Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to discourage DC from entering public sector careers?

163 replies

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 06:58

DD17, DD14 and DS12 have all been talking a lot about jobs they’d like to do lately. They are all very different fish, 2 very academic girls and one creative but not so book smart DS. Their schools to introduce a broad range of careers, but their teachers (understandably) seem to know more about public sector roles such as teaching, legal aid law and health professions (there’s a special ‘get into medicine course DD was encouraged to do).

When I started out, there were good options for people looking to work in the public sector. I headed into a helping profession in a Local Authority (but struggled with the inflexibility and have since moved into private practice). Friends were looking forward to careers in medicine, teaching and the civil service. A couple were pretty snobby about the moral superiority of public sector roles ( I remember an physio friend asking a trainee actuary friend how they got up each morning with such a boring job). Others headed into law, banking, consultancy etc. We were all very well educated and had many options.

However, at 45, things have all come out in the wash, and (with a few exceptions, notably two doctors who are independently wealthy, and a diplomat), those who chose private sector jobs are not just much wealthier but also seem to enjoy more flexible, varied roles and just seem happier in their work. Friends in the public sector complain that they are burnt out, struggling financially and stuck in their jobs with few other options.

AIBU to at least encourage DC to consider that public sector careers might not be the best idea any more? Obviously, they’ll choose what they choose, but to me, the difference between private and public sector roles (especially in London/SE) nowadays seems pretty stark.

OP posts:
Katypp · 19/07/2023 10:42

How many pps who work in the public sector have worked anywhere else? I think a lot have no idea of the reality of working in the private sector. I will give an example. When I went for my covid jab (at a centre dedicated to this), in the 15m walk from my car to the nurse, I encountered the following (and they were all NHS staff as they wore uniform and name badges): 1 person standing under a sign saying Covid Jabs This Way telling me that covid jabs were this way, two people just inside the door, 1 who asked my name and another who found my record card from a very small pile (jabs were pre-booked), another telling me to join the queue, another at the bend if the queue telling me which way to go and another two at the door to the room, one asking my name and another pointing which nurse to go to.
Seven people. in the private sector, this would have been handled by one person asking your name and giving your records and another one taking your records and allocating the jab booth. So five less.
That's why I tend to take tales of woe about short staffing in the public sector with a pinch of salt. Because in the public sector the volume of jobs would not exist in the first place.
OP I think you've fallen for the hype I am afraid.

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 10:40

I am really interested what people are saying about Civil Service roles, especially working out of Whitehall.

I do not know anyone of my generation who opted for that path (except one who is now a deputy High Commissioner, mostly worked overseas). But DH's father worked in central government policy making for a while (on industry secondment but I presume was a Civil Servant) and he absolutely loved it.

It sounds like a really interesting, worthwhile career.

OP posts:
HundredMilesAnHour · 19/07/2023 10:28

SueVineer · 19/07/2023 10:20

Those benefits are not common in the private sector though. You are comparing a few exceptions in the private sector with the public sector. You are also minimizing the pension benefits- defined benefit indexed linked pensions are rarely available outside the public sector and are incredibly expensive to replicate.

Agree with this. I've never heard of 2 years paid sick leave anywhere! In the private sector it varies from 6 months paid to 2 weeks paid. Most companies are cutting back on benefits. For example, the coverage with my private medical insurance is the worst it's ever been. When I was ill last year, I hit my outpatient limit within 1 week and after that I had to self-fund.

What3words · 19/07/2023 10:27

Yes that could be it too. I was an oxbridge genius but have ended up in low paid work. Friends son scraped into uni after btecs and earns squillions now in tech in mid 20s...

ArcticSkewer · 19/07/2023 10:26

This doesn't really work as a comparator.

You'd either have to compare by sector eg public vs private teaching
or perhaps by ability - what other career could a person on track to qualify in medicine do instead, for example.

The problem is that you'd need to compare other careers that save lives, or whatever other motivation there is to join a medical pathway, for it to be a useful comparator.

Perhaps the actual issue is that careers advice is non existent these days

What3words · 19/07/2023 10:25

Something like accountancy or HR or something presumably you can flip?

I don't really know enough about graduate training schemes to advise my kids so will encourage them to look for themselves. There isn't civil service work near us and a lot of grad schemes are London based or a lot of travel which not everyone wants.

What3words · 19/07/2023 10:23

It's quite hard to flip between if you've trained in a public sector role (nurse/ot/teacher) or to even get the higher pay grades so you are limited on income in that sense. Nothing like the mumsnet "oh 70k that's nothing, I'm not well off" threads!

