Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this weather change your attitude to climate change?

240 replies

Allotment123 · 18/07/2023 18:36

It seems like everyone is taking about the weather but no one is thinking about their own personal responsibility to climate change as a result, AIBU to think we are all abdicating responsibility while we can see the dramatic effects all around us? I feel sometimes like in the only one concerned

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 11:08

There is a really interesting episode of the chef Anthony Bourdain's series where he is in Jamaica. He is talking to locals who are campaigning to stop their beach being closed to the public as rich people want to have private sections of it for their villas. Anthony Bourdain says to camera in the future gorgeous places like this will not be for you or even for me. They are going to be for the ultra rich and they will jet from one to another, you won't even know.
The journalist John Pilger has also done a documentary about this and how a global elite has developed who have no allegiance to any country but flit from place to place enjoying luxury we can only imagine.
I see the climate issue being used to reinforce this. Shut down the working person. Take their car. Stop them flying. Keep them in their locality. This is what I am against. I am for equality. If we must cut back as the earth is being destroyed, surely individuals cannot be allowed this sort of excess.

Moonmelodies · 19/07/2023 11:06

Blackbyrd · 19/07/2023 10:48

Many people are too dumb or selfish to give a shiny shit about people living in African countries which are being rendered unliveable by the increase in temperatures. Or Oceanic islands threatened by rising sea levels. Or the havoc being wrought on animal populations. Or indeed anything that doesn't effect them. No changes will happen voluntarily, only legislation and fines seem to work

If Africa is being rendered 'unliveable' one might wonder why they are aiming to double their population by 2050.

malificent7 · 19/07/2023 10:58

Well the rich are the culprits. Most working class fly economy which is more eco than the rich who fly in private jets.
Just saw a programme about Dubai. Who needs 12 bentleys or a ballon arch to greet you as you get on your private jet and goody bags for the flight? They do of course. It's obscene.

malificent7 · 19/07/2023 10:55

I think the bottom line is that it's natural selection! If we are dumb enough to pollute our own home then we won't survive.
It also is natural if the population of anything gets to big it will fail.
Perhaps that is just how nature is.

Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 10:52

I don't have a car. I don't eat meat. I am doing a lot more than you in that sense but you want to feel good about yourself so that's fine. I am saying that resources are finite on this planet. If cuts have to be made in people's consumption then it must start with people using private jets/private heated swimming pools/second homes and so on. Not the poor. Do you disagree with this and if so, why? If not, maybe we are more in agreement than you think. I'm actually not a twat; I care about working class people though and this climate crisis seems to be being used to widen the gap between rich and poor even further, to push ordinary people down into serfdom while the elite continue to burn up the earth's resources.

Blackbyrd · 19/07/2023 10:48

Many people are too dumb or selfish to give a shiny shit about people living in African countries which are being rendered unliveable by the increase in temperatures. Or Oceanic islands threatened by rising sea levels. Or the havoc being wrought on animal populations. Or indeed anything that doesn't effect them. No changes will happen voluntarily, only legislation and fines seem to work

MotherOfDragonflies · 19/07/2023 10:43

Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 10:37

@MotherOfDragonflies Why should poor people reduce their consumption by half? Why don't you reduce yours by ninety percent?

Anyway we get it, you don’t care and you won’t do anything. Well done you.

Fortunately there are others who will.

MotherOfDragonflies · 19/07/2023 10:42

Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 10:37

@MotherOfDragonflies Why should poor people reduce their consumption by half? Why don't you reduce yours by ninety percent?

I thought you weren’t talking to me anymore?

but in any event my 90 percent is probably less than your half..

besides it was simply a figure pulled from the air to make my point that people shouldn’t feel that if they can’t be perfect they shouldn’t bother trying.

LittleMissUnreasonable · 19/07/2023 10:42

Also (and this isn't me, just what I've heard from other people) A lot of people seem to be burying their head in the sand about the high temperatures. There's a lot of shoulder shrugging about the 40° temperatures, when in England we've had constant rain and no proper summer for weeks. People have a very 'not my problem, still raining in England' attitude and seem to be bitter we are not having a heatwave.

Missingmyusername · 19/07/2023 10:38

“Climate change has always been cyclic.

We are still warming up from the last ice-age.

Chill out, peeps.”

^This is your problem OP.

Most people just don’t care, it’s their dream to live in a warm country (I can see why).

Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 10:37

@MotherOfDragonflies Why should poor people reduce their consumption by half? Why don't you reduce yours by ninety percent?

