Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to discourage DC from entering public sector careers?

163 replies

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 06:58

DD17, DD14 and DS12 have all been talking a lot about jobs they’d like to do lately. They are all very different fish, 2 very academic girls and one creative but not so book smart DS. Their schools to introduce a broad range of careers, but their teachers (understandably) seem to know more about public sector roles such as teaching, legal aid law and health professions (there’s a special ‘get into medicine course DD was encouraged to do).

When I started out, there were good options for people looking to work in the public sector. I headed into a helping profession in a Local Authority (but struggled with the inflexibility and have since moved into private practice). Friends were looking forward to careers in medicine, teaching and the civil service. A couple were pretty snobby about the moral superiority of public sector roles ( I remember an physio friend asking a trainee actuary friend how they got up each morning with such a boring job). Others headed into law, banking, consultancy etc. We were all very well educated and had many options.

However, at 45, things have all come out in the wash, and (with a few exceptions, notably two doctors who are independently wealthy, and a diplomat), those who chose private sector jobs are not just much wealthier but also seem to enjoy more flexible, varied roles and just seem happier in their work. Friends in the public sector complain that they are burnt out, struggling financially and stuck in their jobs with few other options.

AIBU to at least encourage DC to consider that public sector careers might not be the best idea any more? Obviously, they’ll choose what they choose, but to me, the difference between private and public sector roles (especially in London/SE) nowadays seems pretty stark.

OP posts:
mondaytosunday · 19/07/2023 08:19

My stepson worked for the NHS (administrative) and he had so much flexibility- was able to schedule his day to be off to watch the Ashes, for example. Now works for the council four days wfh and loving it.
Seems secure and good benefits. He didn't go to uni, just worked his way up.

Libraryloiterer · 19/07/2023 08:06

It is bleak out there at the moment, no doubt, but public service is in the bones of some people and wild horses wouldn't stop them. And my parents disapproval DEFINITELY wouldn't have stopped me, I'm not 7 and presumably your children aren't either.

Overthebow · 19/07/2023 08:01

It really depends how motivated they are and what they are interested in. Public sector pensions and benefits are much, much better. Salaries are often lower but, my friends in teaching and NHS although earn less, they are also contracted for less hours. They also have decided to stick at the band they’re on for a while and not go for promotions, whilst I have actively pushed for promotions and taken on extra work to gain experience throughout my career so far. If we were to compare like for like grades the pay difference wouldn’t be so much.

AlvieSt · 19/07/2023 07:59

Local government. Constant restructures ( redundancy or move of role) as Tory cuts bite. Children’s Services for instance have to save £5.5 million this year ( and last, and the one before).

Not enough staff, including leadership to do the roles. As cuts hit, service use is increasing.

Long hours, many complaints as services just cannot meet the needs of the public. (cuts again)

Constantly undervalued. ‘Cant please everyone all of the time’ - just reading the council SM comments is horrific, parts of the media, so unsupportive.

Many many changes, of staff, meaning systems are not in place or embedded (performance management, career development for instance).

The risk in a restructure of losing the job you had trained for, to be moved to something completely different ( a way to prevent redundancy payments). For instance, PA to an education director is now the governance officer to schools. It means the workforce can be less skilled, just to save redundancy money.

No chance of voluntary redundancy if the new role isn't something you want/are able to do, more so with long service. Too many £££’s to get rid so more likely to be put in a role that was never in your career plan.

Delayed pay awards (last one overdue by 18 months and still not in place).
Less % pay rises than private sector.
Not earning to full potential.

Isolated working, not enough staff to be a ‘team’, not enough time for the team to meet, taking decisions beyond experience.

I feel I have given a working life ( 35 years in) supporting communities, to the detriment of my own health, wellbeing and opportunities.

TheKeatingFive · 19/07/2023 07:55

that wasnt the question

It's a key part of the answer however. It seems that many public sector workers have absolutely no clue how valuable their pensions actually are.

loislovesstewie · 19/07/2023 07:42

I think it depends what you want to do, I'm a retired public sector worker. I spent a miserable 6 months in the private sector. My personality seemed to fit better into the public sector, I think some people just have different personalities/ prefer different ways of working, mine was in the public sector/

ElephantLove · 19/07/2023 07:37

So hard to say as there’s such variety but I’m the only public sector worker in my immediate friendship group, very well qualified but I’m the lowest paid by a mile. Yes my pension will be good but those who earn tens of thousands more than me can afford to invest for their retirement anyway 🤷‍♀️

Twyford · 19/07/2023 07:35

Legal aid law isn't public sector work.

Girasoli · 19/07/2023 07:34

I would just encourage their interests and try to expose them to as many things as you can.

It may be that they totally surprise you in what they want to do as they get older...eg, academic DDs might hate the pressure/networking associated with city careers and want to spend their lives studying 16th century history/the life cycle of bees etc. Creative DS might end up in the third sector doing something like restoration etc.

Willyoujustbequiet · 19/07/2023 07:33

I'm the opposite. I will encourage public sector jobs as having done both I think they provide a far better level of stability and protection than the private sector. Better hours, holidays, flexibility and pension.

DataNotLore · 19/07/2023 07:30

Pension

sunrisechurch · 19/07/2023 07:30

But I would definitely not encourage choosing a job just for the pension benefits that you might or might not reap at 68.

As I’ve got older I’ve felt this more and more strongly. I’m 38 and have been in the civil service since I was in my early 20s. I’ve recently started looking at other jobs and have had a few “but what about the pension?” comments. Hanging on for another 30 years for the pension seems bonkers to me, I’d like to be happier right now not when I’m heading into old age.

Also the point upthread about job security is a good one. It is pretty much impossible for them to get rid of you in the CS but that works both ways and means you’re working with a lot of people who should have been fired years ago.

