Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this weather change your attitude to climate change?

240 replies

Allotment123 · 18/07/2023 18:36

It seems like everyone is taking about the weather but no one is thinking about their own personal responsibility to climate change as a result, AIBU to think we are all abdicating responsibility while we can see the dramatic effects all around us? I feel sometimes like in the only one concerned

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
SmallTreeDeepRoots · 18/07/2023 21:49

I think the real issue is peak oil and running out of feasible fossil fuels (in next 30 years by many reckonings). While renewables are great, we do not have enough fossils fuels and other resources to required to shift global energy production over to 100% renewable. We need to massively and urgently reduce energy use. Not switching our current lifestyles to “green” alternatives. Less transport, more walkable local living. Local food not air (or even lorry) -freighted foods and food products. Less automation, more manual labour. It is irrelevant whether you don’t want to go back to the dark ages, it will be foisted upon us. But a planned and managed personal descent will be better than a sudden plummet forced on us by the governments. Collapse now and avoid the rush!

Climate is concerning, but we will be forced to reduce fossil fuel use naturally by not having any to use. The climate crisis is real, but largely a distraction from the real crisis.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 18/07/2023 21:49

@Lazyusername agree with everything you've said.

tulippa · 18/07/2023 21:49

The amount of denial on this thread is depressing. How hot does it need to get before people realise we have a problem? 50 degrees, 55 degrees? Oh hang on, that's already happening. Constant uncontrollable wildfires? That's already happening too.
We're going to look at electric cars at the weekend. Don't feel I can justify my petrol one anymore.

ThatsAboutEnoughOfThat · 18/07/2023 21:49

I don't think we CAN do anything about climate change.

I used to think we could but I have changed my mind.

As a species we seem to have a blind spot in our brains which is stopping us from acting. Which makes me think it is all part of the natural order of things. We have simply reached the point where humans have consumed too much and will now be cut back down to size by the habitat.

Same as locusts, or any other animal that gets out of control.

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 18/07/2023 21:47

Don't know why you're rolling your eyes. I answered the question. I don't worry about it.

Lazyusername · 18/07/2023 21:46

David Attenborough has one of the biggest carbon footprints of anyone on the planet and has also admitted he eats meat while exhorting others not to. I'm sick of hearing about him.
We are all being told to cycle everywhere, give up meat and wear second-hand clothes and yet apparently it is ok for the rich to continue to fly about the world on private jets. Rishi Sunak recently had the National Grid altered so he could power his heated swimming pool.
If the situation is as dire as we are being told, why haven't private jets been banned? Why aren't second homes banned? And private heated pools? No, the elite want ordinary working people to live like serfs while they continue in the manner to which they are accustomed.
The elite, as individuals, are using up far more of the world's resources than the rest of us. Govenrments need to start with them. Show the public they are serious. Because until they do, why the hell should we all suffer? We get little enough as it is.

Washeroo · 18/07/2023 21:44

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 18/07/2023 21:40

I don't worry about it. Winters in the 60s were ridiculously cold. The summer of 76 was boiling. It's all cyclical.

🙄

Washeroo · 18/07/2023 21:43

I’m very happy with the temp in the UK this week (in my area anyway). Warm (low 20’s) with sunny spells and yes it’s been rainy in parts too - brilliant for my allotment and garden.

I like it 25 best and can tolerate 30. 35-40 is horrible and for the last 2/3 years we have had very hot weather in my area and for a time it didn’t rain for something like 6+ weeks which was awful.

I’m v aware of climate change and try to do my best. Never go to Europe in summer any more as weather is too oppressive. Ultimately though nothing will change unless it’s government policy. I vote Liberal for this reason and Green once (my DH always goes Green) as what good is inheritance tax and other policy when the world resembles MadMax?

JustGotToKeepOnKeepingOn · 18/07/2023 21:40

I don't worry about it. Winters in the 60s were ridiculously cold. The summer of 76 was boiling. It's all cyclical.

NameChange245 · 18/07/2023 21:40

Well I haven't noticed much change in the weather in the UK to be honest. This summer isn't that different to those I remember as a kid. I haven't felt or seen the differences really.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 18/07/2023 21:39

I struggle with the climate change question because our governments clearly don't see it as a problem, and certainly not even approaching an urgent one.

I think, when you see the wanton profligate decisions that the leaders make, it couldn't be a clearer signal from them that they personally categorically do not believe the message that they're giving out.

When Joe Biden (and he is very far from the only world leader like that) flew several of his own vehicles from the USA to the climate conference in Glasgow (and back) - where there are already any number of luxury vehicles that could have been hired - that really was the equivalent of the Archbishop of Canterbury deciding to do a one-man Chubby Brown & Jim Davidson tribute festival and then expecting anybody to take his next sermon, or indeed him, at all seriously again.