LittleMissUnreasonable · 19/07/2023 10:37

I do think a lot of things are done out of convenience. For example, I probably wouldn't add an hour and a half each way to my already long working day, to commute on the train which would also cost me more than if I just drove, and inevitably be delayed. I would be late, 3 hours down per day, stressed and out of pocket. Maybe I would make the sacrifice if celebrities weren't getting private jets to fly to the other end of the country and big corporations weren't dumping oil into the sea. A years worth of me travelling to work in my 1.2 liter car probably wouldn't offset the Z lister private jetting for the Instagram vibes.

Sigmama · 19/07/2023 10:35

I think a lot of people couldn't give a shiny shit, i got called greta thunberg on another thread for pointing out that over use of cars isn't great for the environment

Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 10:35

@MotherOfDragonflies You are working class? You have woodland, an orchard, drive an electric car and have chickens and bees!
Your parents may have been but you are certainly not and if you believe you are you are so deluded it's nto even worth debating with you!

MotherOfDragonflies · 19/07/2023 10:32

MotherOfDragonflies · 19/07/2023 10:28

I am a working class person thanks. Brought up on a council estate. Mum was a cleaner, dad worked in a factory. Get over yourself.

And if everyone reduced their consumption of “stuff” by half it would make an enormous difference so nobody should be put off by twats trying to say that if you can’t be perfect you shouldn’t bother doing anything at all.

tapsofgold · 19/07/2023 10:28

Glamrockgoddess · 18/07/2023 18:50

Climate change has always been cyclic.

We are still warming up from the last ice-age.

Chill out, peeps.

Actually, according to NASA we are in the early stages of a cooling cycle...

Finally, Earth is currently in an interglacial period (a period of milder climate between Ice Ages). If there were no human influences on climate, scientists say Earth’s current orbital positions within the Milankovitch cycles predict our planet should be cooling, not warming, continuing a long-term cooling trend that began 6,000 years ago.

climate.nasa.gov/explore/ask-nasa-climate/2949/why-milankovitch-orbital-cycles-cant-explain-earths-current-warming/

MotherOfDragonflies · 19/07/2023 10:28

Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 10:18

@MotherOfDragonflies 😂😂😂😂 Thanks for making my point for me! Still fly, still drive, still buy new clothes, still eat meat but you have planted an orchard and can tell Tarquin and Jemima all about your "brise soleil". It will make you look ever so good. Eco-credentials dontcha know.
People like you have no idea what is happening in the lives of working class people who are being told they can't drive their work van into town without paying a fee, elderly pensioners who are being told to turn their thermostat down and sit freezing in a jumper and so on.
And carbon offsetting is a load of garbage - rich people buying their way out of compliance.
Posts like this simply reinforce to me what I already know though and will hopefully enlighten others so thanks for that.

I am a working class person thanks. Brought up on a council estate. Mum was a cleaner, dad worked in a factory. Get over yourself.

Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 10:18

@MotherOfDragonflies 😂😂😂😂 Thanks for making my point for me! Still fly, still drive, still buy new clothes, still eat meat but you have planted an orchard and can tell Tarquin and Jemima all about your "brise soleil". It will make you look ever so good. Eco-credentials dontcha know.
People like you have no idea what is happening in the lives of working class people who are being told they can't drive their work van into town without paying a fee, elderly pensioners who are being told to turn their thermostat down and sit freezing in a jumper and so on.
And carbon offsetting is a load of garbage - rich people buying their way out of compliance.
Posts like this simply reinforce to me what I already know though and will hopefully enlighten others so thanks for that.

MotherOfDragonflies · 19/07/2023 10:08

Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 09:41

@MotherOfDragonflies People like you make me laugh and there are quite a few of you on this thread. Lecturing everyone else then, "Oh, but I still fly abroad on holiday as my partner wants to." 😂 If you believe everything you are spouting you should not be flying at all. Or ever replacing your clothing with new. Or ever renewing your phone. I bet your family have a car as well. It seems you don't think it's quite the dire emergency everyone makes out or you would be saying no to your partner.
I'm not concerned about people like you, the middle class eco warriors. I am concerned about poor working class people who are being told the tiny pleasures they currently have - a hot bath, a warm room, a little car to get to work - have to be got rid of to stave off impending disaster.
Meanwhile, everyone else has an excuse why they just have to carry on flying/driving/consuming because they are more important.
A classic example is Coldplay with their "eco-friendly (virtue-signalling) stage" which they drag around the world with them. Why not just not tour? After all it's the end of days. We've all been told that. Yet Coldplay are still touring. You are still flying. So why should anyone else care? 🙂

Laugh away. We have reduced our flying significantly but there are two adults in this family and I only control the views of one of them. We carbon offset and we make choices about destination to minimise our impact. I would happily stay in this country for all of our holidays. DH wouldn’t

