Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect the cleaner to clean for the time she’s paid?

111 replies

Annatinks · 18/07/2023 22:27

Hubby and I both work full time (my hours exceed full time vastly - my choice) We have a two year old son and a late teen who has MH struggles.

Whilst we’ve always tried to be tidy, I’ve been constantly frustrated by the deep cleaning things taking the minimal free time I get and how tired I always am (autoimmune disease). My husband is good at general tidy but doesn’t really notice things like skirting boards, glass cleaning, light shades, door handles etc.

When he was promoted recently with a small but noticeable pay rise he spoke to me about the idea of employing a cleaner to do those deep clean things fortnightly and to mop/hoover etc so on the day before/day of/day after we have a bit more family downtime. I was quite negative about it because of feeling like “we’re not that kind of people” but then feeling horribly judgemental and saying yes we’d try it.

The cleaner is amazing 🤩
She came and had a look round visit and suggested things she could do in the two hours she proposed she comes each fortnight. She polishes the taps so they look new and her hoover is soooo much better than ours!

But…

She’s only been 4 times and last fortnight she left arrived late and left early (about 20min less time). Hubby said a mild “oh are you off already?” (I wasn’t there, he WFH) and she explained how yes she’s got to know our 2bed house better now so it doesn’t take her as long. She then made some comment about having to drop some clients before because they didn’t understand that.

Is this normal? Should a cleaner who quotes two hours and is paid two hours be able to knock off early regularly?
Neither of us get to knock off early for efficiency so it seems unreasonable to me?

Hubny wants to cancel her because he feels like she’s going to take the Mickey ongoing but I’ve appreciated the help soooo much I’m reluctant for it to stop.

OP posts:
hopsalong · 18/07/2023 23:27

How much are you actually paying her? If it's £30+ for two hours then, yes, she needs to find something else to clean. If it's more like £20-25 then you're underpaying her and I can see why she's leaving early once the basic work is done.

nokidshere · 18/07/2023 23:21

Our cleaner also does 2hrs. I employ her to clean (no tidying) living room, kitchen, dining room, 3 bathrooms, sweep & mop all downstairs, Hoover all upstairs. These are core jobs and always get done. It never takes 2hrs, sometimes it's more, sometimes less depending on how much traffic the house has had that week.

She brings her own equipment, she buys my cleaning stuff when she's doing her shopping, if I ask her to do an extra job such as clean the fridge/microwave or windows and/or blinds she will happily oblige.

So if it's just been me & dh at home and there's no extra jobs I don't begrudge her leaving earlier than the 2 hours.

Whadda · 18/07/2023 23:19

I’ve had cleaners for years and, in my experience, a good one is worth their weight in gold.

My current cleaner has been with me now for 2.5 years. She does three hours once a week and I wouldn’t even think to see what time she arrives or leaves. All I know is that my house is spotless, she’s lovely, and I trust her.

Annatinks · 18/07/2023 23:18

Lovingitallnow · 18/07/2023 23:13

My cleaner used to do 2 hours. We've moved house and she said it would take an hour longer more or less. Some weeks she'll get it done it 2.5 hours, some weeks it's messier and it will take the 3 hours. Some weeks she'll do things like hoover and put a damp cloth over the headboards, or start cleaning out the fridge. If I want a specific job done I'll ask her. But I'm paying her to clean the house and not for the hours. I'd say that's what she's saying to you about the 2 hours- you're paying her for a job, if you want to charge by the hour she might not be interested. It's up to you- is the house as clean after 1 hour and 40 mins?

We felt like there were some short cuts. Eg she says she general cleans the kitchen (we always have the washing and dishes done already) but it’s only externally and I was surprised that she didn’t wipe over the blinds or clean the inner microwave. But then perhaps we were looking for improvements because we felt short changed?

She hasn’t ever stay over and doesn’t chat much because hubby is usually in zoom meetings and I’m usually in the office

OP posts:
Jk987 · 18/07/2023 23:18

So many stingy taskmasters on here. The OP said the cleaner is amazing! I repeat amazing! Where is the thanks? Perhaps I'm missing something and she's paid £50 an hour or something. I'd imagine it's more like a tenner though.

Annatinks · 18/07/2023 23:15

Fudgewomble · 18/07/2023 23:01

I write a very long list in order of importance and our cleaners work through it in that order. They are clear that they won’t get through it all but it means there’s a very clear expectation that it’s not a “task-based” engagement, it’s time focussed They would not be finishing 20 minutes early - they are paid per hour and work to the hour give or take a few minutes. Jobs toward the end of the list include ironing (always a huge pile on the go), polishing mirrors, polishing silver picture frames, cleaning fridge shelves, door knobs, light switches, indoor windows etc. we have two separate ladies, each once a week for 5 hours apiece. Neither have ever left early.

Depending on if you feel comfortable doing so I’d hugely appreciate a PM of your list so I could copy the things relevant to our home.

We literally clean before the cleaner comes because we don’t want her to think of us as untidy 🙈 🤣 We feel a bit outclassed in the knowing how this works!

OP posts:
Lovingitallnow · 18/07/2023 23:13

My cleaner used to do 2 hours. We've moved house and she said it would take an hour longer more or less. Some weeks she'll get it done it 2.5 hours, some weeks it's messier and it will take the 3 hours. Some weeks she'll do things like hoover and put a damp cloth over the headboards, or start cleaning out the fridge. If I want a specific job done I'll ask her. But I'm paying her to clean the house and not for the hours. I'd say that's what she's saying to you about the 2 hours- you're paying her for a job, if you want to charge by the hour she might not be interested. It's up to you- is the house as clean after 1 hour and 40 mins?

OhNoYouDidnnt · 18/07/2023 23:13

Shes taking the piss. Paid for 2 hours, should be staying 2 hours.

Annatinks · 18/07/2023 23:11

OhNoYouDidnnt · 18/07/2023 22:54

Did you book her for 2 hours and she agreed to what could be done in the 2 hours? Or did you agree to set jobs?

Reading your post she proposed 2 hours a fortnight and this is what can be done. She is doing what you agreed to, so you are paying for what you agreed to pay for. But did she say I charge x amount an hour, or I am charging you x amount for the jobs I've agreed to do?

We felt like it was the former but perhaps our inexperience misunderstood the latter. She told us her hourly rate, we said we could afford two hours and she suggested things she could do while here

OP posts:
WhatWouldTheDoctorDo · 18/07/2023 23:10

As she is paid by the hour, I would say that DH has mentioned that she said it isn't actually taking her two hours to do the jobs you agreed so could she also do x, y or z whenever she has spare time? Though I'd keep it friendly if she's good - decent cleaners are worth their weight in gold!

Ours is trustworthy and reliable, and does a decent standard clean, which is what I need her to do, but she's not all that at deep clean work (have asked sometimes when we've been on holiday), I'd forgive her an earlier finish if she was fantastic at that!

Jk987 · 18/07/2023 23:08

You say she's amazing and you couldn't do without her so don't! If she completes everything to a high standard in less than 2 hours, she deserves to get rewarded!

What more do you want exactly? She pretend to dust for 20 mins? Clean an area that's not part of her job?

Or you could replace her with a mediocre cleaner who does an ok job for the full 120 mins.

On another note, you could stop your voluntary, unpaid extra hours at work you chose to do and give yourself some more free time. Sounds like you're trying to apply your bonkers standards to your cleaner!

MsFogi · 18/07/2023 23:07

If she's taking the piss already it will only get worse - within six months she'll be doing an hour and you'll be paying for two. She is paid by the hour (not by the job) and should therefore do the time or you should find another cleaner.

Soontobe60 · 18/07/2023 23:06

This could be looked at 2 ways:
A) client has a specific list of tasks to be completed, cleaner quotes for those tasks and says it’s around X hours.
B) client employs a cleaner for X hours and asks them to complete as much as they can from a list of tasks in that time.
Id be happy with A as long as the standard of cleanliness is high, but I’d also be happy with B as long as the cleaner wasn’t being purposely slow to fill the time.

MillicentBystander2022 · 18/07/2023 23:05

I'm a cleaner who sometimes leaves a job 10ish minutes early if I've finished. However! On the days it takes longer and I don't get everything finished within the time, I stay until it is done. Sometimes an extra 20-30 minutes and I don't bill my client for it.

No one has ever complained or dropped me for it, but I would expect them to if I was only leaving early and not staying longer.

If she is a good cleaner and you are happy, you could just think of it as a tip/pay her only for 1 hour 40. You could have a list of 10-20 minute jobs you can ask her to do if she has time left over. Or just look for another cleaner.

Fudgewomble · 18/07/2023 23:01

I write a very long list in order of importance and our cleaners work through it in that order. They are clear that they won’t get through it all but it means there’s a very clear expectation that it’s not a “task-based” engagement, it’s time focussed They would not be finishing 20 minutes early - they are paid per hour and work to the hour give or take a few minutes. Jobs toward the end of the list include ironing (always a huge pile on the go), polishing mirrors, polishing silver picture frames, cleaning fridge shelves, door knobs, light switches, indoor windows etc. we have two separate ladies, each once a week for 5 hours apiece. Neither have ever left early.

zurala · 18/07/2023 22:59

Cleaner, not cleaver, obviously.

zurala · 18/07/2023 22:59

StillPerplexed · 18/07/2023 22:47

My view, as someone who once did cleaning at a small hotel, is that there is a list of stuff a cleaner has to get through, and the more often you do it the quicker you become. I'm sure you'd rather she didn't dawdle while doing the essential stuff. I don't see the issue in leaving early if she's done the stuff.

If the house is still filthy then that's a different question, but you don't need her polishing the silverware for ten minutes at the end of her shift.

As someone who used to work as a cleaner, rubbish! As a domestic cleaver you should do the time you are being paid for and find extra jobs to do if you finish early. There's always something to do! Clean light switches, dust lampshades, clean skirtings, wipe down cupboards. If you are being paid by the hour then you fill up your time.

HappiestSleeping · 18/07/2023 22:56

Fluffycloudsblusky · 18/07/2023 22:36

There is always something to clean in a house. You are paying for two hours cleaning time. Not a certain number of items/areas to clean.

You could write a list of things that can be done eg strip and remake a bed, clean the microwave, wash window. Ask her to add those in if she runs out of things to clean in the two hours . It’s totally reasonable.

This 👆

I would either work out how much less to pay based on the reduced hours, or better still per the quoted comment give a list of other stuff to fill the time.

I can just imagine the face of any of my previous employers in the corporate world if I said "I've done my work now, I'm going home" 🤣

OhNoYouDidnnt · 18/07/2023 22:54

Did you book her for 2 hours and she agreed to what could be done in the 2 hours? Or did you agree to set jobs?

Reading your post she proposed 2 hours a fortnight and this is what can be done. She is doing what you agreed to, so you are paying for what you agreed to pay for. But did she say I charge x amount an hour, or I am charging you x amount for the jobs I've agreed to do?

BatheInTheLight · 18/07/2023 22:53

I 'know my house' very well, but it still takes me the same amount of time to hoover and mop the kitchen floor as it ever did! She's being a CF.

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 18/07/2023 22:52

It depends did she wuote you an hourly rate or the total for the job? More and more cleaners are quoting for job and finish. Personally i hate this as it opens it up to abuse. We just got rid of a cleaner who said after experimenting with our house (also know as skiving off early from the 3 hours she was paid for months!). She could do it in around 2 hours and for that it would be £50. I politely told her where to go. £25 an hour is ridiculous and she was majorly cutting corners in that.

If the cleaner quoted for the jobs you asked and said its x amount and it would take around 2 hours I think you let it go. If she quotes x amount per hour i'd chuck some extra jobs on to do.

Whichwhatnow · 18/07/2023 22:51

Hmm our cleaner is amazing (truly) and does finish 10-15 or so mins early relatively regularly. I kind of see it as paying for the service rather than specific hours - we had a cleaner before her who always did exactly two hours but got far less done (and far less well) in that time than our current cleaner. I do sometimes ask her to do 'extras' like cleaning out the oven or the fridge which she happily does but won't necessarily do stuff like that automatically to fill the last 10-15 mins provided everything else is done.

I'm happy with the current situation but if you're not, maybe just suggest some extras to do when she has time (could also include eg organising and cleaning inside cupboards, cleaning the inside of windows, folding laundry etc?).

Circumferences · 18/07/2023 22:49

My parents had a cleaner (when I was an adult) and when I stayed at my parents house while the cleaner was there I'm pretty sure the cleaner was basically pretending to clean for some of her shift! Two hours is a long time....

You need to perhaps say can you do the bins or do the dusting on the whatevers or very specific things rather than just let her leave 20 mins early.

Unexpectedlysinglemum · 18/07/2023 22:48

HundredMilesAnHour · 18/07/2023 22:47

I have a cleaner for 2 hours every fortnight, and sometimes if I'm at home we get chatting, and she doesn't even charge me for the chatting time. So she might be here for 2.5 hours but she only bills me for 2 hours.

Your cleaner is taking the mickey. BUT good cleaners are hard to come by so think carefully if you decide to give her notice.

My cleaner always done this too and I feel awkward if I don't pay her a little bit more but she always tells me not to as it was her who was being chatty (true!)

StillPerplexed · 18/07/2023 22:47

My view, as someone who once did cleaning at a small hotel, is that there is a list of stuff a cleaner has to get through, and the more often you do it the quicker you become. I'm sure you'd rather she didn't dawdle while doing the essential stuff. I don't see the issue in leaving early if she's done the stuff.

If the house is still filthy then that's a different question, but you don't need her polishing the silverware for ten minutes at the end of her shift.