Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking neighbours for money?

144 replies

DunePeyton · 19/07/2023 00:22

So my elderly neighbours have a big corner plot garden which is ridiculously overgrown. Enormous sycamores, including one which has a forked trunk which fans out and blocks a fair bit of our daily sun, and a eucalyptus tree which sheds its bark all over our lawn (but that’s not my main issue). Hundred of shrubs, vegetables,
nettles etc.

My main issue is I feel continuously invaded by all of their out-of-control greenery that grows over (or through) our border line, leaving me no choice but to constantly cut it all back and fill up our green bin with it. I don’t even like the thankless task of gardening!

I have a fairly large back lawn and a bit of grass at the front and a full cut fills up my entire green bin and I haven’t got space for their crap also! I have jokingly suggested to themthat maybe a gardener might be a good idea, but they are adamant they will do it themselves-
onky problem is they aren’t doing it!

AIBU to ask neighbours for a contribution towards our green bin subscription as I strive to keep a low maintenance garden and so much of the garden waste that fills our green bin is from our neighbour’s garden which doesn’t seem fair. I get invaded on the other side too, but it’s not quite so bad as they have a gardener once a week. Am I right to be pissed off? I spent about an hour today getting pricked while cutting back their rose bushes which are always creeping over our walls.

OP posts:
Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 14:25

Floatlikeafeather · 19/07/2023 14:14

Decadactyl, I do hope in real life you think a bit more deeply about things than your sweeping statements on this thread make it seem. You are basing your whole argument on the fact that your grandparents were never in a position to buy a house but everyone else of their age group who did manage it is now rolling in it! How many of these wealthy 90 year olds do you actually know? If you know any at all, are you privy to their financial situation? My parents had never been able to afford to buy a house. My grandmother died and my father inherited her house. They became home owners but it didn't alter how much money they had coming into their household. Owning a house doesn't affect your income.

It would be rare IME to find elderly people whose parents were homeowners, who did not manage to afford a home themselves.

Regardless of whether this is true or not, it IS true that the majority of those over 75 are frugal. A gardener would be deemed "too expensive" whether they were well off or not. A colleague of mines dad (who is 91) is, in her words "rolling in money" but he sat in the dark cos of the electricity bill going up.

My thoughts on this are such that, if your garden is becoming a nuisance to others, you have an obligation to tame it. If the house you've inherited is too big for you to maintain, you should downsize.

Floatlikeafeather · 19/07/2023 14:14

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 12:29

My point is that my grandparents (if they were alive now) would be early 90s. They never managed to get money together to buy their own council house, so they rented for 60 odd years.

People of their age who DID manage to buy homes have (on the whole) no excuse for being poorly off now.

I think you are confusing an ingrained frugality and reluctance to spend money with actually not being able to afford things.

Decadactyl, I do hope in real life you think a bit more deeply about things than your sweeping statements on this thread make it seem. You are basing your whole argument on the fact that your grandparents were never in a position to buy a house but everyone else of their age group who did manage it is now rolling in it! How many of these wealthy 90 year olds do you actually know? If you know any at all, are you privy to their financial situation? My parents had never been able to afford to buy a house. My grandmother died and my father inherited her house. They became home owners but it didn't alter how much money they had coming into their household. Owning a house doesn't affect your income.

DunePeyton · 19/07/2023 14:01

Just a little bit more info - they take pride in their garden even though it’s an Amazonian wonder. They told me they had a gardener once before but they kept pulling out stuff they didn’t want removed and so they stopped it and have said they don’t trust them. I felt that surely this was a communication issue and even if not, perhaps try a different gardener before writing them all off.

They live in a big detached home and they don’t seem poor (Land Rover etc) so I don’t think it would be a financial impossibility. They have kids in their 40s but never see them, less helping out in the garden. I think it is as someone has said, not being able to own up that they are unable to do it the same.

They haven’t got a green bin and I think they burn sometimes, but I think it’s unfair to pay £100 a year on a bin which I fill with their waste.

We have 5y ds so don’t want thorny roses coming over to prick him. I try and spray, pull off all the Ivy coming through but it’s destroying the fences. Some people seem to have no idea what damage plants can do.

I don’t enjoy gardening, but I’m not against anyone having a lovely wild garden, but at what point do you have to tame it a bit. I’ve got rid of lots of the huge undulating borders that were there when we moved in, and replaced with turf as we have young children and I was spending hours on end maintaining the garden. I’m not an artificial grass kind of person, but I am a boring low maintenance garden type-of-person.

thanks for replies everyone.

OP posts:
MatildaTheCat · 19/07/2023 13:55

Speak with them again. ‘Since we last spoke I noticed you haven’t been able to make much progress with your garden and unfortunately this is really affecting me. How can we resolve this? Perhaps you could getting a gardener in a few times a year to help with the heavy pruning?’

It may take several conversions but nobody wants a garden to become a jungle, it will cost far more to sort out than some regular basic maintenance. It might also be worth mentioning rats.

DatumTarum · 19/07/2023 13:43

Don't pick this fight.

Get a weed proof fence and a compost bin.

ProfessorSlocombe · 19/07/2023 13:43

DunePeyton · 19/07/2023 13:39

I didn’t think that was the case and I’ve heard mixed views on this…

By "mixed" views, you really mean right or wrong.

Especially with neighbours, you really want the right view.

Hence this may be better dealt with in the legal forum.

DunePeyton · 19/07/2023 13:39

That’s was regarding throwing cuttings over

OP posts:
DunePeyton · 19/07/2023 13:39

I didn’t think that was the case and I’ve heard mixed views on this…

OP posts:
ProfessorSlocombe · 19/07/2023 13:26

OP may want this thread moved to legal to get some gown ups to look at it.

8misskitty8 · 19/07/2023 13:18

Put it in their garden bin.

snufkinhat · 19/07/2023 13:14

TheSeaDoesntKnowMyName · 19/07/2023 08:19

Op is paying for a green bin for her green waste not her neighbours waste.

I would push it back over into their garden

Do you have a decent fence?

If she'd have the bin anyway and isn't overfilling it or needing an extra bin due to these branches, then I don't see why she'd ask for money. This isn't costing extra money above what she would be paying anyway.

Dealing with the actual issue of the plants coming over onto her property is separate. But asking for money towards a bin which she'd be paying for anyway just doesn't make sense.

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 12:29

MonumentalLentil · 19/07/2023 08:48

Wouldn't it be great if all older people had mortgage free homes and no money worries...

Some of us don't live in the same world as you, unfortunately. My neighbour has her own house. She is a widow and has her pension. She cancelled her green bin subscription because she wanted to be able to eat. We help with the things she needs doing and can't afford. repairs that are within our scope. She has looked at moving and wants to stay in the home she has had for the last 50 or so years. She is over 70, quite a bit over. Whatever pension her husband had has gone with him it seems.

Another one, elderly couple, sitting in the dark with blankets to keep warm last winter like many other folk. One is very elderly and will never move home, wouldn't be able to cope with it and wants to stay in their home, other one will move when single but stays as is carer for the one that wants to stay. Their garden isn't huge and is overgrown but not a wilderness. I am going round to tidy it up. They don't have pots of money either. They survive, they budget, they can't afford a gardener.

It doesn't matter if you believe it or not. It is actually happening in the real world which is where I live.

My point is that my grandparents (if they were alive now) would be early 90s. They never managed to get money together to buy their own council house, so they rented for 60 odd years.

People of their age who DID manage to buy homes have (on the whole) no excuse for being poorly off now.

I think you are confusing an ingrained frugality and reluctance to spend money with actually not being able to afford things.

Pringleface · 19/07/2023 11:13

caringcarer · 19/07/2023 08:54

Yes just throw it back over their side.

Sigh.

No, don’t throw it over their side unless they have actually asked you to do that. You are supposed to OFFER the cuttings back or dispose of them yourself, not launch them over the fence.

Bearpawk · 19/07/2023 09:47

Do they have a green bin? I'd just say something like 'I'm happy to prune your growth that comes into my garden but unfortunately I can't afford to pay for extra disposal as I already have my own garden waste to dispose of.
I'll need to put it in your green bin for disposal each time'.

LaylaLjungberg · 19/07/2023 08:59

Murdoch1949 · 19/07/2023 06:27

I am just glad I don't have a neighbour like you, concerning yourself with your own needs and discounting those of your elderly neighbours. They have probably lived in their house for years, have gradually been overwhelmed with the garden, cannot afford help and have a moany neighbour badgering them. A kinder person would help them. Not you. You want to charge them for putting the cuttings YOU have removed in your bin. Nice.

This 👆🏻

olympicsrock · 19/07/2023 08:56

Talk to them first- ask if you could put them in their green bin. If no room, could they pay for you to have a second green bin.

JudgeRudy · 19/07/2023 08:55

I'd bounce it back to them. It's their problem and they're making it yours. Ask them where they'd like you to put their cuttings, so throw them over the fence or do they have another suggestion.
I don't know if anyone here can advise but surely allowing your garden to 'invade' someone else's is anti social behaviour. I don't mean a one off, this sounds like it's been going on for a while. They might be older and struggle to manage it, just as I'd struggle to plaster my walls....so l pay for a professional to do it.

caringcarer · 19/07/2023 08:54

TheModHatter · 19/07/2023 00:31

You are allowed to cut anything that overhangs or encroaches onto your property and put it back on their land.

Yes just throw it back over their side.

Prelapsarianhag · 19/07/2023 08:53

Let your neighbours enjoy their lovely wild life garden with their beautiful trees giving shade and helping to cool everything down. Have you seen the news recently? In a year or two you will be very glad of their trees.

SpinCycles · 19/07/2023 08:48

I wish ours was £32 for the year. It's more than double that where I live.

Same here! I was shocked reading that.

MonumentalLentil · 19/07/2023 08:48

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 08:02

I don't believe that for one second.

Wouldn't it be great if all older people had mortgage free homes and no money worries...

Some of us don't live in the same world as you, unfortunately. My neighbour has her own house. She is a widow and has her pension. She cancelled her green bin subscription because she wanted to be able to eat. We help with the things she needs doing and can't afford. repairs that are within our scope. She has looked at moving and wants to stay in the home she has had for the last 50 or so years. She is over 70, quite a bit over. Whatever pension her husband had has gone with him it seems.

Another one, elderly couple, sitting in the dark with blankets to keep warm last winter like many other folk. One is very elderly and will never move home, wouldn't be able to cope with it and wants to stay in their home, other one will move when single but stays as is carer for the one that wants to stay. Their garden isn't huge and is overgrown but not a wilderness. I am going round to tidy it up. They don't have pots of money either. They survive, they budget, they can't afford a gardener.

It doesn't matter if you believe it or not. It is actually happening in the real world which is where I live.

Lindy2 · 19/07/2023 08:48

No I wouldn't ask.

It's perfectly normal regularly to have to cut back hedges, trees etc on borders.

Roses rambling over walls sounds quite nice actually. Just let them grow and benefit from the flowers that bloom on your side.

It sounds like you don't actually like plants in gardens very much. Are you an artificial lawn type of person? One of my neighbours has gravel, artificial grass and even plastic plants in pots in their garden. Nothing actually living at all. Personally I prefer lots and lots of real plants. It must be a great nature garden.

endofthelinefinally · 19/07/2023 08:44

I would get a compost bin for the grass cuttings as a first step. It is a waste to put them in the green bin. That frees up your green bin for any other waste.

FoodFann · 19/07/2023 08:43

Ask the council for advice:

If neighbour's garden are causing problems on your property, it can amount to a nuisance which you can report to the Environmental Health Department of your local council who can pursue legal action

johnd2 · 19/07/2023 08:40

If you chat with them you might get more of an idea of their feelings about it. We used to have an overgrown area full of brambles that backed onto a similar area next door. When we cleared our side it kept getting invaded, but next door hadn't got the energy to do anything, so I sounded them out and then kept spraying it with weed killer which knocked back all the plants coming through the fence.
Obviously don't do that if you think they wouldn't like it, but my point is to try to work together to find a solution that works for both sides.