We have solar panels and electric cars. My car use is down more than 50 percent anyway. The solar also provides us with hot water. From March to late October our cars hardly cost anything in fuel since we generate it. Our energy is on a green tariff. We have massively reduced our meat consumption and don’t eat red meat at all. We buy locally and grow as much food as we can. We have chickens for eggs and bees for honey. We have planted an orchard. We have woodland which we maintain and restock regularly and we use our own wood for heating to supplement the solar. We don’t buy furniture etc new, we are careful in our choices for clothing (don’t buy much anyway) and I recycle everything possible. We do use the internet a lot but are careful to delete anything we don’t need to reduce server impact. We try to eat seasonally and locally, we have significant rainwater harvesting capacity and we don’t use mains drains at all. We don’t use bleach and about 80 percent of the cleaning products etc we use are eco choices (and water extracted where possible to reduce transportation impact). We have brise soleil fitted rather than using fans etc in hot weather, we compost, we have zero food waste (chickens and hot bin composting) etc.

of course there is a lot more we could do but perfection is the enemy of good and those who post like you have are really missing the point quite spectacularly and also deliberately.

GasPanic · 19/07/2023 10:01

No, because I understand the difference between climate and weather.

When we had that really bad cold snap in December I didn't suddenly decide that climate change was a load of crap.

DdraigGoch · 19/07/2023 09:48

SingingNettles · 19/07/2023 01:37

Lifetime Labour voter, want to Torries out, but I might vote for the Greens in the next election regardless of tactical voting considerations or any other aspect of the Green Party’s platform.

A sudden swing in support towards the Green Party is, I suspect, the only thing that will make politicians prioritize climate change.

And yes, I’m aware that we’d need similar to occur across many other countries but it would be a start…

It's not like the Green Party prioritise climate change though. At their conferences the planet hardly gets a look in.

Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 09:41

@MotherOfDragonflies People like you make me laugh and there are quite a few of you on this thread. Lecturing everyone else then, "Oh, but I still fly abroad on holiday as my partner wants to." 😂 If you believe everything you are spouting you should not be flying at all. Or ever replacing your clothing with new. Or ever renewing your phone. I bet your family have a car as well. It seems you don't think it's quite the dire emergency everyone makes out or you would be saying no to your partner.
I'm not concerned about people like you, the middle class eco warriors. I am concerned about poor working class people who are being told the tiny pleasures they currently have - a hot bath, a warm room, a little car to get to work - have to be got rid of to stave off impending disaster.
Meanwhile, everyone else has an excuse why they just have to carry on flying/driving/consuming because they are more important.
A classic example is Coldplay with their "eco-friendly (virtue-signalling) stage" which they drag around the world with them. Why not just not tour? After all it's the end of days. We've all been told that. Yet Coldplay are still touring. You are still flying. So why should anyone else care? 🙂

LuvSmallDogs · 19/07/2023 09:31

@Readthebooks , I get where you're coming from. We have little extra money, we don't own a car and much of our clothing etc is second hand simply because you have to cut your cloth to fit.

Yes we eat meat, but with more than one fussy eater (one with ASD) to cater to I am not going to attempt to overhaul our general diet as well! Not when our moral and intellectual betters are doing as they please for profit and pleasure.

I don't own a factory pumping out pollution and copying its worker's rights from the Victorian era, I don't decide what the minimum welfare standards are in farms and slaughterhouses, I don't decide that the cheapest or only option for a particular fruit/veg should be sealed in plastic - I just try to get by.

MotherOfDragonflies · 19/07/2023 08:33

Everyone needs to focus on doing their bit. Literally everyone. Your best bit might be small but it adds up. It really does. Please don’t believe those who are trying to dissuade. They have an agenda.

LittleApartmentOnThePrairie · 19/07/2023 08:32

Daphnis156 · Today 08:21
No it does not change my opinion, and there's nothing I alone can do about it.
It's just the weather.

You are wrong on both counts there.

  1. Decades of global climate science using multiple models, shows beyond doubt, climate change is happening at a faster rate than would be natural, due to human activity. This is already happening and on a faster trajectory than predicted. As predicted, it has already led to more extreme weather events, wildfires, floods, crop failures, deaths and diseases, mass migration. What’s to come is more of this and it will get worse. Conflict and war over resources is next. The UK will not be protected.
  2. You can make a difference and here is how;

https://www.imperial.ac.uk/stories/climate-action/amp-index.html

9 things you can do about climate change

With so many experts on climate change here at Imperial, many people ask us what they personally can do about it?

https://www.imperial.ac.uk/stories/climate-action/amp-index.html

Swipe left for the next trending thread