Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect the cleaner to clean for the time she’s paid?

111 replies

Annatinks · 18/07/2023 22:27

Hubby and I both work full time (my hours exceed full time vastly - my choice) We have a two year old son and a late teen who has MH struggles.

Whilst we’ve always tried to be tidy, I’ve been constantly frustrated by the deep cleaning things taking the minimal free time I get and how tired I always am (autoimmune disease). My husband is good at general tidy but doesn’t really notice things like skirting boards, glass cleaning, light shades, door handles etc.

When he was promoted recently with a small but noticeable pay rise he spoke to me about the idea of employing a cleaner to do those deep clean things fortnightly and to mop/hoover etc so on the day before/day of/day after we have a bit more family downtime. I was quite negative about it because of feeling like “we’re not that kind of people” but then feeling horribly judgemental and saying yes we’d try it.

The cleaner is amazing 🤩
She came and had a look round visit and suggested things she could do in the two hours she proposed she comes each fortnight. She polishes the taps so they look new and her hoover is soooo much better than ours!

But…

She’s only been 4 times and last fortnight she left arrived late and left early (about 20min less time). Hubby said a mild “oh are you off already?” (I wasn’t there, he WFH) and she explained how yes she’s got to know our 2bed house better now so it doesn’t take her as long. She then made some comment about having to drop some clients before because they didn’t understand that.

Is this normal? Should a cleaner who quotes two hours and is paid two hours be able to knock off early regularly?
Neither of us get to knock off early for efficiency so it seems unreasonable to me?

Hubny wants to cancel her because he feels like she’s going to take the Mickey ongoing but I’ve appreciated the help soooo much I’m reluctant for it to stop.

OP posts:
ikno · 19/07/2023 01:46

I think you didn’t set the right expectations from the start. Did you or your husband say to her that you expect the inside of the microwave to be cleaned? Maybe get a list of tasks ready for her next visit and see how she responds

AnotherTownAnotherTrain · 19/07/2023 01:37

Soontobe60 · 18/07/2023 23:06

This could be looked at 2 ways:
A) client has a specific list of tasks to be completed, cleaner quotes for those tasks and says it’s around X hours.
B) client employs a cleaner for X hours and asks them to complete as much as they can from a list of tasks in that time.
Id be happy with A as long as the standard of cleanliness is high, but I’d also be happy with B as long as the cleaner wasn’t being purposely slow to fill the time.

This is how I see it too.

Blossomtoes · 19/07/2023 01:33

As far as I’m concerned I’m paying for a clean house. As long as it’s done thoroughly and to the standard I want I don’t care how long it takes.

egowise · 19/07/2023 01:29

If my cleaner finishes early, she finds things to do or tells me to pay less. I never do, in fact I over pay because I think she charges too little and she is great.

Coming home to vacuumed stairs makes me so incredibly happy.

Things she done extra include folding washing, taking everything from the top of the cupboards and cleaning them, the windows, carpet/sofa washing.

I am so very lucky!

ThinWomansBrain · 19/07/2023 01:22

either suggest that she comes for an hour and a half, or as suggested by a PP, provide a reserve list of tasks she can move on to if she finishes early.
20 minutes is quite a large chunk out of 120 minutes.

ASandwichNamedKevin · 19/07/2023 01:16

I commented on a similar thread recently
https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4733876-to-be-annoyed-at-cleaner-leaving-early?page=1

My cleaner was leaving early and the finish wasn't amazing so we are looking for someone new. I want to pay by the hour and get the time I'm paying for, if my job gets easier/more efficient because I create a spreadsheet or database I can't just finish early, I do more or move to another task. If a cleaning job gets easier because the room has been cleaned more regularly in the time that I'm paying for it to be cleaned, then I'd prefer the cleaner to do something else in the remaining time.
My previous cleaner used to wipe down the bin or empty the hoover or wipe inside the fridge or whatever, she was a also happy to fold laundry but we moved house too far away.

To be annoyed at cleaner leaving early | Mumsnet

So firstly I realise that having a cleaner is a luxury! Anyway..our cleaner comes once every 2 weeks for 3 hours. She was recommended by a colleague...

https://www.mumsnet.com/talk/am_i_being_unreasonable/4733876-to-be-annoyed-at-cleaner-leaving-early?page=1

Twatalert · 19/07/2023 01:03

Agree you need to pull her up on it. I made the same mistake. At first they left 10 mins early and in the end 30 mins was standard. I was a complete mug and her cleaning wasn't thorough enough to just say 'shes doing a very good job and I don't care it takes her less than 2 hours'.

She also messed me around quite a bit, which also got worse overtime. She thought she could move around her slot to whatever time suited her at short notice. Always an excuse to do with family. I had enough when she decided she wanted to come a different time (not day) because of her adult sons birthday. I finally told her I have a work schedule with prearranged meetings and I couldn't keep accommodating her family at a whim. That day she fired me by text because I had apparently disrespected her family.

My current cleaner is amazing and I do not care at all if she leaves 10 mins early because not once has she taken the piss and my home is absolutely shiny.

The fact that yours says she had to drop clients because of it is a red flag and she knows it's an issue.

Uokhon · 19/07/2023 00:46

I would expect the microwave to be cleaned two-weekly and definitely the toothpaste spray.

I would make a list of things that have been missed and ask her to add them in plus other things like wiping out the fridge, if it pushes her over 2 hours then cut some things back or renegotiate the rate/hours.

mathanxiety · 19/07/2023 00:37

I can't for the life of me understand why cleaning is paid according to time in the UK.

Surely the better way of arranging the work/ payment agreement is to have a list of tasks that need to be done, and pay by task?

It surely makes sense that once the built up grime from, for example, skirting boards or bathroom tiles is dealt with in the initial cleanings, the cleaner will require less time to clean as there simply won't be as much dirt stuck on the surfaces she cleans?

Once the initial deep cleaning is done, regular maintenance cleaning takes less time.

Do you want her to stand there polishing the taps for twenty minutes even though everything she was expected to clean is clean?

Hillary17 · 19/07/2023 00:37

Our cleaner does 3 hours a time. To be honest sometimes it’s less and she’ll leave 15 minutes early, but only if everything is completed. I don’t because equally she does more time when needed and in the grand scheme of things it balances out. Over Christmas for example she did an oven spruce and didn’t charge extra, or something will do all the windows and stay and extra 30 mins. She’s a good cleaner (hard to find) and I’m happy it all balances in the end.

ChocChipHandbag · 19/07/2023 00:33

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 19/07/2023 00:12

I would consider the inside of a microwave to be an element of a periodic deep clean, not part of a weekly 2-hour clean. (Weekly full day clean, yes to inside micro.)

The toothpaste spray is gross. It's essentially a bodily fluid and you should clean that yourself.

Don’t be ridiculous! She said that the toothpaste sprays because her son switches on he brush before it goes in his mouth! No saliva involved but even if there were, of course cleaning toothpaste stains is part of the bathroom clean.

OP just politely point out the jobs that she’s missed that you’d like her to do. Don’t link it to time spent, see what she says..

My cleaner often forgets to do inside microwave. I usually say “ oh I had something a bit messy in there this week, do you mind?” And make out it’s my fault. He’s never complained about being asked.

ChocChipHandbag · 19/07/2023 00:25

Fudgewomble · 18/07/2023 23:01

I write a very long list in order of importance and our cleaners work through it in that order. They are clear that they won’t get through it all but it means there’s a very clear expectation that it’s not a “task-based” engagement, it’s time focussed They would not be finishing 20 minutes early - they are paid per hour and work to the hour give or take a few minutes. Jobs toward the end of the list include ironing (always a huge pile on the go), polishing mirrors, polishing silver picture frames, cleaning fridge shelves, door knobs, light switches, indoor windows etc. we have two separate ladies, each once a week for 5 hours apiece. Neither have ever left early.

Wow. Two cleaners doing a total of 5 hours each! Do you Iive in Downton Abbey?

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 19/07/2023 00:12

I would consider the inside of a microwave to be an element of a periodic deep clean, not part of a weekly 2-hour clean. (Weekly full day clean, yes to inside micro.)

The toothpaste spray is gross. It's essentially a bodily fluid and you should clean that yourself.

Annaishere · 19/07/2023 00:11

YABU you’re paying her for a job not time. If it is time then why ?

Annatinks · 19/07/2023 00:08

hopsalong · 18/07/2023 23:54

I think £30 is a good salary outside central London and middling in it. If you aren't in an expensive part of the country (sorry if I've missed this) and if she isn't working for an agency (taking possibly a large cut) then you're perfectly reasonable to insist on her staying for the full time. Cleaners do take time to learn about your house but it's more that they aren't able to work efficiently, even if very experienced and good at the job, for the first couple of weeks. £15 is a reasonable p/h wage for cleaning for the entire hour if it's paid in cash, she keeps all of it, and you aren't in central London. If you are, then I would consider paying £16 / £17 p/h and insisting that she works for the two hours, cleaning whatever there is to clean.

It might also be that your house is already very clean and there genuinely isn't much to do! I have no experience of this...

We live in Sussex so definitely not central London. No agency involvement and she’s paid cash (whether she declares it or not I don’t know)

The house is tidy and surface clean but on closer inspection definitely not clean. That kinda level where friends could pop in unexpected fine but I’d be mortified if my mother did.

@ZeldaWillTellYourFortune @squidgybits this is precisely WHY I’m asking. I don’t want to be too picky but neither a mug and we have zero experience hiring household workers. As previously said to @Jk987 I think she’s amazing because I’m not having to do these things but there are things missed that I’m surprised aren’t done (eg only outer microwave is wiped over not inside) so I’m trying to get a balanced view

OP posts:
Annatinks · 19/07/2023 00:00

Thank you @tigerbear0906
It’s helpful to have your perspective.

Do you have any templates of what you would guess is a suitable achievement in 2hrs if all tidying is completed in advance of arrival on a small 2bed terrace? (Only thing bedrooms have done is hoovering/mopping)

OP posts:
earsup · 18/07/2023 23:59

If a good worker i wouldnt worry too much but might leave a list, i just fired a student who was meant to help me with the garden but he just stood about and watched my bees.......very slow...got rid !!

squidgybits · 18/07/2023 23:59

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 18/07/2023 23:56

I know.

If her work is satisfactory, I wouldn't quibble about a few minutes here and there.

People who are paranoid about being "ripped off" perhaps shouldn't employ household workers.

👏

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 18/07/2023 23:56

Jk987 · 18/07/2023 23:18

So many stingy taskmasters on here. The OP said the cleaner is amazing! I repeat amazing! Where is the thanks? Perhaps I'm missing something and she's paid £50 an hour or something. I'd imagine it's more like a tenner though.

I know.

If her work is satisfactory, I wouldn't quibble about a few minutes here and there.

People who are paranoid about being "ripped off" perhaps shouldn't employ household workers.

hopsalong · 18/07/2023 23:54

I think £30 is a good salary outside central London and middling in it. If you aren't in an expensive part of the country (sorry if I've missed this) and if she isn't working for an agency (taking possibly a large cut) then you're perfectly reasonable to insist on her staying for the full time. Cleaners do take time to learn about your house but it's more that they aren't able to work efficiently, even if very experienced and good at the job, for the first couple of weeks. £15 is a reasonable p/h wage for cleaning for the entire hour if it's paid in cash, she keeps all of it, and you aren't in central London. If you are, then I would consider paying £16 / £17 p/h and insisting that she works for the two hours, cleaning whatever there is to clean.

It might also be that your house is already very clean and there genuinely isn't much to do! I have no experience of this...

tigerbear0906 · 18/07/2023 23:44

I run a domestic cleaning business. This is one reason why we don't charge per hour but quote for a full house clean. After attending for a while cleaners will naturally speed up as they get to know the house, deeper jobs such as tackling limescale/ mould etc is on top of so quicker each week to clean. Obviously some jobs may then take longer one visit if things are particularly untidy, heavily soiled etc. it's awful to feel someone is timing you to the minute if you are fully cleaning what is agreed and working hard and taking pride in your job.
I would clarify if you are paying her per job or for her time. Obviously if it's for her time then she needs more jobs to do as 20 minutes is a long time to be finishing early in my opinion.

TreadLightly3 · 18/07/2023 23:32

I agree with the PPs who say she’s taking the piss. It is also a personal pet hate of mine when a cleaner makes a veiled threat like yours did about other clients she had to drop because they didn’t understand her leaving early. It’s happened to me before and is a power play to try to put you in the weaker position of needing her more than she needs you.

It’s very unpleasant to say the least when you’re paying her the hourly rate she asked for and up to what you can afford.

My advice is you need to stand up to her now or these power plays will continue and probably get worse over time. It might seem crap now when you think she’s doing such a great job but honestly it never goes well when someone you’ve hired to do a job makes you feel like they’ve got you over a barrel/like a mug.

Annatinks · 18/07/2023 23:31

Yes it’s £30 for the two hours which seemed mid average for our area

OP posts:
Annatinks · 18/07/2023 23:30

Jk987 · 18/07/2023 23:18

So many stingy taskmasters on here. The OP said the cleaner is amazing! I repeat amazing! Where is the thanks? Perhaps I'm missing something and she's paid £50 an hour or something. I'd imagine it's more like a tenner though.

It’s £15 per hour.

I think she’s amazing because she’s saving me doing things that I never have the energy to do. Having said that I have zero cleaner experiences to compare it to? She does miss things that I would presume would be done (eg we have a fancy soap dispenser in the bathroom that our 2yr old sprays toothpaste on because he turns the brush on when it’s not in his mouth yet, I kinda thought if she’s cleaning the bathroom that sort it of thing would be done but it isn’t)

OP posts:
aloris · 18/07/2023 23:29

Annatinks · 18/07/2023 23:11

We felt like it was the former but perhaps our inexperience misunderstood the latter. She told us her hourly rate, we said we could afford two hours and she suggested things she could do while here

I think since you negotiated the arrangement based on her hourly rate and your being able to afford 2 hours, then you should hold her to that. Her shortening the time and saying she had to drop clients because they didn't understand that, is her attempt to get out of the deal she sold to you and that you consented to. I would consider that to be out of bounds and I wouldn't trust her. I would feel like she was always looking for another angle to wiggle out of what she said she would do.

What is the normal hourly rate in your area and is she in that range?

Swipe left for the next trending thread