Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to discourage DC from entering public sector careers?

163 replies

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 06:58

DD17, DD14 and DS12 have all been talking a lot about jobs they’d like to do lately. They are all very different fish, 2 very academic girls and one creative but not so book smart DS. Their schools to introduce a broad range of careers, but their teachers (understandably) seem to know more about public sector roles such as teaching, legal aid law and health professions (there’s a special ‘get into medicine course DD was encouraged to do).

When I started out, there were good options for people looking to work in the public sector. I headed into a helping profession in a Local Authority (but struggled with the inflexibility and have since moved into private practice). Friends were looking forward to careers in medicine, teaching and the civil service. A couple were pretty snobby about the moral superiority of public sector roles ( I remember an physio friend asking a trainee actuary friend how they got up each morning with such a boring job). Others headed into law, banking, consultancy etc. We were all very well educated and had many options.

However, at 45, things have all come out in the wash, and (with a few exceptions, notably two doctors who are independently wealthy, and a diplomat), those who chose private sector jobs are not just much wealthier but also seem to enjoy more flexible, varied roles and just seem happier in their work. Friends in the public sector complain that they are burnt out, struggling financially and stuck in their jobs with few other options.

AIBU to at least encourage DC to consider that public sector careers might not be the best idea any more? Obviously, they’ll choose what they choose, but to me, the difference between private and public sector roles (especially in London/SE) nowadays seems pretty stark.

OP posts:
Mythicalcreatures · 19/07/2023 09:52

I wouldn't encourage either but focus on what their interests are if possible. One thing that gets rarely mentioned here is that good public service sick pay has detriments to those who do not need it. My v small team has had 2 staff off sick for the past 6 months, these posts are not been covered, so the rest of the team - 4 people - have been doing all the extra work for nothing, it's a complete nightmare

LegendsBeyond · 19/07/2023 09:52

No, I’d do the opposite. Myself & my public sector collleagues are soon retiring on 40k+ a year pensions, while a lot of my friends in the private sector have little, if any pension.

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 09:52

Really interesting perspectives, thanks everyone for sharing.

Of course, our children will follow their own paths and we will be proud that they have done so. I guess I want them to be able to take a balanced view of all the possibilities. And to consider what might be the best path if they want to move country, be promoted etc.

The pensions and benefits in the public sector are always cited as a reason to stay. But I know several pubic sector workers who have declined opportunities to move to more interesting roles, or to travel because it meant losing their continuous service benefits- so it has become a bit of a trap.

Also, there are private sector organisations out there with much better benefits than you’d see in the public sector. Aside from the higher salaries ( which when invested more than covers the pension difference), I know people who have had 9-12 months maternity leave on full pay (I got six months, some on half pay), people who decamp and work from overseas every summer, lots of flexibility for working from home and flexi time around child care and people who have been really well looked after when they’ve been sick (including a law firm paying two years’ salary). I would never have known those possibilities were available when I was working in Local Government, as the narrative always was that we had the best benefits (despite constant restructuring and unpaid overtime)

OP posts:
thecatsthecats · 19/07/2023 09:48

The only part I agree with is that teachers don't necessarily know very much about different careers, and often pigeonhole students based on the sort of job they think they should be doing.

I'm very academic (as in, top results in the country level academic). But actually I thrive on physical, practical work. I could easily satisfy my intellectual talents in my private time whilst thriving as say, a builder. And being a builder wouldn't cause me the migraines sitting at a desk does.

witheringrowan · 19/07/2023 09:46

Also, I don't see such a huge difference in the other benefits, although I guess it will vary significantly by sector. Certainly my holiday entitlement is equivalent in the private sector, plus additional loyalty leave for every 5 years of employment, enhanced maternity pay, paternity leave has just been increased to 12 weeks, flexible working patterns can be agreed, great training etc. Not every company is going to offer that, but you certainly don't have to compromise on any of it if you chose the right private sector career.

JaceLancs · 19/07/2023 09:44

DD is NHS worker and DS works for local authority
I envy their salaries (far more than I was earning at similar ages)
both have had quite good career progression opportunities
much better pensions etc longer sick pay, paternity or maternity schemes
far greater job security
I wish I’d joined the civil service as a graduate as I’m sure I would be retired by now! At the time it seemed a safe boring option and at 21 that was not for me

Caledoniadreaming · 19/07/2023 09:41

I think it very much depends what your children want to do, I have been in the civil service my whole career, and while, yes I know I could be paid (a hell of) a lot more in the private sector, the work is varied, interesting and I know more now about a lot of subjects I would never have come across if it wasn't for the flexibility of the Civil Service and the variety of roles you can do in your career. Only now is my husband able to match me in terms of annual leave and pension, and he has worked in the private sector since he graduated from Uni.

One of the things my husband always says to me is the knowledge, work ethic, attitude and his experience of people in the public sector/civil service is superior to private sector - his team at the moment all earn more than I do, for far less responsibility but are they as satisfied with their careers as I am? Probably not.

gogomoto · 19/07/2023 09:36

Quite the opposite I would say. My exh's public sector job pays very well and as for his final salary pension (which I get 20% of on retirement...

Let your children choose their own path, whether it's electrician, banking or nurse

nonmerci99 · 19/07/2023 09:35

RoyKentFanclub · 19/07/2023 07:00

You must be joking. Quite the opposite I’d say. Nowhere else do you get the same level of protection and such amazing pensions.

This, really. Amazing benefits (pension, holiday, parental leave, etc.), amazing employee rights, both of which are generally inferior in the private sector. You might get paid more in terms of salary in the private sector, but you have to consider the benefits of both of these.

witheringrowan · 19/07/2023 09:34

Is the pension really worth it if you're earning so much less throughout your working life?

