Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a worrying trend to cancel folk for opinions and thoughts

208 replies

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 18/07/2023 23:26

I'm not saying I agree with the opinions of Roald Dahl (I dont) but I understand if people want to cancel folk for their actions - don't like cancel culture but that seems reasonable somewhat to react to someone's actions

But why the fuck are we extending cancel culture to the thoughts that someone expressed? He hardly evangelised his anti semitic beliefs- he simply held them... but chose to write fiction books... the impact he left on the world was some good stories for most people

Just read they were putting a sign up to apologise for his beliefs in the Roald Dahl museum - he's dead now, how can you apologise post death for someone else's thoughts?!

OP posts:
OCaptain · 19/07/2023 07:53

@FOJN

It's frightening how many people love the feeling of power they get from a good public shunning.

I'm interested in how you know other people's feelings, particularly on this subject?

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 07:48

dimorphism · 19/07/2023 06:59

We know this. People know that views of what is acceptable have changed over time. We don’t need to be told this. The whole approach is infantilising and morally illiterate. So it does do harm.

Yes and it has a chilling effect when everyone is terrified to ever express their view. It creates an atmosphere where people will not speak out about injustice and terrible things can happen.

What is ironic is that the attitude displayed by people 'cancelling' for wrongthink is actually reminiscent of those they claim to be against. Cancelling the bank accounts of people you disagree with because of their religion and expression of religious views is the sort of thing the Nazi's might have done to the Jews had it been in a time when having a bank account was as essential as it now it. You can't really function in society without a bank account these days. The Nazi's did do things to harm the Jews economically (IIRC they forced all Jews into the highest tax bracket regardless of income and a number of other things to control and strip them of equal rights with others... they didn't start off with a 'we don't think these people deserve to live and want to kill them' it was with things very much like this)

What happens if the person whose bank account is cancelled doesn't have another account to transfer his money to? Does he have to take massive amounts of cash? Then what does he do if he needs to buy something in a shop that only accepts cards? It's very totalitarian and will put people in the position of not being able to participate fully in society. Given the banks in question are partly owned by the UK government, having been bailed out, I really hope the government will step in. The banks are really undermining our democracy if they are allowed to do this.

Who has had their bank account closed due to their religious views?

My best is on Farage is being disingenuous here. Banks like you if you have money in your account; otherwise, the account is closed. (To simply things.) There's no need to start 'It's all totalitarian' when the case may be he simply didn't follow guidelines.

AlisonDonut · 19/07/2023 07:40

IClaudine · 19/07/2023 07:09

Yes, the Communist Party is strongly predicted to win the next election. Isn't it?

Do totalitarians tell people they are totalitarians before they get into power?

determinedtomakethiswork · 19/07/2023 07:31

When I think back to homophobia in the 70s and 80s, everyone who is living, just trying to change the way people behaved, so they wanted gay marriage, they wanted no discrimination at work and representation on TV etc.

What we have now is a situation where our thoughts are controlled. It's not enough for us not to say that men can't be women etc we are not allowed to think of it.

It really is the Emperor's New Clothes. I think we should all be buying that book for our children and grandchildren to read.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 07:24

dimorphism · 19/07/2023 07:11

True, and as previously discussed the Dahl example isn't the best one and OP has agreed with this. However, it is part of the same slippery slope of intolerance of other people's opinion and lack of nuance. It's possible to discuss Dahl's views in the museum so people can make up their own minds without apologising for his views.

Probably not the case for Dahl, but in Nazi Germany there would have been many people who came out with anti-semitic views not because they actually thought that but because they were scared of being branded as committing wrongthink or were simply going along with the ruling groupthink. Some people in the resistance may have even expressed anti-Semitic views in order to divert suspicion.

I’m happy to be intolerant of anti semitism. What I object to is this ridiculous pantomime of scourging of the past to demonstrate how holy and good we are, and fake apologies for things that were nothing to do with us.

FOJN · 19/07/2023 07:15

This could be the family, the descendants of Dahl, wanting to ensure people know that their ancestors' views don't align with their own and to express some form of sincere regret and embarrassment about the distasteful views he may have expressed, especially if they were antisemitic.

I think you are probably correct in your assessment of their motives but I think the more important question is why are they worried that people may think they agree with Dahl's views unless they explicitly say they don't.

Denunciations are coerced out of people to avoid accusations of guilt by association, it's sinister. I feel like I'm watching our entire society getting swept up in a kind of cult that assumes the worst of everyone. No one is allowed to make a genuine mistake, there is no forgiveness, just condemnation and a desire, by spiteful authoritarians, to punish people by destroying their lives.

It's frightening how many people love the feeling of power they get from a good public shunning. I do believe most people are basically decent and used to wonder how authoritarian, genocidal regimes came to power but I don't anymore.

dimorphism · 19/07/2023 07:11

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 07:02

I think we’re confusing different things here. Depriving someone of banking facilities is a great deal worse than sticking an asinine plaque in a museum.

True, and as previously discussed the Dahl example isn't the best one and OP has agreed with this. However, it is part of the same slippery slope of intolerance of other people's opinion and lack of nuance. It's possible to discuss Dahl's views in the museum so people can make up their own minds without apologising for his views.

