Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to discourage DC from entering public sector careers?

163 replies

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 06:58

DD17, DD14 and DS12 have all been talking a lot about jobs they’d like to do lately. They are all very different fish, 2 very academic girls and one creative but not so book smart DS. Their schools to introduce a broad range of careers, but their teachers (understandably) seem to know more about public sector roles such as teaching, legal aid law and health professions (there’s a special ‘get into medicine course DD was encouraged to do).

When I started out, there were good options for people looking to work in the public sector. I headed into a helping profession in a Local Authority (but struggled with the inflexibility and have since moved into private practice). Friends were looking forward to careers in medicine, teaching and the civil service. A couple were pretty snobby about the moral superiority of public sector roles ( I remember an physio friend asking a trainee actuary friend how they got up each morning with such a boring job). Others headed into law, banking, consultancy etc. We were all very well educated and had many options.

However, at 45, things have all come out in the wash, and (with a few exceptions, notably two doctors who are independently wealthy, and a diplomat), those who chose private sector jobs are not just much wealthier but also seem to enjoy more flexible, varied roles and just seem happier in their work. Friends in the public sector complain that they are burnt out, struggling financially and stuck in their jobs with few other options.

AIBU to at least encourage DC to consider that public sector careers might not be the best idea any more? Obviously, they’ll choose what they choose, but to me, the difference between private and public sector roles (especially in London/SE) nowadays seems pretty stark.

OP posts:
littlegrebe · 19/07/2023 11:52

I moved from the private sector to public. I took a pay cut overall, though not if you compare actual hours worked. I was doing 50-60 hour weeks in the private sector, with unachievable targets, awful management, backstabbing colleagues, and a regular requirement to deliberately mislead customers in order to make more money. Now I have a supportive team, I can rely on finishing work at 5pm, and I'm making one small bit of the world a better place.

Obviously this will vary role to role - I know long hours, unachievable targets and awful management will strike a bell with a lot of teachers. I think it helps to have a job that also exists in the private sector because senior managers know it's very easy for us to leave for more money if the non-financial benefits disappear.

Re vaccination centre volunteering, I did it and was given an honorary contract with the NHS. No name badge, just a high vis vest, but on paper I was "employed" by them so not surprised to hear others did get a badge. The organisation got a lot more efficient as time went on but I think it was sensible to overstaff at first as we just didn't know how people would behave.

Donotunderestimateme · 19/07/2023 11:50

Oh @Katypp and when your colleague has been attacked leaving work after a late shift in the dark then yea - people want access to safe secure parking.

FixTheBone · 19/07/2023 11:44

Express0 · 19/07/2023 10:58

If you are in the NHS pension scheme then it is not true that the pension is devalued. It is adjusted each year in line with CPI plus 1.5%. Do this year would have been increased by 11.6%

yes,

but the salary it is based on is being reduced in real terms.

So, yes, the input amounts have an inflation factor applied, but if my salary is £50k this year, and still £50k in 2045, when in real terms it would be worth maybe 65-70k - the actual value of the pension is less.

Plus LTA is fixed and doesn't increase with inflation, further diminishing the maximum value over time.

Donotunderestimateme · 19/07/2023 11:41

Oh and @Katypp when you can’t leave your patient’s side for 12.5 hours unless someone is watching over them to alter the drug rates every minute if required then yes we need our breaks- so that we can do stuff like….. oh you know go for a piss or change a tampon.

SunnyEgg · 19/07/2023 11:38

I wouldn’t discourage it

Dd currently would like to be a doctor, she’s young and also wants to be a scientist and artist

Great fine with the first two, third is nice but can be tricky

Donotunderestimateme · 19/07/2023 11:36

I would not encourage my children to take an NHS job simply because then they can avoid all the judgemental NHS staff bashing that goes on as it is really demoralising. We work bloody hard but the reward is seeing patients get better or supporting families when they don’t.

Ninjasan · 19/07/2023 11:36

RoyKentFanclub · 19/07/2023 07:00

You must be joking. Quite the opposite I’d say. Nowhere else do you get the same level of protection and such amazing pensions.

Agree. Flexible working (sometimes not working), sick leave, crazy high pensions, a lot of annual leave and pay rises. I got 3% this year in private sector. I feel like a looser.

