You are teacher to those kids not their parents.
I am actually confused by a teacher who deals with teens that believes all their actions can be so easily dismissed as ‘making stuff up to hurt someone’. For someone who has so much experience with teens you haven’t figured out they are quite complex, all have different motivating factors, different things going on.
The fact that you dismiss anything but ‘he is making it up and it has no basis in any facts because I say so’ is a huge red flag for a teacher. If a student confided in you that they feel a certain way about something at home, do you jump to ‘you are wrong and saying it to be mean to your parents’.
Yes, schools have clear rules. They don’t (and can’t) cater to every individuals need. Which is why it’s not like parenting at all. But in schools if a child does something they shouldn’t or hurts someone, the school will try and find out why and what’s going on with that child and work to resolve it. They deal with the situation in a calm manner, possible punishment but still aim to fully resolve it.
Again, I find myself asking you where did I say this shouldn’t be dealt with? Where did I say Op should pander to him? Where did I say op couldn’t assert her boundaries and tell him it’s not ok?
Going wild at a child isn’t ok. Handing out petty punishments without working to resolve the problem isn’t ok. That crosses alot of lines. And again, I will remind you, I wasn’t talking to the Op I was talking to people who were saying how they would handle it, by losing their shit, refusing to provide the child with things, disengaging with the child as punishment etc. Which I disagreed with.
As a teacher would you be ok with a parent telling you they will going wild at their kids or disengaging with their child until their child has feelings they agree with it?
a 12 year old is a child. They aren’t emotionally mature. They deal with things in ways they shouldn’t. It’s a parents job to continually teach their children how to deal with these thing. Assuming that their feelings are not valid and just putting it down to ‘they are lying as an excuse to lash out’ isn’t teaching them how to deal with it. It’s teaching them that people don’t want to hear them and will assume they are lying and making things up just to be mean. And if they are lying just to lash out, then that’s clearly an issue there’s something bothering them which shouldn’t be dismissed as ‘they are wrong. They just want to be hurtful’
You want a 12 year old to rationally, calmly explain their feelings 100% of the time? for someone who deals with so many teens your expectations are way off.
I completely disagree with on how you view this. You disagree with me. And that’s really ok. Doesn’t make your posts more valid.