SueVineer · 19/07/2023 10:20

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 09:52

Really interesting perspectives, thanks everyone for sharing.

Of course, our children will follow their own paths and we will be proud that they have done so. I guess I want them to be able to take a balanced view of all the possibilities. And to consider what might be the best path if they want to move country, be promoted etc.

The pensions and benefits in the public sector are always cited as a reason to stay. But I know several pubic sector workers who have declined opportunities to move to more interesting roles, or to travel because it meant losing their continuous service benefits- so it has become a bit of a trap.

Also, there are private sector organisations out there with much better benefits than you’d see in the public sector. Aside from the higher salaries ( which when invested more than covers the pension difference), I know people who have had 9-12 months maternity leave on full pay (I got six months, some on half pay), people who decamp and work from overseas every summer, lots of flexibility for working from home and flexi time around child care and people who have been really well looked after when they’ve been sick (including a law firm paying two years’ salary). I would never have known those possibilities were available when I was working in Local Government, as the narrative always was that we had the best benefits (despite constant restructuring and unpaid overtime)

Those benefits are not common in the private sector though. You are comparing a few exceptions in the private sector with the public sector. You are also minimizing the pension benefits- defined benefit indexed linked pensions are rarely available outside the public sector and are incredibly expensive to replicate.

CapEBarra · 19/07/2023 10:20

I don’t think they need to consider sector. I’ve worked in both and the reality is that it’s not much different and day to day you need the same skills for the same type of role. It would be much more productive to encourage their interests and skills development so that when the time comes they have options. A job is not a job for life anymore and I have spent the last 30 years flip flopping between sectors and academia, as I come across interesting opportunities I’d like to pursue. Education, skills, and experience give your children choices and the opportunity to have a career they enjoy and will enable them to grow.

RunningFromInsanity · 19/07/2023 10:19

Public sector (local government)
Very flexible working, good benefits. 100% job security during the pandemic.
Mediocre pay.

Justtobeclear · 19/07/2023 10:19

The civil service is a great option for those leaving school due to the amount of degree apprenticeships and training programs. Still get a qualification without the debt, paid whilst training and work experience. There’s also no requirement to stay after qualifying and you will deal with external private companies that you can get a feel for should a private move something you want to explore.

KimberleyClark · 19/07/2023 10:17

Terms and conditions are much better in the public sector.

What3words · 19/07/2023 10:15

Coding/computer stuff seems to be where its at on mns. There's threads of people with flexible hours/as long as I get it done I can walk the dog/hang put washing etc.

And good pay

But neither of my kids are tech save at all!

SueVineer · 19/07/2023 10:14

I worked in a similar type of professional job in the public and private sector. The private sector is better paid for that type of role (but not in many) but the pension benefits and work life balance are infinitely superior in the public sector. The people I know in the public sector have done well for themselves- not the huge earners I’ve seen in some of my city friends but generally better paid than the private sector especially out of london.

fitzwilliamdarcy · 19/07/2023 10:10

@sunrisechurch I agree. Many of my colleagues work part time in theory but in reality, clock in more than full time hours. Flexi time is something of a misnomer as we can never take the time back, it's so busy.

Perhaps it's different elsewhere - public sector is huge, after all. But there has been a very noticeable post-COVID shift where I am.

vodkaredbullgirl · 19/07/2023 10:10

Surely they should do what they want to do.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2023 10:08

I’ve just told my dc to make sure they work in a unionised workplace.

sunrisechurch · 19/07/2023 10:07

I'm constantly working unpaid overtime and for the first time I'm questioning whether it wouldn't be easier to just go to a private firm instead. If I'm going to be worked to the bone I'd rather be paid double for it.

This has always been my experience too in the CS. Or at least over the past five years or so.

I think it’s very role/grade dependant and I wonder if the more junior grades are more suited to part time or flexible working on the whole (there will be exceptions of course).

My experience of part time at G7 level has consistently been having to work full time for a part time salary 🤦‍♀️

HundredMilesAnHour · 19/07/2023 10:04

My friends who work in the public sector (NOT teaching) in a variety of roles from the Environment Agency to the Attorney General's Office are relaxed and pretty happy with their lot, and enjoy an amazing work life balance. They think it's a big deal if they have to work past 6pm (happens rarely). My private sector friends, whilst earning more, are stressed to breaking point, work 60+ hours/week on a regular basis and are under constant pressure to perform with very little security.

When I was at uni, my mother (a teacher) tried to pressure me to go into the civil service (that's what she did before teaching). So I of course rebelled and went down the private sector route into Financial Services. Years later, with hindsight, I should have listened to her.