I’m not disputing but am sceptical. There are any number of scientists who query these climate-change models and none of them appear to be lunatics.

I know it's not exactly the same thing, but... whatever the established facts are, all scientists know that any research positions, grants and jobs will be closed to/lost by them if they express any dissent from, or even question, the official line; in the same way that a great many GC people grudgingly stay quiet or grit their teeth and toe the line in order to avoid cancellation and job losses - and therefore would appear by default to be in complete agreement with the prevailing messages about how many different genders there are, there's no such thing as fixed biological sex, some children need puberty blockers and even surgery for 'gender' reasons, it's just common decency to ask people what their pronouns are etc.

What I'm saying is that, even if you are convinced that you have all of the facts about anything indisputably correct, when there is a powerful culture where people are simply not allowed to question or disagree with those facts, it's impossible to genuinely claim that opinion is unanimous.

Alibaba87 · 18/07/2023 21:36

@Superfans To what end? What are the scientists getting out of saying Climate Change is real, if it’s not? (Or at least not quite as black and white as they say)

stayathomer · 18/07/2023 21:35

We are a drop in the ocean though compared to the big corps.
Did the lessening of travel during covid not repair some of the ozone though? That shows if we cut down on travel it would make a difference

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 18/07/2023 21:26

Superfans I think your sources of information need to widen as there are some very odd ways of thinking there. I am afraid you don’t sound like you have enough expertise to disregard the decades of global, multimodal research that has actually been proven right already.

VegMam · 18/07/2023 21:24

Superfans · 18/07/2023 21:16

Well I’m about to get slammed for this and no doubt the post will be reported and deleted at some point.

Let’s just be clear that climate is a complex system, not fully understood by current models. No matter how expert someone appears to be, they cannot say with certainty what the outcome of this highly complex system will be. There is no climate model that will accurately predict outcomes from the past so how can we claim to predict the future. It is noticeable how much censorship and moralising there is around this issue. The “science” is now not to be questioned. If a finding is robust it should be able to be questioned and openly debated. Science is never settled, it works by falsification. Climate science has consistently made incorrect predictions - Maldives under water etc. Whether “extreme weather” events are actually more frequent is questionable and whether that can be directly related to carbon emissions even more so.

Big business is now bought into the climate change/renewables idea however so that is what is being pushed. Even if you believe CO2 is a key driver of warming many of the renewable energy sources don’t even emit much less CO2 if you look at the totality of the outcome (for example, windmills made in China using coal power then shipped to UK, and require back up fossil fuel on standby for when the wind doesn’t blow. Are they truly “carbon neutral”.

Regardless of whether you think man made carbon emissions are the principle cause of a changing global climate or not it should be clear to most that we cannot stop using fossil fuels without widespread poverty, misery and death. Our current technology does not allow it.

Net zero is a complete fantasy and an excuse to decimate the middle class in Western countries. The best option is to invest in our own industry and work force instead of importing everything, use renewables where they make sense, otherwise natural gas and nuclear. Make sure we have energy security and value our farmers. Get the environmental wins that are possible - get the fucking plastic out of the oceans, that’s achievable. Protect more land for wildlife and biodiversity. Support farmers to protect biodiversity and soils while maintaining output. Invest properly In our water and sewerage systems. Don’t listen to the assholes who dare to fly about on private jets while attempting to lecture and indoctrinate us all in this bizarre unevidenced cult.

This is a good summary as to why man made climate change is not a conspiracy https://twitter.com/SteB777/status/1679862501867937792?s=20

https://twitter.com/SteB777/status/1679862501867937792?s=20

Maireas · 18/07/2023 21:19

"bizarre unevidenced cult"
where is the lack of evidence?
why is it a "cult"?

Superfans · 18/07/2023 21:16

Well I’m about to get slammed for this and no doubt the post will be reported and deleted at some point.

Let’s just be clear that climate is a complex system, not fully understood by current models. No matter how expert someone appears to be, they cannot say with certainty what the outcome of this highly complex system will be. There is no climate model that will accurately predict outcomes from the past so how can we claim to predict the future. It is noticeable how much censorship and moralising there is around this issue. The “science” is now not to be questioned. If a finding is robust it should be able to be questioned and openly debated. Science is never settled, it works by falsification. Climate science has consistently made incorrect predictions - Maldives under water etc. Whether “extreme weather” events are actually more frequent is questionable and whether that can be directly related to carbon emissions even more so.

Big business is now bought into the climate change/renewables idea however so that is what is being pushed. Even if you believe CO2 is a key driver of warming many of the renewable energy sources don’t even emit much less CO2 if you look at the totality of the outcome (for example, windmills made in China using coal power then shipped to UK, and require back up fossil fuel on standby for when the wind doesn’t blow. Are they truly “carbon neutral”.

Regardless of whether you think man made carbon emissions are the principle cause of a changing global climate or not it should be clear to most that we cannot stop using fossil fuels without widespread poverty, misery and death. Our current technology does not allow it.

Net zero is a complete fantasy and an excuse to decimate the middle class in Western countries. The best option is to invest in our own industry and work force instead of importing everything, use renewables where they make sense, otherwise natural gas and nuclear. Make sure we have energy security and value our farmers. Get the environmental wins that are possible - get the fucking plastic out of the oceans, that’s achievable. Protect more land for wildlife and biodiversity. Support farmers to protect biodiversity and soils while maintaining output. Invest properly In our water and sewerage systems. Don’t listen to the assholes who dare to fly about on private jets while attempting to lecture and indoctrinate us all in this bizarre unevidenced cult.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 18/07/2023 21:15

BitterAndOnlySlightlyTwisted

We aren’t far off hitting ‘peak oil’ anyway so we need alternatives. We need to invest in renewables heavily, insulate our homes and reduce consumption rapidly.

The scientists that question it tend not to be climate scientists and are mostly either funded by the oil industry or quoting pseudo science funded by the oil industry. The science is unequivocal. There is no doubt. Using multiple models. And the climate scientists have already been proven right. It’s just happening quicker than expected. This is based on decades of global research coming together.

VegMam · 18/07/2023 21:08

clopper · 18/07/2023 21:00

vegmum
You’ll get slated for saying that because it’s not really relevant. What’s currently happening is man made climate change, change at a rate vastly in excess of any natural climate change.

How do scientists know how quickly the climate has changed in the past? I am interested to know this and it seems like you might know this kind of information. Is it ice cores or something?

Here’s a useful summary http://www.climate.gov/maps-data/climate-data-primer/past-climate

As you guessed it’s things like ice, rocks, tree rings, ocean sediments etc.

Past Climate

Some natural processes record the passage of time: for instance, layers of sediments accumulate over many years, and some of them preserve information about weather conditions during the time they were deposited. Throughout Earth's history, global and...

http://www.climate.gov/maps-data/climate-data-primer/past-climate

ohfook · 18/07/2023 21:07

RumandSpinach · 18/07/2023 19:27

We need to be holding governments and industry to account. The push on reducing personal consumption only distracts from the real culprit of business.

Complaining about holidaying non-vegans switches people off and let's the billionaires get away with murder.

This ⬆️.

I used to do shit loads in terms of never using cling film or anything single use, taking my little tub to the butchers, going to refill shops etc. Then I realised all I was doing was making more work for myself with no discernible impact on anything.

In the 80s when CFCs were the problem, the government banned them and it had the desired impact. If we're to do anything now the government needs to tackle the biggest problems with effective legislation. However they won't and no amount of popping to the refill shop or walking the school run will do any good at all.

EveSix · 18/07/2023 21:00

Adora, snap. In the country where I was born, a part of the world that has always been blessed with ample snow in winter and where a big part of the seasonal economy depends on this, there has now just been a thin dusting of powder in winter for the last 10 years. Ski tourism gone. Santa holidays drying up.

Fruit, I really hear you. It is anxiety inducing and the challenge is to stay with this intense feeling of discomfort and cognitive dissonance which arises as we sit with the reality of the global impact of the climate crisis.
Not flinching is hard.
Not looking away or distracting ourselves is hard.

clopper · 18/07/2023 21:00

vegmum
You’ll get slated for saying that because it’s not really relevant. What’s currently happening is man made climate change, change at a rate vastly in excess of any natural climate change.

How do scientists know how quickly the climate has changed in the past? I am interested to know this and it seems like you might know this kind of information. Is it ice cores or something?

OhmygodDont · 18/07/2023 20:57

Problem is everyone wants their cheap fashion everyone wants their holidays abroad like a given right. Everyone wants a dog or cat. People want low maintenance party gardens. Nobody wants to give up these things and those of who have given up parts of those things are still told
yeah but you have children do my jetting across the world is fine blah blah blah.

clopper · 18/07/2023 20:55

Alibaba87
It is confusing. The messaging when I was young was basically we will all freeze to death! I can’t remember anything said about global warming at all.

I feel I do my bit, always recycle, use a bike, don’t fly abroad, don’t use plastic if I can possibly avoid it, try to use local businesses but it does all feel a little hopeless.

fruitpastille · 18/07/2023 20:49

The Netflix film Don't Look Up is an accurate view on the problem.

Personally I find it anxiety provoking to think about it too deeply. I try to have a sensible lifestyle but acknowledge how me doing a bit of recycling and rarely flying makes no difference. Sometimes I try to be optimistic and think human ingenuity will find way. Other times I read dystopian fiction and despair.