Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to discourage DC from entering public sector careers?

163 replies

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 06:58

DD17, DD14 and DS12 have all been talking a lot about jobs they’d like to do lately. They are all very different fish, 2 very academic girls and one creative but not so book smart DS. Their schools to introduce a broad range of careers, but their teachers (understandably) seem to know more about public sector roles such as teaching, legal aid law and health professions (there’s a special ‘get into medicine course DD was encouraged to do).

When I started out, there were good options for people looking to work in the public sector. I headed into a helping profession in a Local Authority (but struggled with the inflexibility and have since moved into private practice). Friends were looking forward to careers in medicine, teaching and the civil service. A couple were pretty snobby about the moral superiority of public sector roles ( I remember an physio friend asking a trainee actuary friend how they got up each morning with such a boring job). Others headed into law, banking, consultancy etc. We were all very well educated and had many options.

However, at 45, things have all come out in the wash, and (with a few exceptions, notably two doctors who are independently wealthy, and a diplomat), those who chose private sector jobs are not just much wealthier but also seem to enjoy more flexible, varied roles and just seem happier in their work. Friends in the public sector complain that they are burnt out, struggling financially and stuck in their jobs with few other options.

AIBU to at least encourage DC to consider that public sector careers might not be the best idea any more? Obviously, they’ll choose what they choose, but to me, the difference between private and public sector roles (especially in London/SE) nowadays seems pretty stark.

OP posts:
storminamooncup · 19/07/2023 18:05

Used to work in the public sector. Left as I was so sick of public money being wasted and people being overpaid to do sweet fuck all. Colleagues online shopping while I'm working away.

Work in the charity sector, lower paid, shit pension, but work bloody hard. Sell services to public sector clients and honestly, the stupidity of some of them is unreal, yet they are on £50,000. Also 23 year olds who are already 'heads of'.

Public sector is the job to aim for for money, pension, annual leave etc. If they don't like one public sector employer, move to another?

Lucimaya · 19/07/2023 17:00

If I had my time around, I wouldn't choose working for the public sector again.

BiddyPop · 19/07/2023 16:57

I have risen to senior management in the public sector so while I could be better paid in private sector, I am still well paid.

I have interesting work and it gets changed regularly (between general rotations of staff and promotion, and just how society and Govt priorities change over time). But what I have done in the past has been relevant to what o do now.

I've had lots of useful training paid for, including a Masters in Economic Analysis.

What I do can make a huge difference to business and to wider society. And I have the levers to make things happen.

I work with interesting people at work, and get to deal with big swathes of society who are mostly interesting too.

I've been able to travel all over the world. Lots to Europe (and all around Europe, not just over and back to Brussels), but also to South America and Far East. Many colleagues have been to the other continents as well. For a mix of negotiations, supporting Ministers, speaking and presenting at events etc. And while I haven't done it yet, there are a number of opportunities even in my own Department (not Foreign Affairs) to do a 4 year posting overseas.

I don't preach about public service values - but doing good for wider society is definitely something that motivates me. But at the same time, I am paid a decent wage for interesting work and given good working terms and conditions. So well worth it as a career.

PandorasBoxers · 19/07/2023 15:44

Billoddiesbeard · 19/07/2023 07:20

It depends what you/your children see as important. Certainly the chances to earn very large salaries are not as forthcoming coming in public sector roles but as others have said the protection, potential for family friendly/flexible working, generous holiday entitlement and pension benefits should be taken into consideration before dismissing these roles as a career choice

I joined the civil service at 21. I had a 30 + year career across different departments doing various roles ranging from health to criminal justice.

I never earned a huge salary, I topped out at 65k but I was able to take an excellent final salary pension for life (although I believe pensions are now average salary based) and retire at 55. For me the long term benefits significantly factored into my career choices.

I completely agree, although earlier on in my career and on less!

However I work 36hrs p/w, get flexi, 6 weeks holiday and 11 privilege days.

After maternity leave I’m taking a career break for a further year and then will hopefully drop my hours a bit too. I work from home which is very convenient with no core hours.

I also love being in a policy area and working in the general area of Ministers and seeing “behind the scenes” but I am a politics geek

waterst · 19/07/2023 14:18

Choosing between public vs private sector matters far less now than choosing a career which won't disappear in the coming years thanks to AI. All that matters is choosing a career that only a human can do.

anniegun · 19/07/2023 14:14

Health care will be privatised by the time they enter they are working (much of it is already). If they become Doctors they can work in many great places around the world including Australia, Canada and New Zealand

doingitforyorkshire · 19/07/2023 14:09

Public Sector for me all the way. At 48, other than 12yrs running my own business, I have always been PS. Never had any inclination to into the private. My kids will be encouraged to work in the sector that suits them best.
To be fair my role doesn't exist in the private sector anyway, I do have scope for movement upwards, sideways and in slightly different contexts but they are all government/MOD run anyway so it's not like I have much choice unless I completely change my career which would me mad as I like what I do, it suites me, has reasonable pay and pension, hours and work environment can be brutal at times though, but you can't have it all!.

