Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this weather change your attitude to climate change?

240 replies

Allotment123 · 18/07/2023 18:36

It seems like everyone is taking about the weather but no one is thinking about their own personal responsibility to climate change as a result, AIBU to think we are all abdicating responsibility while we can see the dramatic effects all around us? I feel sometimes like in the only one concerned

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Rummikub · 18/07/2023 22:38

Anyone else read this and impact on sea level and climate change?

Popular Mechanics:

Earth Has Tilted 31.5 Inches. That Shouldn't Happen.

Humans pumping groundwater has a substantial impact on the tilt of Earth’s rotation.
Additionally, a new study documents just how much of an influence groundwater pumping has on climate change.
Understanding this relatively recent data may provide a better understanding of how to help stave off sea-level rise.
Water has power. So much power, in fact, that pumping Earth’s groundwater can change the planet’s tilt and rotation.

Pumping groundwater appears to have a greater consequence than ever previously thought. But now—thanks to a new study published in the journal Geophysical Research Letters—we can see that, in less than two decades, Earth has tilted 31.5 inches as a result of pumping groundwater. This equates to .24 inches of sea level rise

Helpwhatwouldyoudonext · 18/07/2023 22:38

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-us-canada-66229286

And this link about people 'celebrating' the highest temp on Earth - watch until the guy at the end.
It makes me mad that so many ~Daily Fail~ readers will think HE'S the nutcase.

People pose for pictures with a thermometer showing temperatures reaching 133 F, in Death Valley, California, U.S. July 16, 2023

Tourists flock to Death Valley for heat record

Death Valley in California did not reach its previous record but that didn't stop the tourists.

https://www.bbc.co.uk/news/av/world-us-canada-66229286

NoNonsensePotato · 18/07/2023 22:38

SunnyEgg · 18/07/2023 21:54

Do you have dc?

I am prepared to change habits for them

No kids and no plans to. There's far too many humans on this planet and adding to them is what's got us to where we are.

Tbh, I can't say I'd be too worried about 75% of the human race spontaneously combusting once I'm dead lol.

Fawful · 18/07/2023 22:38

At the same time, @EddyF, the real victims are in developing countries, they are the ones suffering the worst droughts, heatwaves and floods in silence, and they live with an even lower carbon footprint than the poorest in the UK... Because even education and infrastructure has a carbon cost.
We've all got to reduce our carbon footprint. It goes without saying that if you hardly drive, and never fly, it will be lower, so you don't need to do much more to maintain your annual footprint at 2 tons of CO2e per capita per year.
No-one is going to be made super poor because of green measures.

Helpwhatwouldyoudonext · 18/07/2023 22:36

@Glowie I'm fascinated by this, I'd like to share the info (Russia 4% etc)
Do you have a link?
And also Australia flies under the radar here, esp. with fossil fuels. I'd appreciate any further facts & figures for a college assignment (with a ref I can check out).

Moneynewpence · 18/07/2023 22:33

marshmallowfinder · 18/07/2023 18:44

I was really hopeful that after covid, taking flights for non essential purposes would cease. It's just unbelievable how people don't give a shit and fly whenever they like, drive whatever they like, consume whatever they like.☹️

Flights are a tiny, tiny proportion of the problem. Pretending that never flying will solve the crisis is simply inaccurate

JamSandle · 18/07/2023 22:31

EddyF · 18/07/2023 22:28

For a lot of people, worrying about the environment is a privilege they do not have. Someone just said on this thread that they're on their way to buy an electric car. That person has choices. I used to work with service users who are living day to day and they weren't particularly poor. There is vast amount of inequality in the UK and I'm afraid this topic is at the bottom of the pile for the ordinary man and woman.

A very good point.

EddyF · 18/07/2023 22:28

For a lot of people, worrying about the environment is a privilege they do not have. Someone just said on this thread that they're on their way to buy an electric car. That person has choices. I used to work with service users who are living day to day and they weren't particularly poor. There is vast amount of inequality in the UK and I'm afraid this topic is at the bottom of the pile for the ordinary man and woman.

Jadey31 · 18/07/2023 22:22

Glowie · 18/07/2023 18:56

I struggle with the climate change question because our governments clearly don't see it as a problem, and certainly not even approaching an urgent one.

My reasoning;
The UK as a whole is about 1% of global emissions. This means that you could drop the entire island into the sea and that would be the gain.

China and India account for 37% between them (hell, Russia is 4%), so if things were really that dire then the west would have banned all imports from those countries to get that number down.
That's assuming the US hadn't already bombed their industrial areas to death in the first place...

Yes!!!! I watch documentaries/programmes (nothing to do with climate change) and when you see boats pissing oil into the ocean in the background etc you think WE (the small fry) are not the big problem here!

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 18/07/2023 22:14

I do wonder about people’s critical thinking skills sometimes.

Fair enough, so you don't think that leaders should set an example that everybody else is expected/mandated to follow? Maybe I am very simple/stupid as you seem to be implying, but I generally look at people's express behaviours as quite a handy guide as to what they really believe, especially when what they say is completely different. And that holds the same to me whether they're a market trader in Bathgate or the president of the USA.

Lazyusername · 18/07/2023 22:13

@FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper You are correct. It is the same as Boris and Partygate. They must lead by example. If they want us to live a certain way because it is a dire emergency, then let's see them all doing it - riding on bicycles, never going abroad, downsizing into terraced houses. Yes, I would be very impressed if they did and it would motivate me to believe in what they were saying.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 18/07/2023 22:09

I’ll repeat whilst I do not agree with what Biden did, do you think him not doing that as a token gesture (your words) makes ANY difference to the “urgent looming catastrophe”.

No, I don't - my point is that he personally doesn't appear to believe what he is declaring to the rest of us. Not saying that he is right or wrong to have that personal opinion, but it seems a trifle unfair when he is in charge of signing off far-reaching laws off the back of it that millions of ordinary Americans have to adhere to.

Maybe he does believe it wholeheartedly, but figures that as he is old, he simply doesn't care - although he does have grandchildren, so who knows? I'm also not saying that Trump would be any better.

Lazyusername · 18/07/2023 22:09

@Freshair1 But I do have morals. I care a lot about the environment and about other people. But there's something off about this. The very people who are telling us that the doomsday apocalypse is right around the corner are not changing their own behaviours in any way; rather, they are trying to condemn the poor and elderly to sit in freezing houses and disabled and frail people to stay in their homes because they can't ride a bike. They don't want our children to leave this country. Ever. No flying. Just stay in the miserable dump you were born in and keep quiet. Meanwhile they fly overhead en route to their holiday villas. Can you explain to me why I should think this is ok? Why are the Government not curtailing the behaviours of the rich? Surely this would be the logical way to ensure resources were not squandered.

Washeroo · 18/07/2023 22:05

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 18/07/2023 21:56

Whilst it’s terrible for the environment, what Biden did will be justified by the fact it’s a national security issue given what 4 US President’s have been assassinated. Those are not regular cars, they are bullet and god knows what else proof. Not saying I agree that’s right but it’s not a fair comparison.

Still not buying it. The whole point of the COP meetings is not to decide that it might be quite nice if we start making a few token gestures, but rather to address the urgent looming catastrophe threatening our global existence that they are telling us about.

Supposing it were discovered and decreed that a certain food item were found beyond any doubt to be killing all humans who ate it within a year, do you think that Biden (or any of them) would still eat it anyway, 'because it doesn't count when a world leader does it'?

I’ll repeat whilst I do not agree with what Biden did, do you think him not doing that as a token gesture (your words) makes ANY difference to the “urgent looming catastrophe”.

Or, he gets taken out and Trump the climate change denier is President - what a result for COP eh?!

I do wonder about people’s critical thinking skills sometimes. I don’t view world leaders as some great god who I must follow everything they do. I am able to distinguish between the person, the symbolism of the role, and what part I do or don’t play.

Allotment123 · 18/07/2023 22:05

Thanks for your views. I think in all of us there is an inherent selfishness so we deny it so we don't have to change our lives and feel guilty or we think e are inconsequential. Personally I'm really frustrated the Labour Party seemed to have drawn back in this space, we need some really leadership not compromised by sponsorship from carbon polluting giant companies.

I do what I can, haven't flown for 17 years but just me isn't going to make a difference, but I guess me trying to, normalises it and tries to create a culture where we start to bear collective responsibility. I dunt know how we can influence big business without also holding out politicians to account and until we change the culture around us, its not a popular message

OP posts:
FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 18/07/2023 22:01

I don't quite get the argument about the UK only contributing to 1% of global emissions, and thus that it lets us all off the hook. Not when we, like most of the west, are cheerfully allowing China to produce all those emissions on our behalf in making all of the stuff that we consume.

Same with electric cars: fair enough if it is shown that they are better for the environment overall, but we hear so many proponents trying to hoodwink us into thinking that they are completely emission-neutral, and conveniently ignoring the fact that all of that extra electricity (and associated emissions) has to be produced somewhere.

JamSandle · 18/07/2023 21:59

Probably a really unhelpful reply but I don't worry about it. It's been set in motion long ago and cannot be undone at this stage, only managed.

Freshair1 · 18/07/2023 21:59

Have tried having this discussion on aibu before and all I got was 'the rich are still jetting' 'i want to travel' and 'im buying trash off temu or shein and damn my ethics to hell' or variations of. It's utterly fucked up. We're screwed. In real time. Not in the future.
Now.

