Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this weather change your attitude to climate change?

240 replies

Allotment123 · 18/07/2023 18:36

It seems like everyone is taking about the weather but no one is thinking about their own personal responsibility to climate change as a result, AIBU to think we are all abdicating responsibility while we can see the dramatic effects all around us? I feel sometimes like in the only one concerned

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
AdoraBell · 18/07/2023 20:47

YANBU OP on another thread, can’t remember the title now, someone posted about the heatwave and another poster responded “stop worrying, it’s only weather “

We used to live in Chile and fly back to visit GPs. The first year the Andes were covered with snow. Thriving ski tourism industry and the snow melt provided water for the surrounding countries. When we moved back in 2015, and stopped flying so much, in the winter there was zero snow.

clopper · 18/07/2023 20:45

I agree with a previous poster that said the disposable aspect of covid and one use plastic has set us all backwards.

clopper · 18/07/2023 20:43

Alibaba87
I’m just telling you the message in the newspapers and TV when I was young. The science then was that we were going to be in a new ice age.

Bellajac · 18/07/2023 20:39

No.

Alibaba87 · 18/07/2023 20:35

@clopper rising temperatures mean colder climates in certain areas, more snow, colder winters

Lionoso · 18/07/2023 20:34

We should all do what we can on a personal level, but unless the world can convince the worst polluting countries (e.g China) to change it won't slow it down enough.

EveSix · 18/07/2023 20:28

I know quite a few climate sceptics from all walks of life, but what they all have in common is an almost pathological aversion to 'being told what to do'. Which means they're also all covid sceptics. And don't like paying tax.
I find this so frustrating. The inability to consider the macro beyond whatever impingement of individual privilege they perceive. The whatsboutery is strong with this type, and it is so wilfully disingenuous: "What about China-Russia-India? / I bet you're typing on a mobile device, aren't you? / The flight will leave anyway, whether you're on it or not." and so on, ad infinitum. I also reject the notion that unless the big corporations drastically reduce emissions, there's no point in individual action. What we need is a re-framing, and a sustainable management of, our expectations for the future in a heating global climate and to act accordingly on an individual and a collective basis.

VegMam · 18/07/2023 20:23

For those suggesting taking necessary action on made made climate change will send us “back to the dark ages”:

  1. not taking action will send us to worse than the dark ages;
  2. none of the scientifically agreed solutions will do any such thing.
I suggest reading more about the ipcc’s climate mitigation strategies.
VegMam · 18/07/2023 20:19

clopper · 18/07/2023 20:13

glamrockgoddess
*Climate change has always been cyclic.

We are still warming up from the last ice-age.*

I struggle with the whole climate change message. The planet has been both much warmer and colder over millions of years before man existed. And we need to acknowledge that.

When I was growing up there was so much talk of ‘snowball earth’ based on climate models and I used to worry about this as an anxious child. The scientists seemed absolutely convinced at that point on the climate getting colder. You’d probably have to be over 50 to remember this but it really was a thing at the time concerning the reduction of the earths albedo.

But now it’s the complete opposite. There have been mass extinctions more than once on the planet and some scientists believe these were linked to climate change.

I’m not a ‘climate change denier’ , far from it, it’s just that I think that the climate does change cyclically over time and we should be able to state this without getting slated.

You’ll get slated for saying that because it’s not really relevant. What’s currently happening is man made climate change, change at a rate vastly in excess of any natural climate change. It is a choice not an inevitability.

Dont listen to me, listen to nasa:
https://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensus/

"Observations throughout the world make it clear that climate change is occurring, and rigorous scientific research demonstrates that the greenhouse gases emitted by human activities are the primary driver."

Scientific Consensus: Earth's Climate is Warming

Most leading scientific organizations worldwide have issued public statements endorsing the position that climate-warming trends over the past century are extremely likely due to human activities.

https://climate.nasa.gov/scientific-consensus/

VegMam · 18/07/2023 20:16

Haruka · 18/07/2023 20:07

I do believe Covid has a lot to do with it. Just before the pandemic, Blue Planet was a massive thing and everyone around me started moving in the right direction - less waste, more recycling, generally being a bit more environmentally conscious.

Then Covid happened and suddenly everything had to be disposable. Where we had made such huge gains on plastic tat, suddenly facemasks, syringes, packaging etc. abounded and it will take decades, if not centuries, for some of that to decompose.

The confinement and deaths, in addition to the screw-it on the waste front attitude, has invoked a YOLO point of view for so many that, again, people are far more selfish than they were just before the pandemic.

We need another documentary, Attenborough, what are you up to these days.

This is what Attenborough has been up to: https://www.vox.com/2019/4/12/18306566/david-attenborough-our-planet-netflix-advocacy

“I find it hard to exaggerate the peril,” Attenborough said at the IMF earlier in April, according to the Guardian. “This is the new extinction and we are half way through it. We are in terrible, terrible trouble and the longer we wait to do something about it the worse it is going to get.”

David Attenborough, the voice of Our Planet: "Things are going to get worse"

The voice of some of the most stunning nature documentaries ever made is pessimistic about the future of wildlife on earth.

https://www.vox.com/2019/4/12/18306566/david-attenborough-our-planet-netflix-advocacy

clopper · 18/07/2023 20:13

glamrockgoddess
*Climate change has always been cyclic.

We are still warming up from the last ice-age.*

I struggle with the whole climate change message. The planet has been both much warmer and colder over millions of years before man existed. And we need to acknowledge that.

