Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Woman jailed over (very late on in pregnancy) abortion, released on appeal...

143 replies

FadeAwayAndRadiate · 18/07/2023 19:09

Carla Foster: Mother jailed over lockdown abortion to be released - BBC News

So should she have been released? Or made to serve her sentence?

YABU, no she should NOT have been released.

YANBU, yes she SHOULD have been released.

Interested to hear people views.

Royal Courts of Justice

Carla Foster: Mother jailed over lockdown abortion to be released

The Court of Appeal reduces Carla Foster's sentence for illegally taking abortion tablets.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-65581850

OP posts:
Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 23:16

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:14

Again, what are you basing this on, aside from wishful thinking?

I mean do you have a survey that the public disapprove of arson? No, but it’s safe to assume they do. There’s nothing wishful about it, there is very little appetite to extend the time limit on terminations. It isn’t even remotely on the radar.

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:16

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 23:14

Why?

Because I believe that while a fetus/baby/Steve is in someone else’s body then that person’s wishes should be paramount.

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:14

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 23:13

There will never be enough willing doctors to make it a valid service, accessible to all. There might be a small handful but that won’t be enough. Most people don’t go into the medical profession to end the life of viable 35 week healthy babies. Most people see this as barbaric regardless of the woman’s circumstances.

Again, what are you basing this on, aside from wishful thinking?

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 23:14

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:11

At that point there are two separate individuals. Location isn’t a minor detail.

Why?

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 23:13

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:09

I don’t require you to believe me 🤷🏻‍♀️

That you don’t accept that doctors will be willing to perform late term abortions, although they already do indeed exist, doesn’t mean that they won’t be.

There will never be enough willing doctors to make it a valid service, accessible to all. There might be a small handful but that won’t be enough. Most people don’t go into the medical profession to end the life of viable 35 week healthy babies. Most people see this as barbaric regardless of the woman’s circumstances.

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:11

Q2C4 · 18/07/2023 23:09

On that basis, a woman who's given birth but decided she doesn't want to look after the baby would be within her rights to kill it...

At that point there are two separate individuals. Location isn’t a minor detail.

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:09

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 23:05

Sure

I don’t require you to believe me 🤷🏻‍♀️

That you don’t accept that doctors will be willing to perform late term abortions, although they already do indeed exist, doesn’t mean that they won’t be.

Q2C4 · 18/07/2023 23:09

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:03

“If they were handed the lethal injection and instructed to end the life of a 35 week foetus, I guarantee they would suddenly appreciate the moral dilemma behind late terminations, and understand why it is unethical to expect doctors to carry them out as part of a professional ‘duty’. “

You know full well you cannot guarantee that. Hoping you could and knowing you could are two very different things.

For me there is no moral dilemma, a woman will always takes priority.

On that basis, a woman who's given birth but decided she doesn't want to look after the baby would be within her rights to kill it...

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 23:05

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:05

Yes, I would.

Sure

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:05

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 23:03

You would happily do that would you?

Yes, I would.

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 23:03

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:03

“If they were handed the lethal injection and instructed to end the life of a 35 week foetus, I guarantee they would suddenly appreciate the moral dilemma behind late terminations, and understand why it is unethical to expect doctors to carry them out as part of a professional ‘duty’. “

You know full well you cannot guarantee that. Hoping you could and knowing you could are two very different things.

For me there is no moral dilemma, a woman will always takes priority.

You would happily do that would you?

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:03

“If they were handed the lethal injection and instructed to end the life of a 35 week foetus, I guarantee they would suddenly appreciate the moral dilemma behind late terminations, and understand why it is unethical to expect doctors to carry them out as part of a professional ‘duty’. “

You know full well you cannot guarantee that. Hoping you could and knowing you could are two very different things.

For me there is no moral dilemma, a woman will always takes priority.

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 23:01

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 22:51

Will there? The RCOG can make recommendations, they wouldn’t be the individuals carrying it out. Would you be able to inject the heart of a fully formed viable baby, watch its heart stop beating on a screen then deliver its lifeless body? See its face and hands, knowing you ended its life? If not, why not?

I think it would be unlikely for them to support decriminalization knowing that they would not be able to meet the needs of women.

I’m not a doctor, so lack the necessary qualifications. Were I a doctor then yes, I would be willing to perform abortions.

Nat6999 · 18/07/2023 23:00

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 19:12

So all forms of prostitution should be legal? And we should be able to pay homeless people to fight for entertainment?

If a woman chooses to be a prostitute without being forced by a pimp, then yes it should be legal. It's no different than a woman being a stripper or dancing & doing private dances in a club. Abortion should be legal whatever the state of pregnancy, better that than a child born into this world & mistreated, abused or not wanted. This poor woman should not have been dragged through the courts & jailed for making a decision about her own body.

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 22:59

Q2C4 · 18/07/2023 22:34

You'd support abortion at any stage pre birth? 39 weeks? 40 weeks? When the baby is clearly sentient and viable? How is that different to having the baby then killing it?

