Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this weather change your attitude to climate change?

240 replies

Allotment123 · 18/07/2023 18:36

It seems like everyone is taking about the weather but no one is thinking about their own personal responsibility to climate change as a result, AIBU to think we are all abdicating responsibility while we can see the dramatic effects all around us? I feel sometimes like in the only one concerned

OP posts:
Thread gallery
11
WandaWonder · 21/07/2023 01:38

I presume the weather and climate has been changing for millions of years, If humans have created more damage then not sure what we can do about it now just hope the human race doesn't go an damage any other planet

I also think humans need to do as much as they can personally before blaming everyone else/the government as in 'well I demand the right to have central heating on 24/7 but the government should be making it environmentally friendly and cheaper"

Marchitectmummy · 21/07/2023 01:30

Change en mass is always slow, but I think the message is getting through and the more educated ok the matter are making changes, albeit small but it is turning. For example attitude to buying new clothes, things in the home are changing. My daughters attend 3 different private schools and each of those now have popular and well used second hand uniform shops, would have been frowned on 5 years ago.

Food waste is reducing, partly helped by cost of living crisis partly new enterprises springing up to aid companies making the change.

In my sector there has been a massive re-education in attitude towards existing buildings, and a real push rather than lip service to reuse things.

Messaging on recycling has started to change from good to recycle to better not have made in the first place.

Okaygoahead · 21/07/2023 01:17

@BreehyHinnyBrinnyHoohyHah love your bingo card! And yes, given some of the eye-watering nonsense posted already it’s pretty much full now. Bingo!

Am in a place suffering from higher than normal temperatures. Spoke to a resident who in one breath complained about the heat and in the next whined about “the Greens” because construction to expand local public transport was slightly complicating his day. So yeah, people generally have difficulty connecting dots, and are even less willing to act.

NoNonsensePotato · 21/07/2023 00:54

I know waste to energy is a thing over here now. When I worked for one of the world's biggest commercial waste hauliers they were building plants to burn the general waste that would've previously gone to landfill. The idea was to power local communities with the energy produced.

I must check where they got to as covid delayed the completion of the last one and I left around that time..

Moneynewpence · 21/07/2023 00:01

Haruka · 20/07/2023 11:54

For those saying "it doesn't matter what I do if millionaires still do x", well, it kind of does. There are very few millionaires compared to the general population. If, collectively, we all did our bit, then it would have a huge impact.

By the way, the reason why China is such a big polluter, apart from its huge population, is because we ship our waste there and most of our manufactured good are made there. Nothing to do with their lifestyle and all to do with ours.

No, it's because they keep building and using coal fired power stations. The idea that it must be the Evil West [tm] behind everything is really infantilising jsyk

Moneynewpence · 20/07/2023 23:57

It's the take because in the case of China it's true. Choosing to buy from them is another issue.

Fawful · 20/07/2023 20:06

Blaming climate change on the developing countries we use as a manufacturing base really is the take 🤦‍♀️
But maybe not as bad as the "it's not climate, it's the weather"?
No doubt everyone will be amazed when climate refugees start to turn up...
And deeply sad when there is no coral reefs to swim to when they reach their destination, power cuts, flash floods...

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 20/07/2023 19:24

I want to fly soon and didn't want to ease my guilt with a charity (look at most and eye-watering cost of administration).
Instead I looked at third world pollution and other non G7 countries - realised the questionable situation and decided to spend my money on family.

After years of trying to be honest, fair and equitable- it has affected my income, lifestyle and career.

So in conclusion:- boomer lifestyle and if it becomes an issue adapt at that point.

Woke, climate change brat Greta, WEF- its all tedious in the pursuit of profit.

We landfill everything apart from valuable metals as its tax deductible and annoying to sort for no gain.
I also landfill household rubbish as recycling centre is far to much nonsense and same site it all goes in commercial skip.

Fawful · 20/07/2023 15:23

"The point being, there is always more that can be done and no doubt we will all be forced to make big sacrifices in the future. But allow us a tiny bit of life, in the meantime, while we get to grips with what is and what isn't reasonably easy to do. I am sure, over time, many more people will be forced into the kind of money-conscious lifestyle that the poorest (of which I am not one, I might add, just very careful with money due to being a single mum) already lead."

I don't think anyone would criticise you for living the way you describe... We can possibly all do more, but we're also human. The goal is Net Zero, not Absolute Zero. I want to fly soon, and found out I could offset it through donating to a charity. That will have to work for me.

Fawful · 20/07/2023 15:13

Dotjones · 20/07/2023 11:46

It doesn't matter what I do. I'm one person in a country which has a relatively tiny impact on world emissions. If we want to tackle climate change we need to go to the source of the problem and force countries like China to stop polluting the planet. We need to go to countries which are worst affected by climate change (or will be) and force them to stop reproducing. None of this will happen of course because it's easier to walk slowly down a street wearing an orange vest.