Ilovealido · 18/07/2023 21:57

Maireas · 18/07/2023 18:52

We ain't gonna chill at 43°c peep!

😂

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 18/07/2023 21:56

Whilst it’s terrible for the environment, what Biden did will be justified by the fact it’s a national security issue given what 4 US President’s have been assassinated. Those are not regular cars, they are bullet and god knows what else proof. Not saying I agree that’s right but it’s not a fair comparison.

Still not buying it. The whole point of the COP meetings is not to decide that it might be quite nice if we start making a few token gestures, but rather to address the urgent looming catastrophe threatening our global existence that they are telling us about.

Supposing it were discovered and decreed that a certain food item were found beyond any doubt to be killing all humans who ate it within a year, do you think that Biden (or any of them) would still eat it anyway, 'because it doesn't count when a world leader does it'?

SunnyEgg · 18/07/2023 21:54

NoNonsensePotato · 18/07/2023 21:52

The reality is that whilst nobody wants to ruin the planet, none of us will be around more than a few more decades. Nobody will say it but many (most?) people aren't prepared to curtail their one life for the benefit of people they'll never meet who probably won't be grateful in any case as the world is unlikely to be in great shape either way.

Do you have dc?

I am prepared to change habits for them

Hungrycaterpillarsmummy · 18/07/2023 21:53

We as the UK public will make such little impact that it's not fucking worth changing anything.

Industry need to change. Government need to put sanctions in place.
But it's still not Gona make much difference. It needs to be the big hitting countries.

Also though I do think people are quick to jump on the "look its july and it's cold so it has to be climate change" bandwagon when actually it could just be a blip....

NoNonsensePotato · 18/07/2023 21:52

The reality is that whilst nobody wants to ruin the planet, none of us will be around more than a few more decades. Nobody will say it but many (most?) people aren't prepared to curtail their one life for the benefit of people they'll never meet who probably won't be grateful in any case as the world is unlikely to be in great shape either way.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 18/07/2023 21:51

David Attenborough has one of the biggest carbon footprints of anyone on the planet and has also admitted he eats meat while exhorting others not to. I'm sick of hearing about him.

The one that always gets me is that Prince Philip and James Lovelock both spent decades banging on obsessively about overpopulation and how we all had to hugely cut back if humanity were to have any hope of a future... both of them the fathers of four children.

Prince William too - he genuinely doesn't seem to realise what an enormous hypocrite he comes across as when he lectures about caring for the climate and yet still lives the opulent life that he does.

Washeroo · 18/07/2023 21:50

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 18/07/2023 21:39

I struggle with the climate change question because our governments clearly don't see it as a problem, and certainly not even approaching an urgent one.

I think, when you see the wanton profligate decisions that the leaders make, it couldn't be a clearer signal from them that they personally categorically do not believe the message that they're giving out.

When Joe Biden (and he is very far from the only world leader like that) flew several of his own vehicles from the USA to the climate conference in Glasgow (and back) - where there are already any number of luxury vehicles that could have been hired - that really was the equivalent of the Archbishop of Canterbury deciding to do a one-man Chubby Brown & Jim Davidson tribute festival and then expecting anybody to take his next sermon, or indeed him, at all seriously again.

I’m not disputing but am sceptical. There are any number of scientists who query these climate-change models and none of them appear to be lunatics.

I know it's not exactly the same thing, but... whatever the established facts are, all scientists know that any research positions, grants and jobs will be closed to/lost by them if they express any dissent from, or even question, the official line; in the same way that a great many GC people grudgingly stay quiet or grit their teeth and toe the line in order to avoid cancellation and job losses - and therefore would appear by default to be in complete agreement with the prevailing messages about how many different genders there are, there's no such thing as fixed biological sex, some children need puberty blockers and even surgery for 'gender' reasons, it's just common decency to ask people what their pronouns are etc.

What I'm saying is that, even if you are convinced that you have all of the facts about anything indisputably correct, when there is a powerful culture where people are simply not allowed to question or disagree with those facts, it's impossible to genuinely claim that opinion is unanimous.

Whilst I understand what you’re saying in parts, it seems wildly out of context.

Whilst it’s terrible for the environment, what Biden did will be justified by the fact it’s a national security issue given what 4 US President’s have been assassinated. Those are not regular cars, they are bullet and god knows what else proof. Not saying I agree that’s right but it’s not a fair comparison. I’m

Re. the objectivity of scientists relative to funding, I’d perhaps suggest it’s WAY more lucrative to go work for a dubiously funded. 3-times removed from an oil company, research position and be anti-climate change, especially in the US.

Perhaps I could argue people are down the rabbit whole because it makes them feel better a they’re in denial.