I think OP that you're comparing the best of the private sector with the worst of the public sector. Not a fair comparison.

Express0 · 19/07/2023 10:03

SwitchDiver · 19/07/2023 09:15

It’s currently £35k/Yr but rises each year with inflation. However, I started being paid it at age 41; so it is paying out for far longer than the usual public sector pension. I used a calculator to calculate the CETV from now at my current age to my life expectancy with an average 6% annual increase.

Yeah that’s not how you calculate a defined benefit CETV.

Tinkietot · 19/07/2023 10:03

I’m private sector and salary isn’t great for what I’m asked to do (similar pay level to teachers with same numbers of year’s experience).

Lot of people burning out and working late / on weekends in our company

I do get a bonus which is £1.5k roughly, that’s if we get a bonus, some years it’s nothing

Current pension projection is 14k a year with a lump sum of 60k if I retire at 65.

I wouldn’t rule out public sector completely

fitzwilliamdarcy · 19/07/2023 10:01

I'm public sector law and for 15 years we've been hiring staff out of the private sector due to our better working hours and flexibility etc.

For the first time, we're now losing tons of staff back to the private sector. Many firms are matching our offer on working hours and flexibility, but paying twice the salary. Yes, the pension may not be as good, but at twice the salary, people can save a chunk of money to live on in retirement.

I'm constantly working unpaid overtime and for the first time I'm questioning whether it wouldn't be easier to just go to a private firm instead. If I'm going to be worked to the bone I'd rather be paid double for it.

So no, you're not wrong, but plenty of people still have the view that the public sector is a utopia.

Dogsitterwoes · 19/07/2023 09:59

There are pros and cons to both.

Real high flyers undoubtedly do better financially in private sector. But the vast majority of people aren't in top roles, and may be better off overall in public sector. IME many public sector employees have no understanding of how unusual some of things they take for granted are.

I spent most of my life in private sector, moved to public a few years ago, and wish I'd done it earlier. I'm in a professional but non-management role. I could earn more elsewhere but the other benefits more than outweigh that for me.

LondonPapa · 19/07/2023 09:56

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 06:58

DD17, DD14 and DS12 have all been talking a lot about jobs they’d like to do lately. They are all very different fish, 2 very academic girls and one creative but not so book smart DS. Their schools to introduce a broad range of careers, but their teachers (understandably) seem to know more about public sector roles such as teaching, legal aid law and health professions (there’s a special ‘get into medicine course DD was encouraged to do).

When I started out, there were good options for people looking to work in the public sector. I headed into a helping profession in a Local Authority (but struggled with the inflexibility and have since moved into private practice). Friends were looking forward to careers in medicine, teaching and the civil service. A couple were pretty snobby about the moral superiority of public sector roles ( I remember an physio friend asking a trainee actuary friend how they got up each morning with such a boring job). Others headed into law, banking, consultancy etc. We were all very well educated and had many options.

However, at 45, things have all come out in the wash, and (with a few exceptions, notably two doctors who are independently wealthy, and a diplomat), those who chose private sector jobs are not just much wealthier but also seem to enjoy more flexible, varied roles and just seem happier in their work. Friends in the public sector complain that they are burnt out, struggling financially and stuck in their jobs with few other options.

AIBU to at least encourage DC to consider that public sector careers might not be the best idea any more? Obviously, they’ll choose what they choose, but to me, the difference between private and public sector roles (especially in London/SE) nowadays seems pretty stark.

You examples from the public sector may ring true for the NHS or teaching but not for the Civil Service. You're being very unreasonable by dismissing the Civil Service. If your DC go through the Fast Stream after graduation, they can end up in Grade 7 posts paying £55-60k pa (more by time they go through it) with a pension that accrues at 2.32% and pays out a guaranteed rate for life, during retirement.

That's before you get to the flexibility benefits, including fully paid parental leave (not all departments), flexible time off for childcare, WFH (2-4 days at home, 1-3 in office - team dependent).

Source: I work for the Civil Service in a Policy post in a Central Whitehall department. My Work-Life balance is much better than it was previously in NHS and Private Sector. I also get to travel overseas a lot so that is a bonus.

I would advise against working in Operations within the Civil Service, they're usually public facing posts and not good (think Home Office, DWP, HMRC). But they're, largely, the lower, non-professional grades. Hopefully your DC are able to skip via the Fast Stream or Direct Entry routes offered.

What3words · 19/07/2023 09:56

Most public sector workers will not be retiring in 40k a year pensions though realistically.

Most may never get to 40k.