Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to discourage DC from entering public sector careers?

163 replies

SpanadorFanador · 19/07/2023 06:58

DD17, DD14 and DS12 have all been talking a lot about jobs they’d like to do lately. They are all very different fish, 2 very academic girls and one creative but not so book smart DS. Their schools to introduce a broad range of careers, but their teachers (understandably) seem to know more about public sector roles such as teaching, legal aid law and health professions (there’s a special ‘get into medicine course DD was encouraged to do).

When I started out, there were good options for people looking to work in the public sector. I headed into a helping profession in a Local Authority (but struggled with the inflexibility and have since moved into private practice). Friends were looking forward to careers in medicine, teaching and the civil service. A couple were pretty snobby about the moral superiority of public sector roles ( I remember an physio friend asking a trainee actuary friend how they got up each morning with such a boring job). Others headed into law, banking, consultancy etc. We were all very well educated and had many options.

However, at 45, things have all come out in the wash, and (with a few exceptions, notably two doctors who are independently wealthy, and a diplomat), those who chose private sector jobs are not just much wealthier but also seem to enjoy more flexible, varied roles and just seem happier in their work. Friends in the public sector complain that they are burnt out, struggling financially and stuck in their jobs with few other options.

AIBU to at least encourage DC to consider that public sector careers might not be the best idea any more? Obviously, they’ll choose what they choose, but to me, the difference between private and public sector roles (especially in London/SE) nowadays seems pretty stark.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
sunrisechurch · 20/07/2023 19:10

MereDintofPandiculation · 20/07/2023 11:56

yeah, that would change your thinking.

But it's risky not to prepare for retirement on the grounds you may never get there.

Absolutely. Just needs to be a balance I guess.

A lot of people in the CS moan constantly and appear to hate it but say they’re staying for the pension, which makes no sense to me.

Alconleigh · 20/07/2023 18:45

Depends on their personalities and what motivates them. I work in the private sector but with public sector customers. Bluntly, the vast majority of people we deal with on the civil service side are not as bright, as hard working, as motivated or as productive as my colleagues. It's like wading through treacle at times. And useless people seem to get constantly moved sideways to cause more chaos elsewhere rather than either having focused performance improvement or being let go. There are a few great ones but they stand out due to rarity. Some of the lack of progress is systemic rather than individuals but it would drive me bonkers to have to work alongside those people day to day. It all just seems so sludgy. And that's before you even start on local government. The pensions though? Outstanding, for sure.

Doone21 · 20/07/2023 18:33

They have superb benefits tho and to some people the satisfaction of working hard to do good rather than making someone else a quick buck is attractive. I loved working in nhs and was gutted to be made redundant

MereDintofPandiculation · 20/07/2023 11:56

sunrisechurch · 20/07/2023 11:36

Sorry I know it’s morbid but my MIL died at 66 following forty years in the CS, she had a great pension but never got to enjoy it. This has really influenced my thinking recently.

yeah, that would change your thinking.

But it's risky not to prepare for retirement on the grounds you may never get there.

escapingthecity · 20/07/2023 11:52

Teachers definitely don't know enough about the full range of jobs available (at no point in my school careers advice was my sector ever mentioned at all, which is why I like doing careers talks).

sunrisechurch · 20/07/2023 11:50

Dulra · 20/07/2023 11:41

Thera are no guarantees in life but if I was to live well into my old age I would want to enjoy my life and not be stressing about money and paying for food and heat. We can drop dead tomorrow but we may not and we may be glad of a good standard of living long into our retirement, if we die at 66 we are dead anyway and none the wiser that we never got to enjoy our pension 🤔

Yes I think that’s a valid way of thinking as well! There’s no right approach to it really but I know that after my MIL’s death both DH and I have become much more focused on ensuring we are happy in our jobs/lives right now, whereas previously we were probably more inclined to stick things out for the future benefits.