Catspyjamas17 · 19/07/2023 11:34

Katypp · 19/07/2023 11:25

But my post wasn't about how marvellous the NHS is, it was about much more efficient the private sector usually is.
my point is that it is difficult to get on board with how understaffed the NHS is when it is probably overstaffed in the first place. Using my example, I reckon that was five more people than a private sector equivalent would deploy. Yet, in NHS terms, if they only had two staff they would be understaffed by five. Does that make sense?
I was in hospital for a prolonged time a couple of years ago and it really opened my eyes. I am not sure where this nirvana of free parking, finishing on the dot, never working through breaks (not that I have ever had defined breaks) and high pay is in the private sector, but it's not something I have ever experienced in my professional role.

I've been in hospitals more times than you can shake a stick at in my 47 years - certainly not all for me, mostly to do with family and friends and the impression is certainly not of overstaffing. Inefficiency, certainly, at times, but that's often due to getting rid of admin not having too many cooks.

Donotunderestimateme · 19/07/2023 11:33

Katypp · 19/07/2023 10:42

How many pps who work in the public sector have worked anywhere else? I think a lot have no idea of the reality of working in the private sector. I will give an example. When I went for my covid jab (at a centre dedicated to this), in the 15m walk from my car to the nurse, I encountered the following (and they were all NHS staff as they wore uniform and name badges): 1 person standing under a sign saying Covid Jabs This Way telling me that covid jabs were this way, two people just inside the door, 1 who asked my name and another who found my record card from a very small pile (jabs were pre-booked), another telling me to join the queue, another at the bend if the queue telling me which way to go and another two at the door to the room, one asking my name and another pointing which nurse to go to.
Seven people. in the private sector, this would have been handled by one person asking your name and giving your records and another one taking your records and allocating the jab booth. So five less.
That's why I tend to take tales of woe about short staffing in the public sector with a pinch of salt. Because in the public sector the volume of jobs would not exist in the first place.
OP I think you've fallen for the hype I am afraid.

I work in ICU as a nurse. When the covid jab was being rolled out we were offered the opportunity to volunteer (on top of our usual day/ night shifts) at the vaccination centres in various roles. So some of those people pointing the way may have been colleagues who were quite rightly wearing their uniform to do extra work to help with the roll out.
As you can imagine we were quite excited about the vaccine rollout after watching people die of the virus and so some people did volunteer their time. Nice to know you are so judgemental of them just trying to make the whole thing easier for the public. Many of the people going for those first jabs were understandably apprehensive and people just wanted to help.

ArcticSkewer · 19/07/2023 11:31

Katypp · 19/07/2023 10:42

How many pps who work in the public sector have worked anywhere else? I think a lot have no idea of the reality of working in the private sector. I will give an example. When I went for my covid jab (at a centre dedicated to this), in the 15m walk from my car to the nurse, I encountered the following (and they were all NHS staff as they wore uniform and name badges): 1 person standing under a sign saying Covid Jabs This Way telling me that covid jabs were this way, two people just inside the door, 1 who asked my name and another who found my record card from a very small pile (jabs were pre-booked), another telling me to join the queue, another at the bend if the queue telling me which way to go and another two at the door to the room, one asking my name and another pointing which nurse to go to.
Seven people. in the private sector, this would have been handled by one person asking your name and giving your records and another one taking your records and allocating the jab booth. So five less.
That's why I tend to take tales of woe about short staffing in the public sector with a pinch of salt. Because in the public sector the volume of jobs would not exist in the first place.
OP I think you've fallen for the hype I am afraid.

Those were volunteers ....

I know because I did it for a year. Happily I could flex my paid job in the public sector so I caught up on evenings and weekends. Most of the people you will have seen that day were volunteers. There will have been paid security (and sadly we did need that), paid reception staff and paid nurses/vaccinators.

The ones giving directions, standing under signs etc would have been volunteers.

Katypp · 19/07/2023 11:25

Catspyjamas17 · 19/07/2023 11:12

Ok - But still, the way Covid jabs were rolled out across the country was largely pretty amazing, with huge take up. I think it's an example of how good the public sector can be, all coming together like that. I'm sure at some point some units were overstaffed when they didn't know how many people would be coming at once, but I'm sure they were redeployed or reorganised soon after. There was a difference between my first, second and third jabs - process more efficient and fewer staff required each time. It's really not a good example of overstaffing- and we know there is a big shortage of doctors and nurses.

