Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Does this weather change your attitude to climate change?

240 replies

Allotment123 · 18/07/2023 18:36

It seems like everyone is taking about the weather but no one is thinking about their own personal responsibility to climate change as a result, AIBU to think we are all abdicating responsibility while we can see the dramatic effects all around us? I feel sometimes like in the only one concerned

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Thread gallery
11
Daftasabroom · 10/09/2023 18:33

clopper · 18/07/2023 20:55

Alibaba87
It is confusing. The messaging when I was young was basically we will all freeze to death! I can’t remember anything said about global warming at all.

I feel I do my bit, always recycle, use a bike, don’t fly abroad, don’t use plastic if I can possibly avoid it, try to use local businesses but it does all feel a little hopeless.

That was the press misrepresenting a small minority of science papers linking the Maunder minimum solely to solar activity. Even back in the 70s the vast majority of papers predicted warming.

Thebestwaytoscareatory · 25/07/2023 11:19

Hellokittymania · 25/07/2023 06:36

Whoever it was, that wrote something really stupid about the Third World can save itself, and natural disasters are not new, might want to look up what’s considered the third world. Countries very close to the UK, who are experiencing fires, very high temperatures, etc. aren’t the Third World. I haven’t read the latest posts, so maybe I’m missing something, but what happens to our planet is everyone’s responsibility, and this is coming from somebody who has a disability and who has lived in the UK.

it’s very easy for people to say oh, let’s not take responsibility for anything, somebody else will take responsibility. Maybe more people should start changing their thinking a little bit to what can we do to make the world a better place, including about learning what people actually experience.

Yes, it's especially stupid when you consider the UK is an isolated little island that doesn't have enough natural resources to meet the needs of it's population (and unless that is drastically reduced never will).

We are at the mercy of other countries, specifically developing ones, to feed, water, power, and enjoy ourselves. We may remain relatively isolated from the impacts while the global capitalist market is still operating (and we are one of the richest countries) but there is a tipping point where that stops and climate change is rapidly adding weight to just one side of the scale.

Just look at food production. Today we grow approximately 170 crops on a commercially significant scale, depend highly on only about 30 of them to provide us with calories and nutrients that we need every day, with more than 40% of all human consumed calories coming from just three staple crops: rice, wheat and maize (corn).

Corn yields are predicted to decline by 24% by 2030, rice yields decline roughly 10% for every additional degree of temperature rise (and are already being severely impacted by changing weather patterns), wheat production is actually predicted to rise but not by enough to cover the other two loses (17%). Similar patters are present in all commercially significant food crops.

While developing country leaders may be happy to subject their populations to lower standards of living in pursuit of economic growth, by selling their products to developed countries, the populations themselves won't willingly accept starvation, so once yields are reduced enough to tip those in poverty into famine the global markets will stop functioning, as will our abundant food supply.

What are all those "I don't care about things happening over there" posters plans for when global food systems collapse?

Also for all those going on about the UK only accounting for 1% of emissions, please read the work the Global Carbon Project / Future Earth and Carbon Breif do in this area to understand why this is irrelevant.

grabitwithbothhands · 25/07/2023 10:53

CurlewKate · 18/07/2023 19:44

It doesn't change my opinion. But it does make me think it's probably too late to do anything about it.

This. Exactly. It really highlights the futility of making sure I remember to take my bag for life as the wildfires burn. It frankly doesn't matter whether we caused it or not, we can't stop it, just adapt.

JamSandle · 25/07/2023 10:44

Dinosaurs thrived and died out before us. Humans were never supposed to live forever.

Sigmama · 25/07/2023 10:39

One fineness, not everyone who lives in ulez areas will have to pay money, so it's not all about money, plenty of londoners do not own cars

woodhill · 25/07/2023 10:34

Ulez is definitely about money not air quality otherwise the airport would not be able to operate

Lethalinformation · 25/07/2023 09:18

onefinemess · 25/07/2023 09:08

Climate change is a thing, in fact, the climate has been changing for hundreds of millions of years.

No, the human element is a great way to get people to do things, give them something to be afraid of and they can be persuaded to do things to ensure their "safety". Never forget, it's important to be "safe".

