Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this weather change your attitude to climate change?

240 replies

Allotment123 · 18/07/2023 18:36

It seems like everyone is taking about the weather but no one is thinking about their own personal responsibility to climate change as a result, AIBU to think we are all abdicating responsibility while we can see the dramatic effects all around us? I feel sometimes like in the only one concerned

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
SingingNettles · 19/07/2023 01:37

Lifetime Labour voter, want to Torries out, but I might vote for the Greens in the next election regardless of tactical voting considerations or any other aspect of the Green Party’s platform.

A sudden swing in support towards the Green Party is, I suspect, the only thing that will make politicians prioritize climate change.

And yes, I’m aware that we’d need similar to occur across many other countries but it would be a start…

Hellokittymania · 19/07/2023 01:25

I live in Greece, and I don’t have air conditioning at home. So yes, things like this do concern me, and to make me think. And yes, I have said on those threads where people are wishing the heat wave would go to the UK, would they like the fires and the people who really suffer as well?

The cost of running air conditioning here is quite high, so even when people do have it, they only use it for a short amount of time each day and use the fan in the morning if they can, or do their best to just get by. People have been told if they work in a bakery in the heat is too hot, the bakery can shut between 12 and 5 PM if the temperature goes over 40°, so habits do have to change.

in general, people eat seasonally here, so very hard to find fruits and other things that are not in season. The way of life is very different here, more relaxed, and I think in a lot of ways people are more conscientious about what they do and how they live. Not everyone of course, but many.

we can all do our part to help the planet, but people don’t act unless it really affects them and people in the UK who see our heat wave I just think it’ll be OK because we’re only in it for a week, don’t realize the impact it has on the people who live in those places. Someone said to me when I moved in, oh where are the air conditioning vents?? News, but most places in Spain, France, Italy do not have air-conditioning and in Greece there are so many homes you don’t have air-conditioning

Threenow · 19/07/2023 01:07

AdoraBell · 18/07/2023 20:47

YANBU OP on another thread, can’t remember the title now, someone posted about the heatwave and another poster responded “stop worrying, it’s only weather “

We used to live in Chile and fly back to visit GPs. The first year the Andes were covered with snow. Thriving ski tourism industry and the snow melt provided water for the surrounding countries. When we moved back in 2015, and stopped flying so much, in the winter there was zero snow.

Yes, it's the same where I live, less and less snow on the mountains every year. Winters here are getting milder all the time, and the flooding in parts of the country this year is next level.

Threenow · 19/07/2023 00:56

marshmallowfinder · 18/07/2023 18:44

I was really hopeful that after covid, taking flights for non essential purposes would cease. It's just unbelievable how people don't give a shit and fly whenever they like, drive whatever they like, consume whatever they like.☹️

I too was really hopeful, but it didn't take long for people to go back to their old habits Hmm It's always someone else's problem apparently.

Fawful · 19/07/2023 00:44

I found this report fascinating: clear, sobering and solutions-focussed. www.unep.org/interactive/six-sector-solution-climate-change/
It repeats "Actions are required at every level: government, private sector and the public". If you want to wash our hands off it, sorry but it can't be in good conscience.
The good news is that some of the big changes are pretty painless - switch to a green utility company, and avoid food waste, for instance. (Food rotting in landfill produces methane, which is 30 times more potent than carbon dioxide as a greenhouse gas.) As for flying, if you want and can afford to, you can offset your flights through some charities.
There was a Covid-related improvement to the climate btw, though I don't remember the details.

NoNonsensePotato · 19/07/2023 00:31

This guy seems a bit of a smug twat but he's got a point.

https://vm.tiktok.com/ZGJV2UFQk/

TikTok - Make Your Day

https://vm.tiktok.com/ZGJV2UFQk

Fawful · 19/07/2023 00:26

Archeron · 19/07/2023 00:08

The whole UK could disappear with virtually no effect on global emissions. It’s out of our hands. China and India are the problem and they don’t care.

Another way of looking at it is that the carbon footprint of a British person is about 10 tCO2 per year, whereas an Indian person's is 1 tCO2 and a Chinese's is 5.
In the UK, 40% of emissions come from households; it turns out its more your responsibility than that of individual Indians or Chinese.
Obvs the UK is a low emitter because we buy most of our stuff from China. Do you think we have green lifestyles and the Indians and Chinese are energy hogs? Their emissions are yours too

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 00:13

I became disillusioned when Putin invaded Ukraine. His actions will have released millions of tonnes of GHGs into the atmosphere. At the same time we heard about the footprints of various oligarch's and their yachts. It would take me hundreds of years to rack up the emissions that they put out in just one.

I'm not going to go "fuck it" and buy a gas-guzzler, I'll still keep my own conscience clear. I'll just do my best for the planet in the knowledge that we're screwed whatever I do.

Archeron · 19/07/2023 00:08

The whole UK could disappear with virtually no effect on global emissions. It’s out of our hands. China and India are the problem and they don’t care.

Glowie · 18/07/2023 23:57

Helpwhatwouldyoudonext · 18/07/2023 22:36

@Glowie I'm fascinated by this, I'd like to share the info (Russia 4% etc)
Do you have a link?
And also Australia flies under the radar here, esp. with fossil fuels. I'd appreciate any further facts & figures for a college assignment (with a ref I can check out).

Sure:

https://www.worldometers.info/co2-emissions/co2-emissions-by-country/

https://www.statista.com/statistics/270499/co2-emissions-in-selected-countries/

dreamingbohemian · 18/07/2023 23:35

I know quite a few climate sceptics from all walks of life, but what they all have in common is an almost pathological aversion to 'being told what to do'. Which means they're also all covid sceptics. And don't like paying tax.

Yes I've found this too. Also they're all Brexiters who wanted their sovereignty back.

Yeahreally · 18/07/2023 23:17

Marchintospring · 18/07/2023 22:59

Came on to say this really.
Really there’s zero chance of people meaningfully reducing carbon emissions until governments legislate. Reducing your washing machine to 30 degrees will make sod all difference in the grand scheme of things.
Also it’s really unfair to not expect the poorest in the world to want supermarkets full of cheap food, good transport infrastructure and nice homes when they’ve seen us in the west have it for years.

Agree with this 100x over. Morals/consciences can guide actions to a small degree but then bigger the sacrifice/inconvenience that is being required, the more you need a rules-based system with consequences (whether that's a n actual law or a tax consequence).
Let's not pretend that, for instance, when a nation goes to war, its populace can be left to its own devices to organise armies/defences etc. This is what governments are (meant to be) for.

It's our job to let them know that we really really want them to tackle this. Given that our electoral system is such a flawed and ineffective tool, I suggest anyone concerned looks to other means (I.e engage in the climate action movement at a level that suits them, be that mild, moderate or more disruptive). We won't get the leadership until we make our voices louder.

Stratosphear · 18/07/2023 23:09

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

FatherJackHackettsUnderpantsHamper · 18/07/2023 23:07

I wonder when we're going to get to the point that somebody in power who is committed to seriously reducing CO2 levels honestly acknowledges that the one thing that's constantly pumping out immense quantities of it is... all of us.

Will we see a more draconian worldwide version of the Chinese one-child policy? Or will they decide that we simply don't have enough time to wait for the older generations to die off and be replaced by much lower numbers of younger generations, so far more urgent and decisive 'action' needs to be taken NOW?

Will the rich be exempt from any measures and/or be able to buy their way out of the responsibilities that are forced on everybody else, as they usually do?

Who knows?

Marchintospring · 18/07/2023 22:59

EddyF · 18/07/2023 22:28

For a lot of people, worrying about the environment is a privilege they do not have. Someone just said on this thread that they're on their way to buy an electric car. That person has choices. I used to work with service users who are living day to day and they weren't particularly poor. There is vast amount of inequality in the UK and I'm afraid this topic is at the bottom of the pile for the ordinary man and woman.

Came on to say this really.
Really there’s zero chance of people meaningfully reducing carbon emissions until governments legislate. Reducing your washing machine to 30 degrees will make sod all difference in the grand scheme of things.
Also it’s really unfair to not expect the poorest in the world to want supermarkets full of cheap food, good transport infrastructure and nice homes when they’ve seen us in the west have it for years.

Stratosphear · 18/07/2023 22:56

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 18/07/2023 22:55

FeigningConcern · Today 22:46
I also can't actually believe there are still people denying man made climate change!!

It’s hard to understand how that’s possible. But the media aren’t really reporting on it fully. The Guardian does a fairly good job.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 18/07/2023 22:52

Lazyusername

The elite, as individuals, are using up far more of the world's resources than the rest of us. Govenrments need to start with them. Show the public they are serious. Because until they do, why the hell should we all suffer? We get little enough as it is.

Well, it is true that the few wealthiest on the planet have the highest carbon footprints. Can’t argue with that. However…

  1. It’s not the ‘elite’ asking ‘us’ to change. It’s the thousands of climate scientists who have known this was coming for years and are getting depressed because they can’t make us see, it’s the poorest masses in the world that create the least carbon but will be hit first and worst. And it’s people like me. Parents who lie awake at night worrying about their children’s future. That’s who’s asking ‘us’ to change.
  2. Why compare what you do to the wealthiest 2%. Why not compare what you do to the poorest 2%? Because you are desperately trying to find reasons to keep doing the things you know contribute to the problem.