When I was growing up there was so much talk of ‘snowball earth’ based on climate models and I used to worry about this as an anxious child. The scientists seemed absolutely convinced at that point on the climate getting colder. You’d probably have to be over 50 to remember this but it really was a thing at the time concerning the reduction of the earths albedo.

But now it’s the complete opposite. There have been mass extinctions more than once on the planet and some scientists believe these were linked to climate change.

I’m not a ‘climate change denier’ , far from it, it’s just that I think that the climate does change cyclically over time and we should be able to state this without getting slated.

Does this weather change your attitude to climate change?
Diddykong · 18/07/2023 20:12

In COVID we also saw months and months of reduced car use and a switch to home working so no commuting and yet it has little impact on the climate crisis. So if you can't impact it when the world is literally paused then it makes individual actions seem pointless.

I can see switching to green energy as the only way we can do much collectively. And for that you need to remove jolly-jasper who went to the same college old chum as half the cabinet and who now runs whatever oil lobby group makes him the most money. The normal person on the street hasn't a hope in hell of interfering with the games played at that level.

Haruka · 18/07/2023 20:07

I do believe Covid has a lot to do with it. Just before the pandemic, Blue Planet was a massive thing and everyone around me started moving in the right direction - less waste, more recycling, generally being a bit more environmentally conscious.

Then Covid happened and suddenly everything had to be disposable. Where we had made such huge gains on plastic tat, suddenly facemasks, syringes, packaging etc. abounded and it will take decades, if not centuries, for some of that to decompose.

The confinement and deaths, in addition to the screw-it on the waste front attitude, has invoked a YOLO point of view for so many that, again, people are far more selfish than they were just before the pandemic.

We need another documentary, Attenborough, what are you up to these days.

Maireas · 18/07/2023 19:47

I'm sceptical about things which have limited evidence, @BitterAndOnlySlightlyTwisted . Climate change evidence is significant.
How this is resolved is the big, big question.. who wants to go back to living in pre industrial times? We're going to have to produce significant amounts of renewable energy which will require £bns worth of investment.

CurlewKate · 18/07/2023 19:44

It doesn't change my opinion. But it does make me think it's probably too late to do anything about it.

BitterAndOnlySlightlyTwisted · 18/07/2023 19:44

Maireas · 18/07/2023 19:27

I'm always intrigued how a lay person disputes proven scientific evidence, as if it wasn't rigorously researched and peer reviewed. But "hey I don't believe it" seems to constitute an academic rebuttal.

I’m not disputing but am sceptical. There are any number of scientists who query these climate-change models and none of them appear to be lunatics.

The social and economic consequences of stopping to use fossil-fuels completely might turn us all into beggars. Maybe not you because you and I will probably be dead by then, but your children and grandchildren. I read somewhere recently that if Labour press on with their “clean energy” proposals there will need to be 300 wind-turbines installed a week. It’s a total fantasy

dreamingbohemian · 18/07/2023 19:38

Maireas · 18/07/2023 19:27

I'm always intrigued how a lay person disputes proven scientific evidence, as if it wasn't rigorously researched and peer reviewed. But "hey I don't believe it" seems to constitute an academic rebuttal.

Yes this drives me bonkers. I have a colleague who is an expert in his own field, requiring advanced degrees and years of experience -- if any random person tried to tell him his research was wrong, he'd tell them where to go. But he feels perfectly free to say climate science is a scam. It's crazy.

GwinGwyn · 18/07/2023 19:28

RumandSpinach · 18/07/2023 19:27

We need to be holding governments and industry to account. The push on reducing personal consumption only distracts from the real culprit of business.

Complaining about holidaying non-vegans switches people off and let's the billionaires get away with murder.

I could not agree with you more. Well said.

Maireas · 18/07/2023 19:27

I'm always intrigued how a lay person disputes proven scientific evidence, as if it wasn't rigorously researched and peer reviewed. But "hey I don't believe it" seems to constitute an academic rebuttal.

GwinGwyn · 18/07/2023 19:27

VegMam · 18/07/2023 19:16

Yeah what do 99% of the world’s scientists know, they’re only experts who’ve spent years studying these things.

You seem really switched on…

Disingenuity abounds…

Hurricanes, heatwaves, floods, and droughts have happened before and would again, even if humans didn’t exist. But have we intervened in nature to alter weather patterns and the global temperature? Yes we have. Weather isn’t climate but it is affected by climate and we’ve cocked up the climate system.

I don’t agree that because the UK is a lesser contributor that we shouldn’t do our best, that’s selfish thinking. Climate control is a global society issue.

RumandSpinach · 18/07/2023 19:27

We need to be holding governments and industry to account. The push on reducing personal consumption only distracts from the real culprit of business.

Complaining about holidaying non-vegans switches people off and let's the billionaires get away with murder.

VegMam · 18/07/2023 19:16

BitterAndOnlySlightlyTwisted · 18/07/2023 19:09

What @Glowie said. Our own nation’s emissions are almost irrelevant. I’m not even convinced climate change is a thing. All of these predictions are based on modelling, and Covid showed us quite clearly how useful modelling was. Weather is not climate

Yeah what do 99% of the world’s scientists know, they’re only experts who’ve spent years studying these things.

You seem really switched on…

SunnyEgg · 18/07/2023 19:13

Not really as it’s something I’ve thought about before this

It’s just starting to happen - so more extreme weather, and more people trying to leave where they are and more social discord

Parky04 · 18/07/2023 19:09

marshmallowfinder · 18/07/2023 18:44

I was really hopeful that after covid, taking flights for non essential purposes would cease. It's just unbelievable how people don't give a shit and fly whenever they like, drive whatever they like, consume whatever they like.☹️

Yeah, it's called enjoying yourself!