Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

My manager has denounced non-strikers but I truly can’t afford it

308 replies

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:05

In the office today the topic of upcoming strikes came up (public sector). My manager is as left-wing as they come and was not shy in sharing her contempt for people who don’t choose to strike. I’m really worried because I can’t afford to go on strike and she’s (obviously) going to find out that I’m not striking. I’m worried it’s going to damage our relationship. Has anyone been in this situation before?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Yogagrandmum · 22/07/2023 07:02

Also people have very long memories…

PandaExpress · 22/07/2023 00:09

Yes YABU. You need to strike. If you were my colleague and you didn't, I wouldn't be impressed with you either. To not strike, is to undermine their efforts to improve things for all of you! Workers are stronger when they stick together.

EmmaGrundyForPM · 21/07/2023 13:25

@WeightInLine I think you've missed the point. The OP is in a Union and has voted for strike action. But isn't going to take part. Its the hypocrisy that's upsetting people.

WeightInLine · 21/07/2023 12:16

Winterday1991 · 21/07/2023 08:21

Don't strike, but also don't be a CF and take the pay rise once it's won. No one can afford to strike but they do it for long term benefit.

Lots of people aren’t in a union. Are the CFs? Or are they just people who aren’t in a union? Should they be on lower pay?

So many posters are - unpleasantly - trying to create obligations where they don’t exist. Language like ‘guilty of’ or ‘Have a think about that’, trying to shame people doing the job they are employed to do.

Unions are not obligations, and union members can make choices - they are not entitled to impose these choices on others. If you are going to find it a ‘kick in the teeth’ to see others cross the picket line, then maybe don’t get up at 5.30am to go to a picket line? That’s an actual choice too. You aren’t entitled to spite others.

SunRainStorm · 21/07/2023 10:53

I hope OP and everyone who agrees with her enjoy their weekend.

Which was won for them through demonstrations and striking, in days when the stakes were much higher for the working poor.

tribunemag.co.uk/2023/03/how-workers-won-the-weekend

Brefugee · 21/07/2023 10:53

@FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper (i don't have time space to come back to all points one by one but generally...)
I am not about to tell people what words they can and can't use. I have used scab here as shorthand talking generally (i think i may have told OP that what she has done is scab behavoiur? I can't remember exactly) and would in speech generally. I have not and would not use it to someone's face because i believe that we are each beholden to our own conscience.

Having said that: it is not on to join a union for benefits, then vote yes to strike action and then not take it. That has been done to death in this thread. I hope everyone reading has got it now.

In my personal opinion? if you're in a union you must be all in. If you vote no to strike action and the majority vote yes? you really ought to strike. There are hardship funds. I know what they cover, many of my wider family were affected by various strike actions up to and including the miners strike. I know that many families split and aren't yet reconciled. I know women who left striking husbands, and i know families that went through severe poverty all while supporting the striker. Each family / worker must make their own decision.

And if you're in the union and you break a strike? well, you are the one making that decision and must accept the consequences. Better, tbh, to leave the union over that. Non union strike breakers - I wouldn't shout scab at them but i would remember who has my back if they want favours from me (this topic also done to death on this thread. It is not bullying to cooperate and work professionally but not to do favours over and above)

Workers who don't strike/are non union get the benefits of improvements to terms and conditions in the same way they get the detriments when these get worse. It is part and parcel of living in a society with the right to join a union if you want. A win for workers, IMO, is a win for all workers.

It really is all a matter of doing the best for you and your family. That is fine (unless it is shafting your colleagues - but even then, who knows?) Joining a union "for the benefits" then voting to strike and not striking? meh.

notimagain · 21/07/2023 10:39

@ohfook

Good post.

I think it largely depends on your upbringing/area that you're from.

Your outlook I think also depends a lot on the industry and I can only guess that some who have posted here have been very lucky with their choice of employer... they might think differently if as happened where I worked their CEO had gone on record not long after arriving in post as saying that if he had his way he was going to scrap all legacy T&Cs, contracts etc....

Since those T&Cs dictated to a major degree factors such shift length and predictability of stop/start times, days off, rosters, career structure etc etc etc... what he actually did was ensure that a very high proportion of employees, a lot of them very conservative ( with both a big C and small c) were fully paid up members of unions/professional associations various.

More importantly the CEO ensured there was very solid support from members in the union I was in when it came to ballots for IA and actual IA itself on a couple of occasions.

Megifer · 21/07/2023 10:29

notimagain · 21/07/2023 10:08

@Megifer

So what's the crack with say a female who isn't in a union doing the same job as a male who is in a union so benefits from a collective agreement re:pay increase?

AFAIK and certainly where I worked everybody in the cohort gets the payrise, regardless of whether they are in the union or not...to do otherwise AFAIK is illegal.

