Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Asking neighbours for money?

144 replies

DunePeyton · 19/07/2023 00:22

So my elderly neighbours have a big corner plot garden which is ridiculously overgrown. Enormous sycamores, including one which has a forked trunk which fans out and blocks a fair bit of our daily sun, and a eucalyptus tree which sheds its bark all over our lawn (but that’s not my main issue). Hundred of shrubs, vegetables,
nettles etc.

My main issue is I feel continuously invaded by all of their out-of-control greenery that grows over (or through) our border line, leaving me no choice but to constantly cut it all back and fill up our green bin with it. I don’t even like the thankless task of gardening!

I have a fairly large back lawn and a bit of grass at the front and a full cut fills up my entire green bin and I haven’t got space for their crap also! I have jokingly suggested to themthat maybe a gardener might be a good idea, but they are adamant they will do it themselves-
onky problem is they aren’t doing it!

AIBU to ask neighbours for a contribution towards our green bin subscription as I strive to keep a low maintenance garden and so much of the garden waste that fills our green bin is from our neighbour’s garden which doesn’t seem fair. I get invaded on the other side too, but it’s not quite so bad as they have a gardener once a week. Am I right to be pissed off? I spent about an hour today getting pricked while cutting back their rose bushes which are always creeping over our walls.

OP posts:
Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 21:13

Samlewis96 · 19/07/2023 21:05

What a load of bloody rubbish. House could've been bought in the 1960/70 s when ordinary people could buy on a single income. Doesn't mean that the people who have lived there for years have money. They might be on state pension / pension credit which isn't a huge smount

Yeah you don't have to agree with me. But if you were able to afford a house in the 70s, God only knows how you're on pension credit now.

Samlewis96 · 19/07/2023 21:05

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 07:29

We will have to agree to disagree on that. In my opinion, if you are 70 or over and own your own home, you will have money spare.

I don't think its possible to have paid off a mortgage in your working life/inherited a home at some point and now not even have enough money for a gardener.

Those people grew up in a time when jobs were plentiful and Pensions were decent. If they were ever in a position to buy a house, they will have a decent company pension on top of state pension.

What a load of bloody rubbish. House could've been bought in the 1960/70 s when ordinary people could buy on a single income. Doesn't mean that the people who have lived there for years have money. They might be on state pension / pension credit which isn't a huge smount

Hufflemuff · 19/07/2023 20:52

I'd probably be a bit over zealous with my pruning! Maybe then they will get the message and cut themselves.

doingthehokeykokey · 19/07/2023 20:42

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 19:20

@doingthehokeykokey you can think what you like. I stand by what I've said. If a boomer is not set up by now they must've been burning money.

Clearly never heard the rather nasty phrase, the thick, the sick, and the unfortunate.
Sweeping generalisations don’t read any better either.

stand by you opinion if you like, but it’s an opinion, not a fact.

Mutinyonthecrunchie · 19/07/2023 20:30

Sorry OP but daca had to be called out.

thesnailandthewhale · 19/07/2023 20:29

Similar situation here .. my garden is fairly low maintenance. My neighbours on one side rent and the landlord sends a gardener round once or twice a year who cuts the grass and trims a few bushes. In the meantime I have huge brambles coming over my fence that I have to cut back or they would take over my seating area completely. Why should I have to take their rubbish to the tip? (Neither of us have a green bin). If they let general rubbish come into my garden I would return it to theirs, how is it unreasonable to do the same with their brambles?

Mutinyonthecrunchie · 19/07/2023 20:28

Dach you are insulting and judgy, why suddenly so sympathetic to someone's life who is also a 'boomer' horrible expression.btw. Jog along with your faux concern nonsense.
I'm an older person but I don't draw my pension yet and it will only be a state one anyway. I own my home but have never had pots of money for various reasons.
Many oaps are in the same situation.

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 20:03

Yes fair enough, I actually forgot this was originally a thread about an overgrown garden!

heldinadream · 19/07/2023 19:41

Thank you @Dacadactyl that's kind of you.
It took a long time and involved some dodgy relationships- not surprisingly I'm a bit rubbish at relationships - but yes, I'm in a house now that I own with my DH. Obviously I could say a lot more but I don't want to hijack a thread that's about something else! I just had to respond to the blanket judgement on boomers.

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 19:36

heldinadream · 19/07/2023 19:32

I'm a boomer. My mother walked out when I was a child and my father threw me out when I was fifteen. I was homeless at a time when there were no services for homeless kids. I was homeless more than once. I'm pretty damaged actually.
Despite that I'm still here and I finally have some stability in my life. I'm not rich, or well off, and I never will be. I've survived.
I burnt no money en route. HTH.

Sorry to hear of your struggles?

Did you manage to own your own home at any time?

heldinadream · 19/07/2023 19:32

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 19:20

@doingthehokeykokey you can think what you like. I stand by what I've said. If a boomer is not set up by now they must've been burning money.

I'm a boomer. My mother walked out when I was a child and my father threw me out when I was fifteen. I was homeless at a time when there were no services for homeless kids. I was homeless more than once. I'm pretty damaged actually.
Despite that I'm still here and I finally have some stability in my life. I'm not rich, or well off, and I never will be. I've survived.
I burnt no money en route. HTH.

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 19:20

@doingthehokeykokey you can think what you like. I stand by what I've said. If a boomer is not set up by now they must've been burning money.

doingthehokeykokey · 19/07/2023 18:54

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 18:08

I have no issues with boomers but fail to understand what they did with their money if theyre not sitting on a pile of cash by now. Barring ill health I'm their youth they have no excuse to be pleading poverty.

I think your understanding is exactly what’s failing here

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 18:08

I have no issues with boomers but fail to understand what they did with their money if theyre not sitting on a pile of cash by now. Barring ill health I'm their youth they have no excuse to be pleading poverty.

TheBerry · 19/07/2023 17:53

HeddaGarbled · 19/07/2023 00:55

Ah, let the roses grow! Roses tumbling over the wall - how absolutely lovely 🥀

Agree, roses over the walls sounds lovely!

Spirallingdownwards · 19/07/2023 17:41

TheModHatter · 19/07/2023 00:31

You are allowed to cut anything that overhangs or encroaches onto your property and put it back on their land.

This is not quite correct. You have to offer it back to them but if they don't want it you have to dispose of it.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 19/07/2023 17:37

If they don't use their garden just chuck the waste back over the fence

booksandbrooks · 19/07/2023 17:22

My neighbours overhanging and over grown, in maintained plants are a never ending source of jobs I didn't need but personally I wouldn't dream of asking them for money. I cut down what overhangs and weed when I can. I've always assumed it's all part and parcel of having a garden.

I would ask them if you can use their green bin sometimes though.

Leftbutcameback · 19/07/2023 17:02

DunePeyton · 19/07/2023 14:01

Just a little bit more info - they take pride in their garden even though it’s an Amazonian wonder. They told me they had a gardener once before but they kept pulling out stuff they didn’t want removed and so they stopped it and have said they don’t trust them. I felt that surely this was a communication issue and even if not, perhaps try a different gardener before writing them all off.

They live in a big detached home and they don’t seem poor (Land Rover etc) so I don’t think it would be a financial impossibility. They have kids in their 40s but never see them, less helping out in the garden. I think it is as someone has said, not being able to own up that they are unable to do it the same.

They haven’t got a green bin and I think they burn sometimes, but I think it’s unfair to pay £100 a year on a bin which I fill with their waste.

We have 5y ds so don’t want thorny roses coming over to prick him. I try and spray, pull off all the Ivy coming through but it’s destroying the fences. Some people seem to have no idea what damage plants can do.

I don’t enjoy gardening, but I’m not against anyone having a lovely wild garden, but at what point do you have to tame it a bit. I’ve got rid of lots of the huge undulating borders that were there when we moved in, and replaced with turf as we have young children and I was spending hours on end maintaining the garden. I’m not an artificial grass kind of person, but I am a boring low maintenance garden type-of-person.

thanks for replies everyone.

Thanks for the additional detail. In that case I think you need to have an honest chat with them about what’s coming over your side, and the time and money it’s costing you to deal with it. Ask if you can just pop everything back over the boundary for them to deal with (however they choose to do so). As an alternative suggest they keep everything a bit tidier at the boundary. They can keep their garden wild still, but need to realise it’s impacting on you. Good luck.

doingthehokeykokey · 19/07/2023 16:25

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 08:02

I don't believe that for one second.

Well as the AVERAGE U.K. pension pot is valued at £30k (total, not per year), you can believe what you like, but thems the facts!

Ihateslugs · 19/07/2023 16:14

It’s a difficult situation and I understand where you are coming from, trailing plants/weeds can cause massive damage to fences. I have a similar problem with the house that backs onto mine. It is a rental property and the garden is poorly maintained so I have ivy, laurel, holly and other invasive bushes breaking down the fence as they grow. All the neighbours do is cut down their side about once a year with a hedge trimmer but this does not reduce the stuff on my side as the hedge is now too deep for them to reach!

I have spoken to them about a couple of huge leylandii trees and eventually the landlord did get those cut back but the ivy growing around the trunks still encroaches my garden. I just have to accept that I will have to keep hacking back the growth to stop the fence from falling down. When I was physically able to do the work myself, I used to keep on top of it by cutting back where I could reach and also cutting through lower stems to kill off the top growth - much easier to remove when dead!

Now I have to use a Gardner to look after my own garden and he doesn’t really have time to do much clearance on a regular visit so I’m going to have to pay him for an extra visit when I can’t stand looking at the mess any longer!

Luckily we are not charged extra for our green bins which get collected each week as our food waste also goes in them. I bought an extra green bin to put the extra trimmings in which I use about four or five times a year. There are ongoing discussions from our local council about charging extra for green bins so I guess I’ll end up paying for two bins if that happens. I can afford that but it grates a little as it’s not rubbish from my garden.

But I don’t want to fall out with the neighbours, I’m just not that kind of person! If the tenants change though, I’ll certainly be having a chat with the landlord and the new tenants about their gardening plans.

I’m sorry not to have any specific advise to you other than try to kill the bushes that are close to your fence, either by hacking through the stems to let the top branches die off or by applying weed killer. I’ve used a gel type that you dap on with a small brush to successfully kill ivy and other persistent shrubs, you might be able to get the brush though gaps in the fence to get the gel on the lower leaves?

MamskiBell · 19/07/2023 16:03

ScotInExile · 19/07/2023 00:43

Why can't you use their green bin for their trimmings? If they are not doing any gardening then their green bin should be empty.

You generally have to pay for the garden bin...we have to....I don't like, I use my parent's as we have such a low maintenance garden (no grass, just pots and gravel) no not economical for us to pay for it. Our previous council didn't charge but current one does.

Floatlikeafeather · 19/07/2023 15:47

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 14:25

It would be rare IME to find elderly people whose parents were homeowners, who did not manage to afford a home themselves.

Regardless of whether this is true or not, it IS true that the majority of those over 75 are frugal. A gardener would be deemed "too expensive" whether they were well off or not. A colleague of mines dad (who is 91) is, in her words "rolling in money" but he sat in the dark cos of the electricity bill going up.

My thoughts on this are such that, if your garden is becoming a nuisance to others, you have an obligation to tame it. If the house you've inherited is too big for you to maintain, you should downsize.

No. To use your emphatic capitals, it is NOT true that most over 75s are frugal, assuming you mean "pennypinching with no need to be". 75 is not the age your grandparents would have been by now and there is a whole generational difference there. I'm not that old yet, but my husband is exactly that age. However, our parents would be in their 90s now, so not our generation and not the same problems (or causes of those problems). I think you're jumping on the Boomer Misconception bandwagon. We struggled through the absolutely appalling 90s, to pay our mortgage to buy our house. Interest rates were very high and it was a frightening time. Our children are now facing a possibly similar situation. Every generation has its struggles. Please open your mind and stop spouting such generalisations. I agree though that OPs neighbours should be more aware of how their garden is affecting their neighbour. I'm not sure what the solution is but saying that they must definitely have surplus money in their budget to deal with it is not helpful when it probably not the case anyway.

lpbarton · 19/07/2023 14:57

Honestly - yes you ABU - despite most people thinking if you have no mortgage you must be cash rich they could well not have very much disposable income at all and cannot afford it. Will you be offering to soundproof their house if your garden noise is too loud for them? OF course you wouldnt. If you dont like - MOVE! Otherwise do the kind, responsible, nonbitchy and nonselfish thing and trim it back like pretty much every other home owner does and hope when you're elderly theres no cost of living crisis that bites in to your pension!

MonumentalLentil · 19/07/2023 14:46

Dacadactyl · 19/07/2023 12:29

My point is that my grandparents (if they were alive now) would be early 90s. They never managed to get money together to buy their own council house, so they rented for 60 odd years.

People of their age who DID manage to buy homes have (on the whole) no excuse for being poorly off now.

I think you are confusing an ingrained frugality and reluctance to spend money with actually not being able to afford things.

I am not confusing it at all. These people have lived long enough to own the houses. Prices have increased for everything, their income has not increased at the same rate. If one dies they lose one pension. More outgoings, less incomings. They use their savings if they have any left, for necessary repairs and would rather have a roof that doesn't leak than a gardener.

Not everyone of that age would have had a private pension and many only have a State Pension which is really not enough to live on in most cases. It depends on what work they did and whether they were able to save or whether their employer made provision.

Swipe left for the next trending thread