Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a worrying trend to cancel folk for opinions and thoughts

208 replies

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 18/07/2023 23:26

I'm not saying I agree with the opinions of Roald Dahl (I dont) but I understand if people want to cancel folk for their actions - don't like cancel culture but that seems reasonable somewhat to react to someone's actions

But why the fuck are we extending cancel culture to the thoughts that someone expressed? He hardly evangelised his anti semitic beliefs- he simply held them... but chose to write fiction books... the impact he left on the world was some good stories for most people

Just read they were putting a sign up to apologise for his beliefs in the Roald Dahl museum - he's dead now, how can you apologise post death for someone else's thoughts?!

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 17:09

0021andabit · 19/07/2023 16:24

No one is banning him though is he?

Some people would like it if he was. Some people have engaged in harassment campaigns directed at publishers, universities etc. to get them to drop authors or speakers that they disagree with. In some cases they have succeeded. Censorship like that is sinister. It's only a backlash over the last few years that has started to turn the tide back against 'no-platforming'.

No-platforming is not an effective tool against genuinely objectionable vuews anyway. Remember when the BNP won seats in the European Parliament? The BBC invited Nick Griffin onto Question Time, ignoring the protests from people appalled that he was being given a platform. On the show he made a right fool of himself, his party subsequently disappearing without a trace. The best way to tackle genuinely objectionable views is in open debate, forcing them to fester underground will let extremists claim victimhood.

0021andabit · 19/07/2023 16:32

I think the central premise that we’re less tolerant of alternative views now than historically is incorrect though.

I was at school under Section 28 - teachers couldn’t speak positively about gay people, Jacqueline Wilson has spoken about having to make the decision not to make a character openly gay because the book couldn’t be read in schools if they were. THAT’S censorship- that’s cancel culture.

I think potentially there is a problem with the modern media landscape of creators views/ thoughts being so readily expressed on social media - maybe we don’t need to know what everyone thinks about everything to such a great degree.

0021andabit · 19/07/2023 16:24

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 15:51

I would say that those particular sentences do cross a line, and if in a book intended for children they should be removed, but if they were in writing intended for adults they should stay, with suitable mention in the preface and footnotes. Let people come to their own conclusions and debate them.

I certainly wouldn't extend criticism of a particular view beyond that view itself. Richard Wagner had awful views that I strongly disagree with, but I still enjoy his music. In the same way that while I disagree with RD's antisemitic views, I wouldn't 'cancel' (i.e. ban) everything he ever wrote just because of something he once told a newspaper.

No one is banning him though is he?

IClaudine · 19/07/2023 16:20

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 16:12

It's not communist economics, no. The repression of views that contradict the establishment viewpoint however bears a lot of similarities with totalitarian regimes.

Absolutely.

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 16:12

IClaudine · 19/07/2023 15:20

I wasn't rude or condescending, but maybe a bit sarcastic. I didn't chuck any insults your way, though. I'd ask you for the same consideration.

I will ask you again: how do you predict we will slide into communism @LOSTAN ? You said:

Welcome to COMMUNISM - because that's where we are heading folks

and I really wondered how you have come to that conclusion. If the Tories lose the next election and Labour wins... Well the Labour party under Starmer are barely left wing, let alone communist.

Yes, I did acknowledge in my reply to the other poster that the current government has some totalitarian tendencies, but it certainly couldn't be described as communist!

It's not communist economics, no. The repression of views that contradict the establishment viewpoint however bears a lot of similarities with totalitarian regimes.

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 16:01

I also think ... and obv not with Roald Dahl. But there may have been people who had to openly express beliefs that they didn't necessarily personally believe- because that was the only accepted belief or your life would have been in danger at certain times in certain places

We know what can happen with antisemitism and it was horrifying but there are examples today where you have to believe a particular belief or you will face negative consequences- so say someone toes the line and does something in the world that's actually positive in what it leaves... but in 50 years time, it's no longer an acceptable belief yet they expressed it bc at the time it was the norm and expected- not even their own beliefs just ones they had to express to survive (again I do not mean Roald Dahl, this clearly wasn't the case there) ... are we still going to demand the content acknowledges that they ever expressed that belief and make its legacy connected to that belief?

OP posts:
ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 15:52

I think I may have missed a point that perhaps if I'd ever studied English lit beyond school I may have thought of that others have been saying about his mind influencing his writing... perhaps that is usually considered if you study author's works...

I thought antisemitism had nothing to do with his stories

Lewis Carroll is somewhat considered to have had gross intentions towards young girls... but I don't really feel at all influenced by reading Alice in Wonderland that he was ever promoting those beliefs beyond himself? Yes they're abhorrent beliefs to me, I thoroughly disagree and condemn them... but that doesn't make me think we need a trigger warning on the content because of beliefs the author held I guess

OP posts:
DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 15:51

0021andabit · 19/07/2023 14:40

I think Roald Dahl is a bad example because they weren’t just thoughts, they were expressed in print.

Do you know what he said?