Dulra · 20/07/2023 11:41

sunrisechurch · 20/07/2023 11:36

Sorry I know it’s morbid but my MIL died at 66 following forty years in the CS, she had a great pension but never got to enjoy it. This has really influenced my thinking recently.

Thera are no guarantees in life but if I was to live well into my old age I would want to enjoy my life and not be stressing about money and paying for food and heat. We can drop dead tomorrow but we may not and we may be glad of a good standard of living long into our retirement, if we die at 66 we are dead anyway and none the wiser that we never got to enjoy our pension 🤔

Turmerictolly · 20/07/2023 11:37

.

sunrisechurch · 20/07/2023 11:36

MereDintofPandiculation · 20/07/2023 11:35

Even with a “gold plated civil service pension” your income will drop by 50% when you retire - you will feel differently at 67.

Sorry I know it’s morbid but my MIL died at 66 following forty years in the CS, she had a great pension but never got to enjoy it. This has really influenced my thinking recently.

MereDintofPandiculation · 20/07/2023 11:35

Waterlooville · 19/07/2023 07:07

The pensions point is fair, but I need cash now, when I have a young family, what's the point in being comfortable at 67?

Even with a “gold plated civil service pension” your income will drop by 50% when you retire - you will feel differently at 67.

What3words · 20/07/2023 11:31

It was incredible really.

But there's such a variety of public sector jobs - the civil service (not near me!) Where people seem to earn a lot.

Or basic grade teachers/nurses/social workers

Or all the ton of local gov jobs that all seem to pay under 35k (line managers on just over 30, corodinators all sorts. Tons of responsibility with vulnerable people for just over 20...)

What3words · 20/07/2023 11:29

Lots of nhs staff volunteered too.

Katypp · 20/07/2023 09:58

ArcticSkewer · 19/07/2023 22:18

They really were most likely mainly volunteers, not on any wage at all.

I have been told many times they were volunteers but that was not the impression I got. The first lot of jabs the staff were clearly volunteers, but the second round the staff were in pale blue tunics and had NHS name badges on. I might be wrong

ArcticSkewer · 19/07/2023 22:18

Icanttellyouanything · 19/07/2023 20:02

Most of them were students on minimum wage, temporary contracts and not permanent staff.

They really were most likely mainly volunteers, not on any wage at all.

Wellawareofprivilege · 19/07/2023 22:12

Icanttellyouanything · 19/07/2023 20:02

Most of them were students on minimum wage, temporary contracts and not permanent staff.

This. I helped run a vaccine centre and it was entirely run on volunteers for the first few months (including us as the doctors doing it on our days off from our real jobs). Lots of people volunteered as they were out of work, desperate to do something to help.
The rest of the time we are piteously understaffed.

Mew2 · 19/07/2023 21:35

I disagree. They need to choose something that they love and are passionate about.... I am 35 work in public sector- for nhs as an ahp- on £50000 a year (a little more), work 40hrs a week and am generally not having to worry about anything- work can be stressful...
I have some friends who work for private sector who are more stressed.... choosing something they love helps when it gets stressy!!

BiddyPop · 19/07/2023 20:13

In answer to another poster's question, I worked in private sector jobs as well - during uni and also once I graduated. Thank F** I got the public sector job I did as there was no comparison in the opportunities available and mindset in them.

BiddyPop · 19/07/2023 20:06

I probably should add that while I have mostly worked in public service (but not all
My jobs were), my DH has done a couple of roles in public sector but vast majority was private sector. He took a pay cut of roughly 35% a few years ago to move from private sector side to public sector side of his work - it's meant different kinds of issues, a lot less worries about whether the board will just close down sections of the business and make everyone redundant (he had to tell people a good few times that their areas were being closed down and his entire remit was in danger). But while he always had public facing roles, he has far more engagement with the political system and decision making (you never want to see how the sausage is made!) in this role than before.

But he can be more compassionate to staff and manage personal difficulties with humanity - which is his preference rather than worrying about profit all the time.