But humans aren't going to damage the planet. At least not currently. Its survived worst than us. Weather is just weather, but it's convenient to blame people for it and use it as a control measure.

If you got of every single ICE in the UK today, not just cars, but planes, trains, lawnmowers, generators, carbon emissions would reduce by sweet fuck all. Less than one percent.

But tell people that their "killing the planet, small children a dying" and you can manipulate them into accepting control measures which greatly increase tax revenue and streamline the collection processes, making them more reliable and consistent.

The Ulez isn't about the environment, its about money. Saddle ows vast sums to TFL and the Cross Rail fiasco. That tells you how much politicians lie.

Mumsnet

Seriously? 😒

onefinemess · 25/07/2023 09:08

Allotment123 · 18/07/2023 18:36

It seems like everyone is taking about the weather but no one is thinking about their own personal responsibility to climate change as a result, AIBU to think we are all abdicating responsibility while we can see the dramatic effects all around us? I feel sometimes like in the only one concerned

Climate change is a thing, in fact, the climate has been changing for hundreds of millions of years.

No, the human element is a great way to get people to do things, give them something to be afraid of and they can be persuaded to do things to ensure their "safety". Never forget, it's important to be "safe".

But humans aren't going to damage the planet. At least not currently. Its survived worst than us. Weather is just weather, but it's convenient to blame people for it and use it as a control measure.

If you got of every single ICE in the UK today, not just cars, but planes, trains, lawnmowers, generators, carbon emissions would reduce by sweet fuck all. Less than one percent.

But tell people that their "killing the planet, small children a dying" and you can manipulate them into accepting control measures which greatly increase tax revenue and streamline the collection processes, making them more reliable and consistent.

The Ulez isn't about the environment, its about money. Saddle ows vast sums to TFL and the Cross Rail fiasco. That tells you how much politicians lie.

Mumsnet

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 25/07/2023 08:45

@Lazyusername , it was 20 odd years ago now, but I remember a similar situation in Barbados, when there was a proposal to close off sections of beaches (at the time all public) for rich people’s villas.

Pleased to say that IIRC the govt. that was proposing it was swiftly kicked out on its arse. I do hope that hasn’t changed.

Tapasgoofy · 25/07/2023 07:04

Glowie · 18/07/2023 18:56

I struggle with the climate change question because our governments clearly don't see it as a problem, and certainly not even approaching an urgent one.

My reasoning;
The UK as a whole is about 1% of global emissions. This means that you could drop the entire island into the sea and that would be the gain.

China and India account for 37% between them (hell, Russia is 4%), so if things were really that dire then the west would have banned all imports from those countries to get that number down.
That's assuming the US hadn't already bombed their industrial areas to death in the first place...

So the UK is 1% and we are the ones that need to change…. At 1% what are we realistically going to achieve by cutting down anything.

Tumbleweed101 · 25/07/2023 06:57

The world was capable of acting as one for Covid. Why isn’t it doing the same for climate change? The only way for real change to happen is if every nation acts as one.

B72 · 25/07/2023 06:53

No.

Hellokittymania · 25/07/2023 06:36

Whoever it was, that wrote something really stupid about the Third World can save itself, and natural disasters are not new, might want to look up what’s considered the third world. Countries very close to the UK, who are experiencing fires, very high temperatures, etc. aren’t the Third World. I haven’t read the latest posts, so maybe I’m missing something, but what happens to our planet is everyone’s responsibility, and this is coming from somebody who has a disability and who has lived in the UK.

it’s very easy for people to say oh, let’s not take responsibility for anything, somebody else will take responsibility. Maybe more people should start changing their thinking a little bit to what can we do to make the world a better place, including about learning what people actually experience.

sleepwouldbenice · 25/07/2023 00:17

Lazyusername · 19/07/2023 10:18

@MotherOfDragonflies 😂😂😂😂 Thanks for making my point for me! Still fly, still drive, still buy new clothes, still eat meat but you have planted an orchard and can tell Tarquin and Jemima all about your "brise soleil". It will make you look ever so good. Eco-credentials dontcha know.
People like you have no idea what is happening in the lives of working class people who are being told they can't drive their work van into town without paying a fee, elderly pensioners who are being told to turn their thermostat down and sit freezing in a jumper and so on.
And carbon offsetting is a load of garbage - rich people buying their way out of compliance.
Posts like this simply reinforce to me what I already know though and will hopefully enlighten others so thanks for that.