I don't think it really matters though, these sorts of problems resolve themselves. If the world gets too hot humans will die out, we'll stop producing emmissions and over time the climate will stabilize again. It's no big deal, plenty of species had gone extinct before we arrived and plenty more will do so after we're gone.

It's the sheer arrogance of climate protestors that gets me. Their basic assumption that humans are somehow "special" and that their idea of what we should be doing is right, everyone else is wrong, and we all need to live by their very limiting rules. It's all very totalitarian, the population must do and think as they're told by their unelected betters.

Humans aren't special. We're a species that has grown to dominate this particular planet due to our exploitation of the resources it provides.

"Force people to stop reproducing in countries affected by climate change", seriously?
why not enforce that in the countries that created global warming instead of the ones suffering from it?
Also, when people say they worry about the planet, they usually mean they are fond of its current inhabitants, people, animals and living things alike... We're hardly going to be reassured by the thought that when we all go extinct, the globe will still spin.
What a depressing thread.

Yeahreally · 20/07/2023 14:15

Dotjones · 20/07/2023 11:46

It doesn't matter what I do. I'm one person in a country which has a relatively tiny impact on world emissions. If we want to tackle climate change we need to go to the source of the problem and force countries like China to stop polluting the planet. We need to go to countries which are worst affected by climate change (or will be) and force them to stop reproducing. None of this will happen of course because it's easier to walk slowly down a street wearing an orange vest.

I don't think it really matters though, these sorts of problems resolve themselves. If the world gets too hot humans will die out, we'll stop producing emmissions and over time the climate will stabilize again. It's no big deal, plenty of species had gone extinct before we arrived and plenty more will do so after we're gone.

It's the sheer arrogance of climate protestors that gets me. Their basic assumption that humans are somehow "special" and that their idea of what we should be doing is right, everyone else is wrong, and we all need to live by their very limiting rules. It's all very totalitarian, the population must do and think as they're told by their unelected betters.

Humans aren't special. We're a species that has grown to dominate this particular planet due to our exploitation of the resources it provides.

Sorry I don't see any "arrogance in climate protesters nor do I think that they see humans as being special (the damage that humanity has wreaked on the planet is clearly in the forefront of their minds).

I really don't think it's unreasonable or arrogant to be asking our governments and our industries to do more, to prioritise action to address the biggest catastrophe that mankind (and many other species) now face.

In my world, that's simple common sense.

woodhill · 20/07/2023 13:44

I suppose if we stopped buying our economy this stuff would fall apart.

I try to limit my purchases to some extent

Haruka · 20/07/2023 11:54

For those saying "it doesn't matter what I do if millionaires still do x", well, it kind of does. There are very few millionaires compared to the general population. If, collectively, we all did our bit, then it would have a huge impact.

By the way, the reason why China is such a big polluter, apart from its huge population, is because we ship our waste there and most of our manufactured good are made there. Nothing to do with their lifestyle and all to do with ours.

Dotjones · 20/07/2023 11:46

It doesn't matter what I do. I'm one person in a country which has a relatively tiny impact on world emissions. If we want to tackle climate change we need to go to the source of the problem and force countries like China to stop polluting the planet. We need to go to countries which are worst affected by climate change (or will be) and force them to stop reproducing. None of this will happen of course because it's easier to walk slowly down a street wearing an orange vest.

I don't think it really matters though, these sorts of problems resolve themselves. If the world gets too hot humans will die out, we'll stop producing emmissions and over time the climate will stabilize again. It's no big deal, plenty of species had gone extinct before we arrived and plenty more will do so after we're gone.

It's the sheer arrogance of climate protestors that gets me. Their basic assumption that humans are somehow "special" and that their idea of what we should be doing is right, everyone else is wrong, and we all need to live by their very limiting rules. It's all very totalitarian, the population must do and think as they're told by their unelected betters.

Humans aren't special. We're a species that has grown to dominate this particular planet due to our exploitation of the resources it provides.

MasterBeth · 20/07/2023 11:45

Archeron · 19/07/2023 00:08

The whole UK could disappear with virtually no effect on global emissions. It’s out of our hands. China and India are the problem and they don’t care.

Part of the solution is in building international agreements that will reduce global emissions. Every reduction is beneficial. I'm very happy for the UK to be a leader.

MasterBeth · 20/07/2023 11:39

Maireas · 18/07/2023 19:05

You should see the holiday threads "put on sunscreen, drink plenty of water, it'll be fine...." Yeh, 43°c for a beach holiday is totally fine and normal 🙄

43 degrees for a beach holiday is manageable (Stay inside for the hottest period of the day / Hydrate frequently) - and will become normal.