But my post wasn't about how marvellous the NHS is, it was about much more efficient the private sector usually is.
my point is that it is difficult to get on board with how understaffed the NHS is when it is probably overstaffed in the first place. Using my example, I reckon that was five more people than a private sector equivalent would deploy. Yet, in NHS terms, if they only had two staff they would be understaffed by five. Does that make sense?
I was in hospital for a prolonged time a couple of years ago and it really opened my eyes. I am not sure where this nirvana of free parking, finishing on the dot, never working through breaks (not that I have ever had defined breaks) and high pay is in the private sector, but it's not something I have ever experienced in my professional role.

sunrisechurch · 19/07/2023 11:18

Catspyjamas17 · 19/07/2023 11:12

Ok - But still, the way Covid jabs were rolled out across the country was largely pretty amazing, with huge take up. I think it's an example of how good the public sector can be, all coming together like that. I'm sure at some point some units were overstaffed when they didn't know how many people would be coming at once, but I'm sure they were redeployed or reorganised soon after. There was a difference between my first, second and third jabs - process more efficient and fewer staff required each time. It's really not a good example of overstaffing- and we know there is a big shortage of doctors and nurses.

I agree.

I have plenty of criticisms about the public sector (some I have shared on this thread!) but I think the covid vaccine rollout was a huge success.

Carleslireis · 19/07/2023 11:15

I think you’re oversimplifying the type of roles that are available in the public sector. There are so many interesting roles beyond the obvious (eg statistician, trade lawyer, economist, prosecutor, data scientist, marine biologist, park ranger, managing historic buildings, etc) and the public sector often has better remuneration for the hours worked.

FWIW I went to Oxbridge (fairly recent grad) and civil service has been one of the most popular options among my classmates after law and financial services. In fact there are some that went into CS law and financial services (Bank of England/Treasury/FCA) as well as the more standard fast stream.

Catspyjamas17 · 19/07/2023 11:12

Katypp · 19/07/2023 10:50

@Catspyjamas17 already covered that in my posts.Did volunteers were NHS uniform and have NHS name badges and job roles?

Ok - But still, the way Covid jabs were rolled out across the country was largely pretty amazing, with huge take up. I think it's an example of how good the public sector can be, all coming together like that. I'm sure at some point some units were overstaffed when they didn't know how many people would be coming at once, but I'm sure they were redeployed or reorganised soon after. There was a difference between my first, second and third jabs - process more efficient and fewer staff required each time. It's really not a good example of overstaffing- and we know there is a big shortage of doctors and nurses.

Daphnis156 · 19/07/2023 11:01

There's no need to get over-involved in any career you children may choose.

If asked you might give and opinion, but it seems you are assuming you will direct rather than support the choice.

There are of course good and bad jobs and work conditions in both public and private sector careers, so it simply is impossible for you to judge.

Express0 · 19/07/2023 10:58

FixTheBone · 19/07/2023 10:49

I particularly wouldn't go into medicine at the moment.

The salary was good and the final salary pension excellent when I entered med school in 2000.

However, the salaries have stagnated, and the final salary pension has gone, and since its based on salary, is also being devalued at the same rate as the salary due to inflation.

If you went into medicine now, and pension and salaries follow the same pattern of the last 25 years, you'd start on a salary worth the equivalent today of £20k and finish on a salary worth the equivalent of £15k, based on a rough estimate of salaries being devalued by around 30% per 15 years.

If you are in the NHS pension scheme then it is not true that the pension is devalued. It is adjusted each year in line with CPI plus 1.5%. Do this year would have been increased by 11.6%

loislovesstewie · 19/07/2023 10:54

As I said, I'm retired public sector worker, I actually dealt with people who were or were going to become homeless. I was ran off my feet, we were understaffed , because lack of money, I never stopped from 8-5 , when I made sure I went home.My lunch break [ha ha!] was never more than 30 minutes and often consisted of me eating while working. I actually liked my job, when it went well for customers it was very satisfying. Sadly lack of investment in social housing and unrealistic expectations have made customers very angry, unhappy and often abusive. The idea that we all sat around doing nothing/didn't care/had no skills /training /idea, or that a trained monkey could do better are way off the mark. Most of the issues are caused by underfunding and poor governments.