Probably not the case for Dahl, but in Nazi Germany there would have been many people who came out with anti-semitic views not because they actually thought that but because they were scared of being branded as committing wrongthink or were simply going along with the ruling groupthink. Some people in the resistance may have even expressed anti-Semitic views in order to divert suspicion.

IClaudine · 19/07/2023 07:09

LOSTAN · 19/07/2023 02:45

Welcome to COMMUNISM - because that's where we are heading folks.

Yes, the Communist Party is strongly predicted to win the next election. Isn't it?

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 07:02

dimorphism · 19/07/2023 06:59

We know this. People know that views of what is acceptable have changed over time. We don’t need to be told this. The whole approach is infantilising and morally illiterate. So it does do harm.

Yes and it has a chilling effect when everyone is terrified to ever express their view. It creates an atmosphere where people will not speak out about injustice and terrible things can happen.

What is ironic is that the attitude displayed by people 'cancelling' for wrongthink is actually reminiscent of those they claim to be against. Cancelling the bank accounts of people you disagree with because of their religion and expression of religious views is the sort of thing the Nazi's might have done to the Jews had it been in a time when having a bank account was as essential as it now it. You can't really function in society without a bank account these days. The Nazi's did do things to harm the Jews economically (IIRC they forced all Jews into the highest tax bracket regardless of income and a number of other things to control and strip them of equal rights with others... they didn't start off with a 'we don't think these people deserve to live and want to kill them' it was with things very much like this)

What happens if the person whose bank account is cancelled doesn't have another account to transfer his money to? Does he have to take massive amounts of cash? Then what does he do if he needs to buy something in a shop that only accepts cards? It's very totalitarian and will put people in the position of not being able to participate fully in society. Given the banks in question are partly owned by the UK government, having been bailed out, I really hope the government will step in. The banks are really undermining our democracy if they are allowed to do this.

I think we’re confusing different things here. Depriving someone of banking facilities is a great deal worse than sticking an asinine plaque in a museum.

dimorphism · 19/07/2023 06:59

We know this. People know that views of what is acceptable have changed over time. We don’t need to be told this. The whole approach is infantilising and morally illiterate. So it does do harm.

Yes and it has a chilling effect when everyone is terrified to ever express their view. It creates an atmosphere where people will not speak out about injustice and terrible things can happen.

What is ironic is that the attitude displayed by people 'cancelling' for wrongthink is actually reminiscent of those they claim to be against. Cancelling the bank accounts of people you disagree with because of their religion and expression of religious views is the sort of thing the Nazi's might have done to the Jews had it been in a time when having a bank account was as essential as it now it. You can't really function in society without a bank account these days. The Nazi's did do things to harm the Jews economically (IIRC they forced all Jews into the highest tax bracket regardless of income and a number of other things to control and strip them of equal rights with others... they didn't start off with a 'we don't think these people deserve to live and want to kill them' it was with things very much like this)

What happens if the person whose bank account is cancelled doesn't have another account to transfer his money to? Does he have to take massive amounts of cash? Then what does he do if he needs to buy something in a shop that only accepts cards? It's very totalitarian and will put people in the position of not being able to participate fully in society. Given the banks in question are partly owned by the UK government, having been bailed out, I really hope the government will step in. The banks are really undermining our democracy if they are allowed to do this.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 06:11

daisychain01 · 19/07/2023 05:27

My interpretation (Caveat: I haven't read the news article)

This could be the family, the descendants of Dahl, wanting to ensure people know that their ancestors' views don't align with their own and to express some form of sincere regret and embarrassment about the distasteful views he may have expressed, especially if they were antisemitic.

Opinions that are deemed acceptable in one era, that are now wholly unacceptable and distasteful may sit badly with generations to come. A sincere apology by the family is just that, any apology can be expressed and people can either accept it for what it's worth, ignore it or whatever. The apology will only be meaningful to those insulted by the views, for those not impacted, the apology isn't for them. I think it's a no harm done situation.

We know this. People know that views of what is acceptable have changed over time. We don’t need to be told this. The whole approach is infantilising and morally illiterate. So it does do harm.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 06:09

ohfook · 19/07/2023 05:44

As previous posters have mentioned it's not a good example because literally nobody is trying to cancel RD. In fact his books are still widely used in primary schools.

I think it's worth thinking though, whatever your religion or race, if there was an author who had argued that somebody who had committed a mass genocide against your race of religion 'had a point' and then your kids had to sit in school reading his lovely little books it might make you a tad uncomfortable. I certainly can't think of any authors who've spoken that way against white people being used in primary schools.

It seems more like his family who are still making money from his legacy I assume, acknowledging that he was a complex man.

If they feel that much distaste for him, I guess they could always refuse the money?
what’s the betting that won’t happen

WhatNoRaisins · 19/07/2023 06:01

I think all these apologies on behalf of people that you had no control over come across as really fake. Don't blame people who feel pressurised into making them but it does devalue apologies in general.

ohfook · 19/07/2023 05:44

As previous posters have mentioned it's not a good example because literally nobody is trying to cancel RD. In fact his books are still widely used in primary schools.