But when it becomes normal, the extremes will be 45 / 48 / 50 degrees - and rising. That's what's concerning.

Haruka · 20/07/2023 11:32

I do wish people would stop pissing on each other over small changes already made, regardless of how tiny they might be in the grand scheme of things. Yes, we all could do more, but everyone has to start somewhere. Perhaps it can then be built up over time without becoming a huge inconvenience.

My lifestyle is relatively eco-friendly, not always by choice, but often due to monetary issues. I buy a lot of things second-hand, including furniture, toys, books (we use the library weekly, too), my car is second-hand and old enough to almost count as vintage. Old clothes and bedding get put into a sewing box and get made into one-off costumes for silly things like princess parties and whatever else kids get invited to that normally has people buy polyester costumes, which get thrown away after one use. I'm lucky that I am a reasonably gifted seamstress, albeit self-taught and not always picture-perfect. I cycle or walk to the shops unless I do a big weekly shop. I line-dry, even in winter.

I cook from scratch and seasonally where feasible, buy wonky fruit and veg, I do eat meat but never throw any out (e.g. my duck roast lasted 3 meals) and have taught my kids to respect the animals we eat by not wasting any meat.

My garden is attracting an awful lot of wildlife, partially because I planted consciously, but also because I often don't have the time to weed and maintain it to manicured standards.

And yet, no doubt plenty on here would slate me for my lifestyle. I drink tea and carbonated soft drinks, my battery use is high because we use console games and don't have a charging cable (yet), I colour my hair, drive a petrol car, keep small pet animals (not carnivores), heat my home, buy the odd trinket for the hell of it and plan on a big holiday some years in the future in Asia. Oh, and I have kids.

The point being, there is always more that can be done and no doubt we will all be forced to make big sacrifices in the future. But allow us a tiny bit of life, in the meantime, while we get to grips with what is and what isn't reasonably easy to do. I am sure, over time, many more people will be forced into the kind of money-conscious lifestyle that the poorest (of which I am not one, I might add, just very careful with money due to being a single mum) already lead.

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 19/07/2023 21:59

0.008083283122223 excess in Europe, hardly earth shattering and in what context as Elderly and Co morbid terminally ill patient is far different from healthy 20 year old.

Arabians managed for centuries no internet or AC

Washeroo · 19/07/2023 21:32

I’m not getting into a ridiculous reference off as I don’t engage with climate change deniers. The paper you are referencing was published in 2015, so research completed in 2013/14 latest. Given we’ve had record years since that I’d question its usefulness.

The person who said it is Elena Myrivilli the UNs Chief Heat Officer. Go look up her research papers if you wish to pick it apart.

Moonmelodies · 19/07/2023 21:22

Washeroo · 19/07/2023 21:05

I heard on a Podcast today that heat kills
more people than any other significant weather event. Apparently last year there were 60k excess deaths in Europe due to the heatwaves.

I feel like if it’s cold you can at least attempt to heat yourself (not withstanding the cost). Very difficult to cool down at 40+ degrees with no air con.

A peer-reviewed study of 74 million deaths, across 384 locations and 27 years, published in The Lancet a few years ago, showed roughly 17 times more people die of cold than heat.
https://www.thelancet.com/journals/lancet/article/PIIS0140-6736(14)62114-0/fulltext

Washeroo · 19/07/2023 21:05

I heard on a Podcast today that heat kills
more people than any other significant weather event. Apparently last year there were 60k excess deaths in Europe due to the heatwaves.

I feel like if it’s cold you can at least attempt to heat yourself (not withstanding the cost). Very difficult to cool down at 40+ degrees with no air con.

Washeroo · 19/07/2023 21:03

@stbrandonsboat

Thats a ridiculous generalisation. think I posted upthread we don’t leave the UK during summer now as it’s too hot in Europe. No idea who your friends are but maybe everything your read in the red tops isn’t reflective of the ‘whole of the UK’.

stbrandonsboat · 19/07/2023 13:25

I don't think people in the UK are at all bothered because they seem to be obsessed with the heat. I get that this country is often cool and wet, but I think they'd still flock to Spain if it was 52C. They never seem to get too hot. Sunburned yes, but not actually finding the heat unpleasant or dangerous. People don't seem bothered about the rest of the world suffering, they're just happy that we might be warmer 🙄

ThelmaDinkley · 19/07/2023 12:52

Totally agree with you Lazyusername 👏

woodhill · 19/07/2023 12:02

Exactly

It's never been any different

Tbh it's a way to exhort money out of people

However I do try to do my bit