Icanttellyouanything · 19/07/2023 20:02

Katypp · 19/07/2023 10:42

How many pps who work in the public sector have worked anywhere else? I think a lot have no idea of the reality of working in the private sector. I will give an example. When I went for my covid jab (at a centre dedicated to this), in the 15m walk from my car to the nurse, I encountered the following (and they were all NHS staff as they wore uniform and name badges): 1 person standing under a sign saying Covid Jabs This Way telling me that covid jabs were this way, two people just inside the door, 1 who asked my name and another who found my record card from a very small pile (jabs were pre-booked), another telling me to join the queue, another at the bend if the queue telling me which way to go and another two at the door to the room, one asking my name and another pointing which nurse to go to.
Seven people. in the private sector, this would have been handled by one person asking your name and giving your records and another one taking your records and allocating the jab booth. So five less.
That's why I tend to take tales of woe about short staffing in the public sector with a pinch of salt. Because in the public sector the volume of jobs would not exist in the first place.
OP I think you've fallen for the hype I am afraid.

Most of them were students on minimum wage, temporary contracts and not permanent staff.

Noodles1234 · 19/07/2023 19:38

Sorry less than the average wage - not minimum wage!

Noodles1234 · 19/07/2023 19:37

My DP is in the public sector.

yes pensions are good, sick pay is good (although they are loathed to allow you sick and you get grief for it). Your pay is on a scale, so doesn’t matter how hard you work you will be paid the same as some idle worker next to you unless you can bolt on extra job descriptions, so no bonus for being a good worker.

I say his pension is good, he doesn’t have a degree so pay is fairly poor and less than the minimum wage for a fairly important and stressful role (if you have a degree for a degree required job your pay is better, but probably not as good as private sector). However when you add the pension the overall package is good. Just when you take home a smaller amount every month sometimes the pension doesn’t seem as good as it actually is, especially as public sector pensions are changing and dwindling every year or so, so no guarantee
so overall package undeniably is good and helpful, but actual pay and working conditions (no air con, no fancy perks) is to be realised… a colleague said to him “you’ll never be rich”. He’s been there a couple of years and I still remember it. People join and then leave for better pay, the turn over in staff can be phenomenal and bulk of workers are near retirement and don’t have mortgages, younger lot cannot afford to work there so are often huge staff shortages.

I am in the Private Sector. It’s not all roses here either, payrises only occur if we have made enough money, basic pensions, minimal sickpay, but take home pay not bad if you work hard - and bonus if you’re a hard worker you have a better chance of being recognised.

Staff shortages here too, workers bargain for more money in interviews and sometimes this pays off.

overall, I would opt for public sector, if medical yes always! But they may find when it comes to mortgages unless they’re a Dr or high paid they may one day switch to private.

good luck though.

EmmaPaella · 19/07/2023 19:25

Surely it depends what they want to do? It’s a pretty varied set of jobs.

ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 19/07/2023 19:14

I worked in 3 private sector jobs. Bullying, wage confidentiality, brown nosing and presenteeism was horrible.

26 years in public. Unions, wage scales, policies, transparencies ( some) better holidays, better conditions. I would never work to fill someone else’s pocket again.

Ladysassy · 19/07/2023 19:10

I have worked in the public sector all of my working like apart from once, which was the biggest mistake ever.
Worked for a private company there was bullying, monthly meetings where they had a go at all the staff, the boss used to get drunk and send abusive text messages and the staff where horrible to each other.
There was no one to complain to as it was bullying from the top down.
Least in the public sector there are policy’s in place and always someone higher to complain to.

Wobblybobble · 19/07/2023 18:38

Public service doesn’t have to mean a British government employee. DH is what they call an ‘international civil servant’ with an INGO and it’s great. He has a really good work-life balance, the job pays well, we receive excellent private healthcare, and the pension is great. Have a look at UN or NATO type graduate roles. UNjobs.org is the place to browse what’s available if they are interested. It’s best to avoid consultant roles and go for actual staff roles as the staff are definitely looked after (whereas consultants get the short end of the stick), but graduate roles are a great way to get experience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread