Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect the cleaner to clean for the time she’s paid?

111 replies

Annatinks · 18/07/2023 22:27

Hubby and I both work full time (my hours exceed full time vastly - my choice) We have a two year old son and a late teen who has MH struggles.

Whilst we’ve always tried to be tidy, I’ve been constantly frustrated by the deep cleaning things taking the minimal free time I get and how tired I always am (autoimmune disease). My husband is good at general tidy but doesn’t really notice things like skirting boards, glass cleaning, light shades, door handles etc.

When he was promoted recently with a small but noticeable pay rise he spoke to me about the idea of employing a cleaner to do those deep clean things fortnightly and to mop/hoover etc so on the day before/day of/day after we have a bit more family downtime. I was quite negative about it because of feeling like “we’re not that kind of people” but then feeling horribly judgemental and saying yes we’d try it.

The cleaner is amazing 🤩
She came and had a look round visit and suggested things she could do in the two hours she proposed she comes each fortnight. She polishes the taps so they look new and her hoover is soooo much better than ours!

But…

She’s only been 4 times and last fortnight she left arrived late and left early (about 20min less time). Hubby said a mild “oh are you off already?” (I wasn’t there, he WFH) and she explained how yes she’s got to know our 2bed house better now so it doesn’t take her as long. She then made some comment about having to drop some clients before because they didn’t understand that.

Is this normal? Should a cleaner who quotes two hours and is paid two hours be able to knock off early regularly?
Neither of us get to knock off early for efficiency so it seems unreasonable to me?

Hubny wants to cancel her because he feels like she’s going to take the Mickey ongoing but I’ve appreciated the help soooo much I’m reluctant for it to stop.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
pollymere · 07/12/2023 19:20

I would find twenty minutes worth of tasks for her to do. "Freshen bathroom/toilet", Clean kitchen sink and worktops", vacuum upstairs/downstairs on alternate sessions all come to mind.

Alternatively, pay her for 1 hrs 45...

I tutor students and some pay for 45 mins rather than an hour. So if she's earning £20/ph, She'd get £35 and not £40.

Bertiesmum3 · 07/12/2023 16:13

Annatinks · 18/07/2023 23:18

We felt like there were some short cuts. Eg she says she general cleans the kitchen (we always have the washing and dishes done already) but it’s only externally and I was surprised that she didn’t wipe over the blinds or clean the inner microwave. But then perhaps we were looking for improvements because we felt short changed?

She hasn’t ever stay over and doesn’t chat much because hubby is usually in zoom meetings and I’m usually in the office

She doesn’t wipe inside the microwave?
I should think this should be done after every time it’s used!!!
The same with taps they need to be cleaned every time they’re used too to get rid of watermarks!!
you sound like you’re expecting too much from your cleaner as most cleaning jobs need to be done every day, I think it’s ridiculous only having a house cleaned every 2 weeks for 2 hours

changingmyname143 · 23/07/2023 21:55

You're paying for time, not a list of jobs. I always give a list of "if time" jobs above our usual clean in case ours finishes early.

Annatinks · 23/07/2023 21:15

After the amount of things missed for example we thought to look back on the baby monitor and she was in that room less than 6min - didn’t dust the shelves (not even the edges), definitely hoovered round the small play rugs and only mopped the doorway 🙄 we text to say a (very nice) sorry we need to cancel this service; she replied ok, no worries - didn’t ask why at all. I think maybe I thought she was better than she was because I was just grateful not to be doing it myself and because the first few cleans really were good standard.

OP posts:
Irridescantshimmmer · 22/07/2023 13:58

She's trying to wriggle her way out of it.

NeedToChangeName · 22/07/2023 13:58

Fudgewomble · 18/07/2023 23:01

I write a very long list in order of importance and our cleaners work through it in that order. They are clear that they won’t get through it all but it means there’s a very clear expectation that it’s not a “task-based” engagement, it’s time focussed They would not be finishing 20 minutes early - they are paid per hour and work to the hour give or take a few minutes. Jobs toward the end of the list include ironing (always a huge pile on the go), polishing mirrors, polishing silver picture frames, cleaning fridge shelves, door knobs, light switches, indoor windows etc. we have two separate ladies, each once a week for 5 hours apiece. Neither have ever left early.

@Fudgewomble I think that's a great approach. Wish I'd done that

NeedToChangeName · 22/07/2023 13:55

Whichwhatnow · 18/07/2023 22:51

Hmm our cleaner is amazing (truly) and does finish 10-15 or so mins early relatively regularly. I kind of see it as paying for the service rather than specific hours - we had a cleaner before her who always did exactly two hours but got far less done (and far less well) in that time than our current cleaner. I do sometimes ask her to do 'extras' like cleaning out the oven or the fridge which she happily does but won't necessarily do stuff like that automatically to fill the last 10-15 mins provided everything else is done.

I'm happy with the current situation but if you're not, maybe just suggest some extras to do when she has time (could also include eg organising and cleaning inside cupboards, cleaning the inside of windows, folding laundry etc?).

@Whichwhatnow Same here. Our claner always leaves 15 mins early and it irritates me a little, but she does a lot while she's here, and to a very high standard, so I try to think of it as her reward for efficiency / her tea break

Wendysfriend · 22/07/2023 13:53

Leaving 35 minutes early and bringing a child with her... 😲 Nah, I'd get someone else especially if her standards have dropped too. All these minutes add up, if everyone left half an hour early from their job they'd owe their companies money.

nevynevster · 22/07/2023 13:46

I pay my cleaner a set amount every week. If she does it quicker then good but it takes her longer because she's a bit slower that day then also that's on her. I think it's fairest that way as she knows what she needs to do ie kitchen, bathrooms, hoover and mop and as long as it's all done then great.
Good cleaners are hard to come by so maybe you need to discuss with her a set amount arrangement for x, y, z tasks or ask her if she's now familiar with the house would she be able to do some other stuff in the time available. But don't accuse her of cutting you short as she could easily leave by yhe sounds of it

Kaiserchief · 22/07/2023 13:33

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 22/07/2023 09:15

£25 an hour is not fine when the going rate for the area is £15 per hour (i contacted about 30 cleaners to find one and the average was this). £25 per hour is also more than a top band 6 nurse gets per hour! By £4! And i'm sorry but a nurse is a hell of a lot more qualified than a cleaner.

Also the only reason we were given for this jump was "its the biggest house I clean for the least money". She cleans 4 bed house down the road that she consistently spends 3-3.5 hours on and is charging the same. Ours needs 3 hours if done properly. Its a large house. But we only ever have 1 bedroom done in it. She cuts corners and rushes it to get it done in 2 hours to go off elsewhere. None of my pictures are ever dusted, skirtings covered in dust despite being asked. She was good to start with but got cheekier and cheekier. She got a reputation and took advantage of it. I have no patience for that. We treat our cleaners well. Large christmas bonus. Offer a coffee etc. Tidy before they come. Make their lives easier if we can in anyway they ask such as changing times/days if they need to at short notice. I have huge respect for our cleaners. But not when they're demanding a wage thats waaaay beyond their worth and justifying it because we have a big house.

When looking for cleaners there's a lot of chancers out there now it seems. Its seen as 'easy' money. I contacted on person who quoted £80 for the job...she'd just started out. Had 1 reference and had loads of availability. I wonder why!

Why do you get to decide what I charge? I can charge £25/hr even though the average round here is £15/hr. You’re going to be really cross when I tell you my deep cleans are £45/hr. I give a price before booking and I have a long waiting list.

I’m not sure how you came up with the comparison between a cleaner and a nurse? Nurses aren’t underpaid because cleaners can earn a good living. Nurses get holiday pay, sick pay and a pension. We’re self employed. If I’m ill, I don’t get paid. I have zero job security. It’s not ‘easy money’, it’s a hard physical job plus you’re running your own business which comes with a lot of admin. Many cleaners don’t do it for long and go back to having a job.

Many jobs don’t require a high level of academic qualifications yet are extremely well-paid - I have friends in six figure sales roles who left school at 16. I’m educated to post graduate level but I earn more cleaning than I ever did when I had a ‘proper job’ using my degrees.

Some people want a cheap cleaner but amazing results. You can’t always have both and it’s often a case of buy cheap, buy twice.

PolaDeVeboise · 22/07/2023 10:19

With regard to rates, I've found out that it's actually CHEAPER in London - my friends all pay in the region of £15 an hour, whereas, in Central Scotland and Dorset way it's @£19. We figured it was because of the abundance of cleaners in London.

Oh, and she's not that great if she doesn't even clean bathroom taps!

Soozikinzii · 22/07/2023 09:26

I'd observe her yourself and ask her to clean the fridge IF she's got time . I'd give herva chance because you did say she's a good cleaner and not all Cleaners are the same .

MRex · 22/07/2023 09:25

We pay a varying amount and our cleaner flexes her time to get it all done, some weeks there's more to do than others and if she has more time she wante to spend (or needs more money that week), then she hunts for extra tasks. I wouldn't mind a system of an amount of money for guaranteed cleaning in principle, to reward her for her speed, but in your case it sounds like she's leaving early without finishing tasks.

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 22/07/2023 09:19

You sound so angry.

People are allowed to set their prices. If you don't like it, don't hire them. But don't belittle their "worth."

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 22/07/2023 09:19

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 22/07/2023 09:15

£25 an hour is not fine when the going rate for the area is £15 per hour (i contacted about 30 cleaners to find one and the average was this). £25 per hour is also more than a top band 6 nurse gets per hour! By £4! And i'm sorry but a nurse is a hell of a lot more qualified than a cleaner.

Also the only reason we were given for this jump was "its the biggest house I clean for the least money". She cleans 4 bed house down the road that she consistently spends 3-3.5 hours on and is charging the same. Ours needs 3 hours if done properly. Its a large house. But we only ever have 1 bedroom done in it. She cuts corners and rushes it to get it done in 2 hours to go off elsewhere. None of my pictures are ever dusted, skirtings covered in dust despite being asked. She was good to start with but got cheekier and cheekier. She got a reputation and took advantage of it. I have no patience for that. We treat our cleaners well. Large christmas bonus. Offer a coffee etc. Tidy before they come. Make their lives easier if we can in anyway they ask such as changing times/days if they need to at short notice. I have huge respect for our cleaners. But not when they're demanding a wage thats waaaay beyond their worth and justifying it because we have a big house.

When looking for cleaners there's a lot of chancers out there now it seems. Its seen as 'easy' money. I contacted on person who quoted £80 for the job...she'd just started out. Had 1 reference and had loads of availability. I wonder why!

Also to add £25 didnt include products. I supplied those . Supplying what was asked. Including cloths etc. Her costs were £0. She could walk here if she wanted.

Lily0719 · 22/07/2023 09:19

Does she do ironing? Our cleaner always irons if they have time left over. I’d just give her extra jobs.

Antsinmypantsneedtodance · 22/07/2023 09:15

Kaiserchief · 21/07/2023 22:55

I’m a cleaner and I charge per job rather than per hour. I clean the whole house and it costs £x. I leave once everything is clean. If they’ve had guests staying or the kids off school, it takes me longer but doesn’t cost the customer any more. And no-one is watching the clock.

As she quoted an hourly rate, I would assume she’s charging per hour. I would expect her to stay while she’s being paid. Please mention any things she’s missed. I think it’s ok to say “Ooh if you’re finding you’re done before time’s up could you please clean out the fridge/ microwave”. She should bill you less if she’s going early.

We do get faster once we know the house.

@Antsinmypantsneedtodance £25/hr is fine and my customers are happy to pay upwards of this. There are many costs associated with the job; it’s not all profit.

£25 an hour is not fine when the going rate for the area is £15 per hour (i contacted about 30 cleaners to find one and the average was this). £25 per hour is also more than a top band 6 nurse gets per hour! By £4! And i'm sorry but a nurse is a hell of a lot more qualified than a cleaner.

Also the only reason we were given for this jump was "its the biggest house I clean for the least money". She cleans 4 bed house down the road that she consistently spends 3-3.5 hours on and is charging the same. Ours needs 3 hours if done properly. Its a large house. But we only ever have 1 bedroom done in it. She cuts corners and rushes it to get it done in 2 hours to go off elsewhere. None of my pictures are ever dusted, skirtings covered in dust despite being asked. She was good to start with but got cheekier and cheekier. She got a reputation and took advantage of it. I have no patience for that. We treat our cleaners well. Large christmas bonus. Offer a coffee etc. Tidy before they come. Make their lives easier if we can in anyway they ask such as changing times/days if they need to at short notice. I have huge respect for our cleaners. But not when they're demanding a wage thats waaaay beyond their worth and justifying it because we have a big house.

When looking for cleaners there's a lot of chancers out there now it seems. Its seen as 'easy' money. I contacted on person who quoted £80 for the job...she'd just started out. Had 1 reference and had loads of availability. I wonder why!

ZeldaWillTellYourFortune · 22/07/2023 00:07

AnOldCynic · 21/07/2023 22:20

Does this mean the cleaner shouldn't clean the toilet because the OP shits in it? 🤔

One would hope that the shitters aren't leaving visible residue for someone else to deal with.

The toothpaste splatter is visible residue, bodily fluid and disgusting. Take one minute to wipe it off with some loo roll fgs.

Kaiserchief · 21/07/2023 22:55

I’m a cleaner and I charge per job rather than per hour. I clean the whole house and it costs £x. I leave once everything is clean. If they’ve had guests staying or the kids off school, it takes me longer but doesn’t cost the customer any more. And no-one is watching the clock.

As she quoted an hourly rate, I would assume she’s charging per hour. I would expect her to stay while she’s being paid. Please mention any things she’s missed. I think it’s ok to say “Ooh if you’re finding you’re done before time’s up could you please clean out the fridge/ microwave”. She should bill you less if she’s going early.

We do get faster once we know the house.

@Antsinmypantsneedtodance £25/hr is fine and my customers are happy to pay upwards of this. There are many costs associated with the job; it’s not all profit.

AnOldCynic · 21/07/2023 22:20

mathanxiety · 19/07/2023 07:18

Fyi, dentists advise that parents brush children's teeth until well into childhood. Children can learn self care in other areas - teeth are too important to leave them to toddlers to brush properly.

Presumably there is some residual body fluid left from the previous brushing on the toothbrush?

How is the cleaner to know how the splattered toothpaste got onto the soap dispenser? How is she to know that the toothpaste sprayed onto the soap dispenser didn't come from your mouth or your husband's and that you didn't spit it out and miss the sink?

Does this mean the cleaner shouldn't clean the toilet because the OP shits in it? 🤔

Roussette · 21/07/2023 21:45

You are not being unreasonable!

I had a local cleaning company for 15 years. I cleaned before they came (i.e. no dirty toilets, nothing much to do, just polishing up really! No clutter, put it all away, so easy to clean)
We're old, so wanted someone to do shower doors, toilets (clean already but an extra scrub), and we are tiles through downstairs so mopping through.

I came home one day to see no toilets cleaned (I could only tell because there was a speck of toilet paper on one, and the rest you could tell). The house looked no different since before the clean.

And we paid £19 an hour, rural!

I questioned the owner of the local cleaning company, and she said it was because I didn;t provide toilet brushes! I hate toilet brushes and in 15 years have never provided them! ( I clean toilets with rubber gloves in between cleans!)

I had no idea what they do and after paying £19 an hour I gave up.

JudgeRudy · 21/07/2023 21:31

I've never been or employed a cleaner but I think you're daft to dismiss her over 20mins if she's doing a good job.
I can relate to her saying she 'learns' the new house/routine and gets more efficient. If you were happy with her doing the work in 2hrs I really can't see why you wouldn't be happy with her doing the SAME job in 1hr40. I'd be delighted. If I was the cleaner and every time I improved you loaded on more work I'd slow down to my original speed...and hang out in your home for the full 2hrs.

mobear · 21/07/2023 21:20

We had a cleaner like this. I asked her repeatedly to work the time we paid her for but she didn’t and eventually we had to fire her. She also kept asking for advances on her wage though.

Lilly0909 · 21/07/2023 21:15

im a cleaner. Sometimes I’ll estimate 4 hours for a house. It’ll take 4 hours the first time, then 3.5 the next as it’ll be a better standard. When I’m done I ask if they want me to do any extra jobs or if they’re happy with what I’ve done. Don’t lose her, good cleaners are hard to find. X

Annatinks · 20/07/2023 19:19

tigerbear0906 · 19/07/2023 18:54

Hi,
For a 2 bed terrace (presumably with only one bathroom) we would charge aprox £30.
We always clean in twos and this would take us aprox 1hour if it was already tidy.

For a full clean we would tidy any areas, put away belongings etc. Vacuum and mop all flooring including moving out sofas. Dust all shelving, ornaments and surfaces in the bedrooms/ living/ dining areas. Full bathroom clean including limescale removal etc and polishing of all taps, radiators and anything chrome/ glass. Empty bins. In the kitchen we would clean all work tops, wipe down any appliances on the work tops and clean cupboard door fronts. Washing up or stacking dishwasher where needed. We also clean hobs and extractor fans but not internal ovens or microwaves. We would charge extra for skirting boards and internal windows and blinds. Hope this helps in the list of jobs you could expect to be done Smile

@tigerbear0906

Thank you, that’s indeed very helpful.
We are going to look at someone new as the standard has dropped so much. Yesterday she left 35min early and the shower door and sink weren’t cleaned (I’m sure I’ll get slated a bit more by Zelda 😜). The small (box) bedroom has 2 play rugs on it and I thought to look under them - she’s been hoovering and mopping around them. I’m not expecting someone to move mega furniture but a kids rug? Kitchen wasn’t at previous levels either and she bought a kid with her which I’d have liked to be asked (although I’d have probably agreed, it felt weird she didn’t check)
We tidy all belongings before she comes and do any washing up and we only asked for skirting to be dusted (not washed) as it’s square top type so is a magnet for it! Thank you for the guidance.

OP posts: