Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a worrying trend to cancel folk for opinions and thoughts

208 replies

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 18/07/2023 23:26

I'm not saying I agree with the opinions of Roald Dahl (I dont) but I understand if people want to cancel folk for their actions - don't like cancel culture but that seems reasonable somewhat to react to someone's actions

But why the fuck are we extending cancel culture to the thoughts that someone expressed? He hardly evangelised his anti semitic beliefs- he simply held them... but chose to write fiction books... the impact he left on the world was some good stories for most people

Just read they were putting a sign up to apologise for his beliefs in the Roald Dahl museum - he's dead now, how can you apologise post death for someone else's thoughts?!

OP posts:
WandaWonder · 22/07/2023 02:08

Pinkneonballoon · 20/07/2023 13:38

I think in general worry over cancel culture is just a moral panic and people would be better placed worrying about the real impact of the hateful or damaging words and views the supposed victims of cancel culture have.

Who decides what is hateful or damaging?

DdraigGoch · 22/07/2023 02:02

Pinkneonballoon · 20/07/2023 13:38

I think in general worry over cancel culture is just a moral panic and people would be better placed worrying about the real impact of the hateful or damaging words and views the supposed victims of cancel culture have.

Care to provide any examples of "hateful" or "damaging" words and views that you think should not be said? Other than the RD interview where I don't think that anyone would disagree that it crosses a line.

DdraigGoch · 22/07/2023 01:58

0021andabit · 20/07/2023 13:27

But who is being cancelled for being anti abortion? Jacob Rees Mogg is publicly anti abortion & he airs his views on TV (& in parliament). A view may not be the mainstream view in society any more, so you may get more push back/ stronger arguments than you did in a different era but that’s not being silenced or cancelled - it’s just people disagreeing with you.

I remember Tim Farron being torn apart over the issue when he was Lib Dem leader. Even though he took the liberal viewpoint that while he didn't agree with it as a Catholic, what other people did with their consiences was their business.

Catusrusty · 21/07/2023 19:08

Moonberri · 18/07/2023 23:56

I think we're becoming more of an intolerant society. Ironically it tends to be the supposedly "inclusive" sections of society that seek to censor other people's thoughts and language. For example calling people bigoted for not believing that a man magically becomes a woman if he puts on a dress and a wig.

Yep we are definitely becoming more intolerant.

Tropics4 · 21/07/2023 19:01

I think I would call it Totalitarianism! It started with ' politically correct ' whatever that means, now we are heading towards an Orwellian style regime...an opinion or thought is becoming illegal.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 20/07/2023 17:14

Africa Brooke talks a lot about this topic

AgathaSpencerGregson · 20/07/2023 16:51

0021andabit · 20/07/2023 14:13

I think what’s tricky OP is the line between having opinions & causing harm. In that New Statesman interview, Roald Dahl blamed Jewish people’s character for what happened to them in the Holocaust. Those comments were printed in the early 80s. Reading them undoubtedly caused pain & harm to a community still coming to terms with the horror of the Holocaust. So, I think it’s only a good thing that the Roald Dahl are no working with the Jewish community & anti racism charities to address that - that’s not cancelling him, it’s being honest about the complexities of his legacy.

the statements are grotesquely offensive and wrong but I cannot think of any example where they are reflected in his work. I have read a lot of his writing for adults and I cannot even think of examples there. It seems to me that current activities are actually embedding the attitudes within his legacy and causing offence all over again. He was an unpleasant man who produced some great work. Let’s preserve the latter and thank god society is moving on from the former.

0021andabit · 20/07/2023 14:13

I think what’s tricky OP is the line between having opinions & causing harm. In that New Statesman interview, Roald Dahl blamed Jewish people’s character for what happened to them in the Holocaust. Those comments were printed in the early 80s. Reading them undoubtedly caused pain & harm to a community still coming to terms with the horror of the Holocaust. So, I think it’s only a good thing that the Roald Dahl are no working with the Jewish community & anti racism charities to address that - that’s not cancelling him, it’s being honest about the complexities of his legacy.

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 20/07/2023 13:56

Pinkneonballoon · 20/07/2023 13:38

I think in general worry over cancel culture is just a moral panic and people would be better placed worrying about the real impact of the hateful or damaging words and views the supposed victims of cancel culture have.

I mean I personally didn't say that I thought cancel culture should stop entirely, I said it seemed reasonable somewhat even if I don't like it particularly as a culture when it's actions that have consequences that lead to it

I am worried we are going to take it too far if we extend it purely to opinions that aren't the savoury ones (but the example I used as I've said a few times wasn't the best)

I think opinions should be allowed to be held and people should have a chance to be informed on their opinions rather than hide them entirely for fear of backlash professionally, financially and reputationally

OP posts:
Pinkneonballoon · 20/07/2023 13:38

I think in general worry over cancel culture is just a moral panic and people would be better placed worrying about the real impact of the hateful or damaging words and views the supposed victims of cancel culture have.