It used to be a subject of debate at times when I was working but that was the law....We were also very aware of employers and "divide and conquer"....nothing some employers would like more than a non-unionised cohort on a lower rate of pay doing the same job as the Union members...

Seen that, didn't end well.

I thought that was the case, it was years ago when I was involved in a union and then spent a bit of time in HR in a unionised company (thankfully wasn't too involved in dealing with them!)

Would some of the posters be ok then if op just came out if the union because she doesn't want to strike? That has been suggested. So she comes out of the union but would still benefit from any pay increase anyway. (That's not directed at you its a general comment)

Jellycatspyjamas · 21/07/2023 10:26

But even if they did, going on this thread, if word got out that somebody had joined the strike but then got the union to reimburse them their lost earnings (so that they can pay their rent and feed their kids), I can only assume the sheer hatred with which they would be condemned as traitors who were happy for others to suffer for their benefit.

The hardship fund is there to support people who genuinely experienced hardship by going on strike - by definition usually those who are low paid. No resentment at all, we don’t all have spouses who can pick up the slack, or savings or family who would help out. Collective action is the underpinning principle of union membership, I have no issue with unions helping people financially to join collective action. I’d rather that happen than people (who genuinely need a pay increase) break the strike.

ApiratesaysYarrr · 21/07/2023 10:23

MrsTerryPratchett · 19/07/2023 21:10

It's very difficult because this is classic example of where the personal, political and professional collide. I come from a family of miners and mill workers and crossing a picket line is unthinkable. That's the culture I was raised in so although a do a job that is office-based and far from a pit (!) I'd think like your co-worker. It's a core value for many people and difficult to communicate to people who don't feel it. My granddad would literally have rather starved. Literally.

I feel every sympathy for those who can't afford to lose money. Fortunately the threat of strike was enough for us. And understanding that everyone saying they will strike is an important part of negotiations.

My granddad would literally have rather starved. Literally.

I think that principles are great, but when you are faced with your kids starving, or being made homeless due to lack of money, it's harder.

(I'm currently on strike now, but can afford to lose a few days pay, but have been in poverty in the past, and know how awful that is, so I'm not judging anyone who doesn't wish to strike).

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 21/07/2023 10:12

they've been called scabs since forever. You're not going to get people to change that. That is also a bit #BeKind. Where they are actually damaging a collective action.

Everyone has to decide for themselves how they behave and which words they use, when and where.

Do you believe that for all words in longstanding use that are now understood/accepted to be offensive to those being referred to? I can think of a dozen nasty words right now - ones that have been used for many years - that would get this post deleted instantly; of course, I wouldn't dream of using them, precisely because I know that they are hurtful to those being described by them.

I thought the clear advice several posters offered was that the OP contacts the Union and asked about hardship funds or similar - lots of Unions do have them.

Followed swiftly by others saying that the hardship payments are low and will not replace the lost earnings.

But even if they did, going on this thread, if word got out that somebody had joined the strike but then got the union to reimburse them their lost earnings (so that they can pay their rent and feed their kids), I can only assume the sheer hatred with which they would be condemned as traitors who were happy for others to suffer for their benefit.

how are they willfully excluded? unions are there for everyone. I pay a % of my net salary to mine, and the unemployed, students and apprentices pay a few euros a month.

What this whole thread is about: people who are condemned as 'scabs' because losing the earnings would not just leave them having to be careful for a while, like others who are fortunate enough to have some reserves, but would indeed leave them and their families in dire straits. Those who are smugly told that they 'can't afford not to strike'.

Somebody upthread even suggested asking your mortgage lender for a break because you had chosen not to work for however many days (however great the intentions and reasoning, it's still a free choice you've made)!

ohfook · 21/07/2023 10:12

I think it largely depends on your upbringing/area that you're from. Where I live has been massively fucked over by the tories historically and the unions were there for people. I would never cross a picket or do anything to undermine a strike. I believe everybody should have the right to withdraw their Labour if they are unhappy with their working conditions and I think working people achieve more when they work collectively.

I do think unfavourably of people who are willing to take the benefits and protection of union membership but aren't willing to give support when it's needed. The only reason a union works is because it can take collective action when needed if people aren't willing to make that sacrifice then they shouldn't be in one. I also know personally of people who have accessed their union's hardship fund so while I understand that the lowest paid are most impacted by strike action I also think unions are trying to combat this.

notimagain · 21/07/2023 10:08

@Megifer

So what's the crack with say a female who isn't in a union doing the same job as a male who is in a union so benefits from a collective agreement re:pay increase?

AFAIK and certainly where I worked everybody in the cohort gets the payrise, regardless of whether they are in the union or not...to do otherwise AFAIK is illegal.

It used to be a subject of debate at times when I was working but that was the law....We were also very aware of employers and "divide and conquer"....nothing some employers would like more than a non-unionised cohort on a lower rate of pay doing the same job as the Union members...

Seen that, didn't end well.

Megifer · 21/07/2023 09:54

So what's the crack with say a female who isn't in a union doing the same job as a male who is in a union so benefits from a collective agreement re:pay increase? Wouldn't the female then be able to put in an equal pay claim?

Must admit this is an area of HR im not familiar with but surely that would get some union members riled up?

Brefugee · 21/07/2023 09:45

Nobody has responded to my earlier point that, going on this thread, unions are apparently there for underpaid and/or exploited workers, but that the poorest people of all are wilfully excluded.

how are they willfully excluded? unions are there for everyone. I pay a % of my net salary to mine, and the unemployed, students and apprentices pay a few euros a month.

And there are hardship funds. And they can advise about budgeting and i get discounts on home, life and car insurance etc. There are hardship funds and so on and so forth.

notimagain · 21/07/2023 09:41

The clear advice to those on the bones of their arses, with no ability to manage without the lack of pay from striking, is to leave the union entirely. Solidarity of the poor, eh?

I thought the clear advice several posters offered was that the OP contacts the Union and asked about hardship funds or similar - lots of Unions do have them.

Brefugee · 21/07/2023 09:41

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 21/07/2023 09:33

it's not a nice word - but it is the jargon word that is used to describe something that would otherwise take several sentences.

Strike-breaker? Non-striker? Anti-striker? Even traitor, if you want. All of those are short terms (certainly no need for several sentences) that clearly convey your opinion of those people, without comparing a human being with different beliefs or politics from you to a gross, pustulant wound.

they've been called scabs since forever. You're not going to get people to change that. That is also a bit #BeKind. Where they are actually damaging a collective action.

Everyone has to decide for themselves how they behave and which words they use, when and where.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 21/07/2023 09:37

Nobody has responded to my earlier point that, going on this thread, unions are apparently there for underpaid and/or exploited workers, but that the poorest people of all are wilfully excluded.

The clear advice to those on the bones of their arses, with no ability to manage without the lack of pay from striking, is to leave the union entirely. Solidarity of the poor, eh?

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 21/07/2023 09:33

*pustulent

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 21/07/2023 09:33

it's not a nice word - but it is the jargon word that is used to describe something that would otherwise take several sentences.

Strike-breaker? Non-striker? Anti-striker? Even traitor, if you want. All of those are short terms (certainly no need for several sentences) that clearly convey your opinion of those people, without comparing a human being with different beliefs or politics from you to a gross, pustulant wound.

TheCyclingGorilla · 21/07/2023 09:23

Maddy70 · 21/07/2023 09:02

Can you go off sick?

Employers usually cotton on to this quickly and in my job it's not tolerated.

justasking111 · 21/07/2023 09:21

Strik · 19/07/2023 21:25

She will find out though off HR won’t she?

And yes, she is loaded! We are public sector but her DH is in IT.

Champagne socialists really annoy me. Ignore her you can't afford it.

TheCyclingGorilla · 21/07/2023 09:21

My husband lost 18 days pay through striking (CWU/Royal Mail). I took on extra shifts to cover the shortfall. I've been on strike a few times over the last year but have been able to make it up later. Sometimes we were extremely short of cash to the point we were down to the essentials and not going out or doing anything at all. It's just what you have to do.

Bob Crow, the late general secretary of the RMT, said once, "If you fight, you don't always win. But if you don't fight, you will always lose".

As your union if there's a hardship fund. CWU and RMT both had one. It might not cover a whole day's pay but it might help a little.

Ignore your manager. If you want to strike (even if you can't afford it) then do. If you choose not to, you might be called names but you can always raise a complaint. However, I'd say it's better to go on strike because the collective bargaining and mass withdrawal of labour sends a message to the employer that you mean business.

Icannoteven · 21/07/2023 09:15

If you are in the union, have you approached one of the reps about your circumstances? I know that some unions will provide strike pay to individuals experience hardship (our union assess this on an individual basis). This could be an option.

Was your manager acting in their capacity as your manager at the time they made this statement or was this at a union meeting? There are rules about union bullying in the workplace so you could approach HR. Though I do hesitate to mention this because I actually agree with your manager.

If you can’t afford to strike then you can’t afford not to strike in my opinion. There are probably others striking who ‘can’t afford to strike’ but are still making the sacrifice. If you aren’t partaking in the strikes then unfortunately you are working against them/making things harder for them and easier for you employer. But then, I’m from a mining area so to me, strike breaking is unthinkable - I’m well aware of the sacrifices that our parents, grandparents and grandparents had to make so we could live in a world where employers are forced to treat us with a tiny amount of respect for our health, safety and wellbeing!

Maddy70 · 21/07/2023 09:02

Can you go off sick?