Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a worrying trend to cancel folk for opinions and thoughts

208 replies

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 18/07/2023 23:26

I'm not saying I agree with the opinions of Roald Dahl (I dont) but I understand if people want to cancel folk for their actions - don't like cancel culture but that seems reasonable somewhat to react to someone's actions

But why the fuck are we extending cancel culture to the thoughts that someone expressed? He hardly evangelised his anti semitic beliefs- he simply held them... but chose to write fiction books... the impact he left on the world was some good stories for most people

Just read they were putting a sign up to apologise for his beliefs in the Roald Dahl museum - he's dead now, how can you apologise post death for someone else's thoughts?!

OP posts:
AlizeeEasy · 19/07/2023 11:49

If you choose to express your thoughts then others get to comment on them. For example, opposite to many on mumsnet I support trans people. Now I have expressed that opinion you are all free to criticise me as you so wish. That’s not me being cancelled.

I disagree with what JK Rowling has said and do not wish to support her further so I won’t be reading her books. She isn’t cancelled, nor do I want her to be. I am merely choosing who I support and who I do not. If I didn’t know her opinions then I wouldn’t be able to make such a decision.

with regards to RD, The reason we know he was antisemitic is because he expressed those views, so now people can choose if they wish to still read the books. I take the view that once someone is dead it no longer matters anyway so I will continue to enjoy his works and I believe the museum should remain open to those who also wish to still enjoy his books.

ReadRum · 19/07/2023 11:46

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 10:40

Well they've tried to rewrite his books to match modern publishing sensitivities. Which went down well. Can't call Augustus Gloop "fat" now. Apparently the phrase "white as a sheet" to refer to someone shocked or scared is also verboten.

The owners of his estate have edited the books in the hope of retaining or increasing their income stream. It’s a business decision that nobody has forced them to take.

itsmylife7 · 19/07/2023 11:44

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 00:59

I'm far from Nigel Farage's fan base but I do believe his bank shouldn't cancel his account because his values don't align with theirs

I'm pretty sure that it came out that it was shut down because he no longer enough money in there to reach their threshold and he tried to pretend it was his views to outrage people. Happy to be corrected if this isn't true though.

Not true at all.
the true reason has been printed.... nothing to do with money.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 11:43

hamstersarse · 19/07/2023 11:37

@NewNameNigel

i could certainly tolerate and vigorously disagree with those opinions.

Presumably the rape man just has an opinion and has not enacted this opinion to become an actual rapist, because then he could be arrested. There are people in the uk that hold this opinion, the fact you don’t hear them doesn’t mean they still don’t think it, I’d rather have the opportunity to hear it and vigorously oppose it, than it go underground.,

As for the boss guy, yeah I’m happy for that to be tweeted, and I’d never work there and presumably no other women would too.

When I was at college, it was in the relatively early days of female admission there. I was taught by a number of men who had voted against it; who, at least at one time, thought i and those like me should not be there.
they seemed to be able to put that view aside when it came to their teaching lives.

hamstersarse · 19/07/2023 11:42

Tolerate does not mean agree with btw.
it means ‘to carry’ and so in that sense, tolerance means being able to psychologically carry the tension of opposite ideas and feelings. It is not about agreement.

hamstersarse · 19/07/2023 11:39

@OCaptain

i didn’t actually express any opinions or thoughts in my post on the ‘hot topics’
I can assure you if I did, my post would be deleted

hamstersarse · 19/07/2023 11:37

@NewNameNigel

i could certainly tolerate and vigorously disagree with those opinions.

Presumably the rape man just has an opinion and has not enacted this opinion to become an actual rapist, because then he could be arrested. There are people in the uk that hold this opinion, the fact you don’t hear them doesn’t mean they still don’t think it, I’d rather have the opportunity to hear it and vigorously oppose it, than it go underground.,

As for the boss guy, yeah I’m happy for that to be tweeted, and I’d never work there and presumably no other women would too.

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 11:27

@hamstersarse
People need to tolerate an opposite opinion to their own, it is part of being a mature person

Would you tolerate the opinion of a man who thought rape should be legal. How about if that man was your doctor?

What about if your male boss was of the opinion that women should be paid less and tweeted that opinion on his personal twitter account. Would you tolerate that?

If not why not?

JuvenileEmu · 19/07/2023 11:23

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 11:10

That's an exceptionally long post from someone who thinks don't have free speech.