I've done both, but planning to stay firmly in the private sector for the rest of my career. I found the culture in the civil service endlessly frustrating, no one seemed to have any drive to actually make things happen, and I couldn't imagine sticking in that environment for 30+ years, particularly if you are someone who gets value and a sense of self from achieving things at work.

Plus the pay makes a huge difference to my life now. I moved back into the private sector 2 years ago, am making £30k more in basic salary than I was in the civil service and get an annual bonus that's been equivalent to half of my basic pay for the last couple of years. So I've been able to buy a flat near work rather than keep renting, I can plan sensibly for my retirement by putting a good chunk of my salary away without feeling that it's too much of a sacrifice.

In your place, I'd be advising them to try to get as much work experience as possible in different environments, so they can start to figure out what type of culture they are suited to. And let them know that if a job isn't working out, there's no point in staying in an environment that makes them unhappy, even if there is the promise of long term retirement benefits in 35 years time.

Threenow · 19/07/2023 09:31

orangeleavesinautumn · 19/07/2023 07:04

I don't think they should be differentiating between public sector and private sector jobs at all, just following their interests and talents then choosing which jobs to apply for based on terms and conditions in the vacancies they find once they are in the job market.

Most people end up going for jobs they had never even heard of as teenagers

This! Surely you should be encouraging them to find jobs which they think they will enjoy and which will make the most use of their skills/talents.

I'm not in the UK and I've never heard anyone discussing whether they should get a job in the public or private sector. People just go for the jobs they think will suit them.

Parlourgames · 19/07/2023 09:20

I agree completely with you

Nextlifestage · 19/07/2023 09:17

Maybe there's a difference with public facing roles. I've been in the same (professional public sector) public facing role for 25 years and frankly I'm fed up with entitled idiots who make day to day working intolerable.

SwitchDiver · 19/07/2023 09:15

4weeknoalcohol · 19/07/2023 08:47

So your annual pension is over 70k?

It’s currently £35k/Yr but rises each year with inflation. However, I started being paid it at age 41; so it is paying out for far longer than the usual public sector pension. I used a calculator to calculate the CETV from now at my current age to my life expectancy with an average 6% annual increase.

emmylousings · 19/07/2023 09:03

I've nearly always worked in public sector. Pay good enough for me, interesting, meaning work, good holidays etc and nice people on the whole. It depends what your DC want and what interests them.

4weeknoalcohol · 19/07/2023 08:47

SwitchDiver · 19/07/2023 07:21

I did twenty years in the public sector. There is huge variation in jobs though. I’d agree teaching isn’t the best profession for generating wealth…but that’s true private or public. CETV of my defined benefit pension= £2.6m

So your annual pension is over 70k?

Peony654 · 19/07/2023 08:37

You’re very wrong, public sector has other benefits like security and pension. And everyone I know who works in the private sector works awful hours and very high stress due to targets. And lastly it’s really none of your business, they need to find their own way

Blankstatement · 19/07/2023 08:36

I joined the public sector - civil service- in my late 30s. The pay is lower but the benefits, especially flexi time, pension etc are worth far more. Also treated a lot better.

Nextlifestage · 19/07/2023 08:35

FuckTheLemonsandBail · 19/07/2023 08:34

Lol. YABU.

DH and I both work for the NHS in professions. And when DC is old enough, if they ask, we'd both heavily recommend they go into a profession.

Medicine, dentistry, social work, teaching, nursing, whatever, get a degree that opens the door to a career.

We're in the same position and have advised our children exactly the opposite!

Nextlifestage · 19/07/2023 08:35

Not rtft but no I don't think you are.
Dh and I were both public sector workers - I still am and he has moved into the private sector.
Apart from my pension which is good (his was ok but not brilliant) there is nothing good about working in the public sector compared with private in my view.
My children have been put off by seeing how hard we work and what we earn compared with their friends' parents so they are already assuming they'll be looking for private sector jobs.

FuckTheLemonsandBail · 19/07/2023 08:34

Lol. YABU.

DH and I both work for the NHS in professions. And when DC is old enough, if they ask, we'd both heavily recommend they go into a profession.

Medicine, dentistry, social work, teaching, nursing, whatever, get a degree that opens the door to a career.

loislovesstewie · 19/07/2023 08:34

TheKeatingFive · 19/07/2023 07:55

that wasnt the question

It's a key part of the answer however. It seems that many public sector workers have absolutely no clue how valuable their pensions actually are.

Oh don't worry. I always knew how much my pension was worth. I never earned oodles working in the public sector, but my pension has made retirement a good one.

GrammarTeacher · 19/07/2023 08:29

Last summer I went to the 10 year reunion of my first year 7 class where I teach. The public sector workers were much happier in their work in general. I exclude the former student who moved to Denmark and works for Lego. But it's a given he's having the most fun. Those who went into finance/corporate legal roles were the most burnt out.

CornedBeef451 · 19/07/2023 08:28

I am in the public sector and DH has always been in the private sector.

I have much better holidays and flexibility for childcare but we can only afford our mortgage because of DH!

Thepeopleversuswork · 19/07/2023 08:24

I think the public vs private lens isn’t the only thing that you should use to guide them. Much more important overall is finding careers that chime with their strengths, personalities and ambitions.

FWIW I have only ever worked in the private sector and I earn a lot more than my friends in the civil service and teaching. Obviously pension is an advantage in public sector but there are ways to make up for this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread