Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a worrying trend to cancel folk for opinions and thoughts

208 replies

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 18/07/2023 23:26

I'm not saying I agree with the opinions of Roald Dahl (I dont) but I understand if people want to cancel folk for their actions - don't like cancel culture but that seems reasonable somewhat to react to someone's actions

But why the fuck are we extending cancel culture to the thoughts that someone expressed? He hardly evangelised his anti semitic beliefs- he simply held them... but chose to write fiction books... the impact he left on the world was some good stories for most people

Just read they were putting a sign up to apologise for his beliefs in the Roald Dahl museum - he's dead now, how can you apologise post death for someone else's thoughts?!

OP posts:
FOJN · 19/07/2023 13:17

spiderplantparty · 19/07/2023 12:53

@AlizeeEasy It would be helpful if you could summarise the main points from the video please. I'm afraid I don't have a spare hour to watch it from start to finish.

I watched it ages ago, it's very poor. Despite obtaining a PhD for Jammi's 'mesearch', Jammi isn't the sharpest knife in the drawer and the analysis of what JKR actually wrote is limited or refashioned into a dog whistle to suit Jammi's agenda.

I wonder if the person recommending this video has read JKR's essay, I've yet to meet anyone who claims it's full of transphobic that's has actually read it.

I saw a thumbnail of a more recent video where Jammi claims to debunk Lisa Littmans work. I opened it knowing I couldn't endure the video but to read some of the comments to get a sense of the content to find that the widely acknowledged limitations of the study seemed to have been presented as groundbreaking gotchas.

It's just tedious shite.

PuttingDownRoots · 19/07/2023 13:16

There is a fine lone between "I don't agree with what you say but I support your right to say it" and "you shouldn't be allowed to say that". And we all put that line somewhere slightly different.

Many historic figures have views that are extremely questionable now, but were mainstream during that person's lifetime. Take homophobia. The idea that someone could be sacked for being gay is unthinkable now fortunately. In the past, it was illegal and a conviction would bar you from some organisations. All those organisations can do now is apologise... but were they right at the time to condemn illegal behavior?

I do find the idea of bank accounts being closed for your political views quite concerning, more because of the extent it could go to rather than, fir example, a BNP account being shut.

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 13:15

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 13:01

@OCaptain I have, a long time ago when I was a child though

I read a story about witches and whilst I recognise the implication... long nose, print their own money as having been used as racist stereotypes

I wouldn't have made the leap myself whilst reading a fictional story that said they were something entirely different (witches) to being antisemitism

But you know now that the writer was, indeed, anti-semitic. The point I'm attempting to make to you is that no choice a writer makes is independent of their own ethics, religion or politics. It is a product of those things. We may not see overt, obvious references, particularly in works meant for children, but you can be certain they are there because the mind that created the works held those views. It is inevitable.

AlisonDonut · 19/07/2023 13:02

If you see witches with long noses who print money as being Jewish, then is the problem with you?

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 13:01

@OCaptain I have, a long time ago when I was a child though

I read a story about witches and whilst I recognise the implication... long nose, print their own money as having been used as racist stereotypes

I wouldn't have made the leap myself whilst reading a fictional story that said they were something entirely different (witches) to being antisemitism

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 19/07/2023 12:58

*affect

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 12:56

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 12:27

'They don't actually want freedom, they want to force others to listen to their opinion and to be immune from criticism.'*
*
He didn't force anyone to listen to his opinions did he? He held them but they have nothing to do with the work he's actually known for

Say I believe men aren't women (I do) but whilst some people know this is a belief I hold... and not everyone agrees... I don't make my life mission about this subject- instead I do something like some great art, stories, even feed starving children Vs spreading this belief ... why should my achievements be judged by an opinion that yes I hold but has nothing to do with what I actually contribute to the world as my lasting legacy?

Or idk say I am a Muslim (I'm not) and I believe my religion doesn't allow for homosexuality and I express I think homosexuality is a sin as an opinion of mine however I never actually act on my opinion in any meaningful way beyond thinking it and I create idk 🤷‍♀️ an amazing film about wildlife as my lasting legacy to the world... why should that be criticised bc I held a belief that I didn't promote in my film?

Have you ever read "The Witches"? This is a dark, deeply misogynist story. The society of witches, who look quite frightening with looming figures, black lined faces and long noses, even print their own money.

To think there is a worrying trend to cancel folk for opinions and thoughts
ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 12:55

'all people are multifaceted and you can hold a view that doesn't really effect much of what you do with your life. It's like we want to latch onto the negative for the sake of drama'

Completely @WhatNoRaisins

OP posts:
AlisonDonut · 19/07/2023 12:55

I wanted your opinion. As a person on here who stated that you disagreed. I'd like to know on what.

Just one point maybe?

spiderplantparty · 19/07/2023 12:53

@AlizeeEasy It would be helpful if you could summarise the main points from the video please. I'm afraid I don't have a spare hour to watch it from start to finish.

AlizeeEasy · 19/07/2023 12:49

AlisonDonut · 19/07/2023 12:43

One day, when you have time, can you start a thread on what it is that JKR said that you disagree with? I've always wanted to know what upset everyone so much.

Hi Alison. I’m not sure I want to subject myself that much to the mercy of mumsnet, but if you are genuinely interested then I highly recommend this video:

it uses studies and research to refute many of the claims that jkr has stated.

Responding to JK Rowlings Essay | Is It Anti-Trans?

Addressing what was said by JK Rowling in her 'TERF wars' essay. Is it anti-trans?Follow Shaaba: https://www.youtube.com/Shaaba17Reference list: https://www....

https://youtu.be/6Avcp-e4bOs

WhatNoRaisins · 19/07/2023 12:49

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 12:34

I don't think it is that simple. I will use my own experience as an example.

As a black women I have to deal with a lot of racism. I don't always have the mental reserves to debate racist views. It might seem like simple #nodebate cancelling to an outsider who doesn't deal with racism but in reality it is a kind of mental exhaustion that is hard to explain to those who haven't experienced it.

I get needing to protect yourself from racism or other discrimination. I don't think there's anything wrong with personally having to avoid or shun someone who brings this to your life. I certainly don't think it's anyone's responsibility to debate all the time.

It's the mob mentality I can't stand. Agree with PP, all people are multifaceted and you can hold a view that doesn't really effect much of what you do with your life. It's like we want to latch onto the negative for the sake of drama.

AlisonDonut · 19/07/2023 12:43

AlizeeEasy · 19/07/2023 11:49

If you choose to express your thoughts then others get to comment on them. For example, opposite to many on mumsnet I support trans people. Now I have expressed that opinion you are all free to criticise me as you so wish. That’s not me being cancelled.

I disagree with what JK Rowling has said and do not wish to support her further so I won’t be reading her books. She isn’t cancelled, nor do I want her to be. I am merely choosing who I support and who I do not. If I didn’t know her opinions then I wouldn’t be able to make such a decision.

with regards to RD, The reason we know he was antisemitic is because he expressed those views, so now people can choose if they wish to still read the books. I take the view that once someone is dead it no longer matters anyway so I will continue to enjoy his works and I believe the museum should remain open to those who also wish to still enjoy his books.

One day, when you have time, can you start a thread on what it is that JKR said that you disagree with? I've always wanted to know what upset everyone so much.

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 12:36

I realise it's a stretch to suggest Roald Dahl is cancelled and not the best example to illustrate the point I am trying to convey- that there's a trend that worries me to discredit people's achievements and contributions based on things they haven't actively promoted, just thought

OP posts:
NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 12:34

WhatNoRaisins · 19/07/2023 12:27

There's being criticized for your views and theres the sort of instant shun or #nodebate. I think they're very different things. Nothing wrong with a critique or a good discussion of different views, it can even be a learning experience.

I don't think it is that simple. I will use my own experience as an example.

As a black women I have to deal with a lot of racism. I don't always have the mental reserves to debate racist views. It might seem like simple #nodebate cancelling to an outsider who doesn't deal with racism but in reality it is a kind of mental exhaustion that is hard to explain to those who haven't experienced it.

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 12:28

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 12:23

@DdraigGoch
Freedom of speech is balanced by the freedom not to listen. Where I draw the line however is where people try to stop other people being able to listen.

Do you think that mumsnet or any other social media site not wanting to platform certain views falls into this category though? I see if more as them exercising their freedom not to have their brand associated with certain views.

I believe that Mumsnet's moderation policy draws the line very well actually.

Generally I prefer disagreeable views to stand so that I can debate them, rather than hiding them where they will fester. I am confident enough in my convictions that I think that they would stand up to debate. Those who try to shut debate down however often seem to have little in the way of arguments to back their views up.

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 12:27

'They don't actually want freedom, they want to force others to listen to their opinion and to be immune from criticism.'*
*
He didn't force anyone to listen to his opinions did he? He held them but they have nothing to do with the work he's actually known for

Say I believe men aren't women (I do) but whilst some people know this is a belief I hold... and not everyone agrees... I don't make my life mission about this subject- instead I do something like some great art, stories, even feed starving children Vs spreading this belief ... why should my achievements be judged by an opinion that yes I hold but has nothing to do with what I actually contribute to the world as my lasting legacy?