I think it's worth thinking though, whatever your religion or race, if there was an author who had argued that somebody who had committed a mass genocide against your race of religion 'had a point' and then your kids had to sit in school reading his lovely little books it might make you a tad uncomfortable. I certainly can't think of any authors who've spoken that way against white people being used in primary schools.

It seems more like his family who are still making money from his legacy I assume, acknowledging that he was a complex man.

daisychain01 · 19/07/2023 05:31

Hidingawaytoday · 19/07/2023 05:07

I've missed this story - what has the RD museum done/said? In any rate, assuming you mean the one in Bucks... it's been open over 20 years, so it's not newly opened!

I last went a couple of months ago and don't remember seeing anything about his antisemitic views while there (granted, I was with toddler dd). If you're in the area and enjoyed RD's books, it's really worth a visit.

The RD museum is indeed in Bucks, Great Missenden to be precise.

Ive been to the museum loads of times as I used to live within 2 miles of there, and I've never seen anything offensive or antisemitic, just exhibits of his children's stories.

daisychain01 · 19/07/2023 05:27

AgathaSpencerGregson · 18/07/2023 23:40

How is the apology meaningful if it comes from someone else? I’ve never understood this. “I am terribly sorry for something that someone who I had no responsibility for did.” It’s nonsense.

My interpretation (Caveat: I haven't read the news article)

This could be the family, the descendants of Dahl, wanting to ensure people know that their ancestors' views don't align with their own and to express some form of sincere regret and embarrassment about the distasteful views he may have expressed, especially if they were antisemitic.

Opinions that are deemed acceptable in one era, that are now wholly unacceptable and distasteful may sit badly with generations to come. A sincere apology by the family is just that, any apology can be expressed and people can either accept it for what it's worth, ignore it or whatever. The apology will only be meaningful to those insulted by the views, for those not impacted, the apology isn't for them. I think it's a no harm done situation.

Shoxfordian · 19/07/2023 05:16

Roald Dahl hasn’t been cancelled though op, they’re just acknowledging his views were antisemitic and unacceptable. I don’t agree that it’s only thoughts and they’re not harmful either: thoughts influence action.

I’m more surprised they’re making a Michael Jackson musical tbh

hattie43 · 19/07/2023 05:12

Cancel culture is eroding free speech . Not good .

Hidingawaytoday · 19/07/2023 05:07

I've missed this story - what has the RD museum done/said? In any rate, assuming you mean the one in Bucks... it's been open over 20 years, so it's not newly opened!

I last went a couple of months ago and don't remember seeing anything about his antisemitic views while there (granted, I was with toddler dd). If you're in the area and enjoyed RD's books, it's really worth a visit.

AffIt · 19/07/2023 04:57

I used to work at the high end of the wine trade and a lot of my clients banked with Coutts: a lot of them would have made Nigel Farage look like Jeremy Corbyn on a bad day.

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 04:25

@ConnieLinggusThe69th

I guess maybe if the museum has an exhibit around it then it makes sense they might want to say sorry for unexpectedly confronting you with anti semitism when you were expecting fantastic mr fox and Willy Wonker but I still question if they've been open long why its now necessary to start apologising for something he thought

I suppose if you're expecting fluffy bright things and you're confronted with the reality of an actual person behind the work, I can see that could be upsetting for some people. Others would understand that, yes, what he thought deeply influenced his work, and this should be acknowledged rather than never mentioned.

I'd say they've done this now as many phrases in Dahl books have very recently been revised by the publisher, so he's in the news.

GarlicGrace · 19/07/2023 03:29

Any authoritarian regime will do, @LOSTAN. For every Communist "cultural purge" there has been a Fascist "cleansing", both involving ruthless persecution of people suspected of having the wrong thoughts. Then you have all the religious and ethnic genocides, also predicated on wrong beliefs.

In every case, a populace has meandered into the ghastly situation by not wanting to rock the boat, trying to be fair to both sides, and/or thinking it'll just blow over ... Sad

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 03:08

'You cannot separate the writer from the person, just as you cannot separate the artist and the person'

I guess to a degree but like @SueVineer pointed out we don't know if he ever changed his mind. He just said some comments- don't we allow for the possibility people ever change opinion anymore, we need to shame them even post death not for any action they took, he was hardly inciting anything to happen simply for thinking it once whether he ever stuck to it or not and it wasn't his life's work to promote that thought? @OCaptain

I guess maybe if the museum has an exhibit around it then it makes sense they might want to say sorry for unexpectedly confronting you with anti semitism when you were expecting fantastic mr fox and Willy Wonker but I still question if they've been open long why its now necessary to start apologising for something he thought

OP posts:
LOSTAN · 19/07/2023 02:45

Welcome to COMMUNISM - because that's where we are heading folks.

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 19/07/2023 02:32

AgathaSpencerGregson · 18/07/2023 23:40

How is the apology meaningful if it comes from someone else? I’ve never understood this. “I am terribly sorry for something that someone who I had no responsibility for did.” It’s nonsense.

Exactly