lot more than strikes and pay rises. If you regularly work alongside people who aren't in the union (but reap the benefits) and presumably don't call them names or bully them, then it's no different to working with people who can't afford to strike.

Personally, I think everyone (union or not) should just work to rule, stick to their hours, don't do anything extra and it would have a far bigger impact. And no, I don't belong to a union.

daisychaindays · 20/07/2023 00:57

WeightInLine · 19/07/2023 22:12

OP, you are being put under social pressure irl and on here. it is the nasty side of collective action - basically bullying.

You are free to vote how you like and strike or not strike as you like. Do whatever you want. There is no law or obligation otherwise.

Completely agree

BorderlineCool · 20/07/2023 00:51

I feel like the fact you can't afford to strike, shows you actually need to, to be honest.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 19/07/2023 23:59

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:25

She will find out though off HR won’t she?

And yes, she is loaded! We are public sector but her DH is in IT.

Trade union membership is a protected characteristic in GDPR so she shouldn't be able to find out if you're in union or not

Bobcat246 · 19/07/2023 22:55

My colleague is in this position. Uni academic with endless strikes. She genuinely can't afford it as the union strike payments don't touch the sides with small children in nursery and a maxed out mortgage. I have no problem saying I can't afford it but my politics and views towards the union leadership are well known so people don't even try and I'm left alone. She is openly left wing so feels she has to strike out of "solidarity" but is genuinely having sleepless nights and struggling with bills because she doesn't feel able to stand up for herself. The union leaders do not have the same financial issues or students they're letting down. She is very comfortable on her usual salary and her pension is very generous so she privately feels the strike is excessive.

Unions can be as tyrannical as the people they claim to be fighting.

TGNW25 · 19/07/2023 22:47

You voted for strike action but , never intended to take strike action Yourself because of personal financial detriment?

please do the decent thing and Leave your union you are riding on the coat tails of others who cannot afford cannot to strike , but also cannot afford not too…

BillyNoM8s · 19/07/2023 22:46

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:38

I’m not forcing anyone. By voting yes, I’m literally giving others chance to do so if they do choose.

So if everyone took the same stance as you...? Then what? Confused

If you're a union member it's your duty to strike, frankly.

saltinesandcoffeecups · 19/07/2023 22:43

This is purely a question for my knowledge because I think our unions have some differences.

If the OP had voted no, but the total vote was yes to strike wouldn’t they still get the benefits if the strike was successful?

In other words Does her vote really matter? (Assuming the strike action didn’t come down to one vote)

Hbh17 · 19/07/2023 22:40

It should be personal choice. Many years ago, I left my union because I don't believe that public sector staff should ever go on strike. So I continued to go to work quite happily, because the strikes were nothing at all to do with me.