Or idk say I am a Muslim (I'm not) and I believe my religion doesn't allow for homosexuality and I express I think homosexuality is a sin as an opinion of mine however I never actually act on my opinion in any meaningful way beyond thinking it and I create idk 🤷‍♀️ an amazing film about wildlife as my lasting legacy to the world... why should that be criticised bc I held a belief that I didn't promote in my film?

OP posts:
WhatNoRaisins · 19/07/2023 12:27

There's being criticized for your views and theres the sort of instant shun or #nodebate. I think they're very different things. Nothing wrong with a critique or a good discussion of different views, it can even be a learning experience.

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 12:24

AlizeeEasy · 19/07/2023 11:49

If you choose to express your thoughts then others get to comment on them. For example, opposite to many on mumsnet I support trans people. Now I have expressed that opinion you are all free to criticise me as you so wish. That’s not me being cancelled.

I disagree with what JK Rowling has said and do not wish to support her further so I won’t be reading her books. She isn’t cancelled, nor do I want her to be. I am merely choosing who I support and who I do not. If I didn’t know her opinions then I wouldn’t be able to make such a decision.

with regards to RD, The reason we know he was antisemitic is because he expressed those views, so now people can choose if they wish to still read the books. I take the view that once someone is dead it no longer matters anyway so I will continue to enjoy his works and I believe the museum should remain open to those who also wish to still enjoy his books.

"I support trans people" isn't an opinion. It's a statement of fact, just as "I support United" is. A statement of fact can be proven or disproven but opinions relate to feelings and beliefs, which are not so tangible.

An opinion would be "I think that United are the best team" or "I think that transwomen should be allowed to compete in women's sports".

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 12:23

@DdraigGoch
Freedom of speech is balanced by the freedom not to listen. Where I draw the line however is where people try to stop other people being able to listen.

Do you think that mumsnet or any other social media site not wanting to platform certain views falls into this category though? I see if more as them exercising their freedom not to have their brand associated with certain views.

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 12:13

@AlizeeEasy
If you choose to express your thoughts then others get to comment on them. For example, opposite to many on mumsnet I support trans people. Now I have expressed that opinion you are all free to criticise me as you so wish. That’s not me being cancelled.

I think some people who talk about free speech want to be free to express their opinions but then don't want others to have the freedom to criticism them. They also seem to think that platforms like mumsnet twitter etc shouldn't have the freedom to chose who and what they platform.

They don't actually want freedom, they want to force others to listen to their opinion and to be immune from criticism.

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 12:13

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 11:22

Our speech is restricted in many circumstances; I cannot freely talk about trans issues, immigration issues, race issues, religious issues, many family issues such as marriage/divorce, god, you can barely even talk about being a conservative

@hamstersarse is it that you can't speak freely or that other people don't to listen to you or give you a platform to speak? The two are different.

Freedom of speech is balanced by the freedom not to listen. Where I draw the line however is where people try to stop other people being able to listen.

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 12:09

itsmylife7 · 19/07/2023 11:44

Not true at all.
the true reason has been printed.... nothing to do with money.

Yes I saw this on here. I plan to read the released documents after work tonight.

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 12:08

hamstersarse · 19/07/2023 11:39

@OCaptain

i didn’t actually express any opinions or thoughts in my post on the ‘hot topics’
I can assure you if I did, my post would be deleted

@hamstersarse That isn't you not having free speech, that is you not being given a platform.

You have the freedom to express your opinion but others have the freedom to choose not to platform you.

riotlady · 19/07/2023 12:05

AlizeeEasy · 19/07/2023 11:49

If you choose to express your thoughts then others get to comment on them. For example, opposite to many on mumsnet I support trans people. Now I have expressed that opinion you are all free to criticise me as you so wish. That’s not me being cancelled.

I disagree with what JK Rowling has said and do not wish to support her further so I won’t be reading her books. She isn’t cancelled, nor do I want her to be. I am merely choosing who I support and who I do not. If I didn’t know her opinions then I wouldn’t be able to make such a decision.

with regards to RD, The reason we know he was antisemitic is because he expressed those views, so now people can choose if they wish to still read the books. I take the view that once someone is dead it no longer matters anyway so I will continue to enjoy his works and I believe the museum should remain open to those who also wish to still enjoy his books.

Exactly. People are free to think and say what they like, but we’re not all obliged to provide them with an arena in which to say it. You can still read as many Roald Dahl books as you like (and personally I will- although not his stories for adults, if you’ve read any of those it won’t come as a surprise that he wasn’t a very nice man!), a note in a musueum somewhere doesn’t affect that a jot.