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 20/07/2023 13:32

Think I made the confusion on this thread by using cancel culture as a term to describe what I don't actually mean is cancelling.... just a trend getting closer to it

I felt it was appropriate to use bc I didn't know how to make the differentiation between responding to actions vs opinions without - it was meant to illustrate a point but it didn't very clearly

OP posts:
0021andabit · 20/07/2023 13:27

Xenia · 20/07/2023 12:34

I thought this was going to be about the many people with bank accounts closed because some young bank clerk shares a different political view. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/07/06/peers-children-denied-bank-accounts-politics/ These are all aspects of the same point - different views getting harder and harder to express without consequences. Yet I remember in the 1970s we could have anti abortion and pro abortion discussions without anyone being cancelled - you just accepted some people held one view and some another.

But who is being cancelled for being anti abortion? Jacob Rees Mogg is publicly anti abortion & he airs his views on TV (& in parliament). A view may not be the mainstream view in society any more, so you may get more push back/ stronger arguments than you did in a different era but that’s not being silenced or cancelled - it’s just people disagreeing with you.

OCaptain · 20/07/2023 13:12

Xenia · 20/07/2023 12:34

I thought this was going to be about the many people with bank accounts closed because some young bank clerk shares a different political view. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/07/06/peers-children-denied-bank-accounts-politics/ These are all aspects of the same point - different views getting harder and harder to express without consequences. Yet I remember in the 1970s we could have anti abortion and pro abortion discussions without anyone being cancelled - you just accepted some people held one view and some another.

Xenia, I agree with the PP that this i somewhat derailing. However, you left out an important part of the article. "Peers have revealed that their political work is causing their children to be denied bank accounts under draconian money-laundering rules...." So it isn't really so much about one clerk's distaste against a certain person. It's rules regarding money laundering. Colossal amounts of money. This isn't about ordinary people.

Anthillveggie · 20/07/2023 12:38

Xenia · 20/07/2023 12:34

I thought this was going to be about the many people with bank accounts closed because some young bank clerk shares a different political view. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/07/06/peers-children-denied-bank-accounts-politics/ These are all aspects of the same point - different views getting harder and harder to express without consequences. Yet I remember in the 1970s we could have anti abortion and pro abortion discussions without anyone being cancelled - you just accepted some people held one view and some another.

Maybe try one of the 50 other threads on the topic instead of trying to derail this one.

Xenia · 20/07/2023 12:34

I thought this was going to be about the many people with bank accounts closed because some young bank clerk shares a different political view. https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/07/06/peers-children-denied-bank-accounts-politics/ These are all aspects of the same point - different views getting harder and harder to express without consequences. Yet I remember in the 1970s we could have anti abortion and pro abortion discussions without anyone being cancelled - you just accepted some people held one view and some another.

Peers' children denied bank accounts because of their parents' work

Lords also reveal some banks are threatening to drop them if families don't comply with intrusive checks

https://www.telegraph.co.uk/politics/2023/07/06/peers-children-denied-bank-accounts-politics

NewNameNigel · 20/07/2023 12:31

I think this is a really key point - people seem to sometimes equate being critiqued/ criticised/ pushed back against/ argued with with being cancelled.

Absolutely. I can't help but smile when people on the sex and gender page write 8 paragraph posts describing how they are silenced. I always think that it's a lot of words for a silent person.

0021andabit · 20/07/2023 11:59

where I think the line between being cancelled and just being argued with is when it affects your life. Eg people can shout down your opinions, but if your employer is then contacted and you are fired that’s where it crosses the line into cancellation (in my opinion)

I think this is a really key point - people seem to sometimes equate being critiqued/ criticised/ pushed back against/ argued with with being cancelled.

In the case of Roald Dahl, absolutely no one is banning his books - they’re still best sellers, there’s a show of Charlie and the Chocolate Factory touring right now, the Wonka movie is about to come out etc.

But I think it’s fine for people to question whether some of the nastiness that I personally think really does come through in the books - means that it’s time to leave those stories behind.

I think another part of the problem with Roald Dahl question specifically is culture at the moment seems a bit obsessed with nostalgia - endlessly rebooting & reimagining books, films, TV etc from the past rather than focussing on new stories.

Books that were once popular always fall by the wayside if they don’t speak to where society is now & I think that’s fine - they can still be studied etc but in the context of their own time.

AlizeeEasy · 20/07/2023 10:42

0021andabit · 20/07/2023 09:18

I don’t think I’m saying censorship is a new concept.

