Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think there is a worrying trend to cancel folk for opinions and thoughts

208 replies

ConnieLinggusThe69th · 18/07/2023 23:26

I'm not saying I agree with the opinions of Roald Dahl (I dont) but I understand if people want to cancel folk for their actions - don't like cancel culture but that seems reasonable somewhat to react to someone's actions

But why the fuck are we extending cancel culture to the thoughts that someone expressed? He hardly evangelised his anti semitic beliefs- he simply held them... but chose to write fiction books... the impact he left on the world was some good stories for most people

Just read they were putting a sign up to apologise for his beliefs in the Roald Dahl museum - he's dead now, how can you apologise post death for someone else's thoughts?!

OP posts:
AgathaSpencerGregson · 23/07/2023 14:31

OCaptain · 23/07/2023 11:51

@AgathaSpencerGregson

Yes, you do right to backtrack. I would too. especially as it’s also come out that coutts were too good for Farage but apparently happy to take the money of the former PM of Qatar - seemingly quite a lot of it …. but yeah, just capitalism 😂

No backtracking here. Following your reasoning through, though, wouldn't the former PM of Qatar be as undesirable as Farage, politically? (I'd have thought, anyway.) Doesn't your post just show Coutts simply prefers moneyed customers?

We know that already. What it shows is “the company exercising its rights” you’re going in to bat for here are a bunch of complete hypocrites.
but hey, you do you.

OCaptain · 23/07/2023 11:51

@AgathaSpencerGregson

Yes, you do right to backtrack. I would too. especially as it’s also come out that coutts were too good for Farage but apparently happy to take the money of the former PM of Qatar - seemingly quite a lot of it …. but yeah, just capitalism 😂

No backtracking here. Following your reasoning through, though, wouldn't the former PM of Qatar be as undesirable as Farage, politically? (I'd have thought, anyway.) Doesn't your post just show Coutts simply prefers moneyed customers?

AgathaSpencerGregson · 23/07/2023 11:01

OCaptain · 23/07/2023 10:52

We're picking sides? I'm not on anyone's "side" 😳

Yes, you do right to backtrack. I would too.
especially as it’s also come out that coutts were too good for Farage but apparently happy to take the money of the former PM of Qatar - seemingly quite a lot of it ….
but yeah, just capitalism 😂

OCaptain · 23/07/2023 10:52

AgathaSpencerGregson · 23/07/2023 10:04

And it’s probably worth you reading Catherine Bennett in the observer this morning, just to make sure you’ve a proper understanding of whose side you’re on here.
rather you than me. Ugh

We're picking sides? I'm not on anyone's "side" 😳

AgathaSpencerGregson · 23/07/2023 10:04

And it’s probably worth you reading Catherine Bennett in the observer this morning, just to make sure you’ve a proper understanding of whose side you’re on here.
rather you than me. Ugh

AgathaSpencerGregson · 23/07/2023 10:02

OCaptain · 23/07/2023 09:33

@AgathaSpencerGregson

It simply isn’t true that companies are free to withdraw services on any grounds they like. The EA 2010 prohibits discrimination by service providers on grounds of protected characteristics including belief. The extent to which that protects Farage in these circumstances is a matter of debate but please let’s move away from the incorrect premise that banks are free of constraint in this area. they are also bound by regulatory duties to act with integrity and treat customers fairly, as well as the act referred to above.

I didn't state they could withdraw service on "any grounds they like".

Your post stated that withdrawal of services by coutts was “just capitalism” and “a company exercising its rights.” No awareness or acknowledgment at all that coutts’ rights are far from untrammelled here and that there is room for debate over whether they have exceeded them. That needed a correction and it’s been given one.

OCaptain · 23/07/2023 09:33

@AgathaSpencerGregson

It simply isn’t true that companies are free to withdraw services on any grounds they like. The EA 2010 prohibits discrimination by service providers on grounds of protected characteristics including belief. The extent to which that protects Farage in these circumstances is a matter of debate but please let’s move away from the incorrect premise that banks are free of constraint in this area. they are also bound by regulatory duties to act with integrity and treat customers fairly, as well as the act referred to above.

I didn't state they could withdraw service on "any grounds they like".

TodayInahurry · 23/07/2023 08:53

There are tens of thousands of people out there who have had their accounts closed. Some may be for good reason, like fraud or whatever. But many are because of their beliefs. A parents group for gender critical people was refused a bank account because like 90% of people they objected to the trans evil being inflicted on their kids.

banks should judge people on facts, ie how much money they have and how they use the accounts. No on what they think of fashionable beliefs, how many MN people think a man can become a woman by putting on a frock and wanting access to rape crisis centres?

AgathaSpencerGregson · 23/07/2023 08:24

AgathaSpencerGregson · 23/07/2023 08:20

It simply isn’t true that companies are free to withdraw services on any grounds they like. The EA 2010 prohibits discrimination by service providers on grounds of protected characteristics including belief. The extent to which that protects Farage in these circumstances is a matter of debate but please let’s move away from the incorrect premise that banks are free of constraint in this area.
they are also bound by regulatory duties to act with integrity and treat customers fairly, as well as the act referred to above.

It seems this situation is leading lefties to the position that banks should be less regulated. Which is really very funny.

AgathaSpencerGregson · 23/07/2023 08:20

OCaptain · 23/07/2023 02:48

@1dayatatime

Here's the extract from Coutts confirming he met the financial threshold but taking the view that NF's views posed a reputation risk to Coutts:

Is this an internal memo? If so, who released it?

So, Coutts - a private company - has an issue with providing a service to an offensive individual, even though this individual is wealthy enough to afford their services. You have a problem with with that.

That is just capitalism.

It isn't isn't fascism/totalitarianism/whatever-ism is fashionable right now. It's simply a company exercising their rights.

And it isn't 1984. I'm so tired of people parroting "It's so Orwellian!"

Rant over. That wasn't directed at you specifically, but the general thread.

It simply isn’t true that companies are free to withdraw services on any grounds they like. The EA 2010 prohibits discrimination by service providers on grounds of protected characteristics including belief. The extent to which that protects Farage in these circumstances is a matter of debate but please let’s move away from the incorrect premise that banks are free of constraint in this area.
they are also bound by regulatory duties to act with integrity and treat customers fairly, as well as the act referred to above.

Moneynewpence · 23/07/2023 08:05

Moonberri · 18/07/2023 23:56

I think we're becoming more of an intolerant society. Ironically it tends to be the supposedly "inclusive" sections of society that seek to censor other people's thoughts and language. For example calling people bigoted for not believing that a man magically becomes a woman if he puts on a dress and a wig.

You really don't get irony, do you.

Xenia · 23/07/2023 08:02

OCap, NF used solicitors to make a data protection subject access request to see all the bank held on him. The long internal report was released by the bank. This is quite rare. Most customers cannot afford solicitors to exert legal rights and push back on these issues. What is interesting is that the bank took all kinds of subjective views of its own and also used information on social media without checking if it were true and that was used to close his long standing accounts.

NatWest then apparently gave the BBC an allegedly false press notice that his bank was closed because he did not meet the financial thresholds which was not true. The BBC then published that (and have now had to retract that). The report from the bank included a lot of very subjective reasons as to why they did not want him as a customer including that he had Thatcherite views. These kinds of reasons (given banking is pretty much an essential service unlike if you go to a shop to buy a pen) should not be used.

The other issue is that if one bank has refused services then I think that may be disclosable so it is not as simple as saying okay - free market - there are 100 other just as good banks you could use.

OCaptain · 23/07/2023 02:48

@1dayatatime

Here's the extract from Coutts confirming he met the financial threshold but taking the view that NF's views posed a reputation risk to Coutts:

Is this an internal memo? If so, who released it?

So, Coutts - a private company - has an issue with providing a service to an offensive individual, even though this individual is wealthy enough to afford their services. You have a problem with with that.

That is just capitalism.

It isn't isn't fascism/totalitarianism/whatever-ism is fashionable right now. It's simply a company exercising their rights.

And it isn't 1984. I'm so tired of people parroting "It's so Orwellian!"

Rant over. That wasn't directed at you specifically, but the general thread.

MyGuineaPigIs007 · 23/07/2023 00:37

It seems that religious minorities are risking being targeted as well because many Christians Muslims and ultra-orthodox Jews don't support LGBT. Whether you agree it not surely this is a freedom of speech/religion issue.

dimorphism · 23/07/2023 00:31

I mean really it's just 'we don't like NF so we're going to close his bank account'. Who gave these employees such power? Virtually everything in those emails could be contested, it's not based in fact or evidence it's all just opinion.

They even clearly state that NF has not broken any laws and that his political opinions are legally held. And STILL close his account. They clearly thought they COULD simply close the account of anyone they deemed unworthy.

I hope he sues the bank. It's really shocking and it seems it's not just him that's affected.

1dayatatime · 23/07/2023 00:11

@OCaptain

"My best is on Farage is being disingenuous here. Banks like you if you have money in your account; otherwise, the account is closed. (To simply things.) There's no need to start 'It's all totalitarian' when the case may be he simply didn't follow guidelines."

++++

Here's the extract from Coutts confirming he met the financial threshold but taking the view that NF's views posed a reputation risk to Coutts:

To think there is a worrying trend to cancel folk for opinions and thoughts
0021andabit · 22/07/2023 22:36

AlizeeEasy · 22/07/2023 22:30

Pretty sure Stella Creasy has campaigned quite heavily for abortion rights especially in Northern Ireland. She seems pretty pro choice

Oh absolutely sorry - I meant for her pro choice beliefs

MyGuineaPigIs007 · 22/07/2023 22:33

The thing with banks is scary. A reverend has his account cancelled because of his views on Pride. Agree or disagree , yes some may find his views offensive, but who is actually being oppressed by someone not liking pride flags in their bank? Not remotely comparable to anti-Semitism.

AlizeeEasy · 22/07/2023 22:30

0021andabit · 22/07/2023 07:15

I suppose that depends on what we mean by torn apart. Tim Farron certainly wasn’t cancelled by any definition - he’s still an MP, be still commentates regularly on TV & in print media.

I think the level of hatred & abuse MPs get is a different - & really important - issue. Stella Creasey has had a horrifying amount of abuse for being pro choice* - she was even forced to undergo a social services investigation because an online troll thought he was 'entitled' to the that her children should be put into care because of her pro life beliefs.

But I don’t think that the abuse they get is really a “thought police” or censorship issue, because it happens to politicians of all views & opinions (though sadly the evidence is it happens much, much more to MPs who are women and MPs of colour)

  • [Please note that this post has been edited at the poster's request. Post originally said 'pro life' in error].

Pretty sure Stella Creasy has campaigned quite heavily for abortion rights especially in Northern Ireland. She seems pretty pro choice

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 22/07/2023 14:03

What came before the black hole?
If god isn't fiction, where's the dinosaurs🤔
Bible was proof their god is malicious as all seeing and all knowing would have known what Adam and Eve were going to do.
Being an atheist avoids living life in a fairy tale.
All of this narcissistic narrative in life needs people playing along to give it credibility.
Simply don't give it any attention.

WhatNoRaisins · 22/07/2023 10:42

I remember when I was at university in the 2000s we'd have get togethers with people all over the political spectrum and even discuss things without a fall out. It's odd, when I talk about it now I feel like I'm making it up.

Tolerance and freedom of speech are maybe something we tend to take for granted will stick around rather than something we have to work for.

spiderplantparty · 22/07/2023 09:50

I agree that too many people seem to think the only correct views are the ones that they hold. I suspect part of the problem is social media where people can live in little bubbles where they don't come across different viewpoints which could lead to more understanding and tolerance.

malificent7 · 22/07/2023 09:40

It all boils down to being woke. What I think woke really means is that " left wing views are the only correct views. Everything else is bad/ wrong.
I say this as a lefty but I am sick of "woke."

Xenia · 22/07/2023 09:30

Thought police examples? I think there are quite a few. Teachers sacked because of the way they taught a biology lesson. An Indian man in the press today - bank account closed probably because they did not like some of his views (if the evidence from other cases is anything to go by). Men out of a job when not even convicted yet of a s exual offence - the old innocent until proven guilty seems out of the window at times.

I agree however that we should always go by evidence - real examples - like the Garden Court black lesbian barrister case (not just rumours). Having threads like this is good and I agree that rees Mogg is anti abortion and still in a job and we are certainly nothing like many of the worse countries on the planet in some of which it is the law that the death penalty exists if you renounce your faith ( I think on that point alone there are 9 countries worldwide).

We have not closed churches and mosques down for readings from the Bible and Koran whch are anti-gay or sexist . We remain a fairly liberal tolerant society but we have to fight to stay like that.

0021andabit · 22/07/2023 07:15

DdraigGoch · 22/07/2023 01:58

I remember Tim Farron being torn apart over the issue when he was Lib Dem leader. Even though he took the liberal viewpoint that while he didn't agree with it as a Catholic, what other people did with their consiences was their business.

I suppose that depends on what we mean by torn apart. Tim Farron certainly wasn’t cancelled by any definition - he’s still an MP, be still commentates regularly on TV & in print media.

I think the level of hatred & abuse MPs get is a different - & really important - issue. Stella Creasey has had a horrifying amount of abuse for being pro choice* - she was even forced to undergo a social services investigation because an online troll thought he was 'entitled' to the that her children should be put into care because of her pro life beliefs.

But I don’t think that the abuse they get is really a “thought police” or censorship issue, because it happens to politicians of all views & opinions (though sadly the evidence is it happens much, much more to MPs who are women and MPs of colour)

  • [Please note that this post has been edited at the poster's request. Post originally said 'pro life' in error].
Swipe left for the next trending thread