4weeknoalcohol · 19/07/2023 13:57

SwitchDiver · 19/07/2023 09:15

It’s currently £35k/Yr but rises each year with inflation. However, I started being paid it at age 41; so it is paying out for far longer than the usual public sector pension. I used a calculator to calculate the CETV from now at my current age to my life expectancy with an average 6% annual increase.

Okay I understand now yes that sounds about right with your age and also considering your dependents 50% pension rights on your death if they survive you.

10HailMarys · 19/07/2023 13:46

I think YABU to discourage your children from a) public sector careers or b) any career that they want to pursue. They’ll adults by then. It’s not really any of your business.

kikisparks · 19/07/2023 13:35

DH and I do public sector jobs and have had great flexibility, get lots of annual leave, decent sick leave and maternity leave, good pensions, I get flexi time and we both had flexible working applications to compress our hours granted which has been great for childcare purposes and spending more time with our daughter. I could potentially get paid more in the private sector but my pay is still very good, I got promoted straight after taking maternity leave too. Our jobs are also very safe.

Upsizer · 19/07/2023 13:30

I’ve worked in both and now in private sector but the t&c for public sector is so good: sick pay in particular. Yes people leave early but often with considerable pensions, even with early retirement penalties. I am often tempted to return just because it’s literally impossible for me to build up my pension to the same degree outside the public sector.

Proudofitbabe · 19/07/2023 13:24

Gosh I'm the opposite. The people I know in the public sector earn great money and have better flex/T&Cs compared to the private sector ones. Appreciate this will vary by job/field but if my kids fancy the public sector they'll have my full encouragement.

Beachhutnut · 19/07/2023 13:21

I would encourage public sector. The culture and way they look after staff is second to none and pensions etc worth their weight in gold. Also loads of career opportunities in civil service. My friends in private sector are treated appallingly in comparison. It really hit home during COVID. We were really well looked after.

NeedToChangeName · 19/07/2023 13:20

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2023 12:53

Are you a teacher?

That is so not what teaching is like. But continue to pedal the falicy

@ArseInTheCoOpWindow No, I'm not a teacher, but have several.in the family and have discussed working conditions with them on many occasions

Ginmonkeyagain · 19/07/2023 13:03

OP it looks like your public sector experience was in Local Government - which is notoriously shit. It's a case of picking the right public sector job.

I work for an economic regulator - we get flexible working, decent pay (better than the CS) and pensions, generous sick and parental, leave policies, annual bonuses, private healthcare, good offices, free tea and coffee, subsidised gym and canteen. The work is interesting and jobs are pretty secure.

travelallthetime · 19/07/2023 13:01

My husband works in the public sector and is actively discouraging my DS to join. The pay does not match the responsibilities, less staff than there should be, red tape, stress. In my husbands sector they are leaving in droves, quite literally. Is the pension good, yes, but the terms keep changing, paying in more, working longer and getting back less. He currently pays in around 15% so its not as great as it seems!

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2023 12:53

NeedToChangeName · 19/07/2023 12:51

On MN, I hear that teachers have the hardest job in the world

IRL, I know several teachers. They have reasonable workloads, (generally home by 5pm), don't work in school holidays (except exam results day), lengthy school holidays, 6 month sick pay if required, unions fighting their corner and gold-plated pensions. I think they have a good work life balance. They might earn more in private sector, but not necessarily. Many private sector roles don't pay well

Are you a teacher?

That is so not what teaching is like. But continue to pedal the falicy

NeedToChangeName · 19/07/2023 12:51

On MN, I hear that teachers have the hardest job in the world

IRL, I know several teachers. They have reasonable workloads, (generally home by 5pm), don't work in school holidays (except exam results day), lengthy school holidays, 6 month sick pay if required, unions fighting their corner and gold-plated pensions. I think they have a good work life balance. They might earn more in private sector, but not necessarily. Many private sector roles don't pay well

LondonPapa · 19/07/2023 12:34

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 10:40

I am really interested what people are saying about Civil Service roles, especially working out of Whitehall.

I do not know anyone of my generation who opted for that path (except one who is now a deputy High Commissioner, mostly worked overseas). But DH's father worked in central government policy making for a while (on industry secondment but I presume was a Civil Servant) and he absolutely loved it.