“There is a trait in the Jewish character that does provoke animosity, maybe it’s a kind of lack of generosity towards non-Jews. I mean, there’s always a reason why anti-anything crops up anywhere.”

“Even a stinker like Hitler didn’t just pick on them for no reason.”

Can you imagine how it felt for Holocaust survivors or the families of people killed - in recent, living memory - to read that?!

I would say that those particular sentences do cross a line, and if in a book intended for children they should be removed, but if they were in writing intended for adults they should stay, with suitable mention in the preface and footnotes. Let people come to their own conclusions and debate them.

I certainly wouldn't extend criticism of a particular view beyond that view itself. Richard Wagner had awful views that I strongly disagree with, but I still enjoy his music. In the same way that while I disagree with RD's antisemitic views, I wouldn't 'cancel' (i.e. ban) everything he ever wrote just because of something he once told a newspaper.

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 15:44

0021andabit · 19/07/2023 14:40

I think Roald Dahl is a bad example because they weren’t just thoughts, they were expressed in print.

Do you know what he said?

“There is a trait in the Jewish character that does provoke animosity, maybe it’s a kind of lack of generosity towards non-Jews. I mean, there’s always a reason why anti-anything crops up anywhere.”

“Even a stinker like Hitler didn’t just pick on them for no reason.”

Can you imagine how it felt for Holocaust survivors or the families of people killed - in recent, living memory - to read that?!

I know they're in print now but they were transcripts weren't they? Has he written some kind of antisemitic manuscript that I'm unaware of? 🙈

I used him as my admittedly poor example to illustrate my point thinking he had made some comments in his lifetime but never actually promoted his beliefs as worth anyone else adopting

OP posts:
maltravers · 19/07/2023 15:28

When I was at university, I can only remember an attempt to no platform once. Even then, I think the talk went ahead. The approach then was that “despicable” views would be tested, be shown to be wrong by debate and then would be scorned. Much better IMO and informative for all concerned, including for the despicable (or not depending on the merits) view holder. If the matter being discussed is upsetting enough that you don’t want to hear it, stay away. Ideas should be tested and then rejected, not the other way round.

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 15:23

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 13:20

You might be interested to learn that the stereotype of the witch (long nose, pointy hat, black robe, cauldron, etc.) grew from ... anti-semitism in Europe. Sorry.

So did the concept of goblins. After all this time though, these fictional creatures have become detached from their origins. It wasn't a connection that I ever made as a child and I suspect that most modern-day antisemites aren't familiar with the connections either, they just turn up to rallies where people want to wipe Israel off of the face of the earth.

IClaudine · 19/07/2023 15:20

LOSTAN · 19/07/2023 13:56

Your orginal post was both rude and condescending and there was no need for it, therefore I called you obtuse.
I suggest you broaden your horizons. Another poster has already mentioned to you re totalitarianism - you seemed quite happy to acknowledge that point of view.

I wasn't rude or condescending, but maybe a bit sarcastic. I didn't chuck any insults your way, though. I'd ask you for the same consideration.

I will ask you again: how do you predict we will slide into communism @LOSTAN ? You said:

Welcome to COMMUNISM - because that's where we are heading folks

and I really wondered how you have come to that conclusion. If the Tories lose the next election and Labour wins... Well the Labour party under Starmer are barely left wing, let alone communist.

Yes, I did acknowledge in my reply to the other poster that the current government has some totalitarian tendencies, but it certainly couldn't be described as communist!

onefinemess · 19/07/2023 15:02

Cancel Culture is effectively thought crime.

It must be stopped.

You cannot control someone's thoughts, so it's pointless trying. If you genuinely feel that you're really a cow, good luck to you. If you fancy dressing up as a pantomime bovine, if you want to sit in a field all day, chewing grass and going "Mooooooooooooooo", crack on. If that makes you happy, I'm happy for you. But, what you CAN'T do is expect me to also believe that you're really a cow. When I look at you, sitting there in your cow costume, I will think "there's a bloke dressed up as a cow", and no amount of purple flags, "Positive Species" workshops or unconscious bias training is going to make me believe that you're really a cow.

CoffeeCantata · 19/07/2023 14:50

(Sorry - late to this thread, which really interests me but I haven't yet read all the responses)

Firstly - I think Roald Dahl's nastiness IS apparent from his writing as misogyny and cruelty. If you're a woman, you'd better be pretty and young or you'll be a witch or a bitch, for sure.

But he's a very good writer and I don't advocate cancelling him - Evelyn Waugh was a horrible man, but a an absolute genius comic writer and I'd hate to lose that.

Yes, there is a dangerous orthodoxy now, I think, in public discussion etc etc. You have to agree with the prevailing accepted views on certain things or you'll be ignored at best or villified and cancelled at worst.

Anecdote from my student days in the early 80s, which struck me then as the beginning of this kind of thinking. We were in a seminar (English Lit) and the subject of capital punishment in a novel had come up. A man was expressing his viewpoint very rationally when the very right-on young lecturer glared at him and said 'I HOPE you're not agreeing with it!" I was taken aback, because while I'm very anti-death penalty, I get that some people who've given it much thought and consideration might disagree. And that's allowed!!!!