In my experience people who make this argument are making it from the luxury position of behind a screen, knowing they’ll never have to personally be involved with such a messy business, that ‘other people’ will have it on their conscience instead.

If they were handed the lethal injection and instructed to end the life of a 35 week foetus, I guarantee they would suddenly appreciate the moral dilemma behind late terminations, and understand why it is unethical to expect doctors to carry them out as part of a professional ‘duty’.

Equally they can rarely say when exactly this right ends and the rights of the baby begin. When it’s head is born? When the feet are out? When the cord is cut? When the mother has stopped breastfeeding as technically the baby is still dependent on her body for life until then?

‘As early as possible as late as necessary’ is simply a catchy mantra for those who will never personally be involved in the late termination of a healthy baby. And they know that.

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 22:51

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 22:31

What are you basing this on? The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists have come out in support of decriminalizing abortion, there will of course be doctors willing to carry them out.

Will there? The RCOG can make recommendations, they wouldn’t be the individuals carrying it out. Would you be able to inject the heart of a fully formed viable baby, watch its heart stop beating on a screen then deliver its lifeless body? See its face and hands, knowing you ended its life? If not, why not?

Q2C4 · 18/07/2023 22:34

AIBot · 18/07/2023 20:03

I support abortion to term - her body, her choice, but I’m not convinced this was much of an informed choice. The psychology of this is as others have alluded to, complex.

I aLeo think it’s unfair on her existing children being deprived of their mother.

You'd support abortion at any stage pre birth? 39 weeks? 40 weeks? When the baby is clearly sentient and viable? How is that different to having the baby then killing it?

Q2C4 · 18/07/2023 22:32

FlipFlopPlop · 18/07/2023 20:01

This is quite a delicate debate. This wasn't an abortion at a stage where it wouldn't be described as a viable baby, this took place when the baby was viable.

This does remind me of the recent case in the US, the (I believe) 19 year old, gave birth in hospital toilets and discarded the poor baby.

The reactions (I'm just going off what I've observed on social media) , seem different, and I'm wondering why?

Or this one: www.theguardian.com/uk-news/2023/jun/26/teenager-murdered-newborn-son-herefordshire-jailed-paris-mayo

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 22:31

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 22:27

Only in cases where the baby has severe anomalies that would cause them suffering. That’s the justification. Virtually no doctors would carry out such late terminations for social reasons as there’s very little, if any, moral justification.

What are you basing this on? The Royal College of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists have come out in support of decriminalizing abortion, there will of course be doctors willing to carry them out.

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 22:27

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 22:25

Why do you think it’s not a service that could be implemented? There are already doctors that carry out late term abortions.

Only in cases where the baby has severe anomalies that would cause them suffering. That’s the justification. Virtually no doctors would carry out such late terminations for social reasons as there’s very little, if any, moral justification.

whumpthereitis · 18/07/2023 22:25

Sweetashunni · 18/07/2023 21:24

So you think it should be legalised but essentially DIY as it’s not a service we could implement? If somebody handed you the injection, could you inject the heart of a 5lb baby to kill it, watch it die on a screen, then deliver its body and see its face knowing you had ended its life? Or do you just want ‘somebody else’ to do this, but not be involved with the messy side yourself?

Why do you think it’s not a service that could be implemented? There are already doctors that carry out late term abortions.

KeyWorker · 18/07/2023 22:25

PrudenceDictates · 18/07/2023 19:37

Exactly. Beyond the 24 week limit abortion is only allowed if:
*the woman's life is in danger
*there is a severe fetal abnormality, or
*the woman is at risk of grave physical and mental injury.

Those didn't apply, so her actions were illegal.

Carrying a pregnancy you do not want, in its self will cause ‘grave mental injury’ as well as all the potential physical injury’s of pregnancy and birth.

I think this case highlights the need for safe, legal abortion as soon as possible as late as necessary.

People witter on about the 24 week limit and ‘viability’ forgetting there are approximately 16 weeks between 24 weeks gestation and term. That’s 16 weeks of carrying a pregnancy you do not want. 16 weeks of grave mental injury and a potential threat to the woman’s life. No obstetrician in the land would induce preterm birth because a woman does not wish to be pregnant anymore so the only alternative is safe and legal abortion.

gonetogreece · 18/07/2023 22:21

pointythings · 18/07/2023 21:53

I also do not think the girl who killed her newborn at 15 should have been jailed. Again, no benefit to society except to create another criminal.

Is it just the fact she's 15 that you feel this way? What age do you think a woman should be before she's accountable for murdering a defenceless baby?

gonetogreece · 18/07/2023 22:18

I was born at 27 weeks over 40 years ago. I find it shocking that she could do this at such a late stage, she should be made to serve her full prison sentence.

pointythings · 18/07/2023 21:53

I also do not think the girl who killed her newborn at 15 should have been jailed. Again, no benefit to society except to create another criminal.