One thing that might help is to start with a change you do feel happy with. Start small. So if giving up meat sounds awful, just have a meat free day. Or stop eating meat for one meal of the day. If stopping flying seems to hard, cut back. One less flight. If changing your lifestyle to s an absolute no way for you then write to your MP to ask them to vote for greener policies when the time arrives. Switch banks/pensions to a greener option. Change electricity provider.

You ask ‘why the hell should we suffer?’ The suffering that is coming with climate chaos is far far worse than quitting meat or flying.

NoNonsensePotato · 18/07/2023 22:49

Rummikub · 18/07/2023 22:49

I don’t think electric cars are the saviour though. There isn’t enough lithium for the demand.

And the battery required to power a hgv is apparently around 7 tons!

Rummikub · 18/07/2023 22:49

I don’t think electric cars are the saviour though. There isn’t enough lithium for the demand.

woodhill · 18/07/2023 22:48

tulippa · 18/07/2023 21:49

The amount of denial on this thread is depressing. How hot does it need to get before people realise we have a problem? 50 degrees, 55 degrees? Oh hang on, that's already happening. Constant uncontrollable wildfires? That's already happening too.
We're going to look at electric cars at the weekend. Don't feel I can justify my petrol one anymore.

They are so heavy though and some one has to make the batteries

DinnaeFashYersel · 18/07/2023 22:46

Sorry but I'm still going to travel as much as I can for long as it's affordable for business and leisure. Mostly by plane.

But

I will switch to an electric car when they become affordable and when there are enough charging stations to make it practical (I live in Scotland)

I've got solar panels and am diligent about recycling.

I only eat meat a couple of times a week.

So I'm not completely evil.

FeigningConcern · 18/07/2023 22:46

I also can't actually believe there are still people denying man made climate change!!

woodhill · 18/07/2023 22:46

Superfans · 18/07/2023 21:16

Well I’m about to get slammed for this and no doubt the post will be reported and deleted at some point.

Let’s just be clear that climate is a complex system, not fully understood by current models. No matter how expert someone appears to be, they cannot say with certainty what the outcome of this highly complex system will be. There is no climate model that will accurately predict outcomes from the past so how can we claim to predict the future. It is noticeable how much censorship and moralising there is around this issue. The “science” is now not to be questioned. If a finding is robust it should be able to be questioned and openly debated. Science is never settled, it works by falsification. Climate science has consistently made incorrect predictions - Maldives under water etc. Whether “extreme weather” events are actually more frequent is questionable and whether that can be directly related to carbon emissions even more so.

Big business is now bought into the climate change/renewables idea however so that is what is being pushed. Even if you believe CO2 is a key driver of warming many of the renewable energy sources don’t even emit much less CO2 if you look at the totality of the outcome (for example, windmills made in China using coal power then shipped to UK, and require back up fossil fuel on standby for when the wind doesn’t blow. Are they truly “carbon neutral”.

Regardless of whether you think man made carbon emissions are the principle cause of a changing global climate or not it should be clear to most that we cannot stop using fossil fuels without widespread poverty, misery and death. Our current technology does not allow it.

Net zero is a complete fantasy and an excuse to decimate the middle class in Western countries. The best option is to invest in our own industry and work force instead of importing everything, use renewables where they make sense, otherwise natural gas and nuclear. Make sure we have energy security and value our farmers. Get the environmental wins that are possible - get the fucking plastic out of the oceans, that’s achievable. Protect more land for wildlife and biodiversity. Support farmers to protect biodiversity and soils while maintaining output. Invest properly In our water and sewerage systems. Don’t listen to the assholes who dare to fly about on private jets while attempting to lecture and indoctrinate us all in this bizarre unevidenced cult.

Totally agree with you

FeigningConcern · 18/07/2023 22:45

I completely agree with @RumandSpinach and @ohfook

I used to do "my bit" at a cost to my purse and time and effort and mental load, and have come to the same conclusion that it's all a complete waste of time unless governments and big business do something drastic and significant.

I came to the realisation that the government and local government trying to get us to reuse and recycle and use a compost bin etc etc is just a distraction at that costs only the "ordinary people", and diverts our attention away from the fact that they are pretty much doing fuck all to do anything meaningful to pull us back from the now, very obvious, blossoming climate crisis.