I think the CS works well if you can switch off your conscientious gene and just coast for 40 years OR if you’re highly motivated by the work you’re doing. I have worked with some great people but they tend to really enjoy what they’re doing and believe it is worthwhile and valuable to society. They’re certainly not doing it for the financial reward as they get paid exactly the same as the poor performers (maybe they’ll get an extra £50 in simply thanks vouchers if they’re lucky).

MomOfTwoGirls2 · 19/07/2023 07:21

Private all the way! And change jobs every 3 years or so during the early part of career, will keep increasing salary that way.
Invest in a good private pension from the beginning.

But most of all, they should strive to find something they are really interested in.

SwitchDiver · 19/07/2023 07:21

I did twenty years in the public sector. There is huge variation in jobs though. I’d agree teaching isn’t the best profession for generating wealth…but that’s true private or public. CETV of my defined benefit pension= £2.6m

Billoddiesbeard · 19/07/2023 07:20

It depends what you/your children see as important. Certainly the chances to earn very large salaries are not as forthcoming coming in public sector roles but as others have said the protection, potential for family friendly/flexible working, generous holiday entitlement and pension benefits should be taken into consideration before dismissing these roles as a career choice

I joined the civil service at 21. I had a 30 + year career across different departments doing various roles ranging from health to criminal justice.

I never earned a huge salary, I topped out at 65k but I was able to take an excellent final salary pension for life (although I believe pensions are now average salary based) and retire at 55. For me the long term benefits significantly factored into my career choices.

ConnieTucker · 19/07/2023 07:20

TheKeatingFive · 19/07/2023 07:15

What amount of annual pension do you consider to be amazing?

Any direct benefit schemes are likely to be light years better than direct contribution ones.

that wasnt the question.

wherethewaterisdarker · 19/07/2023 07:18

My kids are younger but I agree OP sadly. I think the public sector in this country is in a sorry state - just look at the strikes - and unless things improve radically for workers in the next 15 years, I’ll be encouraging my kids to think much more ruthlessly about themselves and their income than I was raised (which was essentially to follow my heart and do what I love).

ConnieTucker · 19/07/2023 07:18

Apparently the average age teachers retire in the UK is 59. Ive gone through the pension calculator (many times) and it is an great pension if you retire at 75.

It is a known issue in education that expensive teachers get pushed out. And expensive in teaching is over £40k. That’s a starter salary in some industries. And don't forget that is for a post-graduate level entry career.

so when saying it is a great job, look at the pension. Look at the pension value at 59 before you'd be sacked / pushed out, and replaced by a trainee.

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 07:17

That’s really interesting. I agree that there are many interesting public sector careers, I did one for years. But I would definitely not encourage choosing a job just for the pension benefits that you might or might not reap at 68. You can easily make enough to match that in investments in a well paid job.

I wonder if I’m perhaps comparing apples and pears. Ambitious friends (with the exception of the diplomat) generally went into high-level (City) careers and have done really well. They’ve worked and travelled all over the world, have made a great deal of money (several now discussing early retirement/ buying a money drain vineyard plans) and have had the flexibility to move between employers to follow better roles. My DH law firm has much more favourable sickness and maternity benefits than I got in a Local Authority. Whereas friends in roles like teaching, medicine and LA management are no less able and work no less hard but the financial and career rewards are different. And they definitely feel they work harder and seem exhausted.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 19/07/2023 07:15

What amount of annual pension do you consider to be amazing?

Any direct benefit schemes are likely to be light years better than direct contribution ones.

snufkinhat · 19/07/2023 07:12

orangeleavesinautumn · 19/07/2023 07:04

I don't think they should be differentiating between public sector and private sector jobs at all, just following their interests and talents then choosing which jobs to apply for based on terms and conditions in the vacancies they find once they are in the job market.

Most people end up going for jobs they had never even heard of as teenagers

This.

At their age you should be encouraging them to follow their interests. You can switch between private and public in your working life in almost any career/ specialism.

It is more important at this stage that they get qualifications and experience in something that interests and excites them, whatever that is.

ConnieTucker · 19/07/2023 07:10

RoyKentFanclub · 19/07/2023 07:00

You must be joking. Quite the opposite I’d say. Nowhere else do you get the same level of protection and such amazing pensions.

What amount of annual pension do you consider to be amazing?

Redlocks28 · 19/07/2023 07:10

I agree-the friends I’ve got working for the public sector are unhappy, generally not well paid and certainly, the ones who are older and teachers are all gone. They either quit before they were got rid of because their lives were made so uncomfortable or had to leave with an ‘agreed’ reference. Teaching is not a place for those over 50 any more. They are working in other jobs now-supported by spouses, luckily. The ones who are nurses are still working, but part time due to bad backs! The pension may be better in the public sector but if you can’t spend much of your working life in it-it’s just theoretical. The recruitment and retention figures are often dire!

The private sector friend I have mostly work from home very flexibly so have little commuting costs. All are much happier.

Noicant · 19/07/2023 07:09

There was a thread the other day about how a public sector worker couldn’t get their head around what were considered normal working hours in the private sector. Work life balance is better, the pension is literally gold.

Having said that I think some people struggle, DH lasted a few weeks in a public sector organisation because he was just bored. He’s much happier in terms of his work in the private sector.

MorganSeventh · 19/07/2023 07:09

I think you should let them make their own choices. It's important to remember that many of the elements which will have helped contribute to your friends' success - UK membership of the EU, low energy prices, low interest rates - will not be there to benefit your children. There's also a whole new range of challenges for them to deal with, including accelerating climate change, and AI changing the jobs market.

As such, they will be operating in a very different world to you and I think it would be foolish to assume what worked in the past will work in the future. They need to look forward and think about what is likely to happen for them, not back at what worked for their parents' generation.