Until this point in my life I'd been brought up to think that all well-considered views should be listened to - whether you agree with them or not. It stuck in my mind as 'a new wind blowing through academia' even at that young age.

0021andabit · 19/07/2023 14:42

Also Roald Dahl has very much not been cancelled - the Wonka film is literally just about to come out.

0021andabit · 19/07/2023 14:42

LaMaG · 19/07/2023 14:33

I saw a disclaimer recently on a kids Tom and Jerry DVD, it said the stereotypes represented here do not reflect the makers/promoters views today, but the decision was made to leave these elements in because to delete them would be to suggest they never existed. I thought it got the tone right, no cancelling but educating and explaining.

I agree with this - it’s good to have opportunities to discuss those views, rather than pretend they never existed.

0021andabit · 19/07/2023 14:40

I think Roald Dahl is a bad example because they weren’t just thoughts, they were expressed in print.

Do you know what he said?

“There is a trait in the Jewish character that does provoke animosity, maybe it’s a kind of lack of generosity towards non-Jews. I mean, there’s always a reason why anti-anything crops up anywhere.”

“Even a stinker like Hitler didn’t just pick on them for no reason.”

Can you imagine how it felt for Holocaust survivors or the families of people killed - in recent, living memory - to read that?!

Araminta1003 · 19/07/2023 14:39

A lot of artists, composers, inventors etc etc were shitty humans with terrible views. We can’t cancel work that has become part of history and thought anyway, it is entrenched.
Cancel culture itself is a fleeting trend, best to just ignore it. It is already passing anyway.

NewNameNigel · 19/07/2023 14:38

I've yet to meet anyone who claims it's full of transphobic that's has actually read it.

To be fair I wouldn't be surprised if many of GC people who say they support it also haven't read it. I think this an issue that a lot of people pick a side on and then uncritically support anything that they view to be on their "side". It's almost tribal.

LaMaG · 19/07/2023 14:33

I saw a disclaimer recently on a kids Tom and Jerry DVD, it said the stereotypes represented here do not reflect the makers/promoters views today, but the decision was made to leave these elements in because to delete them would be to suggest they never existed. I thought it got the tone right, no cancelling but educating and explaining.

LaMaG · 19/07/2023 14:27

FixItUpChappie · 19/07/2023 01:26

I think we are in an incredibly intolerant moment. I can't stand this concept of persistently judging historical figures by today's standards - its like no one has read a history book properly. Activists seems to have hijacked the entire conversation. Every news piece is laced with the the papers "editorial pov". There is not necessarily lying from big news organizations like BBC (or CBC in Canada) but there is a lot of omitting and selective air time and once you see it you can't un-see it. No one representing us seems to fall in the centre - everything is far left or far right.

Personally, I feel totally silenced, unrepresented and fed up.

Agree with you here, we are becoming increasingly intolerant. It worries me terribly that things are not subject to debate anymore, everything is branded an ism or phobic and while that might be true sometimes it can only be established to be so after open minded debate surely, not at the outset.

LOSTAN · 19/07/2023 13:56

Your orginal post was both rude and condescending and there was no need for it, therefore I called you obtuse.
I suggest you broaden your horizons. Another poster has already mentioned to you re totalitarianism - you seemed quite happy to acknowledge that point of view.

OCaptain · 19/07/2023 13:47

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 13:27

'You might be interested to learn that the stereotype of the witch (long nose, pointy hat, black robe, cauldron, etc.) grew from ... anti-semitism in Europe. Sorry.'

I wasn't aware of that, I would've assumed it came from paganism myself- I don't believe in it myself but know someone who considers herself a witch (I think a nice one) seems to be her religion as such, I haven't seen any evidence that would make me believe that she actually does much, beyond believing her rituals? are beneficial to her - she uses a cauldron mixing up herbs and stuff- also has a black robe and typical witch hat but I think they might just be props she likes

I don't mean the rituals per se, nor paganism, just the typical imagery of 'witch' that pervades society.

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 19/07/2023 13:27

'You might be interested to learn that the stereotype of the witch (long nose, pointy hat, black robe, cauldron, etc.) grew from ... anti-semitism in Europe. Sorry.'

I wasn't aware of that, I would've assumed it came from paganism myself- I don't believe in it myself but know someone who considers herself a witch (I think a nice one) seems to be her religion as such, I haven't seen any evidence that would make me believe that she actually does much, beyond believing her rituals? are beneficial to her - she uses a cauldron mixing up herbs and stuff- also has a black robe and typical witch hat but I think they might just be props she likes

OP posts:
OCaptain · 19/07/2023 13:20

AlisonDonut · 19/07/2023 13:02

If you see witches with long noses who print money as being Jewish, then is the problem with you?

You might be interested to learn that the stereotype of the witch (long nose, pointy hat, black robe, cauldron, etc.) grew from ... anti-semitism in Europe. Sorry.