It sounds like a really interesting, worthwhile career.

I won't go into what I do specifically but I've worked across Policy from development to delivery with a stint in Private Office in the more competitive Whitehall departments (think CO, HMT, DBT, FCDO). I've worked with Ministers and high-ranking officials. The work I do, has a real impact and is highly rewarding. I'm not paid as much as I would be in the Financial Sector, Consulting or Law (especially Law!!) but I have carved out a good work-life balance that has given me more than money can buy.

I'm not saying that those in Ops working out of HO, DWP or HMRC don't have an impact, they do, just not one I'd care to have. Nor deal with. I hate dealing with the general public. I've also heard those departments have terrible cultures. Not that I'm surprised, I had to visit Caxton House and I felt the life drain out of me.

AlvieSt · 19/07/2023 12:12

Katypp · 19/07/2023 10:42

How many pps who work in the public sector have worked anywhere else? I think a lot have no idea of the reality of working in the private sector. I will give an example. When I went for my covid jab (at a centre dedicated to this), in the 15m walk from my car to the nurse, I encountered the following (and they were all NHS staff as they wore uniform and name badges): 1 person standing under a sign saying Covid Jabs This Way telling me that covid jabs were this way, two people just inside the door, 1 who asked my name and another who found my record card from a very small pile (jabs were pre-booked), another telling me to join the queue, another at the bend if the queue telling me which way to go and another two at the door to the room, one asking my name and another pointing which nurse to go to.
Seven people. in the private sector, this would have been handled by one person asking your name and giving your records and another one taking your records and allocating the jab booth. So five less.
That's why I tend to take tales of woe about short staffing in the public sector with a pinch of salt. Because in the public sector the volume of jobs would not exist in the first place.
OP I think you've fallen for the hype I am afraid.

Or maybe this is a tiny observation of over staffing under COVID protections.

My team has been cut from 120 to 15. Same expectations of the LA role, slightly less clients. We are expected to do more to maintain the same service and standards.

FKATondelayo · 19/07/2023 12:12

Haven't read all of this however I think you have to bear in mind that different sectors suit different personalities. I have worked in the private sector all my life apart from past 3 years where I've worked with the public sector (non-profit and local authority stakeholders) on a partnership project. I would rather put hot needles in my eyes than ever do it again, I don't give a shit about the pension benefits. Working in the private sector has so much more challenge, satisfaction and so many more opportunities. The glacial pace and lack of accountability in local authorities are not for me.

Caledoniadreaming · 19/07/2023 12:10

Ariela · 19/07/2023 11:57

I'm trying to encourage DD into civil service for the flexible hours and extra days holiday (which will suit her passion for horses, she'd be able to ride before work or after work really easily and have time off for competing) and for the pension - DH is thinking of retiring and is looking into it at the moment and we are amazed how much pension he will get.

Also, if she were to volunteer with a horse charity could get paid volunteer leave as well. I'm aware this type of leave is available in the private sector, but in my Whitehall department we are actively encouraged to use these types of benefits. All helps for a more contented workforce (excepting pay).

AvanGelist · 19/07/2023 12:01

Also realised I didn't answer the question 🤣
YABU OP.
You need to look at specific roles...

Ariela · 19/07/2023 11:57

I'm trying to encourage DD into civil service for the flexible hours and extra days holiday (which will suit her passion for horses, she'd be able to ride before work or after work really easily and have time off for competing) and for the pension - DH is thinking of retiring and is looking into it at the moment and we are amazed how much pension he will get.

AvanGelist · 19/07/2023 11:57

Carleslireis · 19/07/2023 11:15

I think you’re oversimplifying the type of roles that are available in the public sector. There are so many interesting roles beyond the obvious (eg statistician, trade lawyer, economist, prosecutor, data scientist, marine biologist, park ranger, managing historic buildings, etc) and the public sector often has better remuneration for the hours worked.

FWIW I went to Oxbridge (fairly recent grad) and civil service has been one of the most popular options among my classmates after law and financial services. In fact there are some that went into CS law and financial services (Bank of England/Treasury/FCA) as well as the more standard fast stream.

IME private sector renumeration is much better for professions which are generally in demand. You mentioned data scientist - 60K is very achievable 5 years after graduating with no line management responsibilities and as a middling individual contributor. In the public sector this salary is for a 'senior' role. Same hours.

Public prosecutors are notoriously underpaid which is why they went on strike late last year.

Of course, I agree there are many opportunities, and it's not just the base salary - working at governing bodies that you mentioned gives you a nice fat pay bump when you move to the private sector...