Ignorance works both ways, dontcha know, pratGrinGrinGrinGrinGrinGrin

AnorLondo · 24/07/2023 23:32

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 24/07/2023 23:29

Human nature
We do enough unpleasantness domestically to genuinely disabled and pensioners in poverty etc.
Some woke save the world narcissistic narrative.
Rest of world can save itself.
Third world disasters are nothing new

Not human nature. Your own nature maybe, but most people are capable of empathy.

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 24/07/2023 23:29

AnorLondo · 24/07/2023 23:03

And fuck everyone else who suffers as a result, right?

Human nature
We do enough unpleasantness domestically to genuinely disabled and pensioners in poverty etc.
Some woke save the world narcissistic narrative.
Rest of world can save itself.
Third world disasters are nothing new

DdraigGoch · 24/07/2023 23:23

calyxx · 24/07/2023 20:43

I already felt deeply concerned so no. But it has made me resolve not to fly for holiday if I can poss help it. Back to France I guess!

You don't have to limit yourself to France, take the Nightjet sleeper from Paris, Brussels, or Amsterdam and you can wake up in Vienna, Berlin or Zurich.

AnorLondo · 24/07/2023 23:03

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 24/07/2023 22:42

Do what you like, we landfill our rubbish and it is taxed.
We drive older diesel cars as they are Cheaper pence per mile including maintenance and no finance.
It's all hysteria and hype and we have more pressing concerns than if somewhere else is on fire.
Too much drama and virtue signalling, as repugnant as religion.
It's like sex before marriage etc

Live fast, love fast & die young

And fuck everyone else who suffers as a result, right?

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 24/07/2023 22:42

Do what you like, we landfill our rubbish and it is taxed.
We drive older diesel cars as they are Cheaper pence per mile including maintenance and no finance.
It's all hysteria and hype and we have more pressing concerns than if somewhere else is on fire.
Too much drama and virtue signalling, as repugnant as religion.
It's like sex before marriage etc

Live fast, love fast & die young

calyxx · 24/07/2023 20:43

I already felt deeply concerned so no. But it has made me resolve not to fly for holiday if I can poss help it. Back to France I guess!

BlossomCloud · 24/07/2023 19:46

Washeroo · 23/07/2023 20:53

To PP commenting on climate change and the comparison to currently wearing a jumper during a British summer. Climate change doesn’t just mean heat, it’s also more extreme weather events as seen with cyclones etc. It might just be a wet one for us but there are some climate scientists who think the jet stream may shift more significantly allowing much cooler air from the polar regions.

Plus sea level rises, worse flooding, far more rapid coastal erosion
(Am always baffled by people who live at sea level yet have mammoth carbon footprints)

And species extinctions (insects etc in particular, which then has an impact all the way up the food chain)

Lethalinformation · 24/07/2023 19:43

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 24/07/2023 18:51

We have had periods in history before, we survived-its a shock 😉

Er, no, we have not survived the temperatures predicted. I despair at posters putting winking emojis on their pathetic posts

BlossomCloud · 24/07/2023 19:43

GwinGwyn · 18/07/2023 18:54

I take a lot of personal responsibility and think what we are facing is frightening because we’ve effed up the planet. But what also annoys me is the fact that 71% of emissions aren’t from people going about the daily grind, it’s from business. Where are their sanctions?

But the businesses don't operate in a vacuum, they only do things that are profitable. If we stop buying their crap they will have to scale down (I haven't bought new clothes or furniture in years, I buy it all second hand. In fact all my furniture is second hand. )

SingingNettles · 24/07/2023 19:33

SowingTheSeedsOfLove · 24/07/2023 18:51

We have had periods in history before, we survived-its a shock 😉

What do you mean? The Earth is currently hotter than it has been at any other time since the dawn of civilization and, of course, is predicted to become significantly hotter during the rest of this century.