But it's a post by someone who is completely anonymous. Presumably it's in real life that they feel they are not able to speak freely.

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 11:22

Our speech is restricted in many circumstances; I cannot freely talk about trans issues, immigration issues, race issues, religious issues, many family issues such as marriage/divorce, god, you can barely even talk about being a conservative

@hamstersarse is it that you can't speak freely or that other people don't to listen to you or give you a platform to speak? The two are different.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 19/07/2023 11:16

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 07:48

Who has had their bank account closed due to their religious views?

My best is on Farage is being disingenuous here. Banks like you if you have money in your account; otherwise, the account is closed. (To simply things.) There's no need to start 'It's all totalitarian' when the case may be he simply didn't follow guidelines.

I understand the telegraph has published a bunch of mails released to Farage in response to DSAR which suggests there may be more substance to his claims than previously thought.

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 11:10

hamstersarse · 19/07/2023 10:56

There has been a slow build up of this over many years...

After the Thatcher years were demonised as being all 'greed is good' there was some backlash to that ending up in the 'be kind' era, so anyone who says anything that is deemed 'unkind' to someone somewhere is at risk of being cancelled.

I look at how people like Katie Hopkins were cancelled many years ago and wonder why we let that happen, really. Yes, whatever, she was sometime very 'unkind' but she didn't kill anyone, didn't incite violence and was just expressing an opinion. I know there will be people who will instantly say 'she deserved it'....but I would argue that she didn't deserve to be cancelled, she deserved to have an opinion that you could disagree with. There was a lot of projection going on in her downfall.

I think anyone who believes we have free speech these days is fooling themselves. Our speech is restricted in many circumstances; I cannot freely talk about trans issues, immigration issues, race issues, religious issues, many family issues such as marriage/divorce, god, you can barely even talk about being a conservative. Covid was a hotbed of censorship too - you could barely even say that maybe it is a mistake to close schools without being written off ( family fallouts were even common), never mind saying you didn't want the vaccine. There is an accepted opinion on all these things, and that is that. I admire all the people who despite this social pressure still speak their actual opinions (e.g. Katie Hopkins, Nigel Farrage) because it really is incredibly brave. Take any of the issues mentioned above and actually imagine yourself freely exploring and articulating any thoughts you have on these matters in front of the nation, and I would take a bet you would censor your own thoughts and speech - hence why I would describe these 'subjects of hate' as actually being brave.

People need to tolerate an opposite opinion to their own, it is part of being a mature person. It is also absolutely vital for your own mental health that you are able to explore an opinion that is different to your own.

That's an exceptionally long post from someone who thinks don't have free speech.

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 11:06

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 10:50

@AlisonDonut

Which guidelines did he not follow?

I don't know - I'm not Nigel Farage nor a representative of the bank in question. The keyword in my post was "may".

According to the bank's own documents, he had enough money in his account and was always courteous to staff. The decision to close his account was because of his political views.

hamstersarse · 19/07/2023 10:56

There has been a slow build up of this over many years...

After the Thatcher years were demonised as being all 'greed is good' there was some backlash to that ending up in the 'be kind' era, so anyone who says anything that is deemed 'unkind' to someone somewhere is at risk of being cancelled.

I look at how people like Katie Hopkins were cancelled many years ago and wonder why we let that happen, really. Yes, whatever, she was sometime very 'unkind' but she didn't kill anyone, didn't incite violence and was just expressing an opinion. I know there will be people who will instantly say 'she deserved it'....but I would argue that she didn't deserve to be cancelled, she deserved to have an opinion that you could disagree with. There was a lot of projection going on in her downfall.

I think anyone who believes we have free speech these days is fooling themselves. Our speech is restricted in many circumstances; I cannot freely talk about trans issues, immigration issues, race issues, religious issues, many family issues such as marriage/divorce, god, you can barely even talk about being a conservative. Covid was a hotbed of censorship too - you could barely even say that maybe it is a mistake to close schools without being written off ( family fallouts were even common), never mind saying you didn't want the vaccine. There is an accepted opinion on all these things, and that is that. I admire all the people who despite this social pressure still speak their actual opinions (e.g. Katie Hopkins, Nigel Farrage) because it really is incredibly brave. Take any of the issues mentioned above and actually imagine yourself freely exploring and articulating any thoughts you have on these matters in front of the nation, and I would take a bet you would censor your own thoughts and speech - hence why I would describe these 'subjects of hate' as actually being brave.

People need to tolerate an opposite opinion to their own, it is part of being a mature person. It is also absolutely vital for your own mental health that you are able to explore an opinion that is different to your own.

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 10:52

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 00:59

I'm far from Nigel Farage's fan base but I do believe his bank shouldn't cancel his account because his values don't align with theirs

I'm pretty sure that it came out that it was shut down because he no longer enough money in there to reach their threshold and he tried to pretend it was his views to outrage people. Happy to be corrected if this isn't true though.

It did turn out to be untrue. The minutes regarding the decision have been released under a Subject Access Request. In them the bank repeatedly says he “meets the EC [economic contribution] criteria for commercial retention”

The potential for money laundering is nonsense too. All Politically Exposed Persons have to have extra scrutiny on their accounts to prevent corruption and some banks have indeed refused accounts to (for example) the daughters of peers because of the admin involved. In this case, he is surely less politically exposed than he was in 2016 when he actually held elected office and actively campaigned.

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 10:50

@AlisonDonut

Which guidelines did he not follow?

I don't know - I'm not Nigel Farage nor a representative of the bank in question. The keyword in my post was "may".

IClaudine · 19/07/2023 10:45

Apparently the phrase "white as a sheet" to refer to someone shocked or scared is also verboten

I think if this is about children's books, I can't feel too exercised about it. Trying to avoid white being the default skin colour in children's stories is not a bad thing. Kids need to be able to see themselves in stories and identify with the characters. It helps keep engaged with reading, which is so important.

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 10:40

AnotherTownAnotherTrain · 19/07/2023 00:21

I wouldn't use RD as an example of cancel culture . They didn't close the museum, they haven't as far as I am aware banned his books have they? Having said that I have noticed a worrying trend in demonizing notable people for having differences of opinion . Not even awful opinions like anti Semitic opinions but things like "men can't breastfeed" or "women don't have penises."

Well they've tried to rewrite his books to match modern publishing sensitivities. Which went down well. Can't call Augustus Gloop "fat" now. Apparently the phrase "white as a sheet" to refer to someone shocked or scared is also verboten.

WhatNoRaisins · 19/07/2023 10:39

Agree that there are some people who really appear to get a lot of pleasure from public shunning, language policing and "calling out".

If I pass any wisdom on to my kids it's beware a person that takes pleasure doing this. They'll turn on you the moment they get the opportunity.

IClaudine · 19/07/2023 10:32

LOSTAN · 19/07/2023 09:56

That's not what I said. Is it?
Are you often this obtuse.

Are you often this rude?

How do you predict we will slide into communism @LOSTAN ? There are currently no communist political parties in the UK which have even the teeniest tiniest chance of gaining power.

LOSTAN · 19/07/2023 09:56

IClaudine · 19/07/2023 07:09

Yes, the Communist Party is strongly predicted to win the next election. Isn't it?

That's not what I said. Is it?
Are you often this obtuse.

IClaudine · 19/07/2023 08:53

AlisonDonut · 19/07/2023 07:40

Do totalitarians tell people they are totalitarians before they get into power?

That is a very good point. Look at the totalitarian tendencies of the current Conservative government. It never set those out in its 2019 manifesto.If it could do away with elections at this juncture, it probably would.

AlisonDonut · 19/07/2023 08:14

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 07:48

Who has had their bank account closed due to their religious views?

My best is on Farage is being disingenuous here. Banks like you if you have money in your account; otherwise, the account is closed. (To simply things.) There's no need to start 'It's all totalitarian' when the case may be he simply didn't follow guidelines.

Which guidelines did he not follow?

FOJN · 19/07/2023 08:13

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 07:53

@FOJN

It's frightening how many people love the feeling of power they get from a good public shunning.

I'm interested in how you know other people's feelings, particularly on this subject?

Fair point, I'll amend my remarks:

It's frightening how many people SEEM/APPEAR to love the feeling of power they get from a good public shunning.

MichelleScarn · 19/07/2023 08:04

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 07:53

@FOJN

It's frightening how many people love the feeling of power they get from a good public shunning.

I'm interested in how you know other people's feelings, particularly on this subject?

Not a frequented of the cess pitt of twitter then @OCaptain?