Katypp · 19/07/2023 10:50

@Catspyjamas17 already covered that in my posts.Did volunteers were NHS uniform and have NHS name badges and job roles?

FixTheBone · 19/07/2023 10:49

I particularly wouldn't go into medicine at the moment.

The salary was good and the final salary pension excellent when I entered med school in 2000.

However, the salaries have stagnated, and the final salary pension has gone, and since its based on salary, is also being devalued at the same rate as the salary due to inflation.

If you went into medicine now, and pension and salaries follow the same pattern of the last 25 years, you'd start on a salary worth the equivalent today of £20k and finish on a salary worth the equivalent of £15k, based on a rough estimate of salaries being devalued by around 30% per 15 years.

Catspyjamas17 · 19/07/2023 10:48

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 10:40

I am really interested what people are saying about Civil Service roles, especially working out of Whitehall.

I do not know anyone of my generation who opted for that path (except one who is now a deputy High Commissioner, mostly worked overseas). But DH's father worked in central government policy making for a while (on industry secondment but I presume was a Civil Servant) and he absolutely loved it.

It sounds like a really interesting, worthwhile career.

What I would say in my experience is that they recruit very diversely in terms of sex, race, sexuality - on every area, except class. It is still very middle and upper middle class.

AvanGelist · 19/07/2023 10:47

Why are you focusing on sector rather than job role?
Like any other organization the public sector also has accountants, procurement specialists, project managers so if you choose that path, all good.

Of course a senior civil servant will have many transferable skills for the 'private sector', whereas a driving instructor (also a civil servant btw, with jobs on the gov.uk website) won't.

There's too much variation to consider, or write off an entire sector

Even teachers are leaving the profession in droves and seem to have no issues pivoting into other jobs roles.

In 2023 the only certain things is that careers are fluid....

olivehaters · 19/07/2023 10:46

I think you have more potential to be a very high earner in the private sectors but if you are more of a mid level professional the public sector has more benefits flexibility and a good pension. Unless you are in the NHS as a clinical professional which
which has all of the negatives but none of the perks of public sector. I would never encourage my kids to be a clinical NHS proffesional.

Gravitatio · 19/07/2023 10:46

ConnieTucker · 19/07/2023 07:10

What amount of annual pension do you consider to be amazing?

Pretty much all defined benefit pensions out there are amazing.

Catspyjamas17 · 19/07/2023 10:45

Katypp · 19/07/2023 10:42

How many pps who work in the public sector have worked anywhere else? I think a lot have no idea of the reality of working in the private sector. I will give an example. When I went for my covid jab (at a centre dedicated to this), in the 15m walk from my car to the nurse, I encountered the following (and they were all NHS staff as they wore uniform and name badges): 1 person standing under a sign saying Covid Jabs This Way telling me that covid jabs were this way, two people just inside the door, 1 who asked my name and another who found my record card from a very small pile (jabs were pre-booked), another telling me to join the queue, another at the bend if the queue telling me which way to go and another two at the door to the room, one asking my name and another pointing which nurse to go to.
Seven people. in the private sector, this would have been handled by one person asking your name and giving your records and another one taking your records and allocating the jab booth. So five less.
That's why I tend to take tales of woe about short staffing in the public sector with a pinch of salt. Because in the public sector the volume of jobs would not exist in the first place.
OP I think you've fallen for the hype I am afraid.

A lot of those people were volunteers 🙄

It's not a great example of "public sector inefficiency".

Catspyjamas17 · 19/07/2023 10:43

I wouldn't necessarily discourage it, but I would give them some different opinions, like DH is good at his job and enjoys it, has a good pension, but also has to put a lot into it from his salary, and may have letters after his name but hasn't had a proper pay rise in ten years. So what may start out as a good salary isn't necessarily when you take into account inflation (especially at the moment).

Whereas in my job in the private sector, I have had lots of pay rises, sometimes having to move to get one, and work fewer hours than DH but get paid 40% more, but my pension will probably end up being about the same even though I earn more. And in some jobs I have earned a good deal more than this but that money isn't everything. Stress levels, work environment, job satisfaction, autonomy, trust, creativity, flexibility are all important factors to consider.

If anything I've tried to encourage more thinking outside the box with careers than my parents did (or perhaps were able to)- the best jobs are often ones you make up yourself.

Swipe left for the next trending thread