I’m saying I’m middle aged& I feel like I’m exposed to more plurality of voices & opinions than I ever have been - I absolutely don’t think books like Empireland by Satham Sanghera or documentaries by David Olugosa would’ve been widely available when I was younger as those kinds of ideas about British history were shut out of the conversation entirely, the documentary Once upon a time in Belfast certainly wouldn’t have been on our screens & I doubt Derry Girls would’ve been either: when I was young we got a very, very one-sided version of the troubles, I’ve already mentioned Section 28 & the complete censorship of those stories in our schools…

It is just surprising to me when people suggest we’re hearing less different & varied opinions now than in the past bcos in my experience, I’m exposed to a much, much wider variety of attitudes & opinions than I ever have been in my lifetime before.

I really agree with this.

the reason I think things are so contentious is because there is a wealth of opinions and diversity. We are all arguing with each other but that’s not the same as being cancelled.

the basic premise of many hop topic arguments boil down to whose rights trumps the other.

trans rights - trans rights vs women’s rights
abortion - mothers life vs babys
strikes - employees vs employers

to a certain extent the issue with people being cancelled is due to what ‘society’ at any point has decided upon whose rights are more important. This has and will change over time, so if you don’t keep up with the current trend then your opinion is deemed bigoted or wrong.

where I think the line between being cancelled and just being argued with is when it affects your life. Eg people can shout down your opinions, but if your employer is then contacted and you are fired that’s where it crosses the line into cancellation (in my opinion)

0021andabit · 20/07/2023 09:18

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 17:10

I don't think that anyone is suggesting that censorship is a new concept. On the contrary, it's a practice from the past that should stay in the past.

I don’t think I’m saying censorship is a new concept.

I’m saying I’m middle aged& I feel like I’m exposed to more plurality of voices & opinions than I ever have been - I absolutely don’t think books like Empireland by Satham Sanghera or documentaries by David Olugosa would’ve been widely available when I was younger as those kinds of ideas about British history were shut out of the conversation entirely, the documentary Once upon a time in Belfast certainly wouldn’t have been on our screens & I doubt Derry Girls would’ve been either: when I was young we got a very, very one-sided version of the troubles, I’ve already mentioned Section 28 & the complete censorship of those stories in our schools…

It is just surprising to me when people suggest we’re hearing less different & varied opinions now than in the past bcos in my experience, I’m exposed to a much, much wider variety of attitudes & opinions than I ever have been in my lifetime before.

MichelleScarn · 19/07/2023 22:32

Absolutely @Moonberri!!

Moonberri · 19/07/2023 22:25

Yes it's a fact but they are calling people bigoted for not having a magical belief that a man's feelings turn him into a woman. The belief is gender ideology. The fact is science and reality.

CappucinoAndCornetto · 19/07/2023 22:16

AnotherTownAnotherTrain · 19/07/2023 00:21

I wouldn't use RD as an example of cancel culture . They didn't close the museum, they haven't as far as I am aware banned his books have they? Having said that I have noticed a worrying trend in demonizing notable people for having differences of opinion . Not even awful opinions like anti Semitic opinions but things like "men can't breastfeed" or "women don't have penises."

Again, not opinions. Just facts....

CappucinoAndCornetto · 19/07/2023 22:15

Moonberri · 18/07/2023 23:56

I think we're becoming more of an intolerant society. Ironically it tends to be the supposedly "inclusive" sections of society that seek to censor other people's thoughts and language. For example calling people bigoted for not believing that a man magically becomes a woman if he puts on a dress and a wig.

But that's just scientific fact. It's not a belief.

LOSTAN · 19/07/2023 17:51

IClaudine · 19/07/2023 15:20

I wasn't rude or condescending, but maybe a bit sarcastic. I didn't chuck any insults your way, though. I'd ask you for the same consideration.

I will ask you again: how do you predict we will slide into communism @LOSTAN ? You said:

Welcome to COMMUNISM - because that's where we are heading folks

and I really wondered how you have come to that conclusion. If the Tories lose the next election and Labour wins... Well the Labour party under Starmer are barely left wing, let alone communist.

Yes, I did acknowledge in my reply to the other poster that the current government has some totalitarian tendencies, but it certainly couldn't be described as communist!

Fair enough IClaudine. It is my personal opinion.

I am in China an awful lot with work (The major Cities) ) and have seen a huge deterioration in those peoples rights especially in the last 12 or so years. In particular HongKong which has had so much of the quality of life stripped away from its citizens. Freedom of speech is dead there. I see that being played out here, slowly but surely.

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 17:10

0021andabit · 19/07/2023 16:32

I think the central premise that we’re less tolerant of alternative views now than historically is incorrect though.

I was at school under Section 28 - teachers couldn’t speak positively about gay people, Jacqueline Wilson has spoken about having to make the decision not to make a character openly gay because the book couldn’t be read in schools if they were. THAT’S censorship- that’s cancel culture.

I think potentially there is a problem with the modern media landscape of creators views/ thoughts being so readily expressed on social media - maybe we don’t need to know what everyone thinks about everything to such a great degree.

I don't think that anyone is suggesting that censorship is a new concept. On the contrary, it's a practice from the past that should stay in the